Skip to main content

Full text of "Annals of Wyoming"

See other formats


Library 

Or  TTrE 

Univer?-     3f  Wyoming 

LARAMIE,  820/1 


Digitized  by  the  Internet  Archive 

in  2011  with  funding  from 

LYRASIS  Members  and  Sloan  Foundation 


http://www.archive.org/details/annalsofwyom55121983wyom 


Univer 

L 


Unh 


vV  .    ■ 


2/4NNALS  of  I 


WYOMIN 


I 


Volume  55,  Number  1 
Spring,  1983 


w 


m*  I 


*> 


I 


XL 


ti 


. 


THE  WYOMING  STATE  ARCHIVES,   MUSEUMS  AND  HISTORICAL  DEPARTMENT 

The  function  of  the  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and  Historical  Department 
is  to  collect  and  preserve  materials  which  tell  the  story  of  Wyoming.  It  maintains  the  state's 
historical  library  and  research  center,  the  Wyoming  State  Museum  and  branch  museums, 
the  State  Art  Gallery  and  the  State  Archives.  The  Department  solicits  original  records  such 
as  diaries,  letters,  books,  early  newspapers,  maps,  photographs  and  art  and  records  of  early 
businesses  and  organizations  as  well  as  artifacts  for  museum  display.  The  Department  asks 
for  the  assistance  of  all  Wyoming  citizens  to  secure  these  documents  and  artifacts.  Depart- 
ment facilities  are  designed  to  preserve  these  materials  from  loss  and  deterioration. 

WYOMING  STATE  LIBRARY,  ARCHIVES  AND  HISTORICAL  BOARD 

Ken  Richardson,  Lander,  Chairman 

Mrs.  Suzanne  Knepper,  Buffalo 

Dave  Paulley,  Cheyenne 

Mrs.  Wilmot  C.  McFadden,  Rock  Springs 

Eugene  Martin,  Evanston 

Jerry  Rillahan,  Worland 

Mrs.  Mae  Urbanek,  Lusk 

Frank  Bowron,  Casper 

Attorney  General  Archibald  G.  McClintock  (ex-officio) 


ABOUT  THE  CO  VER—  The  cover  painting,  "The  Wagon  Box  Fight,  "  is  the  third  E.  W. 
"Bill"  Gollings  work  featured  on  an  Annals  cover.  Gollings'  painting,  one  of  four  commis- 
sioned by  the  Legislature  in  1918,  hangs  in  the  Senate  chambers  of  the  State  Capitol.  All 
four  paintings  were  restored  and  rehung  recently.  Gollings,  "The  Cowboy  Artist,  "  was  born 
in  Idaho  in  1878 — 11  years  after  the  incident  commemorated  in  this  painting  occurred.  When 
he  was  ten  years  old,  he  moved  with  his  family  to  Chicago.  By  the  time  he  was  a  teenager, 
he  was  riding  the  range  as  a  cowhand  in  Montana  and  Wyoming.  In  1902  and  on  several 
later  occasions,  Gollings  returned  to  Chicago  to  study  art  at  the  Academy  of  Fine  Arts. 
Sheridan,  Wyoming,  became  his  home  when  he  returned  west  and  in  1909,  he  built  a  studio 
there.  Gradually,  his  works  gained  commercial  acceptance.  He  died  in  Sheridan  on  April 
16,  1932.  The  event  immortalized  in  the  painting  is  part  of  the  story  of  the  "Bozeman  — 
Trail  to  Death  and  Glory.  "  The  story  begins  on  page  32  of  this  issue. 


cA 


NNALS  of  WYOMING 


Volume  55,  No.  1 
Spring,  1983 


GOVERNOR  OF  WYOMING 

Ed  Herschler 

DIRECTOR 

Dr.  Robert  D.  Bush 

CO-EDITORS 

William  H.  Barton 
Philip  J.  Roberts 

ASSISTANT  EDITORS 

Jean  Brainerd 
Rick  Ewig 

EDITORIAL  ASSISTANTS 

Kathy  Martinez 
Ann  Nelson 

PHOTOGRAPHIC 

ASSISTANTS 

Paula  West 
Carroll  Jones 


TABLE  OF  CONTENTS 

F 

PARCO,  WYOMING: 

A  MODEL  COMPANY  TOWN .      2 

By  Gregory  D.  Kendrick 

\J,  £  ST-  Sfc 

McCarthy  era  politics: 

the  ordeal  of  senator  lester  hunt  9 

By  Rick  Ewig 

THE  WILCOX  TRAIN  ROBBERY 

NEWSPAPERS  AND  INSTANT  MYTHMAKING    22 

By  Emmett  D.  Chisum 

THE  BOZEMAN  - 

TRAIL  TO  DEATH  AND  GLORY    32 

By  Sherry  L.  Smith 

THE  WIND-BIG  HORN  RIVER 

AND  THE  ROCKY  MOUNTAIN  FUR  TRADE   51 

By  Keith  Algier 

BOOK   REVIEWS    56 

INDEX   62 

CONTRIBUTORS    64 

ANNALS  OF  WYOMING  is  published  biannually  in  the  Spring  and  Fall. 
It  is  received  by  all  members  of  the  Wyoming  State  Historical  Society  as  the 
official  publication  of  that  organization.  Copies  of  previous  and  current  issues 
may  be  purchased  from  the  Co-Editors.  Correspondence  should  be  addressed 
to  the  Co-Editors.  Published  articles  represent  the  views  of  the  author  and 
are  not  necessarily  those  of  the  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and 
Historical  Department  or  the  Wyoming  State  Historical  Society.  ANNALS 
OF  WYOMING  articles  are  abstracted  in  Historical  Abjpttjacts.  America:  History 
and  Life. 


!£)Copyright  1983  by  the  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Mijieums  and  Histories 

University-fe 


LARAMIE,  82071 


_ 


1  - 

1   . 


*J>. 


i   - 


*    vf£f  ■ 


Parco  Inn,  Sinclair,   Wyoming,  1980 


Parco,  Wyoming:  A  Model  Company  Town 

By  Gregory  D.  Kendrick 


For  three  windy  days  in  1925,  10,000  high  plains 
residents  crowded  the  freshly  swept  streets  of  Parco,  Wyom- 
ing, to  celebrate  the  town's  official  opening.  Arriving  via 
rail  or  following  the  transcontinental  Lincoln  Highway, 
visitors  enjoyed  a  three-day  festival  featuring  Bernadi's  Ex- 
position Show,  numerous  colorful  parades  and  a  dramatic 
air  race.  The  festivities  culminated  with  an  unexpected 
visit  by  Wyoming's  newly  elected  Governor,  Nellie  Tayloe 
Ross,  the  first  woman  governor  elected  in  the  United  States. 
The  Denver  Post,  Rocky  Mountain  News  and  the  local 
Wyoming  press  carried  detailed  front  page  accounts  of 
the  event.  The  Rocky  Mountain  News,  devoting  an  en- 
tire special  section  to  the  celebration,  reported  that  Par- 
co, Wyoming,  "is  truly  an  oasis  in  an  otherwise  drab  desert 
territory."  Located  in  a  desolate  stretch  of  treeless  plains, 
known  throughout  much  of  the  19th  century  as  the  "Great 
American  Desert,"  the  small  company-built  town  did  not 
belie  the  newspaper's  hyperbole.1 

After  two  years  of  frenzied  construction,  Parco  boasted 
a  professionally  designed  city  plan  and  impressive  Spanish 
Colonial  style  residential,  commercial  and  public  architec- 
ture. Encompassing  nearly  160  acres,  the  town  accom- 
modated the  company's  500  employees  and  their 
dependents.  In  addition,  the  town  was  situated  at  the  base 
of  a  small  promontory  to  shelter  its  inhabitants  from  the 
bone-chilling  winter  winds  and  located  immediately 
upwind  from  the  newly  constructed  oil  refinery. 

In  planning,  design  and  construction,  Parco  repre- 
sented a  historical  departure  from  earlier  company-built 
towns  in  Wyoming  and  in  the  trans- Mississippi  West. 
Beginning  early  in  the  19th  century,  industrialists  and 
manufacturers  who  located  their  companies  in  isolated 
rural  areas  recognized  the  necessity  of  providing  company 
housing.  If  most  realized  the  need,  few  were  willing  to 
expend  the  time  or  the  capital  to  construct  well-designed 
and  solidly  built  employee  residences.  Throughout  much 
of  the  19th  century,  company  engineers  provided  the  sim- 
ple grid  street  pattern  and  then  retained  local  contrac- 
tors or  private  speculators  to  provide  the  essential  housing. 
Poorly  designed  and  shabbily  constructed  company  towns 
such  as  the  Union  Pacific  Coal  Company's  Superior,  Wyo- 
ming (1905),  were  usually  the  grim  consequences.2  Parco 
departed  from  this  western  tradition.  This  so-called  "won- 


der town"  combined  both  professionally  designed  residen- 
tial, public  and  commercial  buildings  and  a  professionally 
planned  street/land  use  pattern. 

The  origin  of  Parco  can  be  traced  to  the  career  of 
a  prominent  Denver  oil  baron.  Frank  Kistler  was  born  on 
a  North  Carolina  plantation  in  1882.  Eleven  years  later 
the  entire  family  moved  west  to  begin  a  farm  in  Van 
Buren,  Arkansas.  In  this  rural  setting,  Kistler  first  worked 
in  a  local  mercantile  store.  After  the  death  of  his  father 
in  1895,  the  family  again  moved,  this  time  to  Claremore, 
Oklahoma.3 

His  business  acumen  whetted,  Kistler  left  home  in  1901 
to  accept  a  challenging  position  with  the  Texas  Company, 
a  young  expanding  oil  company  based  in  Houston,  Texas. 
A  series  of  rapid  promotions  quickly  followed,  and  Kistler 
eventually  became  manager  of  leasing  and  operations.  By 
1915,  Kistler  confidently  resigned  to  form  his  own  com- 
pany, Producers  and  Refiners  Corporation  or  PARCO.  The 
company  incorporated  with  capital  stock  of  $20  million 
and  within  the  decade  doubled  its  assets.  Kistler's  personal 
assets  were  conservatively  estimated  at  $12  million.4 

As  president  of  PARCO,  Kistler  immediately  began 
plans  to  tap  Wyoming's  vast  proven  oil  reserves.  A  large 
oil/gas  refinery  and  company-built  town  were  essential  to 
this  strategy.  Proximity  to  productive  oil  fields  and  a 
dependable  transportation  network  dictated  the  location 
of  the  town.  Rawlins,  Wyoming  was  initially  considered 
for  its  combination  of  closeness  to  the  Ferris,  Salt  Creek 
and  Lost  Soldier  oil  fields  and  for  its  intersection  by  two 
major  transcontinental  transportation  routes  —  the  Union 
Pacific  Railroad  and  the  Lincoln  Highway.  After  a  short 
period,  however,  Kistler  abandoned  the  idea  because  of 
vociferous  resistance  by  residents  of  Rawlins  to  the  planned 
oil  refinery.  The  town  was  then  planned  for  six  miles  east 
of  Rawlins  at  the  junction  of  the  Union  Pacific  Railroad 
and  Lincoln  Highway.5 

The  potential  attributes  of  a  modern  company  town 
also  influenced  his  decision  to  relocate  Parco.  Although 
dilapidated  and  inhospitable  industrial  towns  proliferated 
throughout  the  West,  sufficient  precedent  existed,  espe- 
cially in  the  East,  to  economically  justify  a  clean,  attrac- 
tive company  town.  Large  corporations,  for  example,  often 
ordered     hundreds    of    prefabricated    frame    homes 


"Parco  boasted  a  professionally  designed  city  plan  and  impressive  Spanish 
Colonial  style  residential,  commercial  and  public  architecture." 


from  catalogues  published  by  prominent  distributors  such 
as  Sears,  Roebuck  and  Company.  Just  before  1926,  Stan 
dard  Oil  purchased  192  inexpensive,  pre-cut,  two-story, 
detached  single-family  houses  for  their  workers  in  Carlin- 
ville,  Illinois.6 

Other  industrialists  chose  to  hire  professional  archi- 
tects and  planners  to  assist  in  the  construction  of  their 
company  towns.  Indeed,  the  first  two  decades  of  the  20th 
century  witnessed  the  successful  completion  of  several  pro- 
fessionally planned  industrial  towns.  An  intense  demand 
for  surplus  wartime  housing  in  combination  with  a  con- 
tinued humanitarian  concern  for  improved  living  condi- 
tions sparked  a  few  large  corporations  to  develop  a  new 
tradition  in  company  town  construction.  Industrial  towns 
such  as  Kohler,  Wisconsin  (1913);  "Indian  Hill,"  outside 
Worcester,  Massachusetts  (1915);  Erwin,  Tennessee  (1916); 
Warren,  Arizona  (1908);  and  Tyrone,  New  Mexico  (1917) 
utilized  the  skills  of  both  urban  planners  and  recognized 
architects  in  the  design  of  street  patterns  and  buildings. 
Often  these  professional  skills  were  located  within  the  same 
individual  or  firm.7 

Government  studies  corroborated  what  many  leading 
industrialists  already  recognized;  namely,  that  company 
housing  tended  to  attract  a  more  stable  and  controllable 
labor  force  and  thereby  reduce  transience  in  the  skilled 


work  force.  Just  as  important,  many  companies  realized 
a  two  to  three  percent  profit  from  the  construction  of 
employee  housing,  even  when  reasonable  rents  were 
charged.8  Kistler  undoubtedly  understood  that  favorable 
public  relations  would  be  generated  from  the  contruction 
of  a  well-designed  company  town.  The  public  gesture 
could  help  to  negate  much  of  the  antipathy  directed 
toward  oil  companies  resulting  from  the  Teapot  Dome 
scandal. 

Once  Kistler  had  decided  to  build  a  company  town, 
he  turned  to  the  prominent  Denver- based  architectural 
firm  of  Fisher  and  Fisher  to  draw  the  plans  and  prepare 
the  land  use  pattern  for  Parco.  His  decision  was  a  sound 
one.  The  two  brothers,  William  E.  and  Arthur  Fisher, 
already  possessed  a  solid  regional  reputation  in  both  com- 
mercial and  residential  design  when  first  retained  by 
Kistler  in  early  1922.  More  pertinent  perhaps,  William, 
as  President  of  the  Mountain  Division  of  the  Architect's* 
Small  House  Service  Bureau,  had  designed  several  small, 
inexpensive  model  homes.  The  architects  would  utilize 
these  house  plans  when  designing  some  of  the  employee 
residences  in  Parco.9 

Kistler  was  pleased  when,  in  May  of  1923,  he  reviewedl 
Fisher  and  Fisher's  conceptual  plans  for  the  estimated 
$750,000  project.  Indeed,  equipped  with  an  adequate 


1,01% 


Parco  opening  celebration,  1925. 


judget,  the  architects  were  able  to  soon  "turn  over  the 
ntire  office  force"  to  preparing  the  construction  draw- 
ngs.10 

Fisher  and  Fisher  possibly  derived  their  inspiration 
or  Parco  from  architect  Bertram  Goodhue's  1917  plan  of 
Tyrone,  New  Mexico.  Constructed  for  Phelps -Dodge  Cor- 
>oration's  copper  mining  operation,  Tyrone,  like  Parco, 
ncorporated    many    traditional    elements    of    Spanish 

olonial  new  world  town  plans.  Both  towns  grouped  essen- 
ial  public  facilities  such  as  hotel,  post  office,  fire  depart- 
nent,  railroad  depot,  theater,  stores  and  shops  around 

central  plaza.  Unlike  Goodhue's  design,  however,  Fisher 
ind  Fisher  successfully  integrated  residential,  public  and 
ommercial  buildings.  Tyrone  remains  a  "center  without 

town"  since  only  a  single  residential  street  leads  from 

plaza  crowded  with  small  two-room  employee  homes. 
risher  and  Fisher,  on  the  other  hand,  oriented  the  main 
)laza  with  its  corners  pointed  to  the  four  cardinal  points 
tf  the  compass.  Much  like  Spanish  Colonial  communities, 
'arco's  plaza  is  intersected  by  numerous  streets,  all  of  which 
ead  to  completed  residential  sections.  Lincoln  Avenue, 
'arco's  principal  axis,  bisects  the  plaza  and  leads  east  and 
vest  to  residential  neighborhoods.  The  other  minor 
ributaries  lead  north  and  south  from  the  plaza.11 
Fisher  and  Fisher  designed  the  street/land  use  pat- 


tern to  blend  comfortably  with  environmental  realities. 
For  example,  the  residential  street  pattern  and  orienta- 
tion of  most  homes  assured  maximum  solar  exposure. 
Moreover,  the  town's  location  at  the  foot  of  a  low- lying 
mesa  provided  protection  from  the  blustery  winter  winds, 
and  its  position  upwind  from  the  oil  refinery  assured  that 
gas  fumes  would  not  plague  the  residents.  The  architects 
also  placed  the  town  on  an  axis  with  an  undeveloped  sec- 
tion of  land,  anticipating  the  future  growth  of  the 
community.12 

Their  concerns,  however,  were  by  no  means  confined 
to  environmental  issues.  Fisher  and  Fisher  also  focused 
upon  social  and  aesthetic  design  elements.  In  order  to 
foster  a  sense  of  community  spirit,  often  absent  in  com- 
pany towns,  the  brothers  designed  the  circular  plaza  with 
public  buildings  fronting  a  communal  area.  An  interesting 
fountain,  designed  by  Denver  sculptor  Robert  Garrison 
and  constructed  of  Dentero  stone,  highlights  the  plaza. 
Eight  carved  figures  each  half  bear  and  half  cat,  encir- 
cle the  fountain  and  symbolize  the  bear-cat  logo  of  Kistler's 
oil  company.  By  planning  such  a  plaza,  the  brothers  hoped 
to  create  "a  real  community  center"  through  attractive  pro- 
menades and  play  spots  for  the  children.  Similar  con- 
sideration prompted  the  architects  to  separate  the  oil 
refinery  from  the  town  with  small  landscaped  parks  and 


parking  areas.  Perhaps  Fisher  and  Fisher's  most  innovative 
design  decision  was  to  secure  all  electrical  wiring  leading 
to  the  employee  residences  in  underground  conduits,  a 
novel  feature  in  that  day.  Finally,  Fisher  and  Fisher  decid- 
ed to  eliminate  alleys  from  their  original  drawings  for  they 
came  to  view  them  as  "unsightly"  and  unnecessary  in  small 
communities.13 

In  keeping  with  their  Spanish  Colonial  style  planning 
motif,  Fisher  and  Fisher  designed  commercial  buildings 
with  unpainted  stucco,  polychrome  clay  tile  roofs,  arched 
colonnades  and  wrought  iron  balconies  to  simulate  the 
appearance  and  form  of  many  southwestern  mission  com- 
plexes. The  impressive  Parco  Hotel  constructed  in  1924 
at  a  cost  of  $175,000  dominates  the  plaza  and  established 
the  overall  architectural  theme. 

Spanning  an  entire  town  block,  the  Parco  Hotel  is  a 
rectilinear  structure  flanked  by  two  five-story  bell  towers. 
Single  story  wings  extend  from  both  sides  of  the  hotel  and 
house  the  town's  various  shops,  cafes  and  offices.  The  hotel, 
like  all  the  major  commercial  buildings,  is  constructed 
of  hollow  tile,  reinforced  with  steel  joists,  and  covered  with 
several  layers  of  tinted  stucco.  The  structure  also  features 
decorative  impost  moldings,  dentiled  string  cornices,  and 
neo-baroque  spiraled  columns. 

The  hotel's  interior  is  equally  attractive.  After  pass- 
ing through  a  long  arched  entry  vestibule,  guests  enter 
the  tiled  main  lobby.  The  lobby  opens  dramatically  to 


1 &^     *  It* 


A  typical  home  in  the  planned  community  of  Parco. 


a  second  floor,  revealing  hand-painted  cedar  beams,  the 
stencils  designed  by  Thomas  Arrak  of  Denver.  Wrought 
iron  balconies  as  well  as  arched  colonnades  demarcate  the 
second  floor.  Twin  stairways  lead  to  the  second  and  third 
floors  from  the  lobby  with  intersecting  colonnaded  hall- 
ways connecting  the  terrazo  tiled  dining  and  guest  rooms.14 

Fisher  and  Fisher  devoted  an  equal  amount  of  thought 
and  planning  to  the  employee  residences.  The  brothers 
covered  the  detached,  single-family  frame  homes  with 
stucco  to  blend  with  the  commercial  structures.  A  total 
of  14  floor  plan  variations  were  prepared,  divided  accor- 
ding to  "workingman's  housing"  and  "officer's  housing." 
The  rigid  categorization  of  housing  accentuated  the  exist- 
ing social  hierarchy  in  Parco  and  was  a  common  practice 
in  other  contemporary  company  towns.15 

Workers  rented  comfortable  one-story,  four-room  res- 
idences for  $40  to  $50  per  month.  Their  supervisors,  on 
the  other  hand,  received  spacious  two-story  bungalows, 
featuring  three  bedrooms  upstairs.  Although  Kistler  ini- 
tially considered  heating  the  homes  with  surplus  steam 
from  the  refinery,  the  cost  of  such  an  innovative  venture 
proved  prohibitive.  Instead,  each  residence  was  equipped 
with  a  gas  furnace  as  well  as  indoor  plumbing  and 
electricity.16 

Fisher  and  Fisher  retained  Fred  D.  Creglown  of  Casper, 
Wyoming,  an  experienced  architect,  to  supervise  on-site 
construction.17  Parco's  first  ground  was  broken  on  April 
7,  1922.  Rapid  construction  followed.  By  March  of  the 
following  year,  the  refinery  had  begun  refining  10,000  bar- 
rels of  crude  oil  per  day. 

The  construction  company  of  C.  S.  Lambie  then 
began  the  task  of  replacing  the  temporary  tent  town  with 
permanent  housing  and  public  facilities.  Between  1923 
and  1925,  Frank  Kistler  and  William  and  Arthur  Fisher 
periodically  visited  Parco  to  oversee  the  construction  first- 
hand. By  August,  1925,  the  job  was  almost  complete.  One 
hundred  and  twenty  frame  houses,  each  with  a  front  porch 
and  carefully  manicured  lawn,  lined  the  landscaped 
streets.  In  addition,  numerous  residential,  commercial  and 
public  buildings  including  the  social  club,  school,  bank, 
depot  and  garage  enclosed  the  plaza.18 

From  the  beginning,  Parco  exhibited  a  functional 
blend  of  benevolent  paternalism  and  limited  self- 
government.  Employees  rented  their  homes  for  10  -  25  per- 
cent of  their  salary  while  merchants  leased  space  within 
the  commercial  buildings.  As  early  as  April,  1925,  the 
town  incorporated  as  a  distinct  entity,  and  elections  were 
held  the  following  month  to  select  the  city  mayor  and  other 
town  officials.19 

Frank  Kistler  and  the  owners  who  followed  him,  devel- 
oped a  personal  interest  in  the  management  and  preser- 
vation of  the  town.  Although  Fisher  and  Fisher  designed 
the  town's  distinctive  recreational  facilities  and  community 
church,  Kistler  and  subsequent  owners  ensured  that  these 
properties  were  well  maintained.  Moreover,  the  owners 


saa» 


i 


■ 


The  Sinclair  Theatre,  viewed  from  the  west  along  main  street,  1980. 


Exterior  of  the 
Parco  Inn,  1980. 


_, — "' 


charged  reasonable  rents,  landscaped  lawns,  and  main- 
tained parks,  plaza  streets  and  sidewalks. 

Hard  times  befell  Parco  during  the  Great  Depression, 
and  in  1934  Consolidated  Oil  (later  Sinclair  Refining  Com- 
pany) purchased  the  refinery,  townsite  and  oil  fields  for 
over  $7.7  million.  Sinclair  Refining  Company  continued 
to  modernize  and  expand  the  refinery  over  the  ensuing 
decades,  and  the  townspeople  responded  to  their  con- 
tinued prosperity  by  renaming  the  town  Sinclair  in 
December,  1942.  In  1967,  Sinclair  Refinery  Company  sold 
most  of  the  townsite  to  local  residents  at  modest  prices. 
After  merging  with  Sinclair  Refining  Company  in  1970, 
Atlantic  Richfield  Company  acquired  the  refinery  and 
associated  facilities.  The  refinery  and  oil  fields  then  passed 
through  a  series  of  complex  corporate  mergers  and  sales 
with  Amoco  eventually  obtaining  the  oil  fields  and  the 
recently  formed  Sinclair  Oil  Company,  headed  by  R.  E. 
Holding,  purchasing  the  refinery  in  July  of  1976. 20 

Altruism,  paternalism  and  enlightened  self-interest 
are  but  a  few  of  the  ambivalent  motives  surrounding  the 
creation  of  Parco,  Wyoming.  Although  Frank  Kistler  never 
committed  his  sentiments  to  paper,  he  undoubtedly  realiz- 
ed that  the  construction  of  a  company  town  would 
generate  profits  and  provide  a  dependable  insurance  policy 
against  possible  labor  unrest.  On  the  other  hand,  he  tru- 
ly wanted  to  create  a  "model"  company  town  where  the 
most  modern  of  residential  conveniences  could  be  found 
within  a  striking,  if  traditional,  Spanish  Colonial  building 
design.  The  prosperity  and  endurance  of  the  small  isolated 
community  attests  to  his  success. 

1.  "Parco,  Wyoming  Bids  World  to  Opening,"  Rocky  Mountain  News, 
August  2,  1925,  Parco,  Wyoming  Special  Section,  p.   1. 

2.  A  brief  discussion  of  the  evolution  in  industrial  town  planning 
can  be  found  in  Leland  M.  Roth,  "Three  Industrial  Towns  by 
McKim,  Mead  &  White,"/ourrca/  of  the  Society  of  Architectural 
Historians  38  (December  1979):  pp.  317-321. 

3.  Denver  Post,  July  26,  1959,  p.  4aa. 

4.  Town  of  Sinclair,  Parco:  Sinclair,  Wyoming,  (Sinclair,  Wyoming, 
1975). 


"Newest  Town  in  the  United  States  is  Fullfillment  of  Vision  and 
Monument  to  Frank  E.  Kistler,"  Denver  Post,  August  2,  1925,  Par- 
co, Wyoming  Special  Section,  p.  2. 

Sears,  Roebuck  and  Company,  Honor  Built  Modern  Homes, 
(Chicago- Philadelphia,  1926),  p.  4.  This  catalogue  contains 
several  pages  of  advertisements  which  describe  corporate  hous- 
ing projects. 

Leland  M.  Roth,  A  Concise  History  of  American  Architecture, 
(New  York:  Harper  &  Row,  Publishers,  1979),  pp.  220-224. 
Leifer  Magnussion,  "Housing  by  Employers  in  the  United  States," 
Bulletin  of  the  United  States,  Bureau  of  Labor  Statistics,  No.  263, 
(Washington,  D.C.:  U.S.  Government  Printing  Office.  1920),  pp. 
17-21. 

Letter,  William  Fisher  to  Frank  Kistler,  May  16,  1923,  Fisher  and 
Fisher  Collection,  Box  20,  File  Folder  11,  Western  History  Depart- 
ment, Denver  Public  Library,  (hereafter  referred  to  as  the  F  & 
F  Collection). 
Ibid. 

A  short  analysis  of  Bertram  Goodhue's  plan  for  Tyrone,  New  Mex- 
ico, can  be  found  in  Roth,  A  Concise  History  of  American  Arch- 
itecture, p.  220. 

Letter,  William  Fisher  to  Frank  Kistler,  May  16,   1923,  F  &  F 
Collection. 
Ibid. 

14.  The  original  linen  drawings,  site  plans,  street  plans  and  material 
specifications  for  Parco  can  be  found  in  the  F  &  F  Collection. 
Ibid 

Letter,  William  Fisher  to  Frank  Kistler,  August  22,  1923,  Box  20, 
File  Folder  11,  F  &  F  Collection. 

Letter,  William  Fisher  to  Frank  Kistler,  July  21,  1923,  Box  20, 
File  Folder  11,  F  &  F  Collection. 

Gilbert  Stanley  Underwood,  architect  for  the  Union  Pacific 
Railroad  and  designer  for  various  rustic  lodges  within  National 
Parks  in  the  Western  United  States,  prepared  the  drawings  for 
the  depot  in  Parco.  He  apparently  was  persuaded  by  Fisher  and 
Fisher  to  follow  their  general  design  suggestion.  See  for  example, 
William  Fisher  to  Frank  Kistler,  November  26,  1924.  F  &  F 
Collection. 

Town  of  Sinclair,  Parco  Sinclair,  Wyoming.  An  adequate  discus- 
sion of  the  sociology  of  company  towns  in  the  West  is  contained 
in  James  B.  Allen,  The  Company  Town  in  the  American  West, 
(Norman:  University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1966). 
Town  of  Sinclair,  Parco:  Sinclair,  Wyoming.  Interview  with  Ken- 
neth Knight,  Executive  Vice  President,  Sinclair  Oil  Company, 
Englewood,  Colorado,  May  12,  1982. 


12 


13. 


15, 
16. 

17. 

18. 


19. 


'10 


McCarthy  Era  Politics: 


The  Ordeal  of  Senator  Lester  Hunt 


By  Rick  Ewig 


The  fear  of  communism  constituted  one  of  the  most  explosive 
elements  in  American  life  and  politics  in  the  first  two  decades 
following  World  War  II. 

The  anti-communist  hysteria  reached  its  peak  in  the 
early  1950s,  the  so-called  "McCarthy  Era."  Although 
Senator  Joseph  R.  McCarthy  hecame  a  symbol  during 
these  years  of  America's  fight  against  "godless  com- 
munism," in  reality  it  was  a  much  broader  phenomenon. 
Wide  segments  of  American  society  — entertainment, 
business,  labor  and  education  — were  caught  up  in  the 
anti-communist  ferment.  Democrat  Harry  S.  Truman, 
with  his  1947  loyalty  review  program  and  his  red-baiting 
of  Progressive  Party  candidate  Henry  Wallace  in  the  1948 


V 


Sen.  McCarthy  arrives  at  a  Milwaukee  dinner  in  his  honor,  Dec.  11,  1951.  A  few  days  before  McCarthy  began  his  virulent 
anti- communist  campaign,  Congressman  Richard  Nixon  of  California  spoke  at  Lincoln  Day  Dinners  in  Cheyenne  anc 
Laramie  and  warned  that  "one  of  the  major  problems  facing  this  country  today — Communists  high  in  the  government 
of  this  country." 


presidential  election,  added  a  distinctly  bipartisan  flavor 
to  the  anti-communist  attack  — a  fact  until  recently 
overlooked  by  historians.1 

Because  of  the  celebrated  congressional  investigations 
of  the  period  and  McCarthy's  own  presence  in  the  United 
States  Senate,  few  institutions  in  American  government 
touched  by  the  communist  controversy  have  received  more 
scholarly  attention  than  the  senate  in  the  early  1950s. 
Clearly  at  times  the  "politics  of  fear"  virtually  paralyzed 
both  parties  in  the  upper  house,  and  — given  the  nearly 
even  division  among  Democrat  and  Republican  members 
—  party  strategists  sometimes  yielded  to  the  temptation 
to  use  the  communist  issue  (or  related  symbolic  questions) 
to  win  marginal  seats.  A  few  senators— William  Benton, 
Ralph  Flanders,  Margaret  Chase  Smith  and  others  — spoke 
out  forcefully  against  "McCarthyistic"  tactics,  but  until 
1954,  they  were  largely  unsuccessful.  Wyoming's  Lester 
C.  Hunt's  more  modest  role  in  the  controversy  has  largely 


10 


been  ignored  by  academics,  a  somewhat  unusual  fact  ii 
view  of  rumors  linking  the  senator's  suicide  to  "McCar 
thyistic"  tactics  by  his  opponents.2 

Lester  C.  Hunt,  born  in  1892  and  raised  in  a  poo 
Illinois  family,  put  himself  through  St.  Louis  Universit 
school  of  dentistry  by  working  as  a  switchman  on 
railroad.  Graduating  in  1917,  he  opened  a  practice  ii 
Lander,  Wyoming,  having  first  become  familiar  with  th< 
town  by  pitching  for  its  semi-pro  baseball  team  betweei 
spring  and  fall  semesters  and  working  as  a  bartender  ii 
the  evenings.  Hunt  continued  his  dental  career  until  thi 
1930s  when  politics  became  a  full-time  occupation.  Fre 
mont  County  voters  elected  him  to  the  state  legislatun 
as  a  Democrat  in  1932,  and  in  1934  he  won  his  first  o 
two  terms  as  Wyoming's  Secretary  of  State.  First  electee 
governor  in  1942,  he  served  six  years  in  the  state  house 
resigning  midway  through  his  second  term  after  a  sue 
cessful  race  for  the  United  States  Senate. 


Coming  from  a  sparsely-populated  conservative  West- 
ern state,  Hunt's  main  preoccupation  was  constituent  ser- 
vice, but  he  was  not  adverse  to  taking  liberal  stands  if  prin- 
ciples about  which  he  felt  strongly  were  involved.  In  his 
1948  senate  campaign,  Hunt  advocated  a  national  health 
program  in  which  the  federal  government  would  help 
finance  medical  research  and  education  and  assist  in  the 
building  of  hospitals.  He  also  supported  a  reduction  of 
taxes  by  giving  proportionately  greater  relief  to  the  millions 
of  low  income  families  and  repeal  of  the  Taft-Hartley  Act 
which  had  "encouraged  litigation  in  labor  disputes  and  « 
disappointed  the  established  American  policy  of  collec- 
tive bargaining."3  While  in  the  senate,  Hunt  co-signed  a 
letter  addressed  to  President  Truman  calling  for  worldwide 
communication  and  disarmament.4  Senator  Hunt  and  the 
views  he  held  can  be  classified  as  those  of  a  moderate 
liberal. 

Serving  on  the  Armed  Services  Committee,  on  the 
District  of  Columbia  Committee,  briefly  on  the  Rules  and 
Administration  Committee  until  he  became  a  member  of 
the  Committee  on  Interstate  and  Foreign  Commerce  and 
on  the  Kefauver  Crime  Investigation  Committee,  through 
which  he  became  a  minor  national  figure,  Hunt  main- 
tained his  political  independence.  He  supported  Eisen- 
hower's foreign  policy,  and  when  offered  a  position  on  the 
Democratic  Steering  Committee  of  the  Senate,  he  refused, 
saying  he  wished  to  be  free  of  any  obligations  so  he  could 
act  independently  on  all  senate  matters.  Hunt  "was  will- 
ing to  forego  the  policy  of  his  party  whenever  he  felt  it 
came  in  conflict  with  the  best  interests  of  the  people  he 
had  been  chosen  to  serve."5 

As  Sen.  Hunt  entered  office,  a  growing  preoccupa- 
tion with  domestic  communism  was  beginning  to  take 
shape  in  Washington.  The  House  Un-American  Activities 
Committee  searched  for  communist  influence  in  govern- 
ment and  entertainment;  the  Hiss  Case  attracted  popular 
attention;  and  the  Soviet  Union's  detonation  of  its  first 
atomic  bomb  set  off  widespread  fear  of  foreign  espionage. 
Hunt  shared  the  broader  concern  with  communism,6  but 
he  did  not  approve  of  the  methods  employed  in  fighting 
the  "red  menace"  by  such  men  as  McCarthy.  According 
to  Lester  Hunt,  Jr., 

.  .  .  one  of  the  things  that  was  important  to  him  about 
McCarthy,  not  so  much  the  whole  red  thing,  [that]  my  father 
was  not  particularly  worried  about.  He  was  afraid  of  com- 
munists, too,  so  it  didn't  worry  him  that  McCarthy  was  out 
to  get  the  reds  if  there  were  any,  as  much  as  it  did  the  way 
he  went  about  it,  and  the  use  he  made  of  his  senate  position 
[which]  my  father  really  resented.7 
Hunt  did  not  believe  the  office  of  United  States  Senator 
should  be  degraded  in  the  anti-communist  crusade. 

Sen.  Hunt  had  a  strong  personal  dislike  for  McCar- 
thy. He  saw  the  junior  senator  from  Wisconsin  as  "an 
'opportunist,  and  liar,  and  drunk  ....  We  used  to  sit  on 
our  front  porch  and  could  see  McCarthy  guzzling  away 
with  his  girlfriend  in  the  back  yard.  To  my  father  that 
was  just  awful,  that  kind  of  behavior.  It  demeaned  the 


senate,  demeaned  the  position,  made  people  think  poorly 
of  politicians."  On  one  occasion,  a  plane  carrying  both 
Hunt  and  McCarthy  was  forced  down  in  Pittsburgh,  com- 
pelling the  two  senators  to  share  a  hotel  room  for  the  night. 
According  to  his  son,  ".  .  .  Hunt  was  in  .  .  .  fits.  You  [would 
have]  thought  he  had  just  been  with  a  murderer  or  a  Nazi. 
He  felt  unclean  about  having  associated  with  that  per- 
son. He  really  had  a  strong  distaste  for  him  personally."8 
Apparently,  Sen.  Hunt  first  confronted  the  McCar- 
thy techniques  during  the  Malmedy  hearings.  A  number 
of  German  prisoners,  who  had  been  convicted  and  sen- 
tenced for  killing  approximately  150  unarmed  American 
soldiers  at  the  Belgian  village  of  Malmedy  during  the  Bat- 
tle of  the  Bulge,  accused  their  United  States  Army  inter- 
rogators and  prosecutors  of  beating  and  torturing  them, 
and  tricking  them  into  signing  confessions.  An  Armed 
Forces  Subcommittee,  composed  of  Hunt,  Democrat  Estes 
Kefauver  of  Tennessee  and  Connecticut  Republican  Ray- 
mond Baldwin,  investigated  the  charges.  Senator  McCar- 
thy, although  he  was  not  a  member  of  the  subcommit- 
tee, took  up  the  cause  of  the  German  prisoners.  The  chair- 
man, Senator  Baldwin,  in  general,  defended  the  military 
proceedings,  while  McCarthy,  possibly  to  endear  himself 
to  Wisconsin's  large  German  population  and  perhaps  gain 
some  national  headlines,  attacked  the  Army.  While  never 
questioning  the  affidavits  of  the  German  prisoners,  the 
Wisconsin  Senator  accused  the  American  interrogators 
and  prosecutors  of  lying  and  demanded  they  take  lie- 
detector  tests.  When  the  subcommittee  rejected  this  idea, 
McCarthy  charged  his  colleagues  were  conducting  a 
"whitewash"  and  stormed  out  of  the  proceedings. 

Today  when  I  find  the  junior  Senator  from  Wyoming 
and  the  Senator  from  Connecticut  very  obviously  afraid  of 
the  results  of  a  lie-detector  test,  I  can  only  conclude  that 
I  have  confirmed  all  of  the  things  that  disturbed  me  greatly 
all  along,  and  that  was  that  this  committee  is  not  concerned 
with  getting  the  facts  .  .  .  .' 

While  the  subcommittee  ultimately  upheld  most  of  the 
original  military  verdicts,  Baldwin  had  been  so  stung  by 
the  incident  he  shortly  thereafter  seized  the  opportunity 
to  leave  elective  politics  for  a  seat  on  the  Connecticut 
Supreme  Court.10  Although  rather  subdued  throughout 
the  hearings,  Sen.  Hunt  must  have  been  somewhat  pained 
by  the  encounter. 

Sen.  McCarthy  easily  made  the  transition  from  de- 
fending German  prisoners  to  attacking  people  he  con- 
sidered communists.  Although  he  had  dabbled  in  the  issue 
before,"  McCarthy's  anti-communist  campaign  really 
began  February  9,  1950,  in  Wheeling,  West  Virginia, 
when  he  accused  the  State  Department  of  harboring  205 
known  communists  or  party  loyalists.  On  February  20,  he 
took  his  case  to  the  senate  floor  and  detailed  57  cases  of 
"known"  communists  in  the  Department  of  State  —  a  move 
which  led  the  Senate  Foreign  Relations  Committee  to  set 
up  a  subcommittee  to  investigate  the  charges.1* 

The  Democrats  on  the  subcommittee,  led  by  chair- 


is 


11 


man  Millard  Tydings  of  Maryland,  found  McCarthy's 
charges  to  be  unsubstantiated.  The  Democratic  majority 
report  accused  the  Wisconsin  Senator  of  conducting  a 
"fraud  and  hoax"  and  "perhaps  the  most  nefarious  cam- 
paign of  half-truths  and  untruth[s]  in  the  history  of  the 
Republic."13  The  Tydings  report  became  an  issue  in  par- 
tisan politics,  with  the  Democrats  generally  supporting 
it  and  the  Republicans  calling  the  investigation  inade- 
quate. Maine  Senator  Margaret  Chase  Smith  and  six  other 
Republican  moderates  issued  a  "Declaration  of  Con- 
science" acknowledging  the  communist  threat,  but  also 
charging  that  the  senate  had  become  a  "forum  of  hate 
and  character  assassination  sheltered  by  the  shield  of  con- 
gressional immunity"14  Most  moderate  Republicans,  how- 
ever, still  considered  the  Tydings  report  as  excessively  par- 
tisan and  resisted  the  efforts  of  the  Democrats  to  shift  the 
focus  of  attention  from  communism  to  McCarthy's  tac- 
tics. With  the  tacit  support  of  the  Republican  party, 
McCarthy  continued  to  speak  of  "reds"  in  government, 
unimpeded  by  the  subcommittee's  majority  report.15 

The  Wisconsin  Senator  also  turned  his  attention  to 
the  1950  elections,  and  one  in  which  he  was  directly 
involved  was  John  Marshall  Butler's  successful  quest  for 
Tydings'  senate  seat.  McCarthy,  "nourishing  a  desire  for 
revenge,"  joined  Butler  in  his  campaign  by  giving  speeches, 
financial  support  and  aid  in  producing  campaign 
literature.16  The  Washington  Times-Herald,  owned  by 
Robert  R.  McCormick  and  published  by  his  niece  Ruth 
McCormick  Miller,  supported  Butler  and  attacked  Tydings 
on  the  editorial  page  while  also  publishing,  at  a  nominal 
cost,  the  campaign  pamphlet  "From  the  Record,"  which 
accused  Tydings  of  conducting  a  "whitewash"  instead  of 
an    investigation    and    listed    other    unsubstantiated 


"facts"  about  the  communist  leanings  of  Tydings  and  his 
wife.  The  Maryland  Democrat  attempted  to  counter  the 
"whitewash"  charge  by  pointing  out  that  McCarthy  had 
refused  to  repeat  the  charges  without  the  benefit  of  con- 
gressional immunity  but  he  lost  the  election  after  the 
Butler  forces  distributed  a  doctored  "composite"  picture 
of  Tydings  listening  intentively  to  Earl  Browder,  the  leader 
of  the  United  States  Communist  Party.17  Two  observers  con- 
cluded that  McCarthy  and  the  McCormick  press  had  par- 
ticipated in  ".  .  .  the  foulest  episode  in  recent  Amer- 
ican political  history  .  .  .[,]  approaching  Hitler  terror- 
ism."18 

McCarthy's  distorted  anti-communist  campaign 
against  Tydings  was  not  an  isolated  incident  in  1950.  In 
Idaho,  Senator  Glen  H.  Taylor,  who  had  run  for  vice- 
president  on  Henry  Wallace's  Progressive  Party  ticket  in 
1948,  was  seeking  reelection  against  Republican  hopeful 
Herman  Welker,  a  Payette  attorney.  With  the  aid  of  the 
Idaho  Daily  Statesman,  a  Boise  newspaper  which  had 
always  been  critical  of  Taylor,  Welker  successfully  linked 
Taylor  to  the  communist  cause  and  defeated  the  incum- 
bent. The  political  editor  of  the  Daily  Statesman  conceded 
that  he  had  purposely  ran  a  campaign  "under  the  direc- 
tion of  my  publisher  and  editor,  to  destroy  a  person  and 
that  person's  philosophy."19 

Such  techniques  of  political  campaigning  as  practiced 
against  Tydings  and  Taylor  worried  other  senators.  Not 
only  did  the  McCarthyistic  tactics  frighten  senators,  but 
so  did  the  presence  of  McCarthy.  Many  believed  at  the 
time  that  McCarthy  had  defeated  Tydings,  and  by  1953, 
the  Wisconsin  Senator  had  personally  taken  credit  for 
nearly  a  dozen  victories.  Although  subsequent  research 
has  shown  that  his  senate  colleagues  exaggerated  McCar- 


Sen.  Welker  standing  in  front  of 
Lincoln  statue.  Welker  was  a  leader 
of  the  group  which  opposed  efforts 
to  censure  Sen.  McCarthy  in  1954. 


12 


thy's  electoral  influence,  at  the  time,  it  seemed  very  real.20 
Clinton  Anderson,  Democrat  from  New  Mexico,  publicly 
pondered  what  use  opponents  might  make  of  a  picture 
he  had  once  seen  of  a  skinny-dipping  colleague.21 

As  a  result  of  the  tactics  used  against  Tydings,  the 
Senate  Privileges  and  Elections  Subcommittee  investigated 
the  Maryland  election.  The  subcommittee's  report  rec- 
ognized the  insidious  part  McCarthy  had  played  in  Butler's 
campaign,  and  although  the  subcommittee  members  left 
little  doubt  about  their  hostile  attitudes  toward  McCar- 
thy's activities,  they  phrased  their  report  in  words 
upholding  senatorial  tradition  and  courtesy,  a  fact 
diminishing  its  immediate  impact.  The  report  also  failed 
to  suggest  any  action  against  Butler  and  only  vaguely 
referred  to  measures  to  deal  with  such  future  misdeeds. 
The  Maryland  Report  was  only  a  slight  reproach,  and 
although  it  would  play  an  important  role  in  McCarthy's 
eventual  censure,  the  immediate  effects  were  minimal.22 

McCarthy,  meanwhile,  continued  to  ignore  senatorial 
:ourtesy,  which  in  time  led  the  senate  to  take  action  against 
him.  Senator  William  Benton,  Democrat  from  Connec- 
:icut,  hoped  to  use  the  Maryland  Report  to  have  McCar- 
:hy  expelled  from  the  senate,  and  in  August  of  1951,  ask- 
?d  the  Privileges  and  Election  Subcommittee  to  explore 
expulsion  charges  against  the  Wisconsin  Republican.  Most 
senators,  seeing  little  precedent  for  expulsion  and  fear- 
ing an  open  fight  with  McCarthy,  hoped  to  back  away 
xom  Benton's  resolution;  unquestioningly  some  hoped 
yVisconsin  voters  would  oust  McCarthy  in  the  1952  elec- 
tion, thereby  resolving  their  problem.  McCarthy,  however, 
rontinued  on  the  attack  against  several  colleagues,  par- 
ticularly Thomas  Hennings  of  Missouri,  a  member  of  the 
Elections  Subcommittee.  McCarthy  called  upon  the 
Missouri  Senator  to  resign  his  subcommittee  post  because 
a  law  partner  of  Hennings  had  once  defended  a  com- 
munist and  because  Hennings  remained  as  legal  counsel 
tor  the  St.  Louis  Post  Dispatch,  which,  according  to 
McCarthy,  opposed  his  anti-communist  fight  along  the 
:;ame  lines  as  the  communist  Daily  Worker.23  Unable  to 
overlook  McCarthy's  disregard  of  senate  norms  any  longer, 
he  subcommittee  in  late  1951  began  investigating  Ben- 
ion's  charges.24 

The  steps  taken  against  McCarthy  by  the  senate 
amounted  to  little,  however,  as  he  was  able  to  stymie  most 
assaults  by  attacking  his  accusers.  McCarthy  verbally 
assaulted  the  subcommittee  members,  instituted  a  two- 
fnillion  dollar  libel  suit  against  Benton  and  in  April  of 
1952,  introduced  Senate  Resolution  304,  a  proposal  to  in- 
vestigate Benton's  conduct  when  he  served  in  the  State 
Department.  With  the  defeat  of  Benton  in  the  1952  elec- 
ion  and  McCarthy's  own  reelection,  the  hope  of  forceful 
action  against  the  troublesome  senator  dimmed.  The  sub- 
tommittee's  report  of  January,  1953,  listed  McCarthy's 
abuses,  but  did  not  recommend  any  specific  action  against 
him.  He  had  ridden  out  the  storm,  but  senate  opposi- 


tion had  begun  to  form  against  him  and  the  practices  he 
epitomized.25 

While  Benton  and  others  waged  a  direct  frontal 
attack,  various  senators  attempted  to  halt  McCarthy  and 
his  abuses  indirectly  by  introducing  proposals  for  struc- 
tural reform  in  the  senate.  In  January,  1951,  Paul  Doug- 
las, Illinois'  highly  respected  senator,  suggested  that  peo- 
ple attacked  by  a  committee  be  able  to  insert  into  the  per- 
manent record  a  letter  of  rebuttal,  to  testify  on  their  own 
behalf,  to  cross-examine  their  accusers  and  to  have  the 
right  to  call  supportive  witnesses.  On  behalf  of  nine  other 
Democrats  and  eight  Republicans,  Senator  Estes  Kefauver 
sponsored  a  resolution  similar  to  that  of  Douglas.26 

Sen.  Hunt,  meanwhile,  hoped  to  halt  the  broader 
abuses  involved  in  the  tradition  of  congressional  immun- 
ity. Hunt  had  recognized  the  dangers  inherent  in  such  an 
atmosphere  of  abuse  when  he  noted  in  1951  that 
".  .  .  [t]here  have  been  many  suicides  due  to  the  smear- 
ing received  either  in  Committee  hearings  or  from  remarks  : 
made  in  the  United  States  Congress."27  Congressional  Bill 
S.782,  introduced  by  Hunt  in  early  1951,  provided  "for 
civil  suits  against  the  United  States  by  persons  suffering 
damages  as  a  result  of  defamations  committed  by  Mem- 
bers of  Congress  in  the  course  of  their  official  activities."28 
Outraged  by  senatorial  attacks  on  the  President,  cabinet 
members  and  other  high  officials,29  Hunt  cited  three  par- 
ticular dangers  in  an  article  in  the  New  York  Times  Mag- 
azine of  June  24,  1951.  First,  "unscrupulous"  legislators, 
by  bringing  false  charges  against  government  employees, 
might  undermine  any  confidence  the  American  people 
had  in  public  servants.  Second,  a  congressman,  with  no 
fear  of  retribution,  could  verbally  attack  an  individual, 
thereby  giving  himself  unjustified  publicity  and  possibly 
becoming  a  "man  to  be  feared."  Third,  the  person  attacked 
could  be  placed  in  double  jeopardy,  first  being  tried  in 
the  press  and  Congress,  and  then  possibly  in  a  court  of 
law.30 

While  Democratic  Representative  Winfield  K.  Den- 
ton from  Indiana  sponsored  Hunt's  bill  in  the  House,31 
most  legislators  apparently  felt  the  proposal  too  extreme, 
and  it  failed  in  Congress.  Hunt  believed,  however,  that 
if  certain  members  of  Congress  would  not  abide  by  the 
"rules  of  justice  and  fair  play,"  then  the  remaining 
legislators  should  take  "drastic  steps"  to  control  the 
culpable  ones.32  He  continued  to  speak  out  on  this  issue, 
but  the  needed  support  never  coalesced.33 

Meanwhile,  Hunt  observed  the  use  of  the  communist 
issue  in  Wyoming  when  Republican  Frank  Barrett 
defeated  veteran  Democratic  Senator  Joseph  O'Mahoney 
in  the  1952  election.  Of  course  other  issues  were  involved 
in  the  campaign,  but  Barrett  used  the  "red"  issue  effec- 
tively by  accusing  O'Mahoney  of  being  "part  of  the 
Democratic  'Red  coddling'  and  corruption  and  bungling 
which  had  nearly  lost  the  peace  after  World  War  II."34 
Sen.  McCarthy,  campaigning  in  Fremont  County,  Wyo- 
ming, on  behalf  of  Barrett,  supported  the  Republican 


13 


Sen.  McCarthy  and  Dwight 
Eisenhower  in  1952  cam- 
paigning on  the  Eisenhower 
Special. 


candidate's  promise  to  drive  the  communists  out  of  gov- 
ernment. McCarthy's  reception  clearly  distressed  Lester 
Hunt. 

I  remember  in  the  fall  of  1952  when  the  Senator  spoke  in 
our  county  and  the  gentleman  who  introduced  him  put  his 
arm  around  him  and  said,  "I  am  beginning  to  love  Joe 
McCarthy",  [sic]  and  I  fear  Senator  McCarthy  made  a  most 
favorable  impression  on  the  people  attending  that  picnic.35 

After  the  election  of  Dwight  D.  Eisenhower  in  1952, 
Sen.  Hunt  hoped  the  new  president  would  help  under- 
cut McCarthy's  bases  of  support  inside  the  Republican  par- 
ty. Seeing  the  Wisconsin  Senator's  star  descending.  Hunt, 
in  March  of  1953,  predicted  an  open  break  between  the 
Administration  and  McCarthy.36  Eisenhower,  however, 
fearing  McCarthy  would  only  gain  additional  publicity 
from  such  an  intraparty  fight,  adopted  a  much  more 
passive  attitude  than  Hunt  anticipated.37  By  March  of 
1954,  Hunt's  optimism  had  faded  as  he  believed  it  is  "hard- 
ly to  be  expected  that  Eisenhower  could  control  McCar- 
thy even  if  he  took  a  stand  .  .  .  The  encouragement  that 
the  Senator  has  received  all  along  from  members  of  his 
own  party  is  responsible  to  a  great  degree  for  the  situa- 
tion we  are  now  in."38 

Some  of  Hunt's  concern  over  the  volatile  anti- 
communist  issue  may  well  have  sprung  from  his  own  polit- 
ical situation.  Given  the  nearly  even  split  in  the  senate, 
his  seat  was  almost  certain  to  be  hotly  contested  by  the 


Republicans  in  1954.  At  the  same  time,  moreover,  physical 
and  emotional  strain  on  the  61-year-old  senator  had  begun 
to  mount.  In  January  of  1951,  he  had  had  a  minor  opera- 
tion, and  in  1952,  he  had  had  a  cyst  removed  from  his 
side.  Following  that  operation,  his  hands  would  swell  when 
he  exerted  himself  physically.39  His  brother  Clyde's  suicide 
on  April  8,  1952,  must  also  have  affected  Hunt  emotion- 
ally.40 

Another  stressful  period  occurred  after  his  son's  arrest 
and  conviction  on  a  morals  charge.  On  June  9,  1953, 
Lester  C.  Hunt,  Jr.,  the  president  of  the  student  body  at 
the  Episcopal  Theological  School  of  Cambridge,  Massa- 
chusetts, and  an  activist  in  the  fight  against  what  he 
believed  to  be  attacks  on  civil  liberties,  was  arrested  in 
a  Washington,  D.C.,  park  after  agreeing  to  engage  in  a 
homosexual  act.  Because  the  charge  was  only  a  misde- 
meanor and  his  first  offense,  the  police  agreed  not  to  pros- 
ecute Hunt,  Jr. ,  and  the  young  man  shortly  thereafter  went 
to  Cuba,  where  he  worked  for  the  Episcopal  Church  for 
the  summer.  Meanwhile,  a  friend  of  Sen.  Hunt's  in  Wyo- 
ming apparently  received  a  call  from  Senator  Herman 
Welker,  promising  that  Hunt,  Jr. ,  would  not  be  prosecuted 
if  Hunt  himself  did  not  seek  reelection.41 

Refusing  to  be  "blackmailed"  out  of  office,  Hunt 
rejected  the  offer,  after  which  Welker  along  with  Senator 
Styles   Bridges   of  New   Hampshire,    Chairman   of  the 


14 


Republican  Campaign  Committee,  and  a  right-wing 
Republican  newspaper  apparently  carried  through  with 
the  threat.42  On  July  3,  three  weeks  after  the  Hunt  arrest, 
the  McCormick-owned  Washington  Times-Herald  printed 
a  story  on  the  incident.  At  the  same  time  Welker  and 
Bridges  seem  to  have  contacted  Inspector  Roy  Blick,  Assis- 
tant to  the  Deputy  Chief  of  the  Morals  Division  of  the 
Metropolitan  Police  Department.  The  two  senators 
allegedly  attempted  to  pressure  Blick  into  having  Hunt, 
[r. ,  prosecuted.  Disregarding  Blick's  arguments  that  nor- 
mal procedure  had  been  followed  in  the  Hunt  case,  Welker 
said  he  might  be  obligated  to  make  a  speech  on  the  senate 
floor  on  the  matter.  In  October,  1953,  Hunt's  case  came 
to  trial.43 

Judge  John  J.  Malloy  found  Lester  Hunt,  Jr.,  guilty 
3f  soliciting  a  plainclothes  police  officer  for  lewd  and  im- 
moral purposes,  and  concluded  the  trial  with  the  state- 
nent  that  ".  .  .  [t]he  charge  .  .  .  [was]  one  of  the  most 
iegrading  that  .  .  .  [could]  be  made  against  a  man."44 
Instead  of  filing  an  appeal,  which  only  would  have 
ittracted  more  publicity,  Hunt,  Jr.,  paid  the  $100  fine.45 
Sen.  Hunt  feared  his  son's  trial  would  be  used  against 
lim  in  his  race  for  reelection.  "If  the  opposition  brings 
his  up  in  the  Senate  race,"  he  allegedly  told  Drew  Pear- 
on,  "I  shall  withdraw."  Hunt  also  was  reported  to  have 
old  a  member  of  Pearson's  staff  that  he  could  not  bear  g 
o  face  his  senate  colleagues  and  might  not  ever  appear 
>n  the  senate  floor  again.46  Sen.  Hunt  also  felt  a  good 
leal  of  parental  guilt.  According  to  Hunt,  Jr.,  "I  think 
ny  father  was  very  upset  and  he  felt  a  real  guilt  about 
leglect,  things  like  working  so  hard,  not  paying  atten- 
jion  to  me.  He  thought  it  might  have  made  a  difference. 
He  didn't  talk  about  it  much,  but  it  was  pretty  clear."47 
Obviously  this  unhappy  event  affected  Sen.  Hunt  very 
Jeeply. 

The  fear  that  his  son's  incident  might  be  used  against 
jiim  —  that  the  facts  "would  find  their  way  into  every  mail- 
box in  Wyoming"48  plus  a  variety  of  other  problems 
learly  contributed  to  an  ambivalence  Hunt  felt  about 
unning  for  reelection.  He  did  not  want  it  to  appear  as 
he  had  deserted  the  Democratic  party,  and  yet  he  would 
ave  preferred  not  to  run  if  a  reason  could  be  found  to 
jstify  that  course  of  action.  Writing  to  Dr.  P.  M.  Cun- 
,ingham,  Hunt  stated: 

The  desire  to  control  the  Senate  is  intense  among  both  the 
Democrats  and  Republicans,  and  I  think  Bob  [Kerr,  Demo- 
crat from  Oklahoma]  is  right  — my  Democratic  colleagues 
would  not  feel  as  kindly  toward  me  if  I  were  not  a  candidate 
as  they  would  if  I  did  try  and  then  was  defeated.49 

i  few  months  later  Hunt  wrote  to  Henry  Watenpaugh. 

Would  you  be  kind  enough  some  time  during  the  month 
of  February  to  give  me  your  suggestions  with  reference  to 
running  again.  I  am  not  looking  for  encouragement,  Henry. 
Fact  of  the  matter  is  I  would  appreciate  some  discourage- 
ment if  I  could  get  enough  to  justify  my  getting  out  of  the 
game.50 

After  a  period  of  genuine  ambivalence,   however, 


Above:  Frank  Barrett.  Below:  Styles  Bridges. 


15 


Hunt  announced  his  decision  to  seek  reelection  in  April 
of  1954.  Explaining  why  he  chose  to  run,  Hunt  wrote: 

...  as  I  surveyed  the  field  in  Wyoming.  I  couldn't  think  of 
another  Democrat  that  could  make  the  race  for  the  Senate. 
I  could  not  bring  myself  to  letting  down  those  fine  friends, 
like  yourself  who  have  stood  by  me  all  through  the  years.51 

Optimism  prevailed  as  it  was  believed  that  even  Hunt, 
Jr.'s,  trial,  if  used,  would  work  to  Hunt's  advantage. 

Personally,  I  think  that  from  a  political  standpoint  any 
effort  that  Lester's  opponents  try  to  make  of  his  unfortunate 
family  experience  will  not  only  mitigate  against  them  but 
will  boomerang  to  the  point  that  they  will  forever  leave  their 
opponent's  personal  misfortune  out  of  a  political  campaign.52 

Such  optimism  was  apparently  justified  as  Sen.  Hunt 
remained  personally  popular  in  his  home  state.  Having 
never  lost  an  election,  and  after  defeating  the  incumbent 
senator  in  1948  by  over  20,000  votes,  his  chances  in  1954 
■  looked  good.  Former  Wyoming  Senator  Joseph  O'Maho- 
ney  observed  that  ".  .  .  [r]eports  from  Wyoming  have  con- 
tinued to  be  very  encouraging  and  I  feel  confident  .  .  . 
that  he  will  be  reelected."53  The  results  of  a  statewide  poll 
showed  Hunt  receiving  54.4  percent  of  the  votes  cast.54 

Despite  optimism  about  his  chances  in  Democratic 
circles,  Hunt  was  apparently  under  intense  and  mount- 
ing pressure  to  reverse  his  decision.  A  pro-Hunt  legislator, 
Robert  S.  Lowe,  later  charged  that  Hunt's  home  and  office 
phones  were  tapped  and  his  Washington  apartment  once 
ransacked,  and  that  his  son's  trial  would  be  exploited  in 
the  campaign  if  Hunt  ran  again.55  Apparently  unable  to 
stand  the  escalating  pressure  and  harassment.  Hunt  with- 
drew from  the  race  in  June.56  It  is  unclear  what  exactly 
caused  Hunt  to  change  his  mind  so  suddenly,  but  one  can 
surmise  that  the  fear  of  his  son's  trial  being  used  against 
him  in  a  campaign,  which  would  not  only  reflect  poorly 
on  his  son  but  possibly  also  on  what  he  perceived  to  be 
his  failure  as  a  father,  must  have  been  one  factor  in  his 
decision. 

Not  only  was  Hunt  pressured  not  to  run  again,  but 
also  to  resign  immediately.  If  his  seat  were  vacated,  Wyo- 
ming's Republican  governor,  C.J.  Rogers,  could  appoint 
a  Republican  senator  to  finish  out  Hunt's  term,  thereby 
giving  the  Republicans  an  immediate  gain  in  the  hotly 
contested  senate.  High  level  Republican  officials  tried  to 
buy  Hunt  off  by  offering  him  a  $15,000  per  year  position 
on  the  Federal  Tariff  Commission57  — a  practice  appar- 
ently not  uncommon.  Leonard  W.  Hall.  Republican  Na- 
tional Committee  Chairman,  admitted  this  general  prac- 
tice in  a  letter  to  White  House  Chief  of  Staff  Sherman 
Adams.  Being  concerned  with  the  possibility  of  such  sen- 
sitive negotiations  becoming  public,  which  certainly  would 
have  embarrassed  Hunt,  Hall  wrote: 

.  .  .  [A]  Democrat  incumbent  would  be  put  in  the  position 
of  dealing  with  us  behind  the  leadership  of  his  own  party 
and  instead  of  accomplishing  our  objective  — gaining  a  close 
seat  in  the  crucial  Congressional  fight  next  November  — we 
would  probably  end  up  destroying  a  Democrat  politically 
who  was  otherwise  friendly.58 


Apparently  finding  the  offer  appealing,  Hunt  — a  man  of 
modest  financial  means  — asked  for  time  to  think  over  the 
Tariff  Commission  appointment,  but  he  eventually  replied 
negatively.  "Last  week  Hunt  told  the  person  who  had  ap- 
proached him  about  the  job  — a  person  not  directly  con- 
nected with  the  White  House  that  he  could  not  take  it 
because  Wyoming  Democrats  were  putting  'heat'  on  him 
not  to  give  up  his  senate  seat."59 

Countering  the  pressures  employed  by  the  Republicans 
to  induce  Hunt  to  surrender  his  seat,  the  Senator  also 
received  pressure  from  his  supporters  to  seek  a  second 
term.  Former  Sen.  Joseph  O'Mahoney  hoped  to  persuade 
the  Senator  to  "withdraw  the  withdrawal,"  and  continued 
in  this  endeavor  up  to  Hunt's  death,60  but  to  no  avail.  Hunt 
explained  his  decision  not  to  run  by  pleading  ill  health,61 
possibly  a  genuine  reason  and  possibly  only  a  convenient 
excuse  to  escape  the  mounting  pressure  from  all  quarters. 
He  had  been  undergoing  tests  at  Bethesda  Naval  Hospital 
and  he  believed  his  health  had  been  deteriorating  for  two 
years.62  As  Hunt  explained  to  Barnet  Nover,  Chief  of  the 
Denver  Post  Washington  Bureau, 

I'm  61  and  the  checkups  I  have  had  at  Bethesda  (Naval 
Hospital)  showed  I  have  a  bad  kidney  condition.  Don't  make 
any  mistake.  I  am  not  at  death's  door  or  anything  like  it. 
But  I  may  need  surgery  and  I  do  need  a  rest.  Under  the  cir- 
cumstances I  decided  that  I  had  better  get  out  now  [rather] 
than  possibly  make  things  worse  for  myself  if  I  didn't.63 

Some  people  believed  his  condition  to  be  serious,  while 
others  did  not  think  he  was  ill  at  all.64  Whichever  it  was, 
the  Senator  appeared  to  be  tormented  by  his  dilemma 
and  genuinely  concerned  about  his  health.  He  must  also 
have  been  mindful  of  the  physical  pain  that  a  necessarily 
grueling  political  campaign  would  entail  for  him  in  Wyo- 
ming.65 

Sen.  Hunt  did  not  have  to  face  these  and  possibly 
other  pressures66  for  very  long.  On  Saturday,  June  19, 
1954,  Hunt  drove  to  the  Capitol,  calmly  greeted  the 
policeman  on  duty,  and  proceeded  to  his  office.  He  car- 
ried a  .22  caliber  rifle  partially  hidden  under  his  coat. 
Once  in  his  office,  he  shot  himself  in  the  head,  and  died 
a  few  hours  later.67  Apparently  seeing  "no  available  path 
that  [might]  lead  to  a  tolerable  existence,"68  Sen.  Hunt 
chose  the  most  drastic  solution,  suicide  — what  three  auth- 
orities call  "the  end  of  a  process  of  extremely  frustrating 
events."69  Some  people  wanted  him  to  seek  reelection, 
others  wanted  him  to  give  up  his  seat.  Pressed  by  his  party 
and  long-time  supporters  to  run,  Hunt  must  have  dreaded 
the  physical  rigors  and  pains  of  the  campaign  and  the 
exploitation  of  his  son's  trial  by  his  opponents.  (Thirty- 
six  Wyoming  papers  had  not  carried  the  story  earlier.) 
Efforts  to  avoid  the  situation  altogether  by  claiming  ill 
health  clearly  had  not  been  convincing  to  some  of  his 
followers.  Whatever  his  private  reasons.  Hunt's  brother's 
suicide,  carried  out  in  the  same  way  and  at  approximately 
the  same  age,  probably  made  the  Senator  more  predis- 
posed to  taking  his  own  life.  "...  [I]n  general  it  appears 


16 


that  experience  of  a  suicide  in  a  family  increases  the 
likelihood  of  other  family  members  committing  suicide."70 

Sen.  Hunt  did  leave  several  letters  on  his  desk  that 
morning,  but  none  of  these  gives  any  explanation  which 
sheds  light  on  the  real  reason  or  reasons.  One  was  to  Per 
cy  Spencer,  the  president  of  the  Sinclair  Oil  Company, 
asking  him  to  help  Lester,  Jr.,  find  a  job.  Another  was 
to  his  wife  and  was  just  "an  ordinary  sort  of  note,"  and 
a  third  was  to  his  son,  simply  saying  that  it  had  nothing 
to  do  with  him.71  Most  of  the  newspaper  reports  explained 
his  death  by  stating  that  Hunt  was  despondent  over  his 
health.  At  the  Senator's  funeral,  the  Hunt  family  learned 
from  Dr.  Pearly  Cunningham,  a  dentist  from  Cheyenne 
and  dental  school  classmate  of  Hunt,  that  the  Senator  had 
told  him  he  had  leukemia.72  While  acknowledging  the 
health  worries,  columnists  Drew  Pearson  and  Marquis 
Childs  for  the  first  time  wrote  articles  publicly  accusing 
Welker  and  Bridges  of  attempting  to  "blackmail"  Hunt 
and  they  linked  these  activities  to  the  suicide. 

Shortly  thereafter,  Welker  and  Bridges  attempted  to 
refute  the  Pearson-Childs  charges.  A  conversation  was 
transcribed  between  Welker,  Bridges,  Inspector  Roy  Blick 
and  Kenneth  Darnall  Wood,  a  United  States  Prosecutor. 
After  this  conversation  Blick  signed  an  affidavit  on  July 
p,  1954,  in  which  he  certified  and  stated: 

1.   That  Senator  Bridges  of  New  Hampshire  did  not 


call  me  to  his  office  to  discuss  the  so-called  Hunt 
case. 

2.  At  no  time  anywhere  did  Senator  Bridges  of  New 
Hampshire  or  Senator  Welker  of  Idaho  hand  me 
an  envelope  or  any  papers. 

3.  At  no  time  and  no  place  did  Senator  Bridges  of 
New  Hampshire  or  Senator  Welker  of  Idaho  say 
to  me  or  to  anyone  in  my  presence:  "Inspector,  this 
is  your  resignation.  If  you  do  not  prosecute  the 
Hunt  boy,  your  resignation  will  be  accepted 
immediately."73 

This  might  be  considered  unimpeachable  proof  that  Pear- 
son's allegations  were  false,  but  a  close  textual  study  of 
the  affidavit  reveals  that  all  Blick  did  was  cast  doubt  upon 
the  specifics  of  Pearson's  charges,  not  the  charges  them- 
selves. Blick  never  really  denied  that  Welker  and  Bridges 
had  applied  pressure  to  have  Hunt,  Jr.,  prosecuted.  He 
only  denied  some  of  the  details  in  the  Pearson  account. 
This  attempt  at  vindication  is  indeed  a  feeble  one  and 
leads  one  to  believe  that  the  general  allegations  were 
accurate.74 

Hunt  himself,  moreover,  had  apparently  discussed  the 
alleged  "blackmail"  with  a  member  of  Pearson's  staff  and 
several  other  political  friends  and  relatives.  William  M. 
Spencer,  a  cousin  of  Sen.  Hunt  and  the  Chairman  of  the 
Board  of  Directors  of  the  North  American  Car  Corpora- 


Senators  O'Mahoney 
and  Hunt. 


17 


«■    —     «  ^  ■ —— 

Senator  Hunt  (right)  and  unidentified  man. 

tion  in  Chicago,  wrote  a  scathing  letter  to  Herman  Welker 
after  the  Idaho  Republican  eulogized  Hunt  in  the  senate. 
I  was  shocked  when  I  read  this.  It  recalled  to  my  mind  so 
vividly  my  conversation  with  Senator  Hunt  a  few  weeks  before 
he  died,  wherein  he  recited  in  great  detail  the  diabolical  part 
you  played  following  the  unfortunate  and  widely  publicized 
episode  in  which  his  son  was  involved. 

Senator  Hunt,  a  close  personal  friend  of  mine,  told  me 
without  reservation  the  details  of  the  tactics  you  used  in 
endeavoring  to  induce  him  to  withdraw  from  the  Senate,  or 
at  least  not  to  be  a  candidate  again.  It  seems  apparent  that 
you  took  every  advantage  of  the  misery  which  the  poor  fellow 
was  suffering  at  the  time  in  your  endeavor  to  turn  it  to 
political  advantage.  Such  procedure  is  as  low  a  blow  as  could 
be  conceived. 

I  understood,  too,  from  Senator  Hunt,  that  Senator 
Bridges  had  been  consulted  by  you  and  approved  of  your 
action  in  the  matter.75 
Joseph  O'Mahoney,  who  ran  for  Wyoming's  vacant  senate 
seat  in  1954  and  defeated  the  Republican  nominee,  knew 
of  this  attempt  at  keeping  Hunt  from  seeking  reelection 
when  he  wrote, 

As  you  know,  my  candidacy  this  year  was  not  prompted  by 
any  personal  desire  for  a  return  to  public  life,  but  because 
of  the  peculiar  circumstances  which  existed,  namely  the  tac- 
tics employed  against  Senator  Hunt,  and  the  thought  that 
if  I  did  not  run  the  reactionary  Republicans  might  control 
the  Senate  by  default.'6 


While  no  one  can  ultimately  be  certain  of  the  precise 
reasons  for  Hunt's  suicide,  clearly  he  was  under  substan- 
tial personal  and  political  pressures.  To  have  run  for  reelec- 
tion would  involve  a  good  deal  of  physical  discomfort 
(given  Hunt's  swelling  condition),  and  it  might  well  have 
led  to  an  agonizing  public  airing  of  his  son's  troubles.  Given 
the  abusive  and  irresponsible  tone  of  "McCarthyistic" 
politics  in  the  early  1950s,  demonstrated  so  well  in  the 
Maryland  campaign  against  Tydings,  Hunt  must  have 
thought  the  threats  to  "expose"  his  son  were  credible.  Even 
if  such  tactics  ultimately  backfired  to  Hunt's  political  ad- 
vantage, as  some  were  convinced  they  would,  the  public 
discussion  and  embarrassment  of  the  charges  would  sorely 
pain  a  man  of  Hunt's  personal  and  family  sensibilities. 
To  have  given  up  — to  have  withdrawn  from  the  campaign 
as  Hunt  tried  to  do  — involved  the  appearance  of  betray- 
ing his  party  and  loyal  supporters,  a  prospect  that  clear- 
ly caused  Hunt  considerable  anguish  as  well,  particular- 
ly when  some  backers  discounted  his  pleas  of  ill  health. 
Other  factors  may  well  have  been  present,  but  these  con- 
siderations must  have  been  elements  in  Hunt's  drift  toward 
suicide. 

Perhaps  some  protection  against  the  threats  and  innu- 
endos  that  Hunt  faced  in  1953-1954  might  have  been 
achieved  through  more  decisive  senate  action  in  the  Mary- 
land case,  on  the  Benton  Resolution,  on  the  Douglas- 
Kefauver  structural  reform  schemes  or  on  Hunt's  own  con- 
gressional immunity  proposal.  Like  the  executive  branch 
of  government  and  other  institutions  in  American  life  in 
the  early  1950s,  however,  the  United  States  Senate  failed 
to  take  significant  steps  against  the  political  excesses  of 
the  day.  Lester  Hunt's  lonely  final  ordeal  is  at  least  in  part 
a  monument  to  that  failure. 


For  a  better  understanding  of  the  literature  on  anti-communism 
see  Robert  Griffith  and  Athan  Theoharis,  eds.,  The  Specter: 
Original  Essays  on  the  Cold  War  and  Origins  of  McCarthyism 
(New  York:  Franklin  Watts,  Inc..  1974);  Robert  Griffith, 
"Truman  and  the  Historians:  The  Reconstruction  of  Postwar 
American  History."  Wisconsin  Magazine  of  History  (Autumn, 
1975),  pp.  20-50;  and  Thomas  Reeves,  "McCarthyism:  Interpreta- 
tions Since  Hofstadter,"  Wisconsin  Magazine  of  History  (Autumn, 
1976),  pp.  42-54. 

For  an  examination  of  the  senate  during  these  years  see  Robert 
Griffith,  The  Politics  of  Fear;  Joseph  R.  McCarthy  and  the  Senate 
(Rochelle  Park,  New  Jersey:  Hayden  Book  Company,  Inc.,  1970); 
and  Richard  M.  Fried,  Men  Against  McCarthy  (New  York:  Col- 
umbia University  Press,  1976). 

Ralph  Jerome  Woody,  "The  United  States  Senate  Career  of  Lester 
C.  Hunt,"  (Master  of  Arts  Thesis,  University  of  Wyoming,  1964), 
pp.  19-20. 

This  letter  was  in  response  to  President  Truman's  October  14, 
1950,  speech  at  the  United  Nations  General  Assembly  calling  for 
"peace  through  disarmament."  The  letter  urged:  "That  the  first 
step  proposed  be  the  lifting  of  the  iron  curtain  and  the  resump- 
tion of  at  least  that  degree  of  freedom  of  communication  between 
all  the  peoples  of  the  earth  which  existed  between  the  nations 
of  Western  Europe  and  the  American  continents  prior  to  the  Sec- 
ond World  War;  That  the  proposal  be  for  complete  disarma- 


18 


ment  in  an  orderly,  complete  and  rapid  way;  That  a  United 
Nations  Police  Force  be  established  in  accordance  with  the 
original  intention  of  the  Charter  which  shall  be  superior  in  size 
and  armament  to  any  forces  available  to  the  member  nations  for 
the  maintenance  of  civil  order:  And,  finally,  that  the  proposal 
be  permanently  in  effect  and  repeatedly  offered  until  it  is 
accepted."  This  letter  was  signed  by  Ralph  E.  Flanders,  Lester 
C.  Hunt,  H.  Alexander  Smith,  Walter  F.  George,  Estes  Kefauver, 
Margaret  Chase  Smith,  Robert  C.  Hendrickson,  Charles  W. 
Tobey,  Lister  Hill,  Mike  Monroney.  Edward  J.  Thye,  A.  Willis 
Robertson,  John  C.  Stennis,  Brooks  Hays,  Laurie  Battle,  A.  S. 
J.  Carnahan,  with  authorized  signatures  by  James  C.  Auchincloss, 
Frances  P.  Bolton,  Walter  H.  Judd,  Christian  A,  Herter,  Robert 
Hale  and  John  W.  Heselton.  Letter  to  the  President,  February 
26,  1951,  Official  Files,  Box  1075,  394-B-Disarmament 
1945-April  1951,  Truman  Papers,  Harry  S.  Truman  Presiden- 
tial Library,   Independence,  Missouri. 

5.  Woody.  "Senate  Career  of  Lester  C.  Hunt,"  p.  31. 

6.  One  person  who  feared  the  communist  threat  was  a  12-year-old 
girl  from  Detroit,  Michigan.  She  sent  a  letter  to  President  Truman 
in  which  she  wrote:  "My  dear  Mr.  Government,  if  you  want  to 
be  elected  next  election  do  something  about  the  communists.  You 
should  get  at  least  a  small  group  of  of  100  or  200  men  such  as 
army,  navy,  marines,  coast  gard's  at  every  water  system,  phone 
system,  radio  system  and  air  port  station  if  you  don't  the  com- 
minist  government  will  be  telling  you  when  to  take  a  bath."  Miss 
Mary  Alyce  Dwyer  to  the  President,  n.d.,  Official  Files,  Box  880, 
File  no.  263  (1948).  Truman  Papers. 

7.  Personal  interview  with  Lester  C.  Hunt,  Jr..  Chicago.  Illinois, 
December  29,  1979. 

8.  Ibid. 

9.  United  States  Congress.  Senate,  81st  Congress,  Committee  on 
Armed  Services,  Hearings  on  Malmedy  Massacre  Investigations 
(Washington,  1949),  p.  637. 

10.  Griffith,  The  Politics  of  Fear,  pp.  20-26;  Fried,  Men  Against 
McCarthy,  p.  38;  and  Richard  Rovere,  Senator  Joe  McCarthy 
(New  York:  World  Publishing  Company,  1959).  pp.  37,   111. 

1 1 .  For  a  detailed  account  of  McCarthy's  early  use  of  the  communist 
issue  see  Michael  O'Brien,  "The  Cedric  Parker  Case,  November 
1949,"  in  Griffith  and  Theoharis.  eds.,  The  Specter,  pp.  226-238. 

12.  Griffith,   The  Politics  of  Fear,  pp.  48-60. 

13.  Fried,  Men  Against  McCarthy,  p.  86. 

14.  Ibid  ,  p.  83. 

15.  Ibid.,  pp.  58-94. 

16.  Ibid.,  p.  127. 

17.  Ibid.,  pp.  122-153. 

18.  Edward  and  Vera  Slaven  to  William  Benton,  August  14,  1951, 
Box  1,  Folder  2,  William  Benton  Papers.  Wisconsin  State  His- 
torical Society,  Madison,  Wisconsin. 

19.  F.  Ross  Peterson,  "McCarthyism  in  the  Mountains,  1950-1954." 
in  Thomas  Alexander,  ed.,  Essays  on  the  American  West, 
1974-1975  (Provo,  Utah:  Brigham  Young  University  Press,  1976), 
pp.  49-54. 

20.  The  best  scholarship  on  this  is  Fried,  Men  Against  McCarthy  and 
Griffith,  The  Politics  of  Fear.  The  conservative  Tydings  had  sur- 
vived an  attempt  by  President  Franklin  D.  Roosevelt  to  "purge" 
him  in  the  1938  primaries.  James  T.  Patterson,  Congressional 
Conservatism  and  the  New  Deal:  The  Growth  of  the  Conservative 
Coalition  in  Congress,  1933-1939  (Lexington:  University  of  Ken- 
tucky Press,  1967),  pp.  279-284. 

21.  Fried,  Men  Against  McCarthy,  p.  141. 

22.  Ibid.,  pp.  149-153. 

23.  For  a  more  detailed  study  of  Hennings'  role  see  Donald  J.  Kemper, 
Decade  of  Fear:  Senator  Hennings  and  Civil  Liberties  (Colum- 
bia, Missouri:  University  of  Missouri  Press,  1965),  pp.  51-73. 

24.  Fried,  Men  Against  McCarthy,  pp.  198-203. 


25.  Ibid.,  pp.  204-218. 

26.  Ibid.,  pp.   194-195. 

27.  Lester  C.  Hunt  to  Mr.  Bernier,  October  22,  1951,  Box  14,  Lester 
C.  Hunt  Papers,  Western  History  Research  Center.  University 
of  Wyoming,   Laramie,  Wyoming. 

28.  United  States  Congress,  Senate.  81st  Congress,  A  Bill  Providing 
for  Civil  Suits  Against  the  United  States  by  Persons  Suffering 
Damages  as  a  Result  of  Defamations  Committed  by  Members  of 
Congress  in  the  Course  of  Their  Official  Activities.  Congressional 
Bill  S.782,  February  5,   1951. 

29.  Wyoming  Eagle ,  September  22,   1950. 

30.  "Dangers  in  Congressional  Immunity,"  New  York  Times 
Magazine,  June  24,   1951,  Section  6,  p.  14. 

31.  New  York  Times,  January  30,   1951,  p.  18. 

32.  New  York  Times.  December  22.   1950. 

33.  In  September.  1952.  Hunt  denounced  "McCarthy's  Lie  Tech- 
nique" and  stated  that  McCarthy  had  not  found  any  communists. 
"He  has  not,  I  predict  he  will  not.  If  you  tell  a  big  enough  lie 
and  tell  it  often  enough,  someone  is  bound  to  believe  [it]."  Wyo- 
ming  Eagle,  September  26,  1952.  Speaking  from  a  position  of 
respect,  the  Senator  from  Wisconsin  was  believed  by  many.  "Last 
night  I  listened  to  a  speech  by  Senator  Joseph  McCarthy.  Senator 
McCarthy  gave  proof  that  our  Ambassador  at  Large.  Philip  Jessup 
has  Communistic  tendencies.  Surely  the  Senator  would  not  make 
such  a  statement  unless  he  had  absolute  proof  that  it  is  the  truth." 
G.  C.  Hemphill  to  President  Truman.  August  23.  1951 ,  Official 
Files,  Box  1757.  OF-3371,  Truman  Papers. 

34  Barton  R.  Voigt,  "Joseph  C.  O'Mahoney  and  the  1952  Senate 
Election  in  Wyoming."  (Master  of  Arts  Thesis,  University  of  Wyo- 
ming, 1973),  p.   18. 

35.  Lester  C.  Hunt  to  Wandell  Elliott,  March  12,  1954,  Personal  Box, 
Hunt  Papers.  Governor  Barrett  presented  McCarthy  to  the  crowd 
at  the  Diversion  Dam  on  Sunday,  October  12,  1952,  saying:  "I 
love,  admire  and  respect  him  as  an  outstanding  citizen  of  the 
United  States  and  as  a  Senator."  Wyoming  State  Journal,  Octo- 
ber 14,  1952,  p.  1.  In  his  speech  to  the  estimated  3,500  listeners, 
McCarthy  called  the  Democratic  party  the  "Commie-crat "  party. 
"Getting  down  to  cases  in  the  Communism-in-government  issue, 
McCarthy  likened  hunting  Communists  to  killing  skunks,  which 
he  recalled  as  a  disagreeable,  but  necessary,  task  of  his  boyhood. 
In  both,  'the  worse  you  smell,  the  more  successful  you  are.'  the 
fiery  Senator  said."  When  McCarthy  asked,  "Do  you  want  the 
skunk  hunting  stopped?"  the  crowd  roared  back  "No!"  "McCar- 
thy closed  his  speech  with  another  ringing  appeal  to  elect 
Republican  candidates  all  down  the  line,  and  the  crowd  — 
obviously  in  complete  agreement  all  afternoon  — shouted  and 
clapped  its  approval."  Rivcrton  Review,  October  16,  1952.  pp. 
1,  5. 

36.  Wyoming  State  Tribune,  March  23,  1953;  Casper  Tribune- 
Herald,  March  24,  1953. 

37.  President  Eisenhower  explained  why  he  did  not  publicly  oppose 
McCarthy.  "As  for  McCarthy.  Only  a  short-sighted  or  completely 
inexperienced  individual  would  urge  the  use  of  the  office  of  the 
Presidency  to  give  an  opponent  the  publicity  he  so  avidly  desires. 
.  .  .  Permit  me  to  say  that  1  think  there  would  be  far  more  pro- 
gress made  against  so-called  'McCarthyism'  if  individuals  of  an 
opposing  purpose  would  take  it  upon  themselves  to  help  sustain 
and  promote  their  own  ideals,  rather  than  to  wait  and  wail  for 
a  blasting  of  their  pet  enemies  by  someone  else.  Frankly,  in  a 
day  when  we  see  journalism  far  more  concerned  in  so-called 
human  interest,  dramatic  incidents,  and  bitter  quarrels  than  it 
is  in  promoting  constructive  understanding  of  the  day's  problems, 
I  have  no  intention  whatsoever  of  helping  promote  the  publicity 
value  of  anyone  who  disagrees  with  me  — demagogue  or  notl" 
President  Eisenhower  to  Dr.  Milton  S.  Eisenhower.  October  9, 


19 


1953,  Ann  Whitman  Files,  Box  3.  DDE  Diary  October  1954  (4), 
Eisenhower  Papers,  Dwight  D.  Eisenhower  Presidential  Library, 
Abilene,  Kansas. 

38.  Laramie  Bulletin,  March  25,  1954. 

39.  New  York  Times,  January  7,  1951,  p.  46;  San  Francisco  Chroni- 
cle, June  20,  1954,  p.   1. 

40.  Denver  Post,  April  8.  1952,  p.   1;  April  9,  1952,  p.  40. 

41 .  Letter  to  author  from  Mike  Manatos,  Lester  Hunt's  Administra- 
tive Assistant.  April  30,  1980;  Excerpt  from  the  Drew  Pearson 
Program,  heard  at  6:00  p.m.  over  WABD-TV  (NY)  and  Dumont 
Television  Network,  June  20,  1954,  Styles  Bridges  Papers,  New 
England  College,  Henniker,  New  Hampshire;  Drew  Pearson  arti- 
cle in  Rawlins  Daily  Times,  June  23,  1954,  p.  2,  Casper  Morn- 
ing Star,  June  22,  1954.  p.  8,  Rock  Springs  Daily  Rocket,  June 
23,  1954,  Northern  Wyoming  Daily  News,  June  23,  1954.  and 
Laconia  [New  Hampshire]  Evening  Citizen,  June  23,  1954.  Later 
cited  as  Pearson  article.  June,   1954. 

42.  People  in  the  1950s  did  not  view  homosexuality  with  tolerance. 
Society  considered  this  type  of  behavior  abnormal  and  a  sickness 
which  required  medical  attention.  A  1950  Congressional  report 
examining  the  employment  of  homosexuals  in  government 
defined  a  homosexual  as  a  pervert  lacking  in  "moral  fiber,"  who 
"violate[s]  moral  codes  and  laws  and  the  accepted  standards  of 
conduct.  .  .  ."  Because  of  their  vulnerability  to  blackmail, 
homosexuals  were  seen  as  prime  targets  for  foreign  governments 
recruiting  espionage  agents  in  this  country.  United  States  Con- 
gress. Senate,  81st  Congress,  2nd  Session,  Subcommittee  on  Inves- 
tigations Report  submitted  to  the  Committee  on  expenditures  in 
the  Executive  Departments,  Employment  of  Homosexuals  and 
Other  Sex  Perverts  in  Government,  Document  No.  241.  (1950), 
pp.  1-8.  Homosexuality  could  also  damage  a  political  career. 
Allen  Drury  gave  an  example  of  this  in  his  1959  novel.  Advise 
and  Consent,  partially  based  on  Hunt's  case.  Persons  of  all 
political  persuasions  would  consider  using  it.  "Today  we  received 
a  letter  from  a  purported  Army  lieutenant  claiming  he  had  been 
picked  up  in  the  Wardman  Park  by  McCarthy,  gone  with  him 
to  McCarthy's  home,  and  while  the  Lieutenant  was  half  drunk. 
McCarthy  committed  sodomy.  He  offered  to  testify  to  this  effect 
and  said  he  knew  other  officers  whom  McCarthy  had  picked  up. 
He  claims  McCarthy  promised  him  a  transfer  and  never  got  it." 
Whatever  the  reason,  homosexuality  could  be  used  as  a  weapon. 
Memorandum  from  Ralph  Mann  to  William  Benton,  January 
3.  1951,  Box  4.  Senate  Privileges  and  Election,  William  Benton 
Papers.  Alger  Hiss'  defense  wanted  to  discredit  Whitaker 
Chambers  by  showing  him  to  be  a  homosexual,  among  other 
things,  and  therefore  part  of  their  investigation  concentrated  on 
this  aspect.  However,  this  defense  was  not  used  because  it  was 
feared  the  prosecution  would  counterattack  with  allegations  of 
Timothy  Hobson's  homosexuality.  Hobson  was  Hiss'  stepson. 
Allen  Weinstein,  Perjury:  The  Hiss-Chambers  Case,  (New  York: 
Alfred  A.  Knopf,  1978).  pp.  383,  583,  and  passim. 

43.  Pearson  article,  June,   1954. 

44.  Washington  Times  Herald,  October  7,  1954,  p.  5. 

45.  Senator  Hunt  ".  .  .  was  sensitive  about  his  political  reputation. 
...  we  were  often  cautioned  that  we  had  to  behave  in  a  certain 
fashion,  because  it  would  win  you  or  lose  you  votes.  There  was 
a  lot  of  that  going  on  in  our  lives,  .  .  ."  Interview  with  Hunt. 
Jr.  "The  Trial  of  Buddy  Hunt  proved  to  be  a  heart-rendering 
experience  for  the  Senator,  .  .  .  because  he  felt  so  deeply  that 
it  was  a  reflection  upon  his  family."  Letter  to  author  from  Mike 
Manatos,  April  30.  1980.  The  Wyoming  papers  and  their  respec- 
tive counties  which  carried  a  story  on  Lester  Hunt,  Jr.'s,  trial  are: 
Albany  County  -  Laramie  Republican  Boomerang;  Carbon 
County  -  Rawlins  Daily  Times;  Laramie  County  -  Wyoming  State 
Tribune  and  Wyoming  Eagle;  Natrona  County  -  Casper  Tribune- 
Herald  and   Casper  Morning  Star;   Platte  County   -   Guernsey 


Gazette;  Sheridan  County  -  Sheridan  Press;  Sweetwater  County 

-  Rock  Springs  Daily  Rocket;  and  Washakie  County  -  Northern 
Wyoming  Daily  News.  The  Wyoming  papers  which  did  not  carry 
a  story  are:  Big  Horn  County  -  Big  Horn  County  Rustler  and 
Basin  Republican,  Greybull  Standard  and  Tribune  and  Lovell 
Chronicle;  Campbell  County  -  News  Record,  Carbon  County  - 
Saratoga  Sun;  Converse  County  -  Douglas  Enterprise,  Glenrock 
Independent  and  Douglas  Budget;  Crook  County  -  Sundance 
Times  and  Moorcroft  Leader,  Fremont  County  -  Riverton  Ranger 
and  Wyoming  State  Journal;  Goshen  County  -  Torrington  News, 
Guide  Review  and  Torrington  Telegram;  Hot  Springs  County 

-  Thermopolis  Independent,  Johnson  County  -  Buffalo  Bulletin; 
Laramie  County  -  Pine  Bluffs  Post;  Lincoln  County  -  Kemmerer 
Gazette  and  Star  Valley  Independent;  Niobrara  County  -  Lusk 
Herald  and  Lusk  Free  Lance;  Park  County  -  Cody  Enterprise  and 
Powell  Tribune;  Platte  County  -  Wheatland  Times  and  Platte 
County  Record;  Sublette  County  -  Smoke  Signals,  Pinedale 
Roundup  and  Big  Piney  Examiner;  Sweetwater  County  -  Rock 
Springs  Miner  and  Green  River  Star;  Teton  County  -Jackson's 
Hole  Courier  and  Jackson  Hole  Guide;  Uinta  County  -  Uinta 
County  Herald;  Weston  County  -  Weston  County  Gazette  and 
News-Letter  Journal.  The  major  state  newspapers  carried  the 
story  —  usually  only  a  short  paragraph  —  but  the  majority  did  not. 

46.  Pearson  article,  June.  1954.  Pearson  also  wrote  that  ".  .  .  [Hunt's] 
hair  had  turned  almost  white  [and]  .  .  .  [h]is  face  was  pale." 

47.  Hunt,  Jr.,  interview. 

48.  Marquis  Childs'  column  in  Washington  Post.  June  30,  1954. 

49.  Lester  C.  Hunt  to  Dr.  P.  M.  Cunningham,  October  29,  1953, 
Personal  Box,  Hunt  Papers. 

50.  Hunt  to  Henry  Watenpaugh.  January  25,  1954,  ibid. 

51.  Hunt  to  Oscar  Hammond,  April,   1954,  ibid. 

52.  Earle  Clements  to  Joseph  O'Mahoney,  January  18.  1954,  Earle 
Clements  Papers.  University  of  Kentucky.  Lexington,  Kentucky. 

53.  Joseph  O'Mahoney  to  Art  Buck,  November  4,  1953,  Box  180, 
Spindle  File,  Joseph  O'Mahoney  Papers,  Western  History 
Research  Center.  University  of  Wyoming,  Laramie.  Wyoming. 

54.  In  this  poll,  Hunt's  office  sent  10,000  postcards  out  to  Wyoming 
voters.  Every  tenth  person  on  the  motor  vehicle  registration  files 
received  a  card.  Five  possible  seekers  of  the  senate  seat  were  listed. 
Of  the  1,614  returned,  Hunt  received  878  votes.  The  next  closest 
received  only  312  votes.  "Senate  poll,  April  5,  1954,"  Personal 
Box,  Hunt  Papers. 

55.  Rawlins  Daily  Times,  July  1,  1954.  Lester  Hunt,  Jr.,  living  in 
Chicago  at  the  time,  knew  of  the  break-in  and  ransacking,  but 
did  not  know  the  reason  behind  it.  Hunt.  Jr.,  interview.  Such 
pressure  was  not  unknown  in  the  early  1950s.  One  person,  par- 
ticipating in  a  campaign  to  oust  McCarthy  from  the  senate,  wrote: 
"...  The  telephone  rings  at  3  o'clock  every  morning  for  two  weeks. 
If  one  answers  one  receives  a  torrent  of  obscene,  profane  abuse 
absolutely  unprintable.  If  one  doesn't  answer,  the  phone  just  con- 
tinues to  ring  — as  long  as  half  an  hour.  Other  telephone  calls 
come  at  every  other  hour  with  language  that  should  make  the 
wires  burn.  .  .  .  Threatening  mail  comes  by  the  sackful.  .  .  . 
Automobile  tires  are  slashed,  paint  scraped  off,  windows  broken, 
gas  tanks  drained,  door  handles  pried  off.  .  .  .  One's  employer 
gets  anonymous  mail  and  telephone  calls  accusing  the  McCar- 
thy opponent  of  subversion,  perversion,  and  crime."  Being  afraid 
of  more  recriminations  he  signed  the  letter,  "Joe  Must  Go 
Worker."  Milwaukee  Journal,  June  24,  1954,  p.  24. 

56.  "Hunt  left  Washington  to  formally  file  [sic]  papers  for  reelec- 
tion, and  returned  without  doing  so.  He  never  did  explain  why 
the  change  of  heart.  .  .  .  The  only  explanation  Hunt  had  was 
that  he  just  wanted  to  get  away  from  it  all."  Letter  to  author 
from  Mike  Manatos,  April  30,  1980.  Apparently  Hunt's  decision 
to  withdraw  was  made  during  this  trip  to  Cheyenne. 


20 


57.  "L.  C.  Hunt,  Senator,  Possibilities,"  received  May  3,  1954,  Alpha 
file  on  Lester  C.  Hunt,  Eisenhower  Papers.  One  of  those  listed 
was  for  the  Tariff  Commission,  with  a  yearly  salary  of  $15,000 
for  a  six-year  term. 

58.  Leonard  W.  Hall  to  Sherman  Adams,  June  15,  1954,  Records 
of  Leonard  W.  Hall.  Box  84,  24-F  Personal  #1  1954,  Eisenhower 
Library. 

59.  Casper  Tribune-Herald,  June  20,  1954. 

60.  Joseph  O'Mahoney  to  Milton  Coffman,  July  16,  1954,  Box  180 
Spindle  File,  O'Mahoney  Papers. 

61 .  "Regrets  exceedingly  at  this  date  to  advise  you  that,  due  to  per- 
sonal reasons  beyond  my  control,  namely  health,  I  am  compelled 
to  withdraw  my  announcement  as  a  candidate  for  reelection  to 
the  United  States  Senate."  Hunt  to  J.  J.  Hickey,  Democratic  State 
Central  Committee.  June  4,  1954,  Personal  Box,  Hunt  Papers. 

62.  Wyoming  Eagle,  June  22,  1954. 

63.  Denver  Post,  June  20,  1954,  p.   12. 

64.  "...  I  talked  with  Doctor  Fitzgibbon,  who  told  me  of  your  con- 
versation with  him  on  Saturday,  and  I  can  only  say  that  I  appre 
ciate  and  understand  your  reasons."  Dr.  Fitzgibbon  was  a  member 
of  the  American  Dental  Association.  Francis  J.  Garvey  to  Lester 
C.  Hunt,  June  8,  1954,  Personal  Box,  Hunt  Papers.  Drew  Pear- 
son wrote  in  his  diary  on  June  19,  1954:  "About  two  weeks  ago 
Hunt  went  out  to  the  Naval  Hospital  and  afterward  announced 
that  he  was  retiring  from  the  Senate  because  of  his  health.  Actu- 
ally Dr.  Calvert  says  there's  nothing  wrong  with  his  health."  Tyler 
Abell,  ed..  Drew  Pearson  Diaries,  1949-1959  (New  York:  Holt, 
Rinehard  and  Winston,  1974),  p.  323. 

65.  Besides  health,  another  reason  given  by  Hunt  was  the  physical 
strains  that  a  campaign  would  entail.  ".  .  .  and  knowing  the  rigors 
of  a  state  wide  campaign,  I  have  decided  to  withdraw  from  the 
political  scene,  and  will  not  be  a  candidate  for  re-election."  Lester 
C.  Hunt  to  L.  H.  Heyl,  June  18,  1954,  Personal  Box,  Hunt 
Papers.  In  May,  Hunt's  campaign  plans  had  included  renting 
a  bus,  having  it  "properly  painted"  and  an  organ  installed,  and 
then  campaigning  throughout  the  state  in  it.  Hunt  to  Senator 
Earle  Clements,  May  25,  1954,  Clements  Papers. 

66.  T.  A.  Larson  wrote  that  Senator  Hunt  was  "overwhelmed  by  per 
sonal  and  political  problems."  T.  A.  Larson,  History  of  Wyo- 
ming, 2nd  ed.  (Lincoln,  Nebraska:  University  of  Nebraska  Press, 
1965),  p.  572.  On  Friday,  June  18,  1954,  Senator  McCarthy  stated 
that  he  was  investigating  a  Democratic  senator  for  "just  plain 
wrongdoing,"  not  connected  with  the  communist  issue.  San  Fran- 
cisco Chronicle,  June  19.  1954,  p.  9.  Shortly  after  Hunt's  death, 
Senator  Karl  Mundt  of  South  Dakota,  a  friend  of  McCarthy, 
stated  that  Hunt  was  "positively"  not  the  man  McCarthy  had  in 
mind  in  his  earlier  statement.  San  Francisco  Chronicle,  June  20, 
1954;  New  York  Times,  June  20,  1954.  Either  some  people  had 
connected  the  two  events  or  there  was  a  fear  that  they  might  be 
linked.  See  Abell,  ed..  Drew  Pearson's  Diaries,  p.  321. 

67.  A  Capitol  police  guard  reported  that  Senator  Hunt  on  his  way 
to  his  office  "appeared  to  be  in  exceptional  spirits.  .  .  .  [and] 
commented  pleasantly  on  the  weather.  ..."  The  policeman  paid 
no  attention  to  the  rifle  as  Hunt  "frequently  carried  things  into 
the  building  from  his  car."  Memorandum  of  Private  W.  Paul 
Flynn  to  Office  of  the  Captain,  June  19,  1954,  Capitol  Police 
Records,  Senate  Detachment,  Washington,  DC.  Carl  Solberg 
wrote  that  ".  .  .  the  miasma  of  intimidation  and  slander  that 
McCarthyism  spread  over  Washington  in  the  spring  of  1 954  had 
everything  to  do  with  Hunt's  death.  The  Grand  Inquisition  had 
reached  into  the  Senate  and  claimed  a  victim."  Carl  Solberg, 


Riding  High:  America  in  the  Cold  War  (New  York:  Mason  & 
Lipscomb-Publishers,  1973),  pp.  188-190. 

68.  Maurice  L.  Farber.  Theory  of  Suicide  (New  York:  Funk  and 
Wagnalls,  1968),  p.  17. 

69.  G.  Donald  Niswander,  Thomas  M.  Casey,  and  John  A.  Hum- 
phrey, A  Panorama  of  Suicide:  A  Casebook  of  Psychological 
Autopsies  (Springfield,  Illinois:  Charles  C.  Thomas,  Publisher. 
1973),  p.  xi. 

70.  David  Lester,  Why  People  Kill  Themselves:  A  Summary  of 
Research  Findings  on  Suicidal  Behavior  (Springfield,  Illinois: 
Charles  C.  Thomas,  Publisher,  1972),  p.  26. 

71.  Hunt,  Jr.,  interview.  Senator  Estes  Kefauver  wrote:  "He  [Hunt] 
had  some  sensitivities  which  caused  him  to  be  worried  about  his 
son  and  he  took  his  own  life."  Estes  Kefauver  to  Ralph  Jerome 
Woody,  July  24,  1963,  Judiciary  Committee  Correspon- 
dence—88th  Congress  Box,  Estes  Kefauver  Papers,  University  of 
Tennessee,  Knoxville,  Tennessee. 

72.  Hunt,  Jr.,  interview. 

73.  Affidavit  dated  July  9,  1954,  and  undated  transcript.  Bridges 
Papers.  An  undated  note  was  also  found  in  the  Bridges  Papers 
containing  Hunt,  Jr.'s,  address,  phone  number,  date  and  place 
of  arrest,  "arrested  soliciting  as  a  queer,"  and  the  phrase  "gone 
to  Cuba."  Pearson  had  wanted  to  publish  the  "blackmail"  story 
in  December  of  1953  -  six  months  prior  to  Hunt's  death,  but  Tracy 
McCraken,  influential  Wyoming  Democratic  publisher  had 
"pleaded"  with  him  not  to  do  so.  At  that  time  Hunt  had  told 
Jack  Anderson  of  Pearson's  staff  that  publication  of  the  story 
would  cause  his  wife  to  "die"  from  additional  agony  and  embar- 
rassment. Because  of  the  strong  objections  of  Welker  and  Bridges, 
Pearson  claimed  to  have  had  a  "whale  of  a  time"  getting  Bell 
Syndicate  to  distribute  the  column  he  wrote  subsequent  to  Hunt's 
suicide.  Abell,  ed.,  Drew  Pearson's  Diaries,  pp.  321-323. 

74.  Some  critics  charged  that  Pearson's  article  was  only  one  of  his 
usual  attacks  against  prominent  political  figures  with  whom  he 
disagreed  politically.  For  an  example  of  this  see  Pearson's  treat- 
ment of  James  Forrestal  in  Jack  Anderson  and  James  Boyd,  Con- 
fessions of  a  Muckraker:  The  Inside  Story  of  Life  in  Washington 
During  the  Truman,  Eisenhower,  Kennedy  and  Johnson  Years 
(New  York:  Random  House,  1979),  pp.  122-145.  An  editorial 
in  the  pro  Bridges  Manchester  Union  Leader  dubbed  Pearson's 
allegations  a  pro-communist  attack.  "This  left  wing  campaign 
will  be  directed  by  a  group  of  Communists,  pro-Communists  and 
liberals  who  make  their  headquarters  in  New  York  City,  Wash- 
ington and  other  points  on  the  Eastern  seaboard.  These  left 
wingers  are  out  to  destroy  any  senator  who  has  stood  up  against 
Soviet  Russia."  Manchester  [New  Hampshire]  Union  Leader,  July 
15,  1954,  Bridges  Papers.  This  attempt  at  red-baiting  fails  in 
its  efforts  to  explain  Pearson's  allegations  while  completely  ignor- 
ing the  pressure  obviously  applied  on  Hunt.  Pearson  did  give 
Bridges  an  opportunity  to  refute  the  charges  by  inviting  the 
Senator  to  write  a  column  on  any  subject  he  desired.  Bridges, 
however,  refused,  saying  ".  .  .  that  if  I  had  the  gift  and  power 
to  make  each  of  the  850  words  a  jewel  of  rhetoric  or  if  you  should 
increase  your  offer  a  million  fold,  there  would  be  no  atonement 
for  the  damage  you  have  done.  Words  once  engraved  on  the 
human  intellect  can  never  be  erased  by  more  words  or  polished 
gems  of  thought,  [emphasis  added.]  Styles  Bridges  to  Drew  Pear- 
son, August  16,  1954,  Bridges  Papers. 

75.  William  M.  Spencer  to  Herman  Welker,  December  29,  1954, 
Bridges  Papers. 

76.  Joseph  O'Mahoney  to  J.  B.  Sullivan,  November  17,  1954,  Box 
183,  Correspondence  #1,  O'Mahoney  Papers. 


21 


The  Wilcox  Train  Robbery: 


22 


Edward  J.  Harriman  and  the  New  York  bankers  had 
assumed  control  of  the  bankrupt  Union  Pacific  Railroad 
in  1897.  Two  problems  facing  them  were  the  poor  condi- 
tion of  miles  of  track  and  threats  of  train  robberies.  One 
of  the  most  spectacular  robberies  occurred  in  June,  1899, 
and  it  caused  a  sensation  in  the  Wyoming  newspapers  as 
well  as  in  the  national  press. 

An  analysis  of  contemporary  newspaper  accounts 
reflects  the  confusion  the  daring  robbery  caused  among 
law  enforcement  officers  and  the  news  media.  Even  in  a 
state  with  a  sparse  population  and  vast  distances  between 
settled  areas,  word  of  the  robbery  spread  rapidly  and,  cor- 
respondingly, rumors  leapt  into  print.  For  the  regular 
newspaper  reader  of  the  time,  not  only  the  identities  of 
the  robbers  were  in  question  but  reports  of  their  number 
and  the  amount  of  money  stolen  were  equally  contradic- 
tory. 

This  article  will  examine  the  Wilcox  train  robbery  by 
following  the  accounts  chronologically  as  they  were 
reported  by  the  press.  Could  the  readers  decipher  the  real 
story  from  those  accounts?  Even  today's  readers  who  know 
the  complete  story  might  find  the  following  chronological 
reports  confusing  at  times,  the  newspapers  reporting 
rumor  and  fact  as  the  occasion  suited. 

A  spectacular  train  robbery  occurred  at  2:15  a.m., 
June  2,  1899,  a  half-mile  west  of  Wilcox  station,  57  miles 
west  of  Laramie.  Engineer  W.  R.  Jones  stopped  his  loco- 
motive when  two  men  flagged  the  train  and  jumped  into 
the  engine  cab.  They  ordered  him  to  pull  the  train  across 
a  bridge  and  stop.  Jones,  realizing  it  was  a  holdup,  started 
to  move  the  train,  but  the  air  on  the  engine  had  set  the 
brakes.  The  bandits  began  cursing  him  and  one  of  them 
struck  Jones  over  the  head  with  his  six-shooter.  Finally, 
Jones  succeeded  in  releasing  the  air.1 

After  the  train  had  moved  over  the  bridge,  the  other 
members  of  the  gang  placed  a  charge  of  dynamite  on  the 
bridge  and  blew  it  up  to  prevent  the  second  section  of  the 
Overland  Flyer  from  crossing  and  disturbing  them.2 

E.  C.  Woodcock  was  the  express  and  baggageman  on 
the  train.  He  realized  it  was  a  holdup  when  the  outlaws 
came  back  to  the  cars  and  knocked  on  the  baggage  room 
door.  He  refused  to  open  the  door.  After  several  calls  to 
him  they  put  a  charge  of  dynamite  under  the  side  door 
and  blew  it  open.  The  dynamite  charge  knocked  Wood- 
cock down  and  left  him  dazed.  The  robbers  then  entered 
the  car  and  removed  Woodcock.  In  this  car  was  located 
the  train's  safe  which  contained  the  money  and  other 
valuables.  The  safe  was  shattered  with  dynamite  and  thor- 
oughly rifled  and  the  contents  placed  in  a  safesack  which 
one  of  the  men  carried.  The  train  was  held  there  nearly 
two  hours  and  when  the  robbers  left,  Engineer  Jones  cut 
loose  from  the  train  and  ran  the  engine  to  Medicine  Bow 
where  he  telegraphed  officials  at  Laramie  and  Cheyenne 
of  the  robbers.3 

A  special  posse  train  left  Laramie  at  7  a.m.  on  June 
3.   The  posse  was  made  up  of  Sheriff  Charles  Yund, 


William  Owen,  Peter  Smart,  William  Doyle,  John  Davis, 
George  Dobbins,  George  Buck  and  A.  C.  Brautigen.  In 
addition  to  this  posse,  a  carload  of  horses  and  a  dozen 
men  were  brought  to  Wilcox  on  the  passenger  train. 

An  examination  of  the  wrecked  express  car  showed 
that  the  work  was  done  by  experts  and  that  none  of  the 
discharged  railroad  graders  had  any  part  in  the  robbery. 
The  outlaws  used  a  brand  of  dynamite  that  had  been 
manufactured  in  California,  while  the  railroad  was  using 
dynamite  made  in  the  eastern  United  States.  About  a  mile 
from  Wilcox  station  the  robbers  had  camped  with  feed 
for  their  horses  and  blankets  for  protection  from  the 
weather.4 

The  railroad  officials  said  that  the  loss  was  small. 
Others  were  of  the  opinion  that  the  robbers  had  obtained 
some  $34,000  from  the  safe  and  several  thousand  dollars 
in  National  Bank  Notes  being  sent  by  the  U.S.  Treasury 
Department  to  an  Oregon  bank.5 

Another  posse  was  organized  at  Medicine  Bow  and 
still  another  at  Dana.  Plans  had  been  made  to  surround 
the  robbers  as  soon  as  possible.  A  pack  of  bloodhounds 
were  to  be  brought  on  a  special  train  from  Beatrice, 
Nebraska,  but  the  "bloodhound  special"  had  to  be  can- 
celed when  a  snow  storm  hit  the  region.6 

No  accurate  description  had  been  given  of  the  rob- 
bers. One  theory  was  that  they  were  men  working  on  the 
new  railroad  lines.  Large  numbers  of  men  were  being  ship- 
ped in  daily  for  work  on  the  grades.  It  was  assumed  the 
dynamite  was  secured  from  P.  J.  Mahoney's  grading  camp 
located  nearby.  Another  theory  was  that  the  robbery  was 
the  work  of  the  famous  "Hole  in  the  Wall  Gang,"  which 
had  been  notorious  for  many  years  in  central  Wyoming. 
"Butch"  Cassidy  and  his  gang  were  known  to  have  been 
in  the  region  during  thus  time  and  were  given  credit  for 
the  robbery  by  a  number  of  officials.  Another  theory  was 
that  Jack  Nolan  headed  the  gang,  and  the  officers  were 
anxious  to  know  of  his  whereabouts.  Nolan  was  in  Laramie 
about  a  week  before  the  robbery  for  the  first  time  in  22 
years.  He  broke  jail  there  while  awaiting  trial  for  the 
holdup  of  Bob  Foote's  Elk  Mountain  Place.7 

The  first  posse  did  not  leave  Wilcox  until  noon  of  the 
following  day  so  they  were  far  behind  the  holdup  gang. 
The  trail  carried  them  directly  northeast  from  the  railroad 
toward  Laramie  Peak  and  was  easily  followed  for  six  miles 
north.  But  at  that  point  the  robbers  moved  into  grassy 
country  and  the  trail  was  lost.  The  robbers  may  have 
removed  the  shoes  from  their  horses'  feet  so  that  they 
would  leave  no  trail.  Only  three  horses'  tracks  were 
discovered  on  the  trail  which  caused  some  to  declare  that 
there  were  only  three  robbers.  Engineer  W.  R.  Jones 
declared  that  there  were  six  men  and  he  believed  that 
three  of  them  escaped  in  a  wagon  rather  than  on  horse- 
back.8 

Another  posse  organized  on  June  4  lost  the  trail  six 
miles  north  of  Rock  Creek.  In  the  central  part  of  the  state 
several  posses  were  organized  and  headed  in  the  direc- 


23 


tion  of  Laramie  Peak.  The  objective  was  to  try  and  inter- 
cept the  robbers  if  they  attempted  to  go  to  the  "Hole  in 
the  Wall."  The  officials  were  confident  that  with  a  large 
force  of  deputies  on  the  trail  it  would  be  impossible  for 
the  outlaws  to  escape.  Chief  Detective  Canada  and  Super- 
intendent Harris,  both  of  the  Union  Pacific,  followed  the 
deputies  in  the  search.9 

According  to  reports  reaching  Laramie,  the  robbers 
crossed  the  North  Platte  River  at  Casper  at  an  unguarded 
bridge.  The  robbers  went  to  a  livery  stable  and  tried  unsuc- 
cessfully to  get  accommodations  for  their  horses.  They  then 
went  down  the  river  eight  miles  to  a  log  cabin.  Early  the 
next  morning  these  robbers  met  a  sheepherder  by  the 
name  of  Al  Hudspeth  six  miles  from  town  on  Casper 
Creek.  He  discovered  three  men  cooking  breakfast  and 
one  man  carrying  two  Winchesters.  Hudspeth  reported 
his  observations  to  the  officials  in  Casper.  His  report  caused 
an  11  man  posse  to  be  organized  composed  of  Sheriff  Joe 
Hazen,  Sheriff  Oscar  Hiestand,  Dr.  J.  F.  Leeper,  Lee 
Devine,  E.  T  Payton,  Charles  Hallaby,  Tom  McDonald, 
Sam  Fish,  J.  B.  Bradley,  J.  E.  Long  and  J.  T.  Crawford.10 

The  three  robbers  were  overtaken  on  June  5  some  30 
miles  north  of  Casper.  The  robbers  ambushed  the  posse 
with  a  rain  of  bullets  from  their  repeating  Winchester 
rifles.  In  this  fight  at  Dugout  Creek,  the  entire  posse  dis- 


mounted and  ran  into  the  rocks,  but  only  two  return  shot; 
were  made  as  the  robbers  could  not  be  seen.  Two  horse; 
were  shot,  one  of  them  belonging  to  E.  T  Payton  and 
another  belonging  to  J.  E.  Long.  The  robbers  escaped 
leaving  an  empty  money  sack  belonging  to  the  express 
company  and  a  Winchester  gun  from  the  express  car.  Dur 
ing  a  brief  thunderstorm,  two  members  of  the  Casper  posse 
were  knocked  down  by  lightning." 

In  the  battle  at  Dugout  Creek,  Sam  Fish,  a  contrac 
tor  from  South  Dakota,  rode  on  ahead  of  the  robbers  and 
cut  them  off.  He  held  this  position  for  some  time.  Fish 
was  reinforced  by  other  posse  members  but  was  compellec 
to  retreat  when  the  robbers  again  escaped. 

Sheriff  Hazen  and  Detective  Wheeler  of  the  Unior 
Pacific  reached  a  point  near  the  robbers.  When  the  mer 
rose  up  75  yards  away  and  shot  Sheriff  Hazen,  Detective 
Wheeler  narrowly  escaped.12 

Sheriff  Hazen  was  joined  by  Dr.  Leeper.  The  doctoi 
started  in  an  opposite  direction  in  search  of  the  trail  anc 
was  called  by  Hazen  who  remarked  that  he  had  agair 
struck  the  tracks.  Dr.  Leeper  went  toward  Hazen,  and  wai 
within  five  feet  of  him  when  the  robbers  opened  fire  hit 
ting  Hazen  in  the  stomach.  The  ball  entered  near  the  nave 
and  came  out  two  inches  from  the  spine.  Hazen  told  Dr 
Leeper  that  he  had  been  struck  and  the  doctor  gave 


The  railroad  car  after  it  had  been  dynamited  in  the  Wilcox  train  robbery.  Note  the  blown  safe  still  resting  in  the  car. 
24 


what  medical  attention  he  could  under  the  conditions. 
Having  no  shelter  of  any  kind,  the  sheriff  was  exposed 
to  the  weather  until  a  spring  wagon  could  be  secured  to 
take  him  to  town.  Superintendent  Harris  of  the  Union 
Pacific  ordered  a  special  train  from  Cheyenne  to  take  the 
wounded  man  to  his  home  in  Douglas.  Dr.  E.  P.  Rohr- 
baugh  gave  what  medical  attention  he  could  after  the 
wounded  man's  long  wagon  trip.  Dr.  Barber  of  Cheyenne 
was  ordered  to  Douglas  on  a  special  train,  but  by  the  time 
he  arrived  the  patient  had  died.13 

After  the  shooting  of  Sheriff  Hazen,  the  robbers  had 
struck  an  old  road  running  along  the  top  of  a  high  nar- 
row ridge.  During  the  next  night  they  had  followed  the 
road  for  15  miles.  About  daylight  the  three  men  separated 
and  two  of  them  arrived  at  Nelson's  brothers  sheep  camp, 
five  miles  south  of  French's  oil  wells  Tuesday  morning.  The 
men  helped  Herder  Melia  in  preparing  breakfast,  and 
after  breakfast  the  two  men  headed  toward  Tisdale's 
pasture.14 

It  was  reported  on  June  8  that  the  outlaws  appeared 
to  be  headed  for  the  northwest  being  followed  close  by 
about  200  men  in  the  posses.  All  the  saddle  horses  in  the 
county  were  being  utilized.  It  was  reported  that  the  pur- 
suit of  the  bandits  would  not  be  given  up  if  it  required 
years  to  capture  them.15 

A  Mr.  Buck,  a  member  of  the  special  posse  from 
Laramie,  reported  that  saddle  marks  on  the  horses  which 
the  robbers  lost  identified  the  three  men  as  Tom  O'Day, 
iBob  Taylor  and  Manuel  Manetta.  Another  report  was  cir- 
culated that  a  Casper  gambler  by  the  name  of  Cavana- 
gug  was  the  third  man,  rather  than  O'Day.  All  of  these 
men  were  well-known  "Hole  in  the  Wall"  characters  and 
ihad  already  been  accused  of  many  crimes.  Two  of  them 
were  said  to  be  notorious  outlaws,  while  a  third  had  been 
!  before  the  Natrona  County  courts  during  the  past  year. 
Some  of  the  jewelry  stolen  from  the  train  was  found  in 
the  bandits'  saddle  bags.  There  was  also  a  gun  from  the 
express  car  marked  "Pacific  Express."  The  men  were 
evidently  assisted  by  others  because  a  piece  of  beef  loin 
was  left  in  a  rock  in  good  condition.16 

Hazen's  funeral  was  attended  by  a  large  crowd.  There 
was  a  great  deal  of  indignation  over  his  death.  He  was 
well  known  throughout  the  area.  People  of  the  various 
ranches  furnished  the  law  officers  with  information  in 
regard  to  the  bandits.17 

Hazen  was  only  forty-four  years  old  when  he  was  mur- 
dered. Left  behind  was  a  wife  and  two  little  boys.  The 
Union  Pacific  Railroad  contributed  $2,400  and  a  drive 
was  also  made  for  contributions  to  pay  off  the  $300  mort- 
gage on  the  Hazen  home. 

By  June  9  the  robbers  were  reported  to  have  crossed 
the  Powder  River,  but  this  news  was  not  verified.  A  posse 
of  men  started  out  from  Buffalo,  but  the  members  of  the 
posses  from  Casper  were  tired  and  had  jaded  horses.18 

Will  Cook,  one  of  the  original  members  of  the  posse 


that  left  Laramie  on  the  morning  of  June  3,  was  one  of 
the  foremost  pursuers  of  the  bandits.  Cook  reported  that 
all  of  the  horses  with  the  posses  were  "played  out"  and 
it  was  difficult  for  them  to  get  fresh  horses.  He  also 
reported  that  the  only  one  of  the  robbers  whom  he  could 
identify  was  Bob  Taylor.  The  horses  left  behind  by  the 
outlaws  had  been  worked  in  harness  and  it  pointed  out 
the  fact  that  the  robbers  came  to  Wilcox  in  a  wagon.19 

In  a  report  published  June  9  it  was  stated  that  a  posse 
left  Casper  headed  by  Dr.  Lester,  J.  R.  Bradley  and  Dan 
Sullivan.  This  posse  arrived  at  the  Tisdale  Ranch  and  then 
started  on  the  trail  of  the  outlaws  traveling  a  distance  of 
350  miles  through  dangerous,  mountainous  country.  They 
brought  with  them  a  number  of  worn-out  horses  including 
the  three  that  the  outlaws  had  ridden  through  Casper  the 
previous  Sunday  morning.20 

The  people  of  the  village  of  Kaycee  had  not  heard 
of  the  robbery  until  the  arrival  of  the  Casper  posse.  In 
Buffalo,  the  report  was  circulated  that  the  robbers  were 
believed  to  be  surrounded  on  EK  Mountain.  At  this  time 
Marshal  Frank  Hadsell,  ex-Marshal  McDermott,  Detec- 
tive Wheeler  of  the  Union  Pacific  and  Joe  LeFors  were 
still  on  the  bandits'  trail.21 

John  Elmer  Brock  was  a  witness  to  events  taking  place 
in  Johnson  County  in  the  pursuit  of  the  robbers.  Accord- 
ing to  Brock,  two  of  the  leading  men  at  the  time  were 
Joe  LeFors  and  Tom  Horn.  The  posse  stayed  at  the  EK 
Ranch,  and  brought  their  supplies  in  from  Kaycee. 

Brock  related  an  episode  of  the  pursuit  of  the  rob- 
bers on  EK  Mountain: 

When  they  drove  up  the  mountain,  they  started  from  all  sides 
at  once  and  orders  were  given  that  no  shot  was  to  be  fired 
under  any  circumstances  unless  they  saw  the  train  robbers. 
The  closing  circle  of  men  converged  around  the  pass  on  top 
of  EK  Mountain.  They  had  within  the  circle  an  old  silver 
tip  bear.  She  nearly  scared  them  all  to  death.  She  would  give 
a  woof,  woof  and  dash  down  through  the  timber  and  the 
line  on  the  opposite  side  could  hear  her  coming  and  were 
sure  in  their  own  minds  it  was  the  approach  of  the  outlaws. 
Poor  old  mother  bear  finally  found  a  weak  place  and  broke 
through  much  to  the  relief  of  the  frightened  pursuers.  Of 
course,  the  drive  netted  nothing.22 

According  to  the  information  received  from  Roy 
Munkres,  John  Stevenson,  Jr.  and  Lou  Shaw,  the  robbers 
took  a  southwest  backtrack  off  EK  Mountain  and  being 
without  horses,  went  into  the  Bill  Hill  ranch  stable,  stole 
two  saddles  belonging  to  Hill  and  one  of  Alex  Ghen's  sad- 
dles and  then  went  into  the  pasture  and  took  three  horses. 
They  escaped  in  spite  of  some  100  men  on  their  trail.23 

To  escape,  the  robbers  climbed  the  mountain  from 
the  most  southern  point  known  as  "Little  Red  Fork  Can- 
yon." Taking  a  northerly  course,  they  traveled  a  distance 
of  four  or  five  miles  up  to  a  point  opposite  EK  Mountain 
on  the  west.  There  they  changed  their  course  to  an  easterly 
direction  and  descended  the  mountain  into  the  valley, 
coming  out  on  a  wide,  open  plain  about  one-half  mile 
wide.  They  are  supposed  to  have  then  crossed  this  plain 


25 


in  broad  daylight  and  climbed  up  EK  Mountain  for  a 
distance  of  200  yards  where  they  again  changed  their 
course  and  traveled  along  the  mountain  for  three-quarters 
of  a  mile.  Here  they  stopped  and  removed  their  shoes  and 
walked  across  the  west  to  the  mountain  east  of  Red  Fork. 
Here  they  stayed  for  two  nights  before  they  succeeded  in 
stealing  horses  from  Bill  Hill's  ranch.24 

In  another  development,  50  riders  gathered  at  the 
Tisdale  Ranch  at  noon  and  under  the  direction  of  United 
States  Marshal  Frank  Hadsell,  six  men  including  George 
Thompson,  Ed  Gill  and  Ross  Lambert  were  sent  to  Kay- 
cee.  This  group  reported  that  the  country  in  the  vicinity 
of  Kaycee  was  swarming  with  riders  who  were  supposed 
to  be  in  sympathy  with  the  train  robbers.  Therefore,  it 
was  difficult  for  the  lawmen  to  get  any  aid  or  positive  infor- 
mation. The  posse  said  that  the  men  would  be  taken  even 
if  they  had  gone  to  the  "Hole  in  the  Wall."25 

Major  C.  H.  Parmalee  of  the  state  militia  was  instruc- 
ted to  send  a  detail  of  ten  enlisted  men  and  one  officer 
to  Marshal  Hadsell  on  Powder  River.  The  militia  was  led 
by  Lieutenant  Smith  who  came  up  the  trail  from  Casper 
with  ten  men,  each  mounted  and  provided  with  50  rounds 
of  ammunition.26 

The  Wilcox  train  robbers  had  escaped  from  the  posses 
for  the  time  being.  General  Manager  Dickinson  and  rail- 
road officials  reached  Cheyenne  from  Casper  where  they 
had  been  directing  operations.  It  was  apparent  that  the 
robbers  had  hidden  in  the  Powder  River  country  and  were 
secure  from  capture  and  had  also  been  assisted  by  others 
in  their  escape.27 

The  lawmen  received  a  letter  that  the  United  States 
Government,  the  Union  Pacific  Railroad  and  the  Pacific 
Express  Company  had  offered  $1,000  for  the  capture  of 
each  of  the  Wilcox  robbers,  dead  or  alive.  Ten  of  the  posse 
members  returned  and  submitted  bills  to  the  Union  Pacific 
Railroad  for  five  dollars  a  day  for  each  man  and  his 
horse.28 

Sheriff  Yund  of  Albany  County  found  the  wagon  used 
in  the  robbery  at  Rock  Creek.  The  discovery  of  the  wagon 
had  no  particular  value  in  the  hunt  but  it  proved  the 
theory  that  the  men  drove  in  and  departed  from  the  scene 
of  the  robbery  on  horseback.  The  lawmen  were  of  the  opi- 
nion that  George  Curry  was  a  leader  of  the  gang  accom- 
panied by  Harvey  Logan  and  Elza  Lay.29 

Union  Pacific  officials  and  the  lawmen  said  the  rob- 
bers had  made  good  their  escape  into  the  vastness  of  the 
Big  Horn  Mountains,  but  the  men's  identification  was  so 
complete  that  detection  by  the  police  of  the  country  was 
"ultimate."  The  Union  Pacific  Special  that  came  in  from 
Casper  brought  Governor  DeForest  Richards,  Union  Paci- 
fic officials  and  citizens  who  had  gone  to  Douglas  to  attend 
the  funeral  of  Sheriff  Hazen.  The  train  had  a  boxcar  con- 
taining the  three  robbers'  captured  horses.  The  horses  were 
kept  in  Cheyenne  as  evidence  in  the  event  that  the  rob- 
bers were  captured.30 

Two  men  were  brought  to  Cheyenne  from  Kemmerer 


26 


to  identify  the  horses  captured  from  the  outlaws  during 
the  gun  battle  north  of  Casper  and  to  give  what  informa- 
tion they  knew  about  the  robbers.  In  their  testimony,  John 
Hastle  and  M.  Nolin  reported  that  the  buckskin  horse  had 
been  bought  from  Hastle  and  the  pinto  from  William  Feen 
of  Kemmerer.  They  reported  that  the  outlaws  purchas- 
ed, in  addition  to  the  horses,  a  team  wagon,  a  Winchester 
rifle  and  complete  camping  equipment.  The  men  started 
east  from  Kemmerer  on  April  15  which  would  have  given 
them  plenty  of  time  to  reach  Wilcox  station.  The  men 
also  gave  the  authorities  a  description  of  three  of  the  rob- 
bers, but  the  authorities  requested  that  they  withhold  this 
information  for  a  time.31 

People  from  throughout  the  area  were  convinced  they 
had  seen  the  robbers.  Consequently,  newspaper  reports 
carried  a  number  of  conflicting  accounts  of  the  robbers' 
whereabouts. 

According  to  a  Salt  Lake  Herald  reporter,  a  highly 
respected  woman  of  Uinta  County  talked  with  "Butch" 
Cassidy  less  than  a  month  before  the  robbery  and  she 
accounted  for  his  whereabouts  for  the  previous  two 
months.  She  had  not  been  the  least  hesitant  in  saying  that 
he  took  part  in  the  Wilcox  robbery.  Indeed,  the  members 
of  his  gang  could  have  taken  part  in  the  robbery  as  they 
were  within  50  miles  of  Wilcox  a  week  before.  The  fact 
that  Sheriff  Allred  of  Carbon  County  had  heard  that  the 
gang  was  in  the  area  was  further  proof  of  their  participa- 
tion in  the  train  robbery.32 

The  latest  news  from  the  outlaw  chase  was  that  the 
robbers  had  made  good  their  escape.  A  telegram  to  Lara- 
mie from  C.  H.  Parmalee  of  Buffalo  brought  this  news. 
According  to  this  message,  they  succeeded  in  securing  fresh 
horses  and  went  west  of  the  Big  Horn  Mountains.33 

The  trail  of  the  Union  Pacific  robbers  had  been  lost 
in  the  Big  Horns  near  Kirby  Creek  and  all  of  the  posses 
had  been  recalled.  The  two  posses  under  United  States 
Marshal  Hadsell  and  Special  Agent  Wheeler  were  ordered 
to  return  to  Casper  and  then  go  to  Cheyenne  where  a  new 
course  of  action  could  be  formulated.34 

It  was  believed  by  some  of  the  lawmen  that  the  men 
continued  through  the  mountains  making  their  way  to 
British  Columbia.35 

Rumors  were  circulated  in  Laramie  that  some  of  the 
posses  that  had  been  chasing  the  bandits  were  doubling 
back  on  the  trail  to  protect  the  railroad  from  another 
possible  robbery.  This  news  led  to  the  belief  that  the  men 
headed  for  the  Robbers'  Roost  in  Utah.  The  information 


Several  posses  pursued  the  outlaws.  Shown  (top)  are: 
George  Hiatt,  T.  Kelliher,  Joe  LeFors,  H.  Davis,  S.  Funk, 
and  T.  Jeff  Carr.  The  "Wild  Bunch"  are  pictured  below 
in  a  photograph  that  has  become  a  classic. 


was  given  to  Assistant  Superintendent  Hay  of  the  Union 
Pacific.  Hay  informed  Sheriff  Charles  Yund,  who  orga- 
nized a  posse  of  men  composed  of  M.  R.  Knadler,  Robert 
McKay  and  Ralph  Lasher.  They  loaded  their  horses  in  a 
special  baggage  car  and  started  out  on  the  train  for  Rock 
Creek.  They  planned  to  patrol  the  county  in  that  area. 
Other  posses  were  to  search  the  area  along  the  Union 
Pacific  Railroad.36 

Peter  Smart,  Jack  Martin,  Bill  Doyle  and  J.  Harnden 
returned  from  Casper  and  reported  they  had  no  hopes 
that  the  robbers  would  be  captured.  The  men  said  that 
the  robbers  seemed  to  be  headed  for  the  southwestern  part 
of  the  state,  but  no  one  could  really  tell.  The  men  believ- 
ed that  the  robbers  intended  to  remain  in  the  "Hole  in 
the  Wall"  country,  but  were  pressed  by  posses  and  so  con- 
tinued to  travel.37 

The  bloodhounds  could  not  be  used  until  they  were 
within  24  hours  of  the  robbers  because  the  trail  was  too 
cold.  It  was  believed  that  about  three  or  more  men  could 
chase  the  robbers.  According  to  the  officials  the  only  way 
they  could  be  captured  was  for  the  posses  to  get  the  drop 
on  them  while  they  were  in  camp,  or  at  some  unguarded 
moment.  There  were  only  now  about  a  dozen  men  pur- 
suing the  bandits.38 

It  was  believed  that  the  robbers  were  hiding  in  Albany 
County  as  A.  J.  Kenyon  of  Spring  Hill  in  the  northern 
part  of  that  county,  reported  the  stealing  of  a  saddle  horse 
from  his  pasture.  Kenyon  and  others  were  of  the  opinion 
that  the  animal  was  stolen  by  the  train  robbers  as  Ken- 
yon looked  after  his  cattle.  This  ranch  was  located  in  the 
rough  part  of  the  Laramie  Mountains  near  Laramie  Peak 
and  would  have  made  a  good  hiding  place  for  the 
robbers.39 

Three  men  believed  to  be  the  robbers  were  captured 
by  Yellowstone  Park  scouts  just  south  of  Yellowstone.  The 
men  were  surrounded  by  the  park  scouts  just  before 
daybreak,  and  news  of  their  capture  was  announced  by 
the  driver  of  the  Monida-Yellowstone  Park  stage.  The 
names  of  the  captured  men  were  not  released,  but  it  was 
later  proven  that  they  were  not  the  wanted  men  in  the 
Wilcox  robbery.40 

People  were  beginning  to  think  that  the  robbers  had 
been  killed  or  captured.  The  truth  of  the  matter  could 
not  be  verified.  One  woman  who  had  been  cooking  at  the 
"D"  Ranch  100  miles  west  of  Casper  arrived  in  Casper  on 
the  stage  and  reported  that  several  members  of  the  state 
militia  had  been  to  the  ranch  for  supper.  Reports  were 
also  current  that  five  dogs  were  on  the  trail  of  the  rob- 
bers a  few  miles  from  the  "D"  Ranch  and  the  posse  was 
traveling  as  fast  as  the  dogs  could  travel.  The  group  was 
still  four  to  eight  hours  behind  the  robbers.41 

Trailer  Johnson  arrived  in  Casper  with  one  of  his  dogs 
claiming  that  he  had  lost  the  others  in  the  badlands  of 
No  Water  River  about  30  miles  from  Thermopolis.  John- 
son reported  that  the  posses  were  never  nearer  than  three 
days'  travel  from  the  robbers.42 


Johnsons  story  was  not  believed.  Citizens  did  not  think 
that  Johnson  could  leave  two  dogs  under  the  circumstances 
unless  they  were  dead.  Many  people  believed  that  the  rob- 
bers had  been  captured,  and  that  the  lawmen  were  afraid 
to  reveal  their  capture  because  of  the  possibility  of  a 
lynching.43 

Two  men  were  arrested  near  Dillon,  Montana,  who 
were  reported  to  be  the  robbers.  The  two  fit  the  descrip- 
tions of  the  wanted  men.  They  also  had  lots  of  money  and 
had  arrived  on  fatigued  horses  in  a  place  called  Red  Rock. 
They  were  working  for  a  rancher  there  and  he  suspected 
that  they  were  the  bandits  being  hunted  for  the  Wilcox 
station  robbery.44 

The  Dillon  captives  were  brought  to  Cheyenne.  Mail 
clerk  Dietrick  and  Engineer  Jones  were  sent  for  and  both 
saw  resemblance  to  the  train  robbers  at  Wilcox.  Engineer 
Jones  was  sure  that  the  two  men  were  implicated  in  the 
Wilcox  robbery.  Sheriff  Shaver  of  Laramie  County  placed 
the  two  men  in  a  secure  cell  after  the  two  tough  looking 
individuals  gave  their  names  as  Bud  Nolan  and  Dave 
Putty.45 

District  Attorney  Timothy  Burke  could  not  produce 
enough  evidence  to  indict  the  men  on  the  Wilcox  charge, 
but  he  secured  enough  evidence  to  indict  the  two  on  rob- 
bing the  post  office  at  Big  Piney,  Wyoming,  and  the  post 
office  at  Wolton,  Wyoming.46 

Governor  DeForest  Richards  recalled  the  state  militia 
sent  out  to  aid  in  the  chase.  The  only  pursuit  left  was  by 
a  posse  from  the  Shoshone  Indian  Agency  composed  of 
Indian  police  in  charge  of  deputy  Jim  Baldwin  and  a  posse 
from  Lander  under  Richard  Morse,  deputy  marshal. 
These  two  were  following  some  suspicious  characters  that 
were  observed  crossing  Owl  Creek  mountains  in  the  direc- 
tion of  Green  River  one  week  before.47 

There  were  few  in  Casper  who  really  knew  the  "Hole 
in  the  Wall"  country.  The  officials  believed  that  Bob  Curry 
and  his  gang  would  never  be  captured  unless  there  was 
some  foolhardiness  on  the  part  of  the  robbers,  as  was  the 
escape  of  all  but  two  of  the  Folson,  New  Mexico  train  rob- 
bers. These  events  would  tend  to  encourage  other  des- 
peradoes to  make  train  robbery  a  part  of  their  avocation.48 

One  of  the  unsigned  bills  showed  up  in  Laramie.  This 
$100  denomination  was  in  the  safe  the  night  of  the  Wilcox 
robbery.  The  bill  was  unsigned  and  was  being  sent  to  a 
bank  in  Oregon.  It  was  reported  that  the  bill  came  from 
a  ranchman  who  tried  to  use  it  at  a  Laramie  grocery  com- 
pany. A  Mr.  Simpson  at  the  grocery  refused  the  bill  and 
it  was  afterwards  paid  into  the  Albany  National  Bank. 
It  did  not  remain  in  the  financial  institution  very  long, 
as  the  teller  paid  it  out  to  the  next  gentleman  who  came 
along.  Contrary  to  popular  belief,  one  of  the  tellers  at 
the  Albany  National  Bank  informed  the  Boomerang  that 
he  would  accept  any  of  the  bills  that  were  presented. 
According  to  the  teller,  when  the  bills  were  issued  by  the 
U.S.  Treasury  Department  they  became  legal  tender.  This 


28 


teller  said  that  the  express  company  was  responsible  for 
their  safe  delivery  to  the  bank.''9 

Several  of  the  unsigned  bank  notes  consigned  to  the 
bank  in  Portland,  Oregon  were  being  circulated  in  Ther- 
mopolis.  The  complete  contents  of  the  safe  would  never 
be  revealed  by  the  railroad  company,  but  it  was  the  belief 
among  Laramie  lawmen  that  the  robbers  were  still  hiding 
in  the  "Hole  in  the  Wall"  country  and  their  friends  were 
circulating  the  unsigned  bills.50 

The  full  extent  of  the  losses  to  the  railroad  and  ex- 
press company  will  never  be  known  outside  of  the  com- 
panies involved.  The  amount  must  have  been  comparable 
with  the  reward  which  was  extended  to  $3,000  per  man, 
dead  or  alive.  That  reward  totaled  $18,000.51 

Tom  Horn,  a  detective  from  Iron  Mountain,  reported 
the  killing  of  two  train  robbers  in  the  mountains  about 
40  miles  west  of  Jackson  Hole.  According  to  Horn,  he 
killed  the  two  men  while  they  were  in  camp  preparing 
supper.  He  and  his  companion  opened  fire  on  one  of  the 
men  who  was  frying  bacon.  He  was  shot  and  the  other 
man  jumped  behind  a  tree  and  started  firing.  Horn 
advanced  and  killed  him  also.  Horn's  part- Indian  guide 
was  hit  in  the  leg  and  Tom  took  him  to  Opal  on  the 
Oregon  Short  Line  for  medical  attention.  The  two  men 
left  dead  were  Smith  and  Montgomery,  according  to 
Horn.52 


Horn  was  sure  that  the  two  men  he  killed  were  invol- 
ved in  the  robbery  and  he  reported  the  killings  to  two 
Union  Pacific  detectives,  H.  Seavey  and  J.  G.  Harris.  It 
is  unknown  how  much,  if  any,  Horn  was  paid  for  these 
shootings.53 

During  the  months  following  Wilcox,  the  Pinkerton 
Detective  Agency  was  on  the  trail  of  the  outlaws.  In  March 
of  1900,  within  an  hour,  R.  E.  Curry  (alias,  Bob  Curry, 
alias  Bob  Lee)  was  surrounded  by  lawmen  in  a  gambling 
house  in  Cripple  Creek,  Colorado.  The  bandit  was  heavily 
armed,  he  was  dealing  stud  poker  when  Sheriff  O'Brien 
touched  him  on  the  shoulder.54 

He  was  surrounded  by  seven  lawmen  and  was  taken 
to  the  jail  where  two  armed  guards  were  posted  at  the  door, 
watching  every  move  he  made.55 

Lee  was  arrested  in  Cripple  Creek  the  same  day  that 
his  partner  Louis  Curry  alias  Louis  Logan  was  killed  in 
Dodson,  Missouri.  These  two  men  were  brought  up  by 
Lee's  mother,  Mrs.  Hiram  Lee  at  her  home  in  Dodson, 
near  Kansas  City.  They  were  cousins  and  their  close  rela- 
tionship continued  during  the  days  of  their  bandit  life  in 
the  west.  They  went  under  the  name  of  the  Curry 
brothers.56 

There  is  strong  evidence  that  these  two  men  were 
involved  in  the  Wilcox  robbery.  Letters  were  found  from 
one  to  another  with  enclosures  of  the  money  stolen  from 


J—  s 


A  cabin  in  the  Hole-in-the-Wall  country  of  north  central  Wyoming. 


29 


the  express  car.  One  hundred  dollar  bills  were  also  found 
in  Dodson  where  Louis  Logan  was  killed.  Bob  Lee  was 
transferred  from  Cripple  Creek,  tried  and  sent  to  the 
Wyoming  State  Prison  for  a  long  term.57 

It  was  also  reported  that  Louis  Curry  (alias  Kane 
Logan)  was  killed  in  Dodson  trying  to  escape  from  law 
officials.58 

Law  officials  discovered  some  Wilcox  notes  about  the 
Lee  House  where  Louis  Logan  (alias  Curry)  had  lived  with 
their  aunt.  The  law  officials  broke  into  the  house  and 
Logan  ran  out  the  back  door.  The  20-minute  gun  battle 
ended  with  Logan  being  killed  by  the  lawmen.59 

Lony  Logan,  the  outlaw  killed  at  Dodson,  Missouri 
(whose  real  name  was  Louis  Logan)  was  known  in  Crip- 
ple Creek  as  Frank  Miller.  The  Pinkerton  officials  were 
of  the  belief  that  Logan  was  the  leader  of  the  gang,  and 
that  it  was  not  George  Curry,  a  former  resident  of  Chad- 
ron,  Nebraska. 

After  the  Wilcox  Train  Robbery,  Flat  Nose  George 
Currie  said  to  his  gang  that  he  had  enough  of  train  rob- 
bery. He  returned  to  rustling  and  on  the  afternoon  of  April 
19,  he  was  caught  changing  brands  on  cattle  belonging 
to  Webster  Cattle  Company  near  Castle,  Utah.  Sheriff 
Tyler  of  Grand  County,  Utah,  ordered  him  to  halt,  but 
he  refused  and  after  a  brief  gun  battle  Currie  was  shot 
through  the  head  and  killed  instantly.61 

Harvey  Logan  (alias  "Kid  Curry")  held  up  a  Great 
Northern  train  near  Warner,  Montana,  and  secured 
$40,000  in  new  unsigned  bank  notes  similar  to  those  taken 
from  the  train  at  Wilcox.  Harvey  went  to  Knoxville,  Ten- 
nessee, and  tried  to  pass  one  of  the  unsigned  notes  at  a 
clothing  store  there.  The  manager  reported  Logan  to  the 
police.  After  a  chase,  with  Logan  trying  to  escape  on  an 
ice  wagon,  he  was  run  down  and  captured.62 

Logan  was  tried  in  Knoxville  in  the  Federal  Court  and 
received  a  sentence  of  30  years  for  having  in  his  posses- 
sion illegal  money,  but  before  he  was  transferred  to  a 
Federal  jail  he  escaped  from  the  local  jail  and  headed  back 
for  the  "Hole  in  the  Wall"  country.  He  stole  John  May's 
horse,  saddle  and  pistol.  Deputy  Sheriff  Beard  and  the 
posses  of  Kaycee  chased  Logan  and  another  man.  Shots 
were  exchanged  and  apparently  Logan  was  hit.  Logan's 
companion  helped  him  on  a  horse  and  they  escaped.63 

Two  days  after  the  gun  battle,  two  men  came  to  Ther- 
mopolis  in  search  of  medical  attention  for  one  of  the  men. 
Dr.  Julius  A.  Schulke  was  ordered  to  go  with  them.  He 
was  placed  in  a  buggy  and  taken  into  a  room  where  blan- 
kets were  hung  up  around  the  bed.  The  man  in  the  bed 
had  been  shot  through  the  groin  and  the  doctor  dressed 
the  wound.  Two  nights  later  the  men  came  for  the  doc- 
tor again.  He  looked  at  the  wound  and  told  the  men  that 
death  would  come  shortly.  The  doctor  returned  to  Ther- 
mopolis  and  neither  Harvey  Logan  nor  Kid  Curry  were 
heard  from  again.64 

The  next  train  robbery  by  the  "Hole  in  the  Wall"  gang 


took  place  at  Tipton,  Wyoming.  It  was  a  repeat  of  the 
Wilcox  robbery.  The  safe  was  blown  open  and  the  loot 
amounted  to  only  $50.40.  Some  say  that  "Butch"  Cassidy 
stuck  it  in  a  gopher  hole.65 

"Butch"  Cassidy  took  part  in  the  Wilcox  holdup.  While 
George  Currie  and  the  Logan  brothers  rode  north,  "Butch" 
Cassidy  and  two  other  bandits  rode  south.  Sheriff  Swan- 
son  of  Rock  Springs  followed  them  for  a  few  miles,  but 
returned  to  Rock  Springs  when  he  found  the  men  were 
headed  through  Horsethief  Canyon  to  Brown's  Hole.66 

It  is  said  that  after  the  loot  from  the  Wilcox  train  rob- 
bery had  been  divided,  George  Currie  remained  for  a  short 
while  in  Wyoming  at  Brown's  Hole.  He  picked  up  some 
other  bandits  and  continued  to  the  town  of  Green  River, 
Utah,  to  Robbers'  Roost  where  the  gang  had  an  excellent 
hiding  place.67 

Graves  are  scattered  all  over  the  "Hole  in  the  Wall" 
country  as  a  result  of  personal  feuds  among  the  robbers 
and  rustlers  that  once  used  the  place  as  a  refuge  from  the 
law. 

The  robbers,  always  under  the  eyes  of  the  Pinkerton 
detective,  suffered  the  following  fates: 

"Butch"  Cassidy  and  Harry  Longabaugh  were  killed 
by  members  of  the  Bolivian  Army  in  1909. 

Flat  Nose  George  Currie  was  killed  by  Sheriff  Jessie 
M.  Tyler  in  Utah  in  1900. 

Harvey  Logan  was  reported  to  have  died  of  blood  poi- 
soning at  a  ranch  near  Thermopolis,  Wyoming.  Some  law- 
men report  that  he  was  killed  in  a  gun  fight  near 
Parachute,  Colorado  in  1900. 

Bill  Varver  was  killed  by  Sheriff  Ed  Bryant  at  Sonora, 
Texas  while  resisting  arrest  in  1901.68 

The  newspaper  accounts  of  the  Wilcox  train  robbery 
and  its  aftermath  show  how  myths  and  legends  of  fron- 
tier outlaws  cannot  be  totally  blamed  on  "the  pulps."  The 
rumors  picked  up  and  printed  by  the  contemporary  news- 
papers show  how  easy  it  was  for  such  tales  to  be  born. 
It  is  little  wonder  the  debate  continues  on  who  really  par- 
ticipated in  the  Wilcox  train  robbery,  whether  "Butch" 
and  "Sundance"  actually  died  in  Bolivia,  and  over  any 
number  of  other  "badman-who-really-didn't-die"  stories. 
Rumors  became  myth  and  contemporary  newspapers  were 
less  than  blameless  in  their  creation.  Such  accounts  re- 
main popular  even  today. 


1 

Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  3, 

1899. 

2. 

Ibid. 

3. 

Ibid. 

4 

Denver  Daily  News,  June  4,  1899. 

5. 

Ibid. 

6. 

Denver  Daily  News,  June  3,  1899. 

7. 

Ibid. 

8. 

Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  4, 

1899. 

9. 

Ibid. 

10. 

Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  5, 

1899. 

11. 

Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  6, 

1899. 

112. 

Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  7, 

1899. 

30 


13.  Natrona  County  Tribune,  Casper,  June  8,  1899. 

14.  Buffalo  Voice,  June  17,  1899. 

15.  Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  7.  1899. 

16.  Ibid. 
Ibid 

Laramie  Daily  Boomerang.  June  9.   1899. 
Denver  Daily  News,  June  9,   1899. 
Ibid. 

Buffalo  Voice,  June  17.   1899. 
Margaret  Brock  Hanson.  Powder  River  Country,  The  Papers  of 

J.  Elmer  Brock,  (Cheyenne:  Frontier  Printing  Company,   1981) 
pp.  453-456. 

23.  Buffalo  Voice.  June  17,   1899. 

24.  Ibid. 

25.  Laramie  Daily  Boomerang.  June  10,   1899. 

26.  Buffalo  Voice,  June  17.  1899. 
Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  12,  1899. 
Ibid. 

Denver  Daily  News.  June  11.   1899. 
Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  13,   1899. 
Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  19.   1899. 
Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  15,  1899. 
Ibid. 

34.  Denver  Daily  News,  June  21 ,  1899. 

35.  Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  15,   1899. 

36.  Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  16,   1899. 

37.  Ibid. 

38.  Ibid. 

39.  Denver  Daily  News,  June  18,  1899. 

40.  Ibid. 


41.  Ibid. 

42.  Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  20,  1899. 

43.  Ibid. 
Denver  Daily  News,  June  22,  1899. 
Ibid. 
Ibid. 

Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  24,   1899. 
Denver  Daily  News,  June  25,   1899. 
Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  June  27.  1899. 
Ibid, 

Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  July  31,   1899. 
Denver  Daily  News,  July  31.   1899. 
Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  Sept.  23,  1899. 
Ibid. 
Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  Jan.  30,  1900. 

56.  Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  March  12,  1900. 

57.  Ibid. 

58.  Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  Jan.  30,   1900. 

59.  Denver  Daily  News,  March  1,  1900. 
Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  March  12,  1900. 
Alfred  James  Mokler.  A  History  of  Natrona  County,   Wyoming 
1888-1922.  (Chicago:  The  Lakeside  Press,   1923). 
Ibid. 
Ibid 

The  Wyoming  Pioneer.  Vol.  I,  No.  4  (May-June  1941). 
Laramie  Daily  Boomerang,  August  30,   1900. 
Ibid. 
Ibid. 

"The  Wild  Bunch."  Biographical  File.  American  Heritage  Center. 
University  of  Wyoming. 


11 
45. 
46. 
47. 
48. 
49. 
50. 
51. 
52. 
53. 
54. 
55. 


60 
61. 

62. 
63. 
64. 
65. 
66. 
67. 
68. 


31 


A  Wyoming  historian  once  described  the  Santa  Fe 
Trail  as  the  road  of  the  merchant,  the  Oregon  Trail  as 
the  path  of  the  homeseeker  and  the  Bozeman  Trail  of 
Wyoming  and  Montana  as  the  road  of  the  gold  seeker.1 
Before  John  Bozeman  guided  miners  and  emigrants  to  the 
Montana  gold  fields,  however,  the  general  route,  later 
designated  the  Bozeman  Trail,  was  used  for  centuries  by 
Indians  and  their  ancestors  following  game  trails.2  It  was 
not  an  uninhabited  country  before  white  men  arrived.  In 
fact,  during  the  heyday  of  the  fur  trade  in  the  1820s  and 
1830s  mountain  men  called  the  Powder  River  "Ab-sa-ro- 
ka,"  the  land  of  the  Crows.  By  the  1850s  Sioux  and 
Cheyenne  had  eclipsed  the  Crows'  dominance  of  the  area. 
It  was  these  three  Indian  groups,  their  migration  patterns 
and  their  inter-tribal  relations,  that  played  a  major  role 
in  the  drama  of  the  "Bloody  Bozeman." 

Between  1450  and  1880  many  ethnic  groups  moved 
toward  the  Powder  River  Basin  from  various  directions. 
Although  some  of  these  people  were  being  pushed,  they 
were  able  to  go  to  the  plains  because  the  land  offered  a 
secure  hunting  economy.  As  they  moved,  these  Indian  peo- 
ple abandoned  agricultural  economies  and  became 
hunters  and  gatherers,  their  lives  directly  tied  to  the  Basin's 
buffalo.3 

The  Crow  gradually  diverged  linguistically  from 
various  Hidatsa  groups  of  the  Missouri  Valley  at  least  500 
years  ago.  This  linguistic  severance  was  accompanied  by 
an  equally  gradual  movement  to  the  Northwestern  Plains, 
probably  accomplished  in  band-by-band  fashion  rather 
than  as  one  precipitous  migration.  The  Crows'  final 
separation  from  the  Hidatsa  dates  from  the  mid-1700s.4 
Some  Crow  reached  the  Powder  River  Basin  between  1400 
and  1600,  and  found  the  Uto-Aztecan  speaking  Shoshoni 
and  Comanche  groups.  Plains  Apache  groups  and  possibly 
some  Kiowa  already  there.  By  1600-1700  the  Crow 
expanded  across  most  of  the  Basin  and  between  1700-1800 
they  gained  firm  control  of  the  northern  Basin  along  the 
Big  Horn  Mountains  and  down  the  Powder,  Tongue  and 
Yellowstone  Rivers.5  Thus,  when  Edwin  T  Denig  oper- 
ated as  a  fur  trader  on  the  Upper  Missouri  between  1833 
and  1858,  he  found  the  Crow 

through  the  Rocky  Mountains,  along  the  heads  of  Powder 
River,  Wind  River,  and  Big  Horn  on  the  south  side  of  the 
Yellowstone,  as  far  as  Laramie's  Fork  on  the  River  Platte.  They 
were  frequently  found  on  the  west  and  north  side  of  the  river 
as  far  as  the  head  of  the  Muscleshell  [sic]  River,  and  as  low 
down  as  the  mouth  of  the  Yellowstone 

Denig  also  claimed  the  Blackfeet  on  the  west  and  the 
Sioux  on  the  east  were  the  Crows'  "natural  and  eternal 
enemies  .  .  .  from  time  immemorial  without  being  varied 
by  even  a  transient  peace."6  The  Crow  controlled  the 
western  half  of  the  Powder  River  Basin  south  to  Fort 
Laramie  between  1800  and  1850,  although  their  control 
was  declining  as  Sioux  and  Cheyenne  extended  across  the 
Basin. 

During  the  late  18th  and  early  19th  centuries,  Sioux, 


fcs&£ifl         ~^    Is     Cf==T==Msn- 

lv\f>      \  J.:      -A      /i  j!  V  i 

^^^^^^JJ-      XjM^'O^l   PARK     I 


~J         jSoulli  1\,„  Cily  oyju>Jil'™''Ji 


*\ 


«*   °  Vf,l    l*'     I    /    /    Fort  Brioger 

f\  f)  top  T"  »r^ 


Reprinted  by  permission  of  the  publishers,  The  Arthur 


The  Boz( 


By  Sherry  L.  Smith 


32 


t 

N  Fort  Collins*! 
O     L.)  O     R      A   ( 


■Denver 


ny,  from  The  Bozcman    Trail,  by  Grace  Raymond   Hebard  and  E.  A.  Brininstool. 


an 


Trail  to  Death  &  Glory 


33 


Cheyenne  and  Arapahoe  steadily  encroached  on  Crow  ter- 
ritory, a  situation  that  intensified  during  the  1850s,  1860s 
and  1870s  as  the  Sioux  and  others  were,  in  turn,  pushed 
westward  by  migrating  white  settlers.  The  Dakotas  or 
Sioux,  who  often  called  themselves  "Otchenti  Chakowin" 
or  Seven  Council  Fires,  originally  came  from  the  South 
and  established  themselves  on  the  headwaters  of  the 
Mississippi  during  the  16th  century.  From  1700  to  1750 
the  Oglalas  and  Brules,  two  Sioux  groups,  were  slowly  drif- 
ting westward  and  probably  took  part  in  periodic  exped- 
itions which  more  westerly  Sioux  made  against  Missouri 
River  tribes.  They  continued  to  drift  westward  through 
the  middle  of  the  18th  century,  more  often  as  poor  peo- 
ple begging  at  Arikara  towns  than  as  conquerors.  In  1775 
and  1776  an  Oglala  war  party  traveled  far  enough  west 
to  discover  the  Black  Hills,  and  by  1785,  the  Oglalas  drove 
the  Crow  out  of  the  territory  north  of  the  Black  Hills,  forc- 
ing them  to  move  west  of  Powder  River. 

From  the  Black  Hills,  the  Oglalas  migrated  to  the 
vicinity  of  Fort  Laramie  between  1834-1841,  induced  by 
white  traders  to  move  to  the  Platte.  During  the  winter  of 
1841-1842,  the  Oglalas  split  into  two  factions.  About  one- 
half  the  tribe,  known  as  Bull  Bear's  faction,  moved  toward 
the  southeast,  occupying  lands  in  Kansas  and  Nebraska 
between  the  Platte  and  the  Smokey  Hill  Fork.  The  other 
half,  Smoke's  faction,  went  north  occupying  the  head- 
waters of  the  Powder  River  in  northern  Wyoming.7  This 
faction,  under  the  leadership  of  Red  Cloud  and  others, 
played  a  critical  role  in  the  ensuing  history  of  the  Bozeman 
Trail. 

The  Cheyenne,  of  the  Algonquian  family  and  made 
up  of  two  related  tribes,  Tsis  tsis'  tas  and  Suh'tai,  also 
forced  the  Crow  westward  toward  the  mountains,  as  they 
migrated  across  the  plains.  Some  Cheyenne  reached  the 
Missouri  around  1676  where  they  engaged  in  agriculture. 
Before  this  they  lived  along  the  Cheyenne  River  running 
from  the  west  into  the  Red  River  and  earlier  than  that, 
in  Minnesota.  Gradually,  they  moved  out  over  the  prairie, 
gave  up  agriculture,  and  followed  the  buffalo.  The  Chey- 
enne claimed  that  when  they  secured  possession  of  the 
Black  Hills  country,  including  the  Little  Missouri  and 
Cheyenne  Rivers  and  land  toward  the  Powder,  the  Yellow- 
stone and  the  North  Platte,  they  encountered  no  Sioux. 
According  to  Cheyenne  tradition,  the  Sioux  migrated  later 
and  came  with  their  meager  possessions  strapped  on  dog 
travois.  The  Cheyenne  occasionally  provided  them  with 
horses,  generosity  that  resulted  in  more  and  more  Sioux 
crowding  into  the  country. 

The  Cheyenne  and  Sioux  maintained  amicable  rela- 
tions, however,  the  former  never  seriously  quarreling  with 
the  intruder.  Cheyenne  enemies  among  the  Plains  tribes, 
moreover,  coincided  with  the  Sioux's  -  the  Kiowa,  Coman- 
che and  the  Crow,  with  whom  the  Cheyenne  battled  for 
at  least  70  years.8  Friendly  relations  between  Oglalas  and 
Cheyenne,  their  constant  westering  movements  and  their 
mutual  animosity  toward  the  Crow  proved  critical  to 


fcl 


Red  Cloud 


their  allied  efforts  to  block  white  traffic  on  the  Bozeman 
road  in  the  1860s. 

The  Crow  and  the  fur  trappers  viewed  the  Powder 
River  Basin  in  similar  terms.  The  former  believed  the 
Great  Spirit  placed  them  in  exactly  "the  right  place." 
According  to  Crow  Chief  Arapooish,  "When  you  are  in 
it,  you  fare  well;  whenever  you  go  out  of  it,  whichever  way 
you  travel  you  fare  worse."9  The  upper  course  of  the  Powder 
River  was  also  a  favorite  wintering  grounds  for  trappers 
who  crisscrossed  the  territory,  because  of  its  abundant 
pasturage  and  the  winter  trade  with  the  Crow.10  To  them 
it  was  a  hunter's  paradise,  or  as  trapper  Joe  Meek  put  it, 
a  "land  of  Canaan." 

The  Powder  River  area  was  possibly  known  to  trap- 
pers and  fur  traders,  including  de  la  Verendrye,  as  early 
as  1742  although  positive  documentation  is  lacking.  In 
1807-8  Manuel  Lisa  established  trade  with  the  Crow  from 
his  post  at  the  mouth  of  the  Big  Horn  River  and,  as  a 
result,  probably  was  acquainted  with  the  Big  Horn  and 
Powder  River  countries.11 

More  substantial  documentation  exists  though  still 
somewhat  questionable,  that  the  first  white  men  in 
the  basin  fronting  the  Big  Horns  were  French  Canadian 
traders  Charles  LaRaye  (1802)  and  Francois  Antoine 
Larocque  (1805)  and  American  Wilson  Price  Hunt  (1811).12 
In  his  journal,  LaRaye  claimed  to  have  hunted,  trapped 
and  traded  with  Hidatsas  on  an  expedition  along  the 
Powder  and  Tongue  Rivers  and  their  tributaries  in  1802. 
Better  substantiated  is  Larocque's  journey  to  Bozeman 
Trail  country  in  1805.  Operating  as  a  trader  for  the  North- 
west Company  of  Canada,  he  came  to  the  Big  Horn 
Mountains  hoping  to  extend  the  company's  trade  territory. 


34 


Larocque  accompanied  Crow  trappers  along  the  course 
of  the  Powder  and  its  tributaries  near  present-day  Story, 
Big  Horn  and  Dayton.  "It  is  interesting  to  note,"  Bob  Mur- 
ray wrote,  "how  closely  Larocque's  Crows,  were  following 
the  later  alignment  of  the  'Bozeman  Trail,'  bearing  out 
the  contention  of  many  historians  that  this  trail  was  essen- 
tially a  publicized  linking  up  of  earlier  trapper  and  Indian 
trails  that  had  long  been  in  use."13 

One  of  the  first  Americans  to  travel  through  the 
Powder  River  country  was  Wilson  P.  Hunt,  employed  by 
John  Jacob  Astor,  principal  owner  of  the  American  Fur 
Company.  Hunt  crossed  Crook,  Campbell  and  Johnson 
counties  and  the  north  fork  of  Crazy  Woman  Creek  to  the 
Big  Horn  Mountains  on  his  way  to  the  Columbia  River. 

For  the  next  several  decades  the  northeast  quadrant 
of  Wyoming  became  increasingly  well  known  to  fur 
traders,  mountain  men,  explorers  and  missionaries. 

In  the  1830s,  Antonio  Montero,  a  shadowy  figure  of 
whom  little  is  known,  built  a  trading  post  called  the  Por- 
tuguese Houses  (Montero  was  born  in  Portugal)  and 
engaged  in  trade  with  the  Crow  on  the  Powder  River  in 
present-day  Johnson  County.  Working  for  Capt.  B.  L.  E. 
Bonneville,  Montero  operated  the  post  as  late  as  1837.  He 
built  such  sturdy  structures  that  when  Capt.  W.  F. 
Raynold's  1859-1860  Yellowstone  Expedition  passed 
through  the  area,  Raynolds  and  his  guide  Jim  Bridger 
found  remnants  of  the  post  still  visible.14 

A  party  of  trappers  with  Jim  Bridger  wintered  in  the 
Powder  River  plains  during  1830-31  and  1837-38,  and  Joe 
Meek  established  temporary  posts  in  the  Wind  River  and 
Powder  River  valleys  in  1834-35.  Meek  described  relations 
between  the  Crow  and  the  white  traders  as  "a  state  of  semi - 
amity,"  the  Indians  merely  tolerating  the  whites.  The  Crow 
wanted  the  white  man's  trade  goods,  especially  guns  and 
ammunition,  and  both  sides  seemed  satisfied  with  the  ex- 
change. Further,  because  the  Crow  were  enemies  with  the 
Blackfoot,  they  offered  some  protection  from  that  tribe, 
the  trappers'  traditional  nemesis.15 

Other  early  visitors  to  the  study  area  included  Father 
Pierre  DeSmet,  a  Jesuit  missionary  traveling  in  1851  along 
the  future  Bozeman  Trail  course  and  Sir  St.  George  Gore 
on  a  hunting  expedition  that  began  in  spring,  1855.  A 
wealthy  Irish  nobleman,  Gore  organized  a  major  expedi- 
tion of  about  70  men  at  Fort  Laramie,  including  Jim 
Bridger  as  guide.  They  ranged  the  country  from  the  Dry 
Fork  to  the  mouth  of  Powder  River,  wintering  on  the 
Yellowstone.  The  following  spring  Gore's  expedition  hunted 
in  and  explored  the  Big  Horns,  and  its  members  continued 
tramping  around  the  area  drained  by  the  Yellowstone 
River  until  they  departed  Wyoming  in  1856,  arriving  in 
St.  Louis  in  June,  1858.16 

By  the  following  year,  the  U.S.  government  indicated 
official  interest  in  the  area,  when  it  funded  the  1859-60 
Yellowstone  Expedition  led  by  Capt.  William  F.  Raynolds. 
The  expedition's  purpose   was   to   determine   climate, 


resources  and  Indian  populations  of  the  upper  Yellowstone 
and  the  Powder  River  country  and  to  explore  possible 
wagon  routes  between  the  Oregon  Trail  and  the  Yellow- 
stone-Missouri Basin.  Accompanying  the  expedition  were 
topographers,  meteorologists,  artists,  naturalists  and 
surgeons.  Beyond  academic  or  scientific  purposes,  how- 
ever, the  expedition  had  military  designs.  Government 
orders  indicate  the  War  Department  planned  a  network 
of  thoroughfares  that  would  intersect  the  Northern  Plains 
and  eventually  help  open  Sioux  and  Blackfoot  country 
to  white  settlement.17 

On  September  9,  1859,  Raynolds  departed  from  what 
would  later  become  the  site  of  Fort  C.  F.  Smith  on  the 
Big  Horn  River,  traveling  south.  Ten  days  later  the  exped- 
ition reached  Lake  DeSmet,  having  crossed  Tongue  River 
and  Clear  Fork  of  the  Powder.  They  took  one  side  trip 
into  the  Big  Horn  Mountains  and  another  to  the  ruins 
of  Montero's  Portuguese  Houses.  Their  route  from  the  Big 
Horn  River  to  the  Platte,  for  the  most  part,  approximated 
the  future  Bozeman  Trail  course.18 

Raynolds'  expedition  did  not  find  a  definite  route 
through  Powder  River  country,  but  the  Captain  prophet- 
ically reported,  "At  the  eastern  base  of  the  Big  Horn  Moun- 
tains there  is  a  belt  of  country  some  20  miles  in  width  that 
is  peculiarly  suitable  for  a  wagon  road,  and  which  I  doubt 
not  will  become  the  great  line  of  travel  into  the  valley  of 
the  Three  Forks."19  Within  the  decade,  that  belt  of  coun- 
try was  traversed  by  wagon  trains  on  the  Bozeman  Trail 
and  contained  several  Army  posts.  Moreover,  Raynolds' 
maps  were  the  most  detailed  to  date  of  the  Powder  River 
area  and  his  report  indicated  ways  of  penetrating  Sioux 
territory.  In  fact,  when  the  Army  resumed  hostilities  with 
the  Sioux  and  Cheyenne  after  the  Civil  War,  military  per- 
sonnel referred  to  Raynolds'  report  and  maps.20 

The  last  of  the  significant  early  visitors  was  a  group 
of  German  Lutheran  missionaries  who  established  a  small 
settlement  in  1860  on  the  west  bank  of  the  Powder  River, 
near  its  confluence  with  the  Dry  Fork.  Moritz  Braeun- 
inger  and  several  other  missionaries  built  a  log  house,  dug 
a  well  and  planted  a  garden.  As  representatives  of  the  Ger- 
man Evangelical  Lutheran  Synod  of  Iowa,  this  small  group 
thought  they  were  in  friendly  Crow  country,  rather  than 
among  the  Sioux.  It  is  not  clear  how  long  the  Lutherans 
remained  in  the  Powder  River  country,  but  Braueninger 
disappeared  one  day,  evidently  killed  by  Sioux,  and  soon 
after,  his  colleagues  abandoned  the  mission.21 

1841  was  a  turning  point  for  Plains  Indians  as  that 
was  the  year  the  first  Oregon-bound  emigrant  train  trav- 
eled up  the  North  Platte.  It  was  a  harbinger  of  things  to 
come  —  swarms  of  emigrants  moving  across  the  Plains 
where  up  to  then,  only  an  occasional  fur  trader  was  seen. 
The  Cheyenne  and  Sioux  were  alarmed  by  this  develop- 
ment because  emigrants  depleted  scanty  wood  and  grass 
supplies  along  the  road  and  from  the  countryside  fright- 
ened buffalo  herds,  critical  to  Indian  survival.22 

Over  the  next  several  decades,  Americans  followed 


35    ' 


The  North  Platte  road  to  California,  Oregon,  Utah,  Idaho 
and  Montana,  their  numbers  increasing  annually.  Join- 
ing the  "Forty-niners,"  John  Bozeman's  father  left  his  wife 
and  five  children  to  try  his  luck  in  California's  gold  mines. 
He  was  never  heard  from  again  and  the  family  presumed 
he  died  during  the  overland  trip.23  In  1860,  at  age  24, 
John  Bozeman  followed  his  father's  example,  leaving  a  wife 
and  three  daughters  in  his  native  Georgia  to  prospect  in 
Colorado.  By  the  time  he  arrived  in  the  Rocky  Mountain 
area,  however,  the  best  claims  were  taken.  Undaunted, 
he  moved  on  to  Idaho  Territory.  Potential  gold  mines  in 
Idaho  and  Montana  were  drawing  miners  in  droves. 

While  wintering  at  Bannock,  Idaho  Territory,  in 
January,  1863,  Bozeman  heard  rumors  of  an  old  traders' 
trail  along  the  Big  Horn  Mountains  that  could  serve  as 
a  short-cut  to  the  Montana  gold  fields.  Bozeman  and  John 
Jacobs,  a  man  who  had  knocked  around  the  Rocky  Moun- 
tains for  a  number  of  years,  were  intrigued  by  the  possibil- 
ity of  exploring  this  route  and  guiding  emigrants  and 
miners  to  Montana  for  profit. 

Up  to  that  point,  Montana-bound  emigrants  had  two 
travel  options.  One  route  followed  the  heavily  traveled 
wagon  road  up  the  North  Platte,  along  the  Sweetwater 
River,  over  South  Pass  to  Fort  Hall,  Idaho  and  the  western 
Montana  mines.  This  was  a  long,  tiresome  trip.  The  other 
alternative  involved  traveling  up  the  Missouri  River  via 
steamship  to  Fort  Benton.  Although  this  option  was  slow, 


John  Bozeman 


expensive  and  only  a  seasonal  alternative,  it  drew  many 
emigrants.24  "When  faced  with  the  high  cost  of  wagon 
transportation,  the  length  of  time  the  journey  consumed, 
and  the  Indian  problem,"  wrote  one  historian,  "a  major- 
ity of  travelers  from  the  east  chose  to  go  to  Montana  by 
way  of  the  Missouri."  Major  Howell  recorded  that  in  1867, 
some  10,000  miners  went  to  and  from  the  Montana  mines 
on  Missouri  River  steamers.25 

Recognizing  the  disadvantages  of  these  two  alterna- 
tives, Bozeman,  Jacobs  and  Jacobs'  half-blood  daughter 
left  Bannock  in  spring,  1863,  to  search  for  a  shorter,  less 
expensive  and  more  convenient  route  to  Montana  from 
the  south.  On  May  13,  the  three  met  a  party  of  Crow  on 
the  east  bank  of  the  Big  Horn  River  near  Rotten  Grass 
Creek.  Although  some  of  the  Indians  wanted  to  kill  the 
intruders,  they  instead  stripped  them  of  their  possessions, 
beat  the  girl  for  associating  with  white  men  and  sent  them 
on  their  way.  Upon  the  Crows'  approach,  Bozeman  had 
stashed  his  rifle  and  a  handful  of  bullets  in  some  sage- 
brush, so  the  small  party  was  not  totally  defenseless.  They 
proceeded  250  miles  south  to  the  North  Platte  emigrant 
road,  arriving  destitute  and  famished.  Bozeman  and 
Jacobs  recuperated  at  Deer  Creek  Station  and,  not  dis- 
mayed by  their  run-in  with  the  Crow,  began  organizing 
a  wagon  train  to  travel  their  "new"  route.26 

On  July  6,  1863,  46  wagons,  89  men  and  an  unspec- 
ified number  of  women  and  children  crossed  the  North 
Platte  at  Deer  Creek  and  became  the  first  wagon  train 
to  try  the  new  cutoff.  Led  by  John  Bozeman,  John  Jacobs 
and  Rafael  Gallegos,  a  Mexican  familiar  with  the  old 
traders'  trail,  the  emigrants  were  attracted  to  the  route 
because  it  promised  to  shorten  the  trip  to  Bannock  from 
800  miles  on  the  Oregon  Trail  to  about  450  miles  on  the 
Bozeman  Trail.27 

Several  diaries  and  reminiscences  from  this  first 
Bozeman  Trail  wagon  train  survive  and  provide  clues  to 
Bozeman's  physical  appearance  and  personality.  "Boze- 
man," according  to  James  Kirkpatrick,  "not  as  voluable 
[sic]  as  Jacobs,  was  a  tall,  fine  looking  Georgian  of 
somewhat  light  complextion  [sic],  a  tinge  of  red  in  his 
cheeks.  He  wore  a  fine  suit  of  fringed  buckskin,  and  had 
the  looks  and  ways  of  a  manly  man."28  And  W.  Irwin,  II, 
later  reminisced  that  "He  was  six  feet  two  inches  high, 
weighting  [sic]  200  pounds,  supple,  active,  tireless  and  of 
handsome  stalwart  presence.  He  was  genial,  kindly  and 
as  innocent  as  a  child  of  the  ways  of  the  world."29 

All  went  smoothly  for  the  first  Bozeman  wagon  train 
until  it  reached  a  branch  of  Clear  Creek  near  present- 
day  Buffalo.  At  that  point,  about  150  Sioux  and  Cheyenne 
interrupted  the  train,  protesting  its  movement  further 
north  and  threatening  to  attack  if  it  did  not  return  to  the 
Platte  road.  Uncertain  about  proceeding,  but  dreading 
the  prospect  of  backtracking  to  the  Oregon  Trail,  the 
emigrants  discussed  their  options.  A  small  group  raced 
down  the  Bozeman  to  seek  a  military  escort,  while  the 
rest  of  the  wagons  retreated  at  a  more  leisurely  pace. 


36 


Unable  to  secure  military  aid,  the  train  returned  to  Deer 

j  Creek  under  Jacobs'  leadership. 

However,  about  10  men  (including  Bozeman)  chose 
to  continue  through  Indian  country.  This  group  crossed 
the  Big  Horn  Mountains  at  the  headwaters  of  the  Powder 
River,  turning  north  upon  reaching  the  Wind  River  Coun- 
try. They  eventually  reached  the  Yellowstone  River  and 
the    Gallatin    Valley    without    encountering    any    more 

i  Indians.30 

The  following  season  (1864),  three  wagon  trains  chose 

'to  follow  the  Bozeman  Trail  to  Montana.  The  first  was 
guided  by  Bozeman  himself  and  left  from  the  Lower  Platte 
Bridge  around  July  18,  1864.  The  wagon  train  took  42 
days  to  reach  the  Gallatin  Valley  and  encountered  no 

■Indians  who  resisted  their  movements. 

The  same  luck  did  not  hold  for  the  next  train,  often 

(called  the  Townsend  Train.  Several  different  groups  of 

jemigrants  decided  to  take  the  Bozeman  cutoff  over  a  five- 
day  period,  consolidating  about  34  miles  out  by  July  3. 
The  train  was  a  large  one  of  150  wagons,  375  men,  36 
women,  56  children,  636  oxen,  79  horses,  10  mules  and 
194  cows.  The  emigrants  had  the  capacity  to  fire  more 
than  1,500  shots  without  reloading.31 

Near  the  Powder  River,  the  train  was  attacked  by 
Cheyenne.  The  emigrants  corralled  the  wagons  and  held 
off  the  Indians  for  several  hours.  Four  emigrants  died, 

tone  inside  the  corral  and  the  others  outside  of  it.  The  next 

■day  the  Townsend  Train  proceeded  up  the  trail  and  even- 
tually reached  its  destination. 

Following  the  Townsend  Train  by  several  weeks  was 
a  67-wagon  group  of  prospectors  led  by  Maj.  Cyrus  C.  Cof- 
finbury.  The  Coffinbury  train  started  on  the  Bozeman  July 
16  and  reached  its  destination  September  8,  taking  a  total 
of  59  days.  Although  this  group  was  not  challenged  by 

i  any  Indians,  they  did  encounter  the  graves  from  the  Town- 

isend  Train  fight  and  were  well  aware  of  the  trail's 
dangers.32 

Word  of  the  Bozeman  route's  hazards  reached  wester- 
ing emigrants  and  very  few  chose  to  follow  it  during  1864. 
The  vast  majority  took  either  the  Oregon  Trail  or  the 
Bridger  Trail,  another  short-cut  that  traversed  the  Big 
Horn  Basin  on  the  west  side  of  the  Big  Horn  Mountains.33 

!  Bridger's  Trail  crossed  more  arid  land,  was  a  bit  slower, 
but  was  safer  than  Bozeman's.  In  1864,  the  year  of  heaviest 
emigration  from  this  direction  to  the  Montana  mines,  nine 
trains  used  Bridger's  route  compared  to  three  on  Boze- 
man's.34 

As  Native  American  resistance  to  the  flow  of  emigrants 
intensified,  the  United  States  government,  in  turn,  inten- 
sified its  efforts  to  ensure  the  safety  of  miners,  emigrants 
and  settlers  on  the  Plains.  The  U.S.  Army,  no  longer 
engaged  in  the  Civil  War,  turned  toward  the  Plains  in  an 
attempt  to  subdue  those  Indians  who  attacked  white 
travelers  and  settlers. 

The  Indian  Wars  raged  south  of  the  Platte  during 
1864-5.  When  Col.  John  M.  Chivington's  volunteer  militia 


attacked  Black  Kettle's  Cheyenne  village  on  Sand  Creek, 
Colorado  Territory,  fugitives  from  that  fight  —  Southern 
Cheyenne,  some  Oglala  and  Northern  Arapahoe  warriors 
traveled  north  to  the  headwaters  of  the  Powder  River 
to  tell  Oglalas,  Minneconjous,  and  Sans  Arcs  Sioux  and 
the  Northern  Cheyenne  living  there,  of  the  white  soldiers' 
outrages.  They  urgei  the  Sioux,  Cheyenne  and  Northern 
Arapahoe  to  declare  war  and  participate  in  massive  raids 
against  stage  stations,  wagon  trains,  ranches  and 
settlements.35 

On  January  7,  1865,  Indians  attacked  the  stage  sta- 
tion, store  and  warehouse  at  Julesburg,  Colorado.  Raiding 
parties  operated  all  along  the  South  Platte  Valley  and 
Indians  of  the  Powder  River  Country  "warmly"  received 
Bozeman  Trail  travelers,  as  noted  above.  Northern  Sioux, 
led  by  the  Hunkpapas,  and  living  from  the  Missouri  River 
west  to  the  Lower  Powder,  continued  their  war  with  white 
Americans,  which  was  begun  during  the  1856  expedition 
of  Gen.  William  Harney.36 

In  response,  westerners  clamored  for  military  aid  and 
protection.  In  March  1865,  Generals  John  Pope  and  Gren- 
ville  M.  Dodge  formulated  plans  to  smash  the  Plains 
Indians  by  a  three  pronged  attack  —  one  south  of  the 
Arkansas,  led  by  Gen.  James  Ford,  one  across  Dakota 
north  of  the  Black  Hills,  led  by  Gen.  Alfred  Sully  and 
one  against  the  Powder  River  camps,  led  by  Gen.  Patrick 
Connor.  These  plans  were  postponed,  though,  by  a  Con- 
gressionally-mandated  peace  offensive,  brought  about  in 
part  by  Eastern  revulsion  toward  the  Sand  Creek  affair.37 

This  pacifistic  mood  changed,  however,  after  the 
Powder  River  groups  combined  forces  and  attacked  a 
company  of  the  11th  Kansas  Cavalry  which  guarded  the 
Oregon  Trail  crossing  of  the  North  Platte  at  the  Platte 
Bridge  Station,  about  130  miles  west  of  Fort  Laramie. 
By  the  time  these  Indians  returned  to  their  camps  and 
villages,  Gen.  Patrick  E.  Connor's  Powder  River  Expedi- 
tion was  underway.  The  expedition  consisted  of  three  col- 
umns, a  right,  middle  and  left,  that  were  to  join  around 
September  1  on  Rosebud  Creek.  The  right  column  of 
1,400  men  under  Col.  Nelson  Cole's  command  was  to 
march  up  Loup  Fork  of  the  Platte,  strike  Indians  at  Bear 
Butte  and  skirt  the  northern  edge  of  the  Black  Hills  until 
they  reached  the  vaguely  defined  rendezvous  point.  The 
middle  column  of  600  men,  under  Lt.  Col.  Samuel 
Walker's  leadership,  was  supposed  to  march  from  Fort 
Laramie  northeast  to  the  western  base  of  the  Big  Horns, 
on  to  the  headquarters  of  the  Little  Missouri  and  then 
northwest  to  the  Rosebud.  The  left  column,  led  by  Con- 
nor, and  consisting  of  about  500  soldiers  and  94  Pawnee 
and  Omaha  scouts,  left  Fort  Laramie  on  July  30.  On 
August  2,  a  contingent  crossed  the  Platte  at  LaBonte 
Creek,  marched  upriver  to  the  future  site  of  Fort  Fetter- 
man  and  then  turned  north  up  the  Bozeman  Trail,  while 
a  smaller  column  made  a  wide. sweep  to  the  west.  It  was 
one  of  the  most  comprehensive  expeditions  to  take  the  field 
against  Plains  Indians.38 


37 


On  August  11,  1865,  Connor's  column  reached  the 
Powder  River  and  several  days  later  began  constructing 
a  post  and  stockade  named  Fort  Connor.  August  22,  some 
of  the  troops  continued  their  march,  sometimes  parallel- 
ing, sometimes  intersecting  the  Bozeman  Trail.  Six  days 
later  Pawnee  scouts  reported  the  presence  of  an  Indian 
village  on  the  Tongue  River  near  present-day  Ranchester, 
Wyoming,  and  in  the  early  morning  hours  of  August  29, 
Connor  with  125  cavalrymen  and  90  Indian  scouts, 
attacked  Black  Bear's  Arapahoe  village  containing 
between  200  and  300  lodges.  Though  outnumbered,  Con- 
nor's forces  had  surprise  and  howitzers  on  their  side.  While 
Connor  inflicted  serious  damage  on  the  Arapahoes,  he 
also  withdrew  from  the  battle  under  fire  —  hardly  a  clear- 
cut  victory  for  the  Army.39 

Meanwhile,  the  Cole  and  Walker  columns  struggled 
through  country  that  lacked  sufficient  water  and  grass. 
Scurvy  struck  Cole's  command  and  rations  were  low. 
August  18,  1865,  the  two  columns  joined  and,  on  the  20th, 
reached  the  Powder  River.  Hunkpapa  Sioux  attacked 
Cole's  animal  herd  on  September  1,  and  September  4  a 
large  group  of  Sioux,  Cheyenne  and  Arapahoe  harassed 
the  columns,  though  the  Army's  artillery  kept  them  at  bay. 
Pawnee  scouts  from  Connor's  command  found  the  two  col- 
umns and  informed  them  that  Fort  Connor  was  down- 
river 80  miles.  On  September  20,  they  struggled  into  camp 
in  the  shadow  of  Connor's  fortification.  Several  days  later 
Connor  arrived,  reuniting  the  Powder  River  Expedition.40 

Although  he  planned  to  combine  forces  and  strike  at 
the  Powder  River  tribes  again,  Connor  received  orders  to 
disband  the  expedition  and  proceed  to  Salt  Lake  City  to 
serve  as  District  of  Utah  commander.  This  development, 
in  part,  reflected  post-war  Army  reorganization.  But  it 
also  reflected  Pope's  disenchantment  with  Connors  instruc- 
tions to  his  command  to  kill  all  male  Indians  over  the  age 
of  twelve.  "These  instructions  are  atrocious,"  Pope  wrote 
to  Dodge.  "If  any  such  orders  as  Gen.  Connor's  are  car- 
ried out,  it  will  be  disgraceful  to  the  Government,  and 
will  cost  him  his  commission,  if  not  worse.  Have  it  rec- 
tified without  delay."41  Connor,  keenly  disappointed  with 
his  new  orders,  never  completed  a  report  on  the  expedi- 
tion and  eventually  left  the  Army  altogether. 

The  Powder  River  Expedition  was  an  intricate,  large- 
scale  plan  probably  destined  to  fail.  Cole  and  Walker  lost 
almost  1,000  horses  and  mules,  and  great  quantities  of 
supplies.  Thirteen  men  were  killed,  five  were  wounded 
and  two  were  missing  as  a  result  of  Indian  skirmishes.  Both 
men  were  inexperienced  in  Indian  warfare  and  led  vol- 
unteer, mutinous  regiments  that  lacked  discipline.  Their 
supply  system  was  slow,  communication  was  poor,  and 
knowledge  of  the  enemy  and  the  Plains  weather  and  ter- 
rain was  inadequate.  Finally,  lack  of  a  well-defined  Indian 
policy  in  Washington,  D.C.,  undermined  military  efforts 
to  subdue  militant  Plains  Indians.  Department  of  Interior 
officials  and  Army  officers  disagreed  over  methods  to 


achieve  safe  passage  of  American  citizens  through  Indian 
country  —  the  former  pressing  for  a  "peace  policy,"  the 
latter  urging  a  forceful,  and  presumably  lasting,  con- 
quest.42 

Connor's  column  did  capture  some  Arapahoe  ponies 
on  the  Tongue,  but  the  Indians  believed  themselves  the 
victors  in  the  Powder  River  Expedition  battles.  They 
fought  their  own  way  —  harassment  from  afar  and  run- 
ning off  stock  —  lost  few  men,  took  many  horses  and 
counted  many  coup  during  the  fights.  Those  Indians  who 
encountered  the  Walker  and  Cole  columns  later  spoke 
brightly  of  those  incidents  as  they  enriched  their  camps 
with  cavalry  horses,  mules  and  carbines.43 

As  Connor's  men  marched,  or  straggled,  through 
Powder  River  country.  Col.  James  A.  Sawyer  led  a  wagon 
train  into  the  same  territory.  In  March,  1865,  Congress 
appropriated  funds  for  the  survey  of  a  wagon  road  between 
Niobrara,  Nebraska  Territory,  and  Virginia  City.  Actually, 
the  Sawyer  expedition  did  not  build  a  road.  Rather,  it 
pioneered  and  publicized  a  route  connecting  Sioux  City 
with  the  Bozeman  Trail  and,  thus,  Montana.44 

According  to  one  participant,  the  Sawyer  train  con- 
sisted of  15  wagons  each  drawn  by  three  oxen,  18  double 
wagons  drawn  by  six  yoke  of  oxen,  5  emigrant  wagons  and 
26  mule  wagons  that  belonged  to  the  military  escort.45 
The  survey  expedition  involved  53  men  plus  a  military 
escort,  commanded  by  Capt.  George  W.  Williford,  of  168 
men  from  the  Fifth  U.S.  Volunteer  Infantry  and  the  First 
Dakota  Volunteer  Cavalry.46  Sawyer  and  Williford  feuded, 
and  the  military  escort  made  and  broke  camp  when  and 
where  it  wished,  leaving  the  surveyors  to  provide  their  own 
guard  duty. 

Departing  on  June  13,  1865,  the  expedition  soon  began 
suffering  from  lack  of  water  and  encountered  impassable 
country,  having  to  backtrack  to  find  suitable  alternative 
routes.  For  the  most  part,  though,  the  Sawyer  Expedi- 
tion encountered  no  serious  problems  until  August  15 
when  about  500  warriors  under  Dull  Knife  (Cheyenne) 
and  Red  Cloud  (Oglala  Sioux)  harassed  the  party  for  four 
days.  Under  Capt.  Williford 's  strong  opposition,  Sawyer 
offered  some  Indians  a  wagon-load  of  goods,  hoping  to 
buy  safe  passage  through  the  Powder  River  country. 
Demonstrating  an  ambivalence  that  sometimes  accom- 
panied inter-tribal  warfare,  part  of  the  Sioux  and 
Cheyenne  were  willingly  bought  off  while  others  continued 
to  harass  the  Sawyer  party.47 

Sawyer  knew  an  Army  expedition  against  Powder 
River  Indians  was  underway  that  summer.  He  sent  two 
scouts  to  locate  the  expedition  and  bring  help.  The  scouts 
returned  with  news  of  a  fresh  wagon  trail  on  the  Dry  Fork 
of  the  Powder  River.  The  entire  expedition  moved  south 
until  it  struck  the  trail  and  followed  it  to  Fort  Connor. 
Capt.  James  H.  Kidd,  commanding  the  fort,  ordered 
Capt.  Williford 's  troops  to  remain  at  the  post  and 
designated  the  U.S.   6th  Michigan  Cavalry  as  Sawyer's 


38 


escort.  The  expedition  then  continued,  generally  follow- 
ing the  Bozeman  Trail  to  Montana.  It  was  delayed, 
however,  at  the  Tongue  River  when  Capt.  O.  F.  Cole  of 
the  6th  Michigan  wandered  away  from  his  colleagues  and 
was  killed  by  Indians  on  August  31,  1865.  The  next  day, 
while  crossing  the  Tongue  the  train  was  attacked  and  cor- 
ralled about  midway  between  present-day  Ranchester  and 
Dayton,  Wyoming.  Among  the  hostile  Indians  were  Black 
Bear's  Arapahoe  against  whom  Connor  had  fought  several 
days  before. 

Sawyer's  train  remained  corralled  on  the  Tongue  River 
for  almost  two  weeks,  waiting  for  couriers  to  bring  relief 
from  Connor.  The  Arapahoe  camped  nearby,  sometimes 
openly  hostile,  sometimes  professing  friendship.  Assum- 
ing no  help  was  on  the  way,  the  Sawyer  party  finally  began 
to  retreat  down  the  Bozeman  corridor,  toward  Fort  Con- 
nor, when  a  relief  column  led  by  Capt.  A.  E.  Brown  from 
Connor's  command  met  the  road  surveyors,  took  charge 
and  escorted  them  to  the  Big  Horn  River.  From  that  point 
on,  they  were  considered  safe  from  Indian  attack.  After 
almost  five  months  and  over  1,039  miles  of  travel,  the  expe- 
dition reached  Virginia  City  on  October  12,  1865. 48 

In  spite  of  their  problems,  the  Sawyer  and  Powder 
River  Expeditions  had  several  long-term  effects  which 
proved  detrimental  to  the  Powder  River  tribes'  interests. 
First,  it  increased  public  awareness  of  that  country  and 
the  Bozeman  Trail.  Second,  the  Army  expedition  estab- 
lished Fort  Connor  along  the  Bozeman  Trail  at  the  Dry 
Fork  Crossing.  Both  of  these  factors  encouraged  more 
emigrants  to  follow  the  Bozeman  cutoff  in  1866.  And 
increased  emigrant  travel,  in  turn,  meant  increased 
demands  for  government  protection. 

As  the  Powder  River  Expedition  wound  down,  Wash- 
ington, D.C.  officials  gave  Dakota  Territory  Governor 
Newton  Edmunds  authority  to  make  peace  treaties  with 
the  Sioux.  He  was  able  to  sign  treaties  with  a  number  of 
Missouri  River  bands,  but  none  of  them  had  participated 
in  the  recent  hostilities.  A  copy  of  the  treaty  was  then  sent 
to  the  commanding  officer  at  Fort  Laramie  along  with 
orders  to  bring  in  chiefs  from  the  Powder  River  country 
and  induce  them  to  sign  peace  agreements. 

This  was  not  the  first  effort  to  treat  with  Northern 
Plains  Indians.  As  early  as  1850,  Congress  had  author- 
ized the  Indian  Bureau  to  establish  formal  relations 
between  these  tribes  and  the  United  States.  The  follow- 
ing year  Agent  Thomas  Fitzpatrick  negotiated  a  treaty 
:at  Fort  Laramie  with  the  Teton  Sioux,  Cheyennes,  Arapa- 
'hoes,  Crows,  Assiniboins,  Mandans,  Gros  Ventres  and 
Arikaras,  assigning  specific  boundaries  for  each  tribe.  The 
treaty  was  aimed  at  winning  security  for  east-west  overland 
trail  routes  by  binding  the  Indians  to  peace  among  them- 
J  selves  and  with  white  Americans.  It  is  unclear  how  many 
Indian  signatories  understood  or  seriously  intended  to 
i  adhere  to  the  agreements.49  As  Bozeman  Trail  travelers 
and  Connor's  men  learned  by  1865,  they  did  not  intend 


to  allow  white  traffic  through  the  Powder  River  Basin. 

Hardly  in  a  mood  to  sign  peace  treaties  after  their 
successes  against  the  Powder  River  Expedition,  only  a  few 
traveled  to  Fort  Laramie.  But  running  low  on  trade  goods, 
particularly  arms  and  ammunition,  and  assuming  treaty 
gifts  and  trade  would  include  these  items,  Red  Cloud,  Red 
Leaf,  Man-Afraid-of-his-Horse,  Spotted  Tail  and  others 
eventually  came  in,  arriving  by  June,   1866. 50 

E.  B.  Taylor  of  the  U.S.  Indian  Office  headed  the  trea- 
ty commission.  Other  members  were  Col.  Henry  E. 
Maynadier,  commanding  officer  of  Fort  Laramie,  Col. 
Adam  McLaren  and  Mr.  Wister  of  Philadelphia.  Their 
hopes  for  a  lasting  peace  were  evidently  based  on  the  belief 
that  disappearance  of  the  buffalo  and  other  game  had 
made  the  Indians  destitute  and  thus  willing  to  trade  peace 
for  presents  and  subsistence.  Also,  Col.  Maynadier, 
obviously  uninformed  about  the  Sioux's  angry  mood, 
assured  Taylor  that  the  Powder  River  Indians  were  ready 
for  peace.  He  believed,  incorrectly,  that  Spotted  Tail  had 
influence  over  Red  Cloud  and  would  urge  him  to  sign  the 
treaty.51 

Operating  on  these  assumptions,  the  commissioners 
pressed  the  Sioux  to  withdraw  from  the  Powder  River  or 
Bozeman  Road.  The  chiefs  flatly  refused.  Commissioner 
Taylor  tried  to  explain  the  road  was  not  "new"  and  that 
it  would  not  harm  their  hunting  grounds.  However,  when 
word  reached  them  that  a  large  body  of  infantry  under 
Col.  H.  B.  Carrington  was  on  its  way  to  establish  a  string 
of  Army  posts  along  the  Bozeman  Trail,  Red  Cloud  and 
others  were  enraged.  The  Oglala  chief  made  a  violent 
speech  before  the  Commissioners,  accusing  them  of 
duplicity  in  the  road  matter  and  of  deliberately  with- 
holding information  about  the  troops  and  proposed  forts. 
The  Powder  River  tribes  gathered  their  belongings  and 
stormed  out  of  Fort  Laramie.  Those  they  left  behind  did 
sign  a  treaty,  but  their  signatures  were  meaningless,  as 
they  had  no  stake  in  the  Powder  River  country.52 

Carrington  and  the  Second  Battalion,  18th  Infantry, 
marched  up  the  Bozeman  Trail  planning  to  garrison  posts 
along  the  road  and  protect  emigrants.  Demonstrating  a 
misunderstanding  of  the  Indians'  violent  mood,  Gen. 
William  T.  Sherman  urged  officers  to  bring  their  wives 
and  children  and  Carrington  claimed  he  planned  to  treat 
the  Indians  with  "patience,  forebearance,  and  common 
sense."53  Further,  although  Carrington  had  nearly  2,000 
men  the  Army  strategists  miscalculated  on  several  counts. 
The  soldiers,  mostly  new  recruits  with  no  experience  in 
fighting  Indians,  were  stretched  out  along  the  Bozeman 
road  at  widely  separated  posts  —  too  distant  to  form  an 
effective  fighting  force.  Moreover,  Carrington  was  a 
42-year-old  Yale  educated  lawyer,  well  versed  in  military 
regulations,  engineering  and  administration,  but  lacking 
in  field  experience.  A  Civil  War  political  appointee  to  the 
officer  corps,  Carrington's  position  attracted  animosity 
from  subordinate  officers  who  had  more  combat  experi- 
ence.54 


39 


•-■• 


iVUlUUfliti 
be. 


X^W^  Iflpl 


rs 


!")'.r  rim.  Kearney  as  it  ArrEAKH>  josb  5th. 
Fort  PA*7  Kearny  as  it  appeared  June  5,  1876,  Frank  Leslie's  Illustrated  Newspaper. 


Carrington  first  fortified  Fort  Connor,  on  the  Powder 
River,  renaming  it  Fort  Reno,  before  proceeding  to  the 
forks  of  Piney  Creek  where  he  began  construction  of  Fort 
Phil  Kearny.  The  colonel  sent  another  party  up  the  Boze- 
man  to  the  Big  Horn  River  where  they  built  Fort  C.  F. 
Smith.  Taking  a  defensive  position,  rather  than  an  offen- 
sive one  against  the  hostile  Powder  River  Indians,  Car- 
rington threw  all  resources  into  building  formidable  forts. 
No  time  was  spent  training  recruits,  and  officers,  anxious 
for  some  offensive  action,  became  increasingly  insub- 
ordinate.55 

Within  one  week  of  the  18th  Infantry's  arrival  at  the 
Piney  forks,  Red  Cloud  struck.  Oglalas,  Minneconjous, 
Sans  Arcs,  Brules,  Cheyennes  and  Arapahoes  continually 
harassed  the  fort  and  wagon  trains  traveling  the  Bozeman 
road.  They  did  not  attempt  an  assault  on  the  fort,  but 
rather  ran  off  stock  from  civilian  and  military  trains  and 
attacked  wagon  and  wood  trains  transporting  logs  from 
the  pinery  to  the  fort  as  well  as  individuals  who  strayed 
too  far  from  train  or  Army  post. 

One  attack  on  a  small  military  train  at  Crazy  Woman 
Creek  typified  the  mode  of  Indian  warfare  during  Red 
Cloud's  War.  Outside  of  the  Fort  Phil  Kearny  vicinity,  the 
Bozeman  Trail  crossing  of  Crazy  Woman  Creek  was  one 
of  the  Indians'  favorite  spots  for  attack,  as  its  terrain  was 
especially  amenable  to  ambush.  July  20,  1866,  a  party 
of  about  30  men  and  women  under  Lt.  A.  H.  Wands  left 
Fort  Reno  for  Fort  Phil  Kearny.  Lieutenants  Napoleon  H. 
Daniels  and  George  H.  Templeton  rode  in  advance  look- 
ing for  a  campsite  on  Crazy  Woman  Creek.  Unable  to 
locate  a  suitable  place,  they  turned  to  rejoin  their  party 
when  as  Templeton  wrote  in  his  diary, 


Lieut,   remarked  "look  there"  and  spurred  his  horse  up, 
going  away  ahead.   I  looked  over  my  right  shoulder,  but 
could  see  nothing,   but  upon  looking  over  my  left,   I  saw 
between  50  and  60  Indians  mounted  and  in  fall  chase  about 
150  yards  in  the  rear.  I  spurred  up  old  Pegasus,  punched  him 
with  my  gun  and  did  everything  to  increase  speed,  but  the 
horse  seemed  to  me  to  be  moving  very  slowly.  After  Mr. 
Daniels  had  gone  200  yards  he  was  shot  with  an  arrow 
through  the  back  and  fell  off  his  horse,  the  saddle  turning. 
I  could  do  nothing  to  help  him  and  did  not  expect  to  get 
away  myself  .  .  . 
Templeton,  hotly  pursued,  reached  the  train  which  then 
corralled  on  a  bluff  overlooking  the  Creek.  The  battle  con- 
tinued for  several  hours,  until  a  cavalry  patrol  traveling 
from  Fort  Phil  Kearny  on  its  way  to  Fort  Reno,  under  Capt. 
George  Burroughs'  command,  relieved  the  beleaguered 
party.56 

Also  typical  of  the  Indian  decoy-ambush  tactic  was 
the  December  6,  1866,  attack  on  a  wood  train  near  Fort 
Phil  Kearny.  Carrington  and  a  small  mounted  force  joined 
Capt.  William  J.  Fetterman  with  a  company  of  mounted 
infantry,  and  Lt.  H.  S.  Bingham  with  a  company  of 
cavalry,  who  rushed  to  the  train's  defense.  They  relieved 
the  wood  train  and  then  tried  to  pursue  and  cut  off  the 
Indians.  Chasing  the  Indians  over  Lodge  Trail  Ridge,  the 
three  units  reunited  just  before  300  Sioux  converged  on 
them.  Lt.  Bingham  and  Sgt.  Gideon  Bowers  were  killed 
and  the  rest  only  narrowly  escaped.57 

Carrington's  basically  defensive  position  suited  the 
Powder  River  tribes.  Forts  Phil  Kearny,  C.  F.  Smith  and 
Reno  were  not  technically  under  siege,  but  the  Sioux, 
Cheyenne  and  Arapahoe  continuously  raided  their  vicin- 
ities, perpetrating  about  one  incident  per  day  around  Fori 
Phil  Kearny.  For  many  of  the  warriors,  these  fights  had 


40 


social  and  economic  benefits  which  they  viewed  mostly 
in  individual  terms  (honor  in  counting  coup,  for  exam- 
ple). A  few,  however,  including  Crazy  Horse  and  Red 
Cloud  of  the  Oglalas  and  High  Back  Bone  of  the  Min 
neconjous,  understood  the  serious  and  permanent  threat 
the  military  men  represented  and  so  tried  to  cut  the  forts 
off  from  one  another  and  engage  in  large-scale  battles, 
to  protect  tribal  interests  and  territory.58 

On  December  21,  1866,  these  leaders  had  their  way. 
High  Back  Bone  organized  the  operation,  Crazy  Horse 
led  the  decoy  party,  Black  Leg  and  Black  Shield  (Sioux), 
Dull  Knife,  Walking  Rabbit  and  other  Cheyenne  chiefs 
; participated  as  well.  Red  Cloud  was  not  present.  In  typical 
[fashion,  a  party  of  Indians  attacked  the  wood  train.  Car- 
irington  ordered  Capt.  Fetterman  to  relieve  the  train  and 
(cautioned  him  not  to  pursue  the  Indians  over  Lodge  Trail 
(Ridge,  probably  recalling  his  own  narrow  escape  beyond 
jthe  Ridge  on  December  6.  Fetterman,  one  of  those  offi- 
cers who  chafed  at  Carrington's  cautious  defensive  posi- 
tion, favored  more  offensive,  aggressive  action.  So,  Fet- 
terman, Lt.  George  W.  Grummond,  three  other  officers, 
'67  soldiers  and  two  civilians,  not  only  relieved  the  wood 
train  but,  disregarding  Carrington's  orders,  followed  the 
Indians  over  Lodge  Trail  Ridge  and  rode  into  a  deadly 
ambush. 

Behind  the  fort's  stockade,  Carrington  and  others 
'helplessly  watched  Fetterman's  men  disappear  over  Lodge 
Trail  Ridge  and  heard  sharp  rifle  reports,  indications  of 
fierce  fighting.  The  commmanding  officer  ordered  Capt. 
•Ten  Eyck  and  40  men  to  Fetterman's  rescue,  but  by  the 
time  they  reached  the  crest  of  the  ridge,  the  fight  was  over. 
All  of  Fetterman's  command  was  dead.  Estimates  of 
Indian  dead,  difficult  to  ascertain,  range  from  15  to  50. 
Their  losses,  whatever  the  exact  number,  were  relatively 
high  for  small  bands  living  in  a  hostile  environment.59 

In  a  panic,  Col.  Carrington  sent  two  volunteer  cour- 
iers, John  "Portugee"  Phillips  and  Daniel  Dixon,  on  a  four- 
Iday,  190 -mile  ride  to  the  Horseshoe  Telegraph  Station  on 
the  Oregon  Trail  with  news  of  the  disaster  and  a  plea  for 
jhelp.  It  is  not  known  if  they  traveled  together  at  the  outset. 
(But  paralleling  the  Bozeman  Trail  while  avoiding  the  road 
litself,  they  arrived  together  at  Fort  Reno  and  they  were 
(together  when  they  reached  the  telegraph  station  at  about 
110  a.m.  on  Christmas  Day.  Carrington's  dispatches  were 
Iwired  to  the  department  commander  at  Omaha  and  to 
the  commanding  officer  at  Fort  Laramie.  Phillips  went 
Dn  to  Fort  Laramie  with  a  separate  message  for  Col.  I. 
N.  Palmer,  commanding  officer,  from  Lt.  Col.  Henry  W. 
Wessels  at  Fort  Reno.60  Word  of  the  Fetterman  disaster, 
of  course,  preceded  Phillip's  arrival  at  Fort  Laramie  and 
preparations  for  relief  were  already  underway. 

In  the  aftermath  of  the  Fetterman  disaster,  Gen. 
'Phillip  St.  George  Cooke  ordered  Lt.  Col.  Wessels  to  take 
command  of  Fort  Phil  Kearny  and  Carrington  was  ordered 
to  Fort  Caspar.  Two  companies  of  the  2nd  Cavalry  and 
four  of  the  18th  infantry  marched  up  the  Bozeman  Trail 


to  reinforce  Forts  Reno  and  Phil  Kearny.  Wessels,  who 
served  33  years  in  the  military  including  the  Mexican  and 
Civil  Wars,  reopened  communications  with  Fort  C.  F. 
Smith,  concentrated  on  training  the  soldiers  and  saw  that 
supply  trains  passed  along  the  Bozeman  road.61  Finally, 
the  troops  were  supplied  with  new  breech-loading  rifles, 
an  innovation  that  proved  important  the  following  sum- 
mer. 

With  spring,  the  Powder  River  tribes  commenced 
their  annual  raiding  and  again  succeeded  in  virtually  clos- 
ing down  the  Bozeman  Trail  to  all  civilian  traffic.  For  the 
most  part  the  Army  posts  were  only  protecting  themselves. 
These  raids  culminated  in  two  fights  —  the  Wagon  Box 
Fight  outside  Fort  Phil  Kearny  and  the  Hayfield  Fight  near 
Fort  C.  F  Smith.  Oglala,  Minneconjou,  Sans  Arc  Sioux, 
Northern  Cheyenne  and  Northern  Arapahoe  congregated 
on  the  Little  Big  Horn  River  in  July  for  their  annual  sun 
dance.  From  there  about  500  Indians  proceeded  to  Fort 
C.  F.  Smith  and  engaged  a  small  party  of  haycutters  in 
a  three-hour  fight.  Another  1,000  Indians  rode  to  Fort 
Phil  Kearny  where  they  attacked  32  men  in  a  wood  camp. 
Capt.  James  Powell  ordered  the  men  to  make  a  corral  out 
of  their  wagon  bodies  or  boxes  and,  at  the  cost  of  several 
casualties,  successfully  prevented  Indian  attempts  to  over- 
run their  position.  The  Indians  withdrew  from  the  field 
when  Maj.  Benjamin  Smith's  relief  party  appeared  from 
the  nearby  fort.62 

The  Indians,  however,  did  not  view  either  fight  as  a 
defeat  since  they  lost  relatively  few  men  and  did  run  off 
military  stock  and  kill  several  soldiers.  They  could  not  suc- 
cessfully storm  the  wagon  box  breastworks  because  its 
defenders  had  new  breech-loading  rifles,  seriously  under- 
mining the  Indian  tactic  of  attacking  while  soldiers 
reloaded.  For  the  soldiers,  on  the  other  hand,  both  fights 
represented  at  least  a  psychological  victory.  With  discip- 
line and  improved  weapons  they  successfully  turned  back 
large  numbers  of  Indians  and  avoided  Fetterman's  fate.63 
From  the  onset  of  "Red  Cloud's  War,"  few  trains  fol- 
lowed the  Bozeman  Trail.  This  fact  did  not  escape  official 
notice.  Several  weeks  after  the  Wagon  Box  Fight,  Capt. 
Wishart  reported  to  a  Philadelphia  newspaper  from  Fort 
Kearny: 

That  the  road  is  not  kept  open  all  who  have  been  on  it  lately 

know  full  well.  No  train  can  be  sent  along  it  without  from 

two  to  three  companies  of  soldiers,  one  of  which  is  generally 

a  Cavalry  company,  and  one  piece  of  artillery,  and  at  the 

present  time  the  safety  of  Government  trains,  even  with  these 

large  escorts,  is  considered  questionable  .  .  .  trains  only  come 

along  the  road  semi-occasionally,  and  the  consequence  is  that 

the  miners  take  the  Salt  Lake  City  Route.64 

Several  parties  did  use  the  Bozeman  route  during  1866, 

however.  Gen.  W.  B.  Hazen  conducted  an  inspection  of 

northern  plains  forts  in  1866  and  traveled  the  Bozeman. 

Among  his  recommendations  was  that  blockhouses  be 

built  on  one  of  the  forks  of  the  Cheyenne,  one  on  Crazy 

Woman  Creek  and  one  on  a  fork  of  the  Tongue  River.65 


41 


Nelson  Story,  a  Montana  merchant  followed  Hazen  up 
the  trail  several  weeks  later  with  a  wagon  train,  a  herd 
of  Texas  cattle  and  26  cowboys.  Indians  harassed  Story's 
cattle  drive,  bound  for  the  Gallatin  Valley  market,  but 
the  cowboys  fended  them  off.66 

In  the  wake  of  the  Fetterman  fight,  however,  no  sig- 
nificant number  of  emigrants  or  miners  chose  the  Boze- 
man  route  in  1867  or  1868.  One  historian  estimated  that 
between  1864  and  1868  not  over  1,000  emigrants  took  the 
trail  to  Montana  —  out  of  the  entire  territorial  popula- 
tion in  1868  of  20, 000. 67 

Policy-makers,  then,  began  to  wonder  if  a  route  used 
almost  solely  by  the  military  justified  the  cost  and  man- 
power. Also,  by  1868,  the  Union  Pacific  Railroad  was 
advancing  toward  the  Salt  Lake  City-Virginia  City  route 
and,  in  the  process,  rendering  the  Bozeman  Trail  obsolete 
for  Montana  traffic.  The  Bozeman  route  could  not  com- 
pete through  the  1860s  with  the  Missouri  River  steamboat 
traffic  or  with  the  safer  South  Pass- Fort  Hall  route. 
Moreover,  Gen.  W.  T  Sherman  committed  almost  all  the 
Army  troops  to  the  un-reconstructed  American  South  and 
was  not  prepared  or  able  to  send  20,000  soldiers  to  engage 
in  a  fight  to  the  finish  with  the  Northern  Plains  tribes. 

In  April,  1868,  peace  commissioners  returned  to  Fort 
Laramie,  conceding  the  Bozeman  Trail  country  to  the 
Powder  River  tribes  and  abandoning  Forts  Reno,  Phil 
Keamy  and  C.  F.  Smith.  Red  Cloud,  who  would  not  come 
in  until  the  Army  evacuated  its  forts,  finally  signed  the 
treaty  on  November  6,  1868,  thus  ending  Red  Cloud's  War 
and  beginning  a  period  of  relative  peace  on  the  North- 
ern Plains  that  lasted  until  1876. 68 

By  the  terms  of  the  1868  peace  treaty,  the  U.S.  Gov- 
ernment declared  the  land  north  of  the  North  Platte  River 
and  east  of  the  Big  Horn  Mountains  Indian  territory  and 
stated  that  whites  could  not  settle  there  or,  without  Indian 
permission,  even  pass  through.  It  also  stipulated  that  the 
Bozeman  Road  was  closed.  One  contemporary,  living  at 
Fort  Laramie  from  1867  on,  claimed  that  absolutely  no 
one  traveled  the  Bozeman  Trail  between  1868  and  1876. 69 
Perhaps  an  occasional,  intrepid,  small  group  of  miners 
traveled  through  the  Powder  River  Basin,  but  that  region 
was  effectively  cut  off  from  whites  for  about  eight  years. 

In  the  intervening  years,  however,  the  government 
sponsored  trespassing  on  Northern  Plains  Indians'  territory 
-  providing  Northern  Pacific  Railroad  surveyors  with  a 
military  escort  in  1871  and  again  in  1873.  In  1874  Gen. 
Phillip  Sheridan,  commander  of  the  Division  of  the 
Missouri,  ordered  Col.  George  A.  Custer  to  conduct  a 
reconnaissance  of  the  Black  Hills  in  anticipation  of 
establishing  a  post  there.  This  expedition  outraged  North- 
ern Plains  tribes,  but  they  did  not  attack.  Several  pro- 
spectors accompanied  the  Custer  expedition  and  discov- 
ered gold  in  the  Black  Hills.  Word  of  the  gold  find  swept 
the  region,  gold  seekers  began  illegally  filtering  into  the 
Indian  territory  and  the  Army  could  not  turn  back  the 


"Black  Hills  Invasion."  Unable  to  stop  the  trespassers,  the 
government  in  September,  1875,  sent  another  commission 
to  negotiate  with  the  Sioux  for  cession  of  the  Black  Hills. 
The  Indians  were  incensed.  The  Black  Hills  were  not  for 
sale.70 

President  Grant  took  a  tougher  position  in  Novem- 
ber, 1875,  ordering  the  Indians  of  the  Powder  River  and 
Big  Horn  country  to  come  into  their  agencies  by  January 
31,  1876.  If  they  refused,  military  troops  would  drive  them 
in.  The  Sioux  ignored  the  ultimatum.71  In  anticipation 
of  enforcing  compliance  with  Grant's  order  to  the  Indians, 
Gen.  George  Crook  had  assembled  an  expedition  to  strike 
Powder  River  "hostiles"  at  Fort  Fetterman  by  the  end  of 
February,  1876.  Fort  Fetterman,  on  the  North  Platte,  was 
a  post  built  in  1867  to  provide  protection  for  Bozeman 
Trail  travelers.  It  was  not,  however,  abandoned  with  the 
others  in  1868.  Once  again,  the  Bozeman  Road  became 
a  thoroughfare  of  the  American  military,  now  prepared 
for  a  fight  to  the  finish  with  the  Sioux  and  Cheyenne  over 
control  of  the  Northern  Plains. 

Crook's  expedition  of  almost  900  officers,  enlisted  men 
and  civilians  was  commanded  by  Col.  Joseph  J.  Reynolds, 
Third  Cavalry.  Their  primary  targets  were  the  Northern 
Cheyenne  and  the  western  division  of  Sioux  (Lakota), 
including  the  Oglala,  Brule,  Hunkpapa  and  Minnecon- 
jou  bands.  On  March  1,  the  troops  crossed  the  North 
Platte  at  Fort  Fetterman  and  marched  up  the  Bozeman 
Trail.  On  March  17,  a  portion  of  the  column  under 
Reynolds  attacked  a  Cheyenne  village  in  southern  Mon- 
tana. The  soldiers  inflicted  some  damage,  killing  one  war- 
rior, burning  the  village  and  capturing  the  pony  herd. 
But  after  a  five-hour  fight  they  were  turned  back  and  the 
Cheyenne  recovered  most  of  their  ponies.  The  soldiers  were 
disgruntled  that  their  dead  comrades  were  left  unburied 
on  the  field  and  when  they  rejoined  the  rest  of  the  col- 
umn, feuded  over  the  mismanaged  attack.  March  26,  the 
command  hobbled  into  Fort  Fetterman  and  Crook  began 
court-martial  proceedings  against  Reynolds  for  bungling 
the  battle.72 

The  Cheyenne  did  suffer  the  loss  of  their  lodges,  robes, 
provisions  and  about  200  ponies.  They  were  also  forced, 
in  cold  winter  weather,  to  seek  sanctuary  in  other  villages. 
"Most  important  of  all,"  wrote  one  historian,  "the  attack 
convinced  all  that  the  ultimatum  from  Washington  meant 
that  they  were  marked  for  extermination  and  their  lands 
for  seizure  by  the  relentless  and  greedy  white  man.  The 
dreaded  day  had  come  when  they  must  fight  for  survival. 
In  bitter  desperation  they  began  gathering  into  one  power- 
ful camp  for  self-preservation."73  Northern  Plains  tribes 
were  enraged  by  the  unexpected  Reynolds'  campaign  and 
Sioux  and  Cheyenne,  under  Sitting  Bull  and  Crazy  Horse, 
combined  to  counter  the  military  threat. 

Meanwhile,  Crook  assembled  another  column  of 
troops  at  Fort  Fetterman  which  again  took  to  the  Bozeman 
Trail  on  May  29.  This  was  one  of  three  offensive  forces 
in  the  field,  along  with  Col.  John  Gibbon's  column  travel- 


42 


ing  eastward  through  Montana  and  Gen.  Alfred  Terry's 
column  (with  Custer's  doomed  Seventh  Cavalry)  moving 
west  through  Dakota,  that  hoped  to  force  the  Sioux  to 
their  agencies.  This  time  Crook  assumed  personal  com- 
mand of  51  officers  and  more  than  1,325  soldiers  and 
Indian  allies.  On  June  17,  they  engaged  some  hostiles  at 
Rosebud  Creek,  Montana.  The  battle  was  a  tactical  draw, 
but  a  strategic  defeat  for  Crook  who  did  not  achieve  his 
goal  of  smashing  the  opposition.  The  Indians,  on  the  other 
hand,  halted  Crook's  progress  and  saved  an  attack  on  their 
village.74  Eight  days  later  Custer  and  his  command  met 
their  fate  on  the  Little  Big  Horn  River. 

The  Battle  of  the  Little  Big  Horn  represented  the 
combined  Sioux/Cheyenne  forces  at  their  zenith.  From 
that  point  on,  they  were  less  able  to  secure  supplies  and 
ammunition.75  Public  sentiment  to  avenge  the  Seventh 
Cavalry's  defeat  reached  a  fever  pitch.  In  response,  Gen. 
Nelson  Miles  pursued  Sitting  Bull  across  Montana  while 
Gen.  Crook  assembled  yet  another  column  at  Fort  Fet- 
terman  during  the  fall  of  1876.  This  expedition  of  about 
2,200  men,  left  Fort  Fetterman  November  14,  1876,  and 
marched  up  the  Bozeman  Trail.  Stopping  at  the  trail's 
Powder  River  crossing,  the  troops  established  a  supply  base 
named  Cantonment  Reno,  about  three  miles  upstream 
from  the  former  Fort  Connor/ Reno  site.  They  resumed 
the  march  until  a  scout  informed  Crook  of  a  Northern 
Cheyenne  village  in  the  upper  valley  of  the  Red  Fork,  one 
of  the  Powder  River  headwater  streams  in  the  Big  Horns. 
Camping  on  Crazy  Woman  Creek,  Crook  ordered  Col. 
Ranald  Mackenzie  and  10  cavalry  troops  to  attack  the 
village.  At  daybreak  on  November  25,  1876,  the  troops 
and   scouts   charged   the   sleepy,    unsuspecting   village. 


After  a  fierce  fight,  which  included  some  hand-to-hand 
combat,  the  Army  destroyed  the  village.76  Participant 
Capt.  John  Bourke  later  wrote, 

The  full  loss  of  the  Cheyennes  was  not  determined  until  their 
surrender  at  Red  Cloud  Agency  several  weeks  later,  when  they 
submitted  a  list  of  forty  killed,  but  .  .  .  either  on  account 
of  superstition  or  repugnance  to  dwelling  on  the  subject, 
never  mentioned  the  number  wounded.  From  the  desperate 
cold  of  the  following  night  they  suffered  as  much  as  from 
the  fight;  eleven  babies  froze  to  death  in  the  arms  of  famished 
mothers,  and  ponies  were  killed  that  feeble  old  men  and 
women  might  prolong  their  lives  by  inserting  feet  and  legs 
in  the  warm  entrails." 

The  battle  represented  a  crushing  defeat  for  the  Cheyenne 
and  an  important  victory  for  the  U.S.  Army. 

By  the  close  of  1876  the  Sioux  and  Cheyenne  scattered 
into  small  bands,  most  eventually  surrendering  and 
wandering  onto  reservations.  Depleted  buffalo  herds,  the 
Army's  practice  of  winter  attacks  on  Indian  villages  and 
their  technologically  advanced  weaponry  all  contributed 
to  the  Plains  tribes'  demise.  The  hotly  contested  Powder 
River  country  finally  belonged  to  the  U.S.  Government 
and  was  open  for  white  settlement. 

The  United  States  Army,  after  a  dozen  years  of  con- 
flict, controlled  the  Powder  River  Basin  and  rendered  the 
Bozeman  Road  safe  to  northern  Wyoming  and  Montana. 
The  military  remained,  operating  from  Fort  Fetterman, 
the  southern-most  post  on  the  Bozeman  Trail,  and  from 
Cantonment  Reno,  the  supply  base  built  by  Capt.  Edwin 
Pollock  of  the  Ninth  Infantry  during  the  1876  Sioux  cam- 
paign. In  1877,  Pollock  requested  the  name  be  changed 
to  Cantonment  McKinney  distinguishing  it  from  the  ear- 
lier Fort  Reno  located  three  miles  downstream  on  the 


The  Grand  Council 
held  at  General  Crook's 
headquarters  on  Goose 
Creek,  June  15,  1876, 
Frank  Leslie's  Illus- 
trated Newspaper. 


Mi  I  1  ,  ;«-      ,  '*      ■  - 


43 


Officers'  Quarters  (Fort  Reno)  Fort  McKinney,  1876-1877. 


Powder  River  and  another  Fort  Reno  in  Indian  Territory. 
August  30,  1877,  the  camp  became  Fort  McKinney  and 
in  1878  the  post  was  moved  to  Clear  Creek,  two  miles  west 
of  present-day  Buffalo. 

One  of  the  first  post-Sioux  War  projects  (and  a  tell- 
ing symbol  of  American  plans  for  this  country)  was  a 
telegraph  line  built  between  November,  1877,  and  January, 
1878,  from  Fort  Fetterman  to  a  small  camp  on  Antelope 
Springs.  The  line,  which  paralleled  the  Bozeman  Road, 
was  then  extended  to  Fort  McKinney  #1  on  the  Powder 
River  by  January,  1878,  and  on  to  the  new  Fort  McKin- 
ney on  Clear  Creek  by  March,  1879.  This  140-mile 
telegraph  line  was  frequently  out  of  order,  and  during  the 
winter  of  1886  did  not  operate  at  all.78  Nonetheless,  it 
linked  these  frontier  outposts  with  military  headquarters 
and  served  as  a  symbol  of  "civilization"  to  potential  settlers. 

With  the  end  of  the  Indian  threat  and  the  continued 
military  presence  in  this  territory,  white  settlers  began 
trickling  into  the  Powder  River  country.  Between  1876  and 
1878,  however,  there  was  no  mail  service  (another  impor- 
tant symbol  of  American  civilization  to  potential  settlers), 
except  for  an  occasional  private  carrier  or  military  courier. 
Late  in  1878  the  United  States  Post  Office  remedied  this 
by  contracting  with  George  L.  McDonough  to  provide 
mail  service,  three  days  a  week,  between  Rock  Creek  Sta- 
tion on  the  Union  Pacific  Railroad  and  Echeta,  Montana. 
McDonough  subcontracted  to  a  Mr.  Fisher  who,  in  turn, 
subcontracted  with  O.  P.  Hanna  and  Charles  Ferguson 
to  carry  the  mail  between  Fort  McKinney  and  Fort  Custer, 
Montana.  Presumably,  they  traveled  the  general  Bozeman 
route.  Hanna,  who  participated  in  various  Yellowstone  ex- 
peditions during  the  1870s,  settled  near  present-day  Big 


Horn  in  1878  and  signed  a  contract  with  Fort  McKinney's 
commanding  officer  to  furnish  wild  meat  to  the  garrison. 
In  addition,  he  assumed  the  job  of  mail  courier,  carry- 
ing four  or  five  letters  a  week.  Hanna  claimed,  however, 
that  "Fisher  took  the  contract  too  cheap  and  went  broke, 
so  Ferguson  and  I  never  got  anything  for  our  work."  More- 
over, Hanna  wrote,  "  Ferguson  was  held  up  several  times 
by  Road  Agents.  They  would  examine  his  letters  and  if 
there  was  nothing  of  any  value  they  would  threaten  to 
'shoot  his  light  out.'  "79 

Not  satisfied  with  the  McDonough/Fisher  service,  the 
Post  Office  cancelled  that  agreement  and  contracted  with 
J.  M.  Thorn  of  Echeta  for  a  short  time.  In  March,  1879, 
the  Post  Office  re-contracted  for  mail  service  with  George 
E.  Kirk  and  William  H.  Gleason  of  Washington,  D.C., 
who  subcontracted  to  M.  T  Patrick  and  A.  H.  Brown. 
In  this  way,  the  "Rock  Creek  Stage  Line"  was  launched 
and  the  Bozeman  Trail  corridor  entered  another  era  in 
its  long  history  as  a  thoroughfare.80  A  good  portion  of  the 
stage  route  followed  the  Bozeman  route,  with  minor  varia- 
tions, until  it  reached  Sheridan  County  where  it  passed 
east  of  the  trail  corridor  in  order  to  serve  the  fledgling 
town  of  Sheridan. 

Beginning  with  tri-weekly  service  in  April,  1879,  the 
Patrick  Brothers  line,  as  it  was  known  (Algernon  S.  Patrick 
managed  the  line  for  his  brother,  Col.  Mathewson 
Patrick),  expanded  to  four  trips  a  week  in  July,  1879,  and 
daily  service  by  mid-1880s.81  The  Cheyenne  Daily  Leader 
announced  in  its  April  15,  1879,  issue  that  "Col.  Matt 
Patrick  and  his  brother,  Al  S.  Patrick  have  established 
a  stage  line  from  Rock  Creek  Station  to  Fort  Custer,  via 
Forts  McKinney,  Fetterman  and  Kearny.  The  line  went 


44 


into  operation  yesterday.  Al  Patrick  will  manage  the  con- 
cern." In  August,  the  newspaper  noted  that  Col.  Patrick 
recently  returned  from  a  trip  on  his  stage  line  and  reported 
it  passed  through  "the  finest  cattle  region  in  the  world."82 
O.  P.  Hanna  later  griped  that  "the  Patrick  Brothers  secured 
the  contract  for  the  mail  and  increased  it  to  a  daily,  put 
on  buckboards  and  went  flying  through  the  country, 
although  all  the  mail  could  have  been  carried  in  a  man's 
pocket.  They  got  about  $90,000  a  year."  He  added, 
somewhat  begrudgingly,  "However,  it  was  a  good  thing 
for  the  country  as  it  helped  to  develop  it."83 

The  company's  principal  stage  stations  that  fell  within 
the  Bozeman  corridor,  were  Fort  Fetterman  (replaced  in 
1886  by  Douglas),  Sage  Creek,  Brown  Springs,  Antelope 
Creek,  Seventeen  Mile  Ranch,  Powder  River  Station,  Trab- 
ing  at  Crazy  Woman  Creek,  Buffalo,  Big  Horn,  Dayton, 
Ohlman  and  others  in  Montana.  There  was  also  a  stop 
in  Sheridan.84 

The  Patrick  Brothers  stage  line  employed  about  48 
men  and  used  162  horses.85  Passengers  included  ranchers 
and  people  connected  with  the  military  posts  —  dis- 
charged soldiers,  new  recruits,  officers  and  their  wives. 
It  was  not  an  especially  comfortable  means  of  travel  for 
there  were  no  night  lay-overs  during  the  three-day  trip 
between  Rock  Creek  and  Echeta  and  there  were  only  brief 
stop-overs  for  meals  and  team-driver  changes.  Major  Wise, 
an  Englishman  who  rode  the  stage  line  in  1880  while  on 
a  Powder  River  country  hunting  trip,  noted  the  trip's 
discomforts  in  his  diary.  After  stopping  briefly  at  Fort  Fet- 
terman, the  stage  headed  northwest  and, 

I  rolled  myself  up  in  my  'possum  rug  and  tried  to  sleep,  a 
feat  by  no  means  easy  to  accomplish  in  a  jolting  coach  with 
one's  legs  cramped  up  .  .  .  but  I  slept  every  now  and  then, 
when  the  jolting  was  least.  About  6  I  unwound  myself.  We 


were  jogging  alone  over  the  'boundless  prairie.'  As  far  as  the 

eye  could  see  in  every  direction  were  grass  rollers  like  the  big 

rolling  billows  of  the  ocean.  .  .  ." 
Beyond  its  physical  discomforts,  the  stage  trip  could  also 
be  dangerous,  as  O.  P.  Hanna  noted.  Although  documen- 
tation of  hold-ups  is  sketchy,  some  sources  claim  they  were 
frequent  in  the  ear'y  days  of  the  stage  line,  particularly 
in  one  area  of  the  trail  north  of  Fort  Fetterman,  known 
as  "Holdup  Hollow."8'  One  documented  hold-up,  of  sorts, 
occurred  at  the  Antelope  Creek  stage  station  in  1887.  Army 
Paymaster  Maj.  Daniel  N.  Bash,  on  his  way  to  Fort  McKin- 
ney  with  the  troops'  pay  stopped  at  the  station  for  lunch 
and  carelessly  left  the  satchels  containing  $7,000  in  soldiers' 
pay  on  the  stage.  Charles  "Charley"  Parker,  a  Texas  cowboy 
lounging  around  the  station  that  day,  grabbed  the  valises 
and  fled  on  horseback.  Bash,  no  doubt  sheepishly, 
returned  to  Douglas  to  report  the  event.  Forces  from  Fort 
McKinney  searched  for  Parker,  including  post  guides 
Frank  Grouard,  Baptiste  'Little  Bat'  Gamier  and  Private 
John  C.  Conroy,  but  were  unable  to  track  the  Texas 
cowboy.  Parker,  in  the  meantime,  moved  on  to  Nebraska 
where  he  assumed  an  alias,  bought  a  horse  herd  and 
planned  to  open  a  store.  He  was  discovered,  however, 
found  guilty  of  stealing  $7,282.78  and  sentenced  to  five 
years  in  the  Wyoming  penitentiary.88  "The  people  of  Wyo- 
ming were  rather  disappointed  at  his  apprehension," 
according  to  Minnie  Rietz,  "as  he  was  generally  well  liked 
and  Maj.  Bash  was  not  so  they  were  not  averse  to  seeing 
him  receive  a  bit  of  punishment."89 

Besides  the  paymaster,  passenger  and  mail  trade, 
freight  for  military  posts  and  settlements  was  also  hauled 
over  the  road  used  by  stage  coaches.  Freight  was  first  ship- 
ped via  Cheyenne  to  Rock  Creek  on  the  main  line  of  the 
Union  Pacific  Railroad  and  then  up  to  the  Bozeman  Trail 


"****&     j:  * 


U  !  »     * 


3ffl 


iA^rfta: 


' 


jtiis^mi'l 


Fort  Fetterman  in  Winter. 


45 


corridor.  Freighters  initially  drove  oxen,  usually  a  team 
of  six  or  eight  that  pulled  three  wagons  strung  together. 
Mule  teams  succeeded  oxen  because  they  were  faster  and 
required  less  food.  Their  drivers,  called  "Mule  Skinners," 
were  often  recruited  from  the  ranks  of  ox  team  drivers  or 
"Bull  Whackers." 

Among  the  most  famous  were  the  "Monkers  and 
Mathers"  mule  teams  (of  George  A.  Monkers  and  Eugene 
Mather's  firm)  consisting  of  four  six-mule  teams,  each 
team  drawing  two  wagons.  Later  they  used  two  ten-mule 
teams  with  each  team  drawing  three  wagons.  The  first 
Monkers  and  Mathers  teams  arrived  in  Buffalo  in  1882, 
delivering  supplies  to  Robert  Foote's  store  from  the  Baker 
and  Johnston  wholesale  store  in  Cheyenne.  This  particular 
trip  took  almost  a  month  from  Rock  Creek  to  Buffalo  as 
the  roads  were  bad.  "It  required  unlimited  endurance  and 
patience  on  the  part  of  both  men  and  teams,"  wrote  one 
historian,  "to  make  these  trips  through  snow  and  sleet  over 
roads  that  had  developed  from  Indian  trails  and  were  not 
repaired  except  in  the  case  of  washouts  and  these  were 
usually  detoured  soon  making  another  curve  in  an  already 
winding  road.  Then  the  blazing  sun  of  summer  with  no 
shade  to  break  the  monotony,  tried  both  courage  and 
physical  energy  to  the  breaking  point."90 

Establishment  of  a  stage  line  with  its  mail,  passenger 
and  freight  service  was  a  crucial  entering  wedge  for  white 
settlement  in  the  Powder  River  country  and  along  the 
eastern  edge  of  the  Big  Horns.  Among  the  first  American 
citizens  to  settle  in  the  area  were  people  who  first  became 
acquainted  with  it  through  military  service  or  by  work- 
ing as  teamsters,  freight  contractors  and  laborers  for  the 
Army.  One  settler  who  first  saw  the  Powder  River  coun- 
try when  he  served  under  Crook  in  1876  was  Mike  Henry. 
Mustered  out  of  the  Army  in  1877,  Henry  returned  first 
to  the  Dry  Fork  of  the  Cheyenne  River  and  then  moved 
to  Brown  Springs,  a  Bozeman  Trail  campsite  and  loca- 
tion of  several  Indian  skirmishes  during  the  1860s.  Henry 
built  a  three-room  cabin,  the  start  of  the  '88'  ranch,  and 
in  1878  brought  his  wife,  Catherine  and  their  six  children 
to  live  there.  The  Henry  ranch  operated  as  a  stage  stop- 
relay  station  for  the  Patrick  Brothers  Stage  Line,  keeping 
fresh  horses  for  the  coaches  and  making  repairs  on  the 
stagecoaches  and  wagons  at  the  Henry  blacksmith  shop. 
The  ranch  also  served  as  a  roadhouse  for  stage  passengers, 
offering  groceries  and  medicines  for  travelers  to  buy.  When 
herds  of  Texas  longhorns  moved  up  the  trail  during  the 
1880s,  the  Henry  boys  earned  some  extra  cash  herding 
cattle  while  the  cowboys  rested.  Beyond  serving  the 
Bozeman  Trail  traffic,  the  Henry  establishment  was,  of 
course,  a  working  ranch.  Mike  Henry  raised  and  sold  draft 
and  saddle  horses  (he  sold  3,000  horses  during  the  Boer 
War),  developed  the  natural  hay  meadows  along  Brown 
Springs  Creek  and  raised  sheep.  One  of  Mike's  daughters, 
Lizzie,  married  Frank  Merrill  and  the  couple  ran  the  next 
stage  stop  on  the  line,  Sand  Creek  Station,  at  the  Double 
Box  Ranch.91 


Other  stage  stations  along  the  Bozeman  Trail  route 
sustained  some  of  the  earliest  settlers  in  the  Powder  River 
country.  Although  it  did  not  have  government  sanction, 
the  Antelope  Creek  station  or  Antelope  Ranch  operated  ! 
about  49  miles  north  of  Fort  Fetterman.  It  was  a  rest  stop 
for  travelers,  had  good  drinking  water  and  a  blacksmith 
shop.  Virginia  Benton,  traveling  to  northern  Wyoming, 
passed  through  in  1881.  Her  father,  a  Boston-educated 
Baptist  minister,  homeopathic  doctor  and  dentist,  went 
to  the  door  of  the  ranch  to  make  inquiries  and  found  "eight 
men  gambling,  which  so  horrified  him  that  he  hurried 
away  and  drove  two  miles  farther  through  sandbeds  and 
stopped  for  dinner  in  a  dry  creek  bed."92 

Another  of  the  early  communities  along  the  Bozeman 
Trail  cropped  up  in  the  vicinity  of  Cantonment  Reno/Fort 
McKinney  on  the  Powder  River.  Army  posts  provided  work 
for  citizen  contractors  and  soldiers  represented  a  poten- 
tial market  for  various  goods  and  services.  When  the  Army 
abandoned  the  Powder  River  site,  and  moved  the  fort  to 
Clear  Creek,  the  Patrick  Brothers  Stage  Line  moved  one 
of  the  log  cavalry  stables,  with  government  permission, 
to  the  east  bank  of  the  river  and  north  of  the  Dry  Fork's 
confluence  with  the  Powder.  The  stable  and  several  other 
buildings  they  constructed  constituted  the  Powder  River 
State  Station.  A  small  community,  Powder  River  Cross- 
ing, developed  around  the  station  and  the  iron  bridge 
which  spanned  the  river  by  1883.  Amanda  and  Horace 
Brown  ran  the  roadhouse  at  Powder  River  Crossing 
between  1884  and  1887. 

We  made  good  money,  Amanda  Brown  reminisced,  but  I 
sure  worked  myself  down.  I  cooked  for  all  the  way  from  ten 
to  forty  people,  did  all  my  washing,  cleaned  the  rooms,  and 
waited  on  people.  We  kept  the  stage  people  ...  I  always 
had  to  be  ready  for  a  stage  full,  and  sometimes  it  was  cer- 
tainly full,  and  sometimes  there  was  only  the  driver.  There 
were  all  the  different  people  that  make  up  a  new  country 
traveling  on  the  road  —  ranchmen,  cowboys,  gamblers,  horse 
thieves  and  occasionally  stage  robbers.93 

Powder  River  Crossing  which,  according  to  Brown,  never 
had  more  than  four  families  living  there,  had  a  store,  post 
office  and  saloon.  It  declined  in  importance  after  the 
Northern  Pacific  Railroad  reached  Custer  Station  in  Mon- 
tana and  Fort  McKinney  mail  and  passenger  traffic  chose 
that  route  over  the  Bozeman  Trail  stage  line.94 

Another  thinly  populated  settlement  developed  near 
Crazy  Woman  Creek.  In  1878  August  Trabing  established 
a  trading  post  several  hundred  yards  north  of  the  creek. 
He  supplied  emigrants  and  ranchers  with  staples,  boots, 
hats  and  liquor  goods  which,  in  turn,  attracted  the 
attention  of  road  agents.  In  part  because  of  hold-up  prob- 
lems, Trabing  moved  his  store  to  a  site  on  Clear  Creek, 
now  Buffalo,  in  1879.  After  he  left  Crazy  Woman,  the 
building  became  a  post  office  for  ranchers  and  stockmen 
and  a  stage  station  along  the  Bozeman  Trail.  J.  Tom  Hall, 
whose  father  changed  horses  on  the  Buffalo-Sussex  mail 
route  at  Trabing  (Sussex  eventually  replaced  Powder  River 
Crossing  as  that  area's  post  office),  remembered  it  as  a 


46 


POWDER  RIVER  CATTLE  COMPANY 

MORETON  FREWEN,  General  Manager. 

FRANK  A,  KEMP,  Assistant  Manager. 


P.  O.  address,  Cheyenne,  Wyo. 
Fred.  Hesse,  Foreman  Pow- 
der River  P.  O.,  Wyo. 

Ranpes,  Powder  River  and  its 
tributaries  and  Tonprue  River, 
Johnson  County,  Wyo. 


lb     97    -<V 


Also  own  the  followingbrands: 

JIM 


KC     W 

CDK   I  Vv°I  ^S  K 


and 


3< 


Also  Rawhide  branch  of  Pow- 
der River  Cattle  Company, 
Rawhide,  Laramie  County, 
Wyo.  E.  W.  Murphy  arid 
Aiuos  Spaugh,  Foremen. 

Also  branded  1  A/ll  on  left  side 
and  on  botliYyj-J  sides.  z 

Tf^^W  W|H?H  Jy  j 

Horses  branded       |U         Jill     and     \A/  Hi  1 

Moreton  Frewen's  Powder  River  Cattle  Company  Brands, 
Wyoming  Stock  Growers'  Association  1884  Brand  Book. 

haven  for  ranchers  and  freighters  where  they  could  rendez- 
vous and  exchange  news.  The  main  building  was  a  long, 
;og  structure  paralleling  the  road,  with  three  rooms.  At 
■he  south  end  of  it  were  two  small  log  buildings,  one  a 
iichoolhouse,  the  other  a  blacksmith  shop.  To  the  east  was 
another  large  long  building  (the  stable)  and  several 
!:orrals.95 

In  the  early  years  of  white  settlement,  two  basic  kinds 
of  settlers  came  to  the  Powder  River  country.  There  were 
;:he  classic  pioneers  entrepreneurs  and  farmers  drawn 
;o  places  like  Buffalo  with  the  business  opportunities  of 
lear-by  Fort  McKinney  or  drawn  by  the  fertile  land  along 
:he  foot  of  the  Big  Horns.  The  other  type  of  "settler"  was 
;:he  big,  speculative  cattle  company  that  controlled  vast 
holdings  of  public  range  land  merely  by  occupying  it.96 
An  example  of  the  latter  was  the  Powder  River  Livestock 
.Company,  incorporated  in  Colorado  in  1882  for  the  "pur- 
pose of  raising,  breeding,  buying,  selling  and  pasturing 
of  stock  and  especially  cattle;  the  purchase,  preemption, 
holding  and  selling  of  such  ranches  as  may  be  suitable 
for  said  business."97  Although  the  company's  headquarters 
was  in  Colorado  Springs,  much  of  its  range  was  in  the  old 
Fort  Reno  and  McKinney  areas  along  the  Powder  River. 

The  Powder  River  Cattle  Company,  organized  by  a 
Briton,  Moreton  Frewen,  also  grazed  its  cattle  in  this  vicin- 
ity. But  the  British  suffered  financial  failure  and  pulled 
'out  while  members  of  the  Powder  River  Livestock  Com- 
pany remained  until  the  company  dissolved  in  1893. 
SAnother  of  the  largest  cattle  outfits  was  Hackney,  Hold 
and  Williams  Livestock  Company  —  later  called  the  Wyo- 


ming Land  and  Cattle  Company.  Headquartered  about 
four  miles  south  of  Buffalo  on  Cross  H  Ranch,  this  com- 
pany homesteaded  all  the  land  it  could  in  the  vicinity  and 
ran  10,000  head  of  cattle  or  more.  Some  of  the  other  huge 
livestock  companies  were  Pratt  &  Ferris,  using  the  U  Cross 
brand;  the  Western  Union  Beef  Company,  branding  EK; 
and  the  Murphy  Cattle  Company  using  the  Flying  E.98 

Small-scale  ranches,  farmers  and  businessmen  fol- 
lowed the  Bozeman  Trail  to  the  Powder  River  country  and 
settled  at  the  foot  of  the  Big  Horns.  O.  P.  Hanna  staked 
a  claim  on  Little  Goose  Creek  in  1878  and  in  spring  1879, 
brought  a  plow,  some  oates  and  some  seed  from  Cheyenne 
to  begin  a  small  farm,  selling  his  produce  to  cattlemen 
coming  into  the  country.99  That  same  year,  W.  F.  Davis 
opened  a  sawmill  in  the  vicinity  and  for  the  next  several 
years  other  families  began  staking  claims  nearby.  Finally 
in  1881,  Hanna  and  several  others  surveyed  and  platted 
the  town  of  Big  Horn  on  the  Bozeman  road.100  Buffalo 
developed  largely  because  of  the  market  provided  by  Fort 
McKinney  and,  about  the  time  that  post  was  completed 
in  1882,  its  commanding  officer  Col.  Verling  K.  Hart  laid 
out  the  townsite.  The  Army  presence  continued  to  be  the 
dominant  economic  factor  in  Buffalo  until  it  abandoned 
Fort  McKinney  in  1894.  The  next  year  the  post's  buildings 
were  donated  to  the  state  and  in  1903  became  the  Wyom- 
ing Soldiers  and  Sailors  Home,  providing  care  and  treat- 
ment for  veterans.101 

The  two  different  types  of  settlers  in  the  Bozeman 
Trail  country  —  small  ranchers,  farmers  and  business- 
men, on  the  one  hand,  and  big  speculative  cattle  com- 
panies, on  the  other  did  not  live  harmoniously.  The 
devastating  winter  of  1886-87  took  a  deadly  toll  on  the 
cattle  herds.  The  Powder  River  Livestock  Company,  for 
example,  ran  24,000  head  during  the  spring  of  1886.  The 
following  spring,  after  the  disastrous  winter,  only  8,000 
head  were  gathered.102  As  a  result,  many  cowboys  and 
other  employees  lost  their  jobs  and  some  began  searching 

THE  PRATT  L  FERRIS  CATTLE  COMPANY. 


P.  0.  address,  Cheyenne,  Wyo. 

Range,  north  side  North  Platte 

River,   below   Fort  Laramie. 

Wyo.  and  Neb.,  Rawhide  ana 

Sheep  Creeks. 
Rrand,  same  as  out,  with   ^1 

on  left  jaw;  wattle  under  f| 

tail  on  back  of  ham. 


Horses  branded  same  as  rut  on  left  shoulder. 


Ranpe,  Clear  Fork  of  Powder 
River  and  Crazy  Woman,  and 
between  the  mouth  of  Crazy 
Woman  and  the  mouth  of 
Clear  Fork  on  Powder  River, 
Wyo. 

Rrand,  same  as  cut  on  both 
sides.  ■   i 

Horses  branded    W    left  hip. 


47 


mini 


2§«I$ 


"The  Line,  "  Fort  McKinney,  1891. 


the  range  for  mavericks  which  they  then  branded  with 
their  own  irons.  Some  even  branded  cattle  known  to 
belong  to  the  large  companies.  This  angered  the  larger 
cattle  operations  —  as  did  the  legal  homesteads  settlers 
were  taking  up  along  streams  with  good  grass.  This  was 
land  claimed,  by  virtue  of  occupation,  by  the  big  cattle 
outfits.  Tension  and  violence  escalated  into  the  Johnson 
County  War  in  1892.103 

Partly  because  of  the  turmoil  generated  by  the  Johnson 
County  War,  Buffalo  and  Johnson  County  were  bypassed 
by  the  Burlington  Railroad  in  1892  when  it  built  a  line 
across  Wyoming  from  the  South  Dakota  border  to  Mon- 
tana. However,  the  Burlington  was  only  30  miles  away  at 
Clearmont  making  passenger  travel  and  freighting  via 
railroad  more  comfortable  and  cheaper  than  travel  and 
freighting  over  the  dusty,  jolting  Bozeman  Trail  stage  line. 
The  federal  government  eliminated  contracting  for  mail 
service  during  the  late  1880s  and  the  Rock  Creek  Stage 
Line  shut  down  as  a  result.  But  stagecoach  days  on  the 
Bozeman  were  not  over  yet.  For  20  more  years  stages 
operated  locally  including  twice-a-day  service  between 
Burlington  trains  and  Buffalo.  Another  stage  traveled  the 
old  Bozeman  Trail  route  to  Banner,  Big  Horn  and  then 
down  the  Little  Goose  to  the  Sheridan  Inn.  Other  local 
routes  went  out  from  Buffalo  to  service  the  Powder  River 
area,  again  traveling  the  Bozeman.104 


By  1915  a  railroad  spur  connected  Buffalo  with  Clear 
mont,   a  line  soon  made  obsolete  by  paved  highways 
Stagecoaches  were   retired,    also   rendered   obsolete   b} 
highways  and  autos.   The   Bozeman  Trail  corridor,   ir 
places,    adapted   to   the   changes   and   continued   as   i 
transportation  route.  During  the  20th  century  parts  of  tht 
trail  were  improved  as  county  roads,  eventually  even  paved 
Ranchers  and  others  traveled  segments  that  remainec 
unimproved.  These  marked  changes  over  time  did  noi 
escape  notice.  In  1930,  a  Converse  County  historian  wrote 
That  part  of  the  Bozeman  Trail  that  was  northwest  of 
Douglas,  which  is  now  the  Ross  Road,  is  now  a  Government 
mail  route.  This  road,  passage  over  which  was  so  hotly  con- 
tested by  the  Indians  in  the  days  of  Red  Cloud,  is  lined  on 
either  side  by  mail  boxes,  a  few  cream  stations  and  one  or 
two  small  stores.   Instead  of  the  Indian  wars  and  savage 
reprisals  there  is  government  with  courts  of  justice;  instead 
of  long-horned  Texas  cattle  there  are  white  faced  Herefords; 
and  instead  of  a  few  syndicate  ranches  with  their  thousands 
of  cattle  and  claims  to  the  "open  range"  there  are  hundreds 
of  farms  and  small  ranches  with  a  few  grazing  livestock  and 
small  dairy  herds.105 

1.  Grace  Hebard,  "Pioneer  Mothers  on  the  Oregon  Trail,"  speed 
reprinted  in  the  Fort  Laramie  Scout,  June  3,  1926,  p.  1. 

2.  Dan  Cushman,  The  Great  North  Trail:  America's  Route  of  th 
Ages  (New  York:  McGraw-Hill  Book  Co.,  1966),  p.  135. 

3.  Dr.  Charles  A.  Reher,  The  Western  Powder  River  Basin  Survey 
Report  of  Survey  Results  Vol.  I.  (unpublished  mss.  on  file  at  thi 


48 


University  of  Wyoming  Contracting  Division,  Wyoming  Recrea- 
tion Commission,  1979),  pp.  91,  94. 

4.  Raymond  W.  Wood  and  Alan  S.  Downer,  "Notes  on  the  Crow  — 
Hidatsa  Schism,"  Plains  Anthropology:  Journal  of  the  Plains  Con- 
ference, Memoir  13,  part  2  (1977):  p.  83. 

5.  Reher,  pp.  99-104. 

6.  Edwin  Thompson  Denig,  Five  Indian  Tribes  of  the  Upper 
Missouri  (Norman:  University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1973),  pp.  139, 
144. 

7.  George  Hyde,  Red  Cloud's  Folk:  A  History  of  the  Oglala  Sioux 
(Norman:  University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1976),  pp.  3,  14,  31,  55. 

8.  George  Bird  Grinnell,  The  Fighting  Cheyennes  (Norman:  Univer- 
sity of  Oklahoma  Press,  1971),  pp.  3,  37. 

9.  David  Wishart,  The  Fur  Trade  of  the  American  West,  1807-1840 
(Lincoln:  University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1979),  p.   188. 

10.  Hiram  Martin  Chittenden,  The  American  Fur  Trade  of  the  Far 
West,  Vol.  II  (New  York:  Francis  P.  Harper,  1902),  p.  756. 

1 1 .  Henry  Lott,  "Much  Early  History  of  Wyoming  Centers  in  Johnson 
County,"  WPA  Writers  Project  Files  (unpublished  mss., 
Cheyenne,  Wyoming:  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and 
Historical  Department,  n.  d),  p.  1. 

12.  Robert  A.  Murray,  "First  Tracks  in  the  Big  Horns,"  Montana: 
the  Magazine  of  Western  History  26  (January  1976):  pp.  2-13. 
In  the  Spring,  1976,  edition  of  Montana:  the  Magazine  of  Western 
History,  "Letters  to  the  Editor"  section,  T.  A.  Larson  notes  that 
while  Murray  treats  the  LeRaye  journal  as  authentic,  both  George 
Hyde  and  Bernard  DeVoto  regard  it  as  a  forgery.  Larson  believes 
that  the  LeRaye  account  remains  questionable,  until  someone 
refutes  these  scholars  convincingly,  p.  78. 

13.  Ibid.,  p.  9. 

14.  Edgeley  W.  Todd,  "Antonio  Montero,"  in  The  Mountain  Men 
and  the  Fur  Trade  of  the  Far  West,  Vol.  II,  LeRoy  R.  Hafen 
(ed.)  (Glendale,  California:  The  Arthur  Clark  Co.,  1965),  p.  253. 
Todd  notes  at  least  four  variations  of  the  name.  He  attributes 
the  "mistaken  form"  of  Mateo  to  Raynolds,  see  footnote,  p.  247. 

15.  Wishart,  p.  189. 

16.  Grace  Hebard  and  E.  A.  Brininstool,  The  Bozeman  Trail,  Vol. 
II  (Cleveland:  The  Arthur  Clark  Co.,  1922),  pp.  225-228;  E.  S. 
Topping,  Chronicles  of  the  Yellowstone  (Minneapolis:  Ross  & 
Haines,  Inc.,  1968),  p.  17. 

17.  William  F.  Raynolds,  "Report  on  the  Exploration  of  the 
Yellowstone  and  the  Country  drained  by  that  River,"  Sen.  Exec. 
Doc  77,  40th  Congress,  2d  Sess.,  (1868)  p.  4;  and  William  H. 
Goetzman,  Army  Exploration  in  the  American  West,  18031863 
(New  Haven:  Yale  University  Press,  1959),  p.  418. 

18.  David  J.  Wasden,  From  Beaver  to  Oil:  A  Century  in  the  Develop- 
ment of  Wyoming's  Big  Horn  Basin  (Cheyenne:  Pioneer  Print- 
ing and  Stationery  Co.,  1973),  p.  72. 

19.Raynold,  p.  13. 

20.  Goetzman,  pp.  421-422. 

21 .  Burton  S.  Hill,  "Frontier  Powder  River  Mission,"  Annals  of  Wyo- 
ming 38  (October  1966),  p.  222. 

22.  Grinnell,  The  Fighting  Cheyennes,  p.  44. 

23.  For  information  on  John  Bozeman  see  Merrill  G.  Burlingame, 
"The  Story  of  Montana  Trail  Maker,  John  Bozeman  and  Bozeman 
Trail,"  Mississippi  Valley  Historical  Review  27  (March,  1941), 
pp.  541-568;  and  John  S.  Gray,  "Blazing  the  Bridger  and 
Bozeman  Trails,"  Annals  of  Wyoming  46  (Spring,  1977),  pp. 
23-51. 

24.  Merrill  J.  Mattes,  Indians,  Infants  and  Infantry:  Andrew  and 
Elizabeth  Burt  on  the  Frontier  (Denver:  The  Old  West  Publishing 
Company,  1960),  p.  109. 

25.  William  E.  Lass,  A  History  of  Steamboating  on  the  Upper  Mis- 
souri River  (Lincoln:  University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1962),  p.  41. 

26.  Gray,  pp.  26-29. 

27.  Burlingame,  p.  544. 


28.  Ibid.,  p.  545. 

29.  Ibid.,  pp.  547-548. 

30.  Ibid.,  p.  547. 

31 .  Benjamin  Williams  Ryan.  "The  Bozeman  Trail  to  Virginia  City, 
Montana,  in  1864,"  Annals  of  Wyoming  19  (July,  1947),  p.  87. 

32.  Gray,  pp.  49-50. 

33.  Ibid.,  p.  23. 

34.  Robert  Murray,  Clrss  I,  Cultural  Resource  (Historic)  Inventory 
Narrative  History  (U.S.  Bureau  of  Land  Management,  Worland, 
Wyoming  District,   1978),  p.  39. 

35.  Robert  M.  Utley,  Frontiersmen  in  Blue:  The  United  States  Army 
and  the  Indian,  1848-1865  (New  York:  Macmillan  Publishing 
Co.  Inc.,  1973),  pp.  300-302. 

36.  Hyde,  pp.   115-116. 

37.  Utley,  pp.  308-309. 

38.  Ibid.,  pp.  324-325. 

39.  Ibid.,  p.  325. 

40.  Ibid.,  p.  330. 

41.  Ibid.,  pp.  330-331. 

42.  For  evaluations  of  Connor's  Powder  River  Expedition  see  Fred 
B.  Rogers,  Soldiers  of  the  Overland:  Being  Some  Account  of  the 
Services  of  General  Patrick  Edward  Connor  and  His  Volunteers 
in  the  Old  West  (San  Francisco:  The  Grabhorn  Press,  1938),  pp. 
158-159,  224-245;  Utley,  p.  332. 

43.  See  Anthony  McGinnis,  "Strike  and  Retreat:  Intertribal  War- 
fare and  the  Powder  River  War,  1865-1868,"  Montana:  the 
Magazine  of  Western  History  30  (Autumn,  1980),  pp.  34-35;  and 
Hyde,  p.   133. 

44.  Utley.  p.  327. 

45.  A.  M.  Holman  and  C.  R.  Marks,  Pioneering  the  Northwest  (Sioux 
City,  Iowa:  Dutch  and  Larmar  Co.,  1924),  p.  4. 

46.  Rogers,  p.  205. 

47.  McGinnis,  p.  36. 

48.  Utley,  p.  327;  Rogers,  p.  206;  Holman,  pp.  22-23;  and  Dorothy 
M.  Johnson,  The  Bloody  Bozeman:  The  Perilous  Trail  to  Mon- 
tana's Gold  (New  York:  McGraw-Hill  Book  Co.,  1971),  p.  163. 

49.  Utley,  p.  69. 

50.  George  Hyde,  Spotted  Tail's  Folk:  A  History  of  the  Brule  Sioux 
(Norman:  University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1961),  pp.  123-124,  128. 

bl.Ibid.,  p.  129  and  James  Olson,  "The  'Lasting  Peace'  of  Fort 
Laramie:  Prelude  to  Massacre,"  American  West  2  (Winter,  1965); 
p.  49. 

52.  Hyde,  p.  30. 

53.  Hyde,  Red  Cloud's  Folk.  p.  140,  and  Robert  M.  Utley,  Frontier 
Regulars:  The  United  States'  Army  and  the  Indian,  1866-1890 
(New  York:  Macmillan  Publishing  Company,  Inc.,  1973),  p.  98. 

54.  Merrill  J.  Mattes,  Indians,  Infants  and  Infantry:  Andrew  and 
Elizabeth  Burt  on  the  Frontier  (Denver:  The  Old  West  Publishing 
Company,  1960),  p.  109  and  Robert  A.  Murray,  Military  Posts 
in  the  Powder  River  Country  of  Wyoming,  1865-1894  (Lincoln: 
University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1968),  pp.  77-78. 

55.  Utley,  Frontier  Regulars,  p.  103. 

56.  George  Templeton  diary,  Newberry  Library,  Chicago,  Illinois. 

57.  Murray,  Military  Posts,  pp.  82-83. 

58.  McGinnis,  "Strike  and  Retreat,"  pp.  37.  40. 

59.  Utley,  Frontier  Regulars,  p.  105;  McGinnis  "Strike  and  Retreat," 
p.  38;  and  George  Bird  Grinnell,  The  Fighting  Cheyennes  (Nor- 
man: University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1971),  pp.  223-234. 

60.  The  "Portugee"  Phillips  story  has  taken  on  mythic  dimensions 
in  Wyoming  lore.  For  the  most  accurate  account  see  Robert  A. 
Murray,  "The  John  Portugee'  Phillips  Legends,  a  Study  in  Wyo- 
ming Folk  Lore,"  Annals  of  Wyoming  40  (April  1968),  p.  46. 
Also  see  Francis  A.  Barrett,  "The  Greatest  Ride  in  Wyoming  His- 
tory," Annals  of  Wyoming  38  (October  1966),_pp.  223-228  and 
Edward  M.  Sterling,  "The  Winter  Ride  of  Portugee  Phillips," 
Montana:  the  Magazine  of  Western  History  9  (Winter  1965),  pp. 
2-11. 


49 


61.  Murray,  Military  Posts,  pp.  86-87. 

62.  For  information  on  the  Wagon  Box  Fight  see  Murray,  Military 
Posts,  pp.  95-96;  Utley,  Frontier  Regulars,  p.  125;  F.  H.  Sinclair, 
"White  Man's  Medicine  Fight;  An  Account  of  the  Fort'  Phil 
Kearny  'Wagon  Box  Fight'  "  Montana:  the  Magazine  of  Western 
History  6  (July  1956).  pp.  1-10;  Dr.  George  Bird  Grinnell,  'The 
Wagon  Box  Fight,'  The  Midwest  Review  9  (February-March 
1928),  Nos.  2  and  3. 

63.  McGinnis,  "Strike  and  Retreat,"  p.  39;  Murray,  Military  Posts, 
pp.  95-96. 

64.  "Letters  of  Captain  Wishart,"  The  Bozeman  Trail  Scrapbooh 
(Sheridan,  Wyoming:  The  Mills  Company,   1967),  p.  20. 

65.  General  W.  B.  Hazen,  "Report  of  October  16,  1866,  to  Major 
H.  G.  Litchfield,  Department  of  the  Platte,"  reprinted  in  House 
Executive  Documents  No.  45,  39th  Congress,  2nd  Session,  p.  3. 

66.  E.  S.  Topping,  Chronicles  of  the  Yellowstone  (Minneapolis:  Ross 
and  Haines,  1968),  p.  46;  Robert  A.  Murray,  "Johnson  County: 
175  Years  of  History  at  the  Foot  of  the  Big  Horn  Mountains," 
unpublished  mss.  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and 
Historical  Department,  Cheyenne,  Wyoming. 

67.  Murray,  "Johnson  County,"  p.  86. 

68.  Utley,  Frontier  Regulars,  pp.  135-137;  Hyde,  Spotted  Tail's  Folk, 
pp.   141-142. 

69.  Hebard  and  Brininstool,   The  Bozeman  Trail,  p.  258. 

70.  John  S.  Gray,  Centennial  Campaign:  The  Sioux  War  of  1876  (Fort 
Collins,  Colorado:  Old  Army  Press,  1976),  pp.  16-17,  23. 

71.  For  discussion  of  Indian  reaction  see  Hyde,  Spotted  Tail's  Folk, 
pp.  224-245. 

72.  J.  W.  Vaughan,  The  Reynolds  Campaign  on  Powder  River  (Nor- 
man: University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1961),  p.  160;  Gray,  Centen- 
nial Campaign,  p.  58;  and  Utley,  Frontier  Regulars,  p.  251. 

73.  Gray,  Centennial  Campaign,  p.  58. 

74.  Ibid.,  p.  124;  Vaughan,  Reynolds  Campaign,  p.  189;  Utley,  Fron- 
tier Regulars,  p.  262;  and  George  Crook,  "Autobiography,"  mss. 
at  United  States  Military  History  Institute,  Carlisle  Barracks,  Pa.; 
and  "Nickerson's  Typescript  of  Crook's  experiences  with  Indians, 
1866-1890,"  mss.  at  USMHI,  Carlisle  Barracks,  Pa. 

75.  Vaughan,  p.  189. 

76.  Ibid.,  p.  109  and  Utley,  Frontier  Regulars,  pp.  275-276. 

77.  John  G.  Bourke,  On  the  Border  With  Crook  (New  York:  Charles 
Scribner's  Sons,   1891). 

78.  Robert  A.  Murray,  "Military  Posts  of  the  Powder  River,"  typed 
mss.  at  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and  Historical  Depart- 
ment, Cheyenne,  Wyoming,  p.  195. 

79.  O.  P.  Hanna,  "An  Old  Timer's  Story,"  typed  mss.  at  Western 
History  Research  Center,  University  of  Wyoming,  Laramie, 
Wyoming,  p.  4. 

80.  Murray,  "Johnson  County,"  p.  Ill;  "Star  Route  Investigations." 
House  Executive  Document,  No.  100,  48th  Congress,  1st  session, 
pp.  192-193. 

81.  Murray,  "Johnson  County,"  p.  111. 

82.  Cheyenne  Daily  Leader,  April  15,  1879,  and  August  20,  1879. 

83.  Hanna,  "An  Old  Timer's  Story,"  p.  4. 


84.  "Rock  Creek  to  Custer  Station,"  Wheatland  Times,  September 
23,  1937;  DeLos  Brandon,  "The  Old  Stage  Coach  Line  from  Rock 
Creek,  Operated  by  Patrick  Brothers,"  originally  published  in 
the  Sheridan  Journal,  January  15,  1929.  A  typescript  is  available 
at  the  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and  Historical  Depart- 
ment, p.  3. 

85.  Murray,  "Johnson  County."  p.  111.  Edward  Clark,  "The  Early 
Stage  Lines  from  Rock  Creek,"  WPA  Writers  Project,  WPA  Subj. 
148.  Wyoming  State  Archives.  Museums  and  Historical  Depart- 
ment, p.  6;  Minnie  A.  Rietz,  "The  Old  Stage  Line."  WPA  Subj. 
141,  p.  2. 

86.  Henry  Lott,  ed.,  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and  Histo- 
rical Department,  "Major  Wise,  An  Englishman  Recites  Details 
of  Hunting  Trip  in  Powder  River  Country  in  1880,"  Annals  of 
Wyoming,  12  (April,  1940),  p.  86. 

87.  Rietz,  "The  Old  Stage  Line,"  p.  2.  However,  DeLos  Brandon 
claims  that  during  the  Patrick  Brothers'  years  in  business  there 
were  no  holdups,  only  an  occasional  horse  theft,  p.  2. 

88.  Robert  A.  Murray,  "  'They  Say  Some  Disaster  Befell  the 
Paymaster,'  or  Charlie  Parker's  Road  to  Dismal  River  and 
Beyond,"  By  Valor  and  Arms  3  (Spring,  1975). 

89.  Rietz,  p.  3. 

90.  Ibid.,  p.  5. 

91.  "88  Centennial,"  Casper  Magazine  9  (Feb. -March,  1979),  pp. 
3-13.  Also  see  Josephine  Lucas,  "Michael  Henry."  Bits  and  Pieces, 
4  ( 1 968).  The  88  Ranch  is  still  operated  by  descendants  of  Mike 
Henry. 

92.  "Virginia  Benton  Diary  -  1881,"  in  Bozeman  Trail  Scrapbook, 
p.  47. 

93.  Amanda  Hardin  Brown  and  Margaret  Isaac,  "A  Pioneer  in  Col- 
orado and  Wyoming,"  Colorado  Magazine  35  (October  1958): 
p.  273. 

94.  "General  Brisbin  in  Wyoming  -  1887,"  in  Bozeman  Trail  Scrap- 
book,  p.  52;  Murray,  "Johnson  County,"  p.  167. 

95.  J.  Tom  Wall,  Crossing  Old  Trails  to  New  in  North  Central  Wyo- 
ming (Philadelphia:  Dorrance  and  Company,  1973),  pp.  7-8. 

96.  Murray,  "Johnson  County,"  p.  106. 

97.  Agnes  Wright  Spring,  "Powder  River  Livestock  Company,"  The 
Colorado  Magazine  28  (January,  1951):  p.  32. 

98.  Burton  S.  Hill,  "Old  Buffalo,  Ancient  Cow  Town."  Annals  of 
Wyoming  35  (October,  1963):  pp.  132-33. 

99.  Hanna,  p.  9. 

100.  Ibid.,  p.  9;  Maurine  Carley  (compiler),  "Bozeman  Trail  Trek: 
Trek  No.  14  of  the  Emigrant  Trail  Treks,"  Annals  of  Wyoming 
36  (April,  1964),  p.  66;  Vie  Willits  Garber,  Big  Horn  Pioneers 
(Big  Horn,  Wyoming:  Big  Horn  Public  Schools,  1961),  p.  3. 

101.  W.  J.  Thorn,  "Early  Business  Men  of  Buffalo,  Wyoming," 
typescript  mss.,  Western  History  Research  Center,  University  of 
Wyoming,  Laramie,  Wyoming,  p.  5. 

102.  Spring,  "Powder  River  Livestock  Company."  p.  34. 

103.  Hill,  "Buffalo-Ancient  Cow  Town,"  p.  144. 
\04.Ibid.,  p.  151;  Murray,  "Johnson  County,"  pp.  210-214. 

105.  John  LeeRoy  Waller,  "Economic  History  and  Settlement  of  Con- 
verse County,  Wyoming  Annals  of  Wyoming  6  (January,  1930): 
p.  337. 


50 


THE 

WIND-BIG  HORN 
RIVER 

AND  THE 

ROCKY  MOUNTAIN 

FUR  TRADE 


BY  KEITH  ALGIER 


The  early  white  history  of  the  Rocky  Mountain  West 
is  largely  the  history  of  the  beaver  trade.  Not  only  did  it 
form  the  basis  for  the  first  instance  of  the  region's  economic 
exploitation  by  the  United  States,  it  was  responsible  for 
exploration  of  lands  that  otherwise  probably  would  have 
been  neglected.  The  pursuit  of  beaver  was  instrumental 
in  establishing  American  claims  over  an  area  in  which 
boundaries  were  at  the  time  vague  and  indefinite. 

Despite  its  location  in  the  heart  of  fur  country,  the 
role  of  the  Wind-Big  Horn  River  in  this  enterprise  has 
never  been  examined.  Rising  in  the  Wind  River  and  Absa- 
roka  ranges,  it  flows  in  an  easterly  direction  until  joined 
by  the  Popo  Agie  near  Riverton,  Wyoming.  Here  its  course 
veers  sharply  north  to  cut  its  way  through  Wind  River  Ca- 
nyon. Emerging  from  the  canyon  with  a  new  identity,  the 
river  meanders  northward  to  Big  Horn  Canyon  through 
which  it  makes  its  escape  ultimately  to  join  the  Yellowstone 
River. 

At  the  time  of  Euro-American  penetration,1  the  entire 
area  drained  by  the  river  was  occupied  on  a  more  or  less 
permanent  basis  by  Crow  Indians.  Actually,  England,  in 
the  person  of  a  North  West  Company  employee  named 
Menard,  who  trapped  and  traded  among  the  Crow  on 
several  occasions  prior  to  1800,  preceded  the  United  States 
into  the  Crow  homeland.2  Then  in  1805, 3  the  same  British 
company  sent  a  small  expedition  led  by  Francois  Antoine 
Larocque  to  the  river  to  establish  a  trading  relationship 
with  that  tribe.  He  met,  by  prearrangement,  a  band  of 
Crow  at  the  Mandan  villages  in  late  June  and  subsequently 
accompanied  them  to  their  home  territory.  They  reached 
the  Big  Horn  River  near  the  point  where  it  disgorges  from 
Big  Horn  Canyon  on  August  30,  and  from  there  proceeded 
at  a  leisurely  pace  to  the  Yellowstone  River,  which  they 
reached  on  September  10.  Larocque  spent  three  more  days 
with  the  Crow  attempting  to  convince  them  that  it  would 
be  to  their  advantage  to  spend  the  winter  trapping  for 
beaver  in  preparation  for  his  return  with  trade  goods  the 
following  summer.4 

As  it  turned  out  Larocque  did  not  keep  his  promise 
to  return.  But  there  had  occurred,  in  1803,  the  transfer 
of  the  Louisiana  Territory  to  the  United  States  from 
France,  and  this  transaction  set  in  motion  a  series  of  events 
which  brought  American  citizens  to  Crow  country  at  about 
the  same  time  Larocque  was  expected.  William  Clark, 
descending  the  Yellowstone  in  the  final  stage  of  the  epochal 
Lewis  and  Clark  expedition,  reached  the  mouth  of  the 
Big  Horn  on  July  26,  1806.  He  did  not  encounter  any  Crow 
on  his  way  down  the  Yellowstone,  and  therefore  was  not 
called  upon  to  exchange  trade  goods,  as  pledged  by 
Larocque,  for  their  beaver.  Clark  did,  though,  make  an 
assessment  of  fur  trade  potential  on  the  lower  reaches  of 
the  Big  Horn  by  taking  a  seven-mile  walk  up  its  east  bank.5 

President  Jefferson,  who  at  the  time  he  had  arranged 
for  the  purchase  of  Louisiana  was  uncertain  what  he  had 
bought,  had  specifically  instructed  the  two  young  army 
officers    to    appraise    lands    traversed    for    commercial 


51 


possibilities.6  He  hoped  apparently  that  the  newly  acquired 
lands  contained  resources  which  would  attract  a  sufficient 
number  of  American  citizens  to  secure  the  region  against 
British  territorial  ambitions. 

When  the  explorers  returned  to  civilization  they 
reported,  among  other  things,  that  all  of  the  lands  drained 
by  the  Missouri  River  abounded  in  beaver.7  Their  opti- 
mistic appraisal,  however,  included  a  caveat  that  if  the 
United  States  failed  to  occupy  the  area  in  the  near  future, 
the  British  surely  would.8 

Intelligence  that  there  existed  a  virgin  beaver  field 
simply  waiting  to  be  harvested  had  the  effect  of  attract- 
ing American  entrepreneurs  into  the  northern  Rockies 
much  as  iron  filings  are  attracted  to  a  magnet.  Cir- 
cumstances dictated  that  the  lower  Big  Horn  River  serve 
as  the  base  of  operations  for  this  movement.  Not  only  was 
that  part  of  the  river  stocked  with  beaver,9  it  was  adja- 
cent to  the  lower  Yellowstone  and  within  reasonable  prox- 
imity to  the  Three  Forks  of  the  Missouri,  both  prime  trap- 
ping areas. 

Another  attractive  feature  of  the  area  was  its  occupa- 
tion by  the  Crow  Indians.  These  happened  to  be  a  tradi- 
tional foe  of  the  neighboring  Blackfoot  tribe,  which,  in 
turn,  was  implacably  hostile  to  white  Americans.10 
Because  it  was  controlled  by  the  Crow,  the  lower  Big  Horn 
seemed  to  promise  protection  from  the  Blackfeet.  The 
Crow  welcomed  American  trappers  for  their  own  practi- 
cal reasons.  Direct  access  to  trade  goods  precluded  the 
necessity  of  trading  with  tribes  who  lived  along  the 
Missouri  River,  most  of  whom  had,  over  the  years,  sys- 
tematically exploited  the  Crow.11  Also,  greatly  out- 
numbered by  the  Blackfeet,  the  Crow  viewed  Americans 
as  potential  allies  in  an  internecine  struggle  with  a  stronger 
enemy.12 

The  first  organized  expedition  to  enter  the  area  was 
led  by  Manuel  Lisa,  a  St.  Louis  resident  with  many  years 
of  fur  trade  experience  on  the  lower  Missouri  River.  His 
party  of  50  arrived  at  the  mouth  of  the  Big  Horn  in 
November,  1807,  where  it  immediately  began  construc- 
tion of  a  fort  to  serve  as  headquarters  for  a  trading  empire 
which  was  intended  to  eventually  extend  as  far  south  as 
Santa  Fe.13 

While  the  garrison,  which  Lisa  named  Fort  Raymond 
after  his  only  son,  was  yet  under  construction,  several 
experienced  trappers  were  sent  out  into  surrounding  ter- 
ritory to  recruit  customers.  Edward  Rose,  a  Kentuckian 
of  obscure  ancestry,  was  given  trade  articles  and  dispatched 
to  an  unidentified  band  of  Indians  with  whom  he  spent 
the  winter.14  The  peripatetic  John  Colter  is  reported  to  have 
traveled  some  500  miles  that  same  winter  in  search  of  the 
Crow  and  other  tribes.15  The  spate  of  literature  his  adven- 
tures have  generated  notwithstanding,  it  simply  is  not 
possible  to  retrace  Colter's  route  on  this  particular  journey. 
It  probably  included  the  Stinking  Water  (Shoshone)  River 
because  trapper  tradition  credits  him  with  its  discovery.16 


The  itinerary  of  a  third  wayfarer,  George  Drouillard, 
can  be  reconstructed  with  some  precision  because  he  later 
provided  William  Clark  with  details  of  his  travels. 
Drouillard's  data  were  incorporated  into  a  map  of  the 
lower  Big  Horn  region,  drawn  by  Clark  in  1809,  which  is 
readily  available  to  investigators  of  the  early  history  of  this 
part  of  the  West.17  Setting  out  from  the  fort,  he  followed 
the  Yellowstone  River  west  to  the  mouth  of  Clark's  Fork 
where  the  explorer  set  a  new  course  south  along  that 
tributary  to  its  source.  From  there  Drouillard  continued 
in  a  southerly  direction  to  the  confluence  of  the  Stinking 
Water  and  Valley  (South  Fork  of  the  Shoshone)  rivers 
where  he  happened  upon  a  Crow  village.  Here,  near  the 
site  of  Cody,  Wyoming,  he  spent  several  days,  presumably 
apprising  the  Indians  of  new  and  exciting  trading  oppor- 
tunities being  made  available  to  them,  before  returning 
to  the  fort.  The  following  spring  Drouillard  explored  parts 
of  the  Little  Big  Horn,  Tongue  and  Rosebud  rivers.  Lisa 
had  apparently  instructed  him  to  investigate  the  feasibility 
of  making  contact  with  the  closest  Spanish  outpost  because 
one  of  the  notations  on  Clark's  map  indicated  that  a 
Spanish  settlement  could  be  reached  by  traveling  south 
along  the  Big  Horn  River  for  18  days. 

Lisa  returned  to  St.  Louis  sometime  during  the  spring 
of  1808,  leaving  Benito  Vasquez  in  command  of  Fort 
Raymond.18  Vasquez  dispatched  various  parties  to  trap  and 
trade,  at  one  time  or  another  over  the  next  several  months, 
on  the  Three  Forks  of  the  Missouri,  the  Wind  River  Valley, 
the  Green  River  and  the  Snake  River  country  of  eastern 
Idaho.  But  in  the  end  Blackfoot  harassment  forced  him 
to  temporarily  abandon  the  fort  during  the  winter  of 
1808-9,  and  beat  a  hasty  retreat  to  the  Missouri  River.19 

Lisa  arrived  at  the  Mandan  villages,  where  Vasquez 
awaited  his  return,  in  September  of  1809.  While  in  St. 
Louis,  Lisa  had  raised  additional  capital  by  organizing 
the  Missouri  Fur  Company  and  had  been  able  to  recruit 
more  than  200  men  to  re-enforce  the  small  band  of  trap- 
pers he  had  left  at  Fort  Raymond.20  Because  he  had  heard 
a  rumor  on  the  voyage  up  river  that  the  British  were  con- 
structing a  trading  post  in  the  Three  Forks  area,  he  was 
anxious  to  re-establish  a  presence  in  trapping  country  as 
soon  as  possible.21  Andrew  Henry,  a  partner  in  the  newly- 
formed  company,  was  sent  immediately  to  the  mouth  of 
the  Big  Horn  with  40  men.  Pierre  Menard,  another  part- 
ner, followed  a  month  later  with  an  additional  50  men.22 

As  soon  as  weather  permitted,  in  February,  Henry 
led  most  of  his  trappers,  including  Menard  and  Reuben 
Lewis,  to  the  Three  Forks  where  they  first  constructed 
a  small  stockade  and  then  broke  up  into  small  parties.23 
Trapping  turned  out  to  be  spectacularly  good,  but 
Blackfoot  opposition  ultimately  forced  the  trappers  to 
abandon  this  rich  beaver  field.  By  early  May  the  Indians 
had  killed  eight  Americans,  including  George  Drouillard, 
and  had  stolen  horses,  traps,  supplies  and  most  of  the  furs 
which  had  been  collected  by  Henry's  men.24  At  this  point 


52 


•discretion  won  out  over  valor.  Menard  and  nine  others, 
among  them  John  Colter,  returned  to  the  relative  safety 
bf  Fort  Raymond  and  then  on  to  St.  Louis.  Henry  and 
:he  rest  of  the  party  elected  to  continue, trapping  but 
removed  to  the  less  dangerous  Flathead  country.  There, 
in  a  tributary  of  the  Snake  River,  later  named  Henry's 
Fork,  they  built  another  stockade  to  serve  as  trapping  and 

Irading  headquarters.25 
Manuel  Lisa,  who  had  returned  to  St.  Louis  during 
he  fall  of  1809,  was  meanwhile  experiencing  different  dif- 
ficulties. His  partners  were  unhappy  with  the  small  returns 
:rom  the  1809  season,  and  he  was  meeting  resistance  in 
lis  efforts  to  raise  sufficient  capital  to  finance  the  upcom- 
ng  trapping  season.26  His  problems  were  exacerbated  by 
.he  presence  in  St.  Louis  of  Wilson  Price  Hunt,  a  part- 
tier  in  the  Pacific  Fur  Company.  Hunt,  organizing  an  ex- 
pedition destined  for  the  Pacific  Coast,  was  hiring  men 
and   buying   supplies   in    direct    competition   with    the 

(Missouri  Fur  Company.27 
Lisa  was  a  year  late  in  bringing  supplies  and  did  not 
arrive  at  Fort  Mandan,  located  just  below  the  confluence 
Of  the  Little  Missouri  and  the  Missouri  rivers,  until  June, 
1811.  He  had  encountered  Benito  Vasquez  downstream, 
and  had  been  informed  by  him  that  all  tribes  inhabiting 
the  fur  country,  including  the  Crow,  were  becoming 
Dbstreperous  and  that  Andrew  Henry's  situation  was  par- 
ticularly precarious.  The  veteran  trader  was  relieved  to 
learn  at  Fort  Mandan  that  Henry  was,  in  fact,  safe  and 
on  his  way  to  the  fort  with  a  substantial  quantity  of 
ipeltries.28  Lisa  nevertheless  decided  that  even  the  lower 
|Big  Horn  was  too  dangerous  to  accommodate  the  con- 
tinued operation  of  Fort  Raymond.  He  subsequently  closed 
the  facility  and  thereafter  administered  the  company's 
operation  in  Crow  territory  from  Fort  Mandan.29  Lewis 
spent  the  better  part  of  the  next  two  years  on  the  Little 
Big  Horn,  and  other  parties  operating  out  of  the  fort  work- 
ed the  Big  Horn  and  Wind  rivers  during  the  same 
period.30 

By  the  spring  of  1813,  the  Indian  situation  had  dete- 
riorated to  the  point  that  even  the  normally  peaceful  tribes 
.on  the  Missouri  had  become  a  problem.31  The  consequent 
insecurity  coupled  with  a  sharp  drop  in  fur  prices  which 
occurred  about  the  same  time  forced  Lisa  to  withdraw 
from  the  upper  Missouri  River  altogether.  There  followed 
.a  hiatus  of  eight  years  during  which  no  Crow  furs  appeared 
in  St.  Louis  markets.32  It  can,  therefore,  be  inferred  that 
there  were  few  if  any  Americans  in  Crow  country  during 
these  years.33 

In  the  year  1820,  the  Indian  situation  was  stable  and 
fur  prices  were  at  a  reasonable  level.  In  addition,  econ- 
omic conditions  in  St.  Louis  made  fur  trade  operations 
once  again  attractive  to  investors.  Although  Lisa  died  that 
year,  the  Missouri  Fur  Company  continued  to  operate, 
at  least  for  a  time.  A  St.  Louis  businessman,  Joshua 
Pilcher,  who  had  become  a  partner  some  years  before 
Lisa's  death,  assumed  direction  of  the  firm  and  reorga- 


nized it  in  preparation  for  another  assault  on  the  north- 
ern Rockies.34 

The  company  enjoyed  a  modicum  of  initial  success 
in  what  would  turn  out  to  be  its  last  venture  in  Crow  coun- 
try. Robert  Jones  and  Michael  Immel35  were  selected  by 
Pilcher  to  command  an  expedition  which  arrived  at  the 
mouth  of  the  Big  Horn  in  early  fall,  1821. 36  Immel  and 
Jones  supervised  construction  of  a  new  trading  post,  which 
they  christened  Fort  Benton,  and  then  dispersed  their  trap- 
pers onto  neighboring  beaver  streams  and  rivers.37 

In  February,  1823,  Jones  and  Immel  decided  to  press 
their  luck  by  leading  the  majority  of  the  fort's  contingent 
into  Three  Forks  country.  They  were  able  to  evade  the 
Blackfeet  long  enough  to  conduct  a  successful  hunt,  but 
their  luck  ran  out  along  the  Yellowstone  on  their  way  back 
to  the  garrison.  As  they  approached  the  mouth  of  Pryor 
Creek  on  May  31,  a  band  of  Blackfeet  appeared  out  of 
nowhere,  taking  them  by  surprise.  In  the  ensuing  battle 
seven  Americans  were  killed,  includingjones  and  Immel, 
and  the  marauding  Blackfeet  made  off  with  most  of  the 
trappers'  horses  and  equipment  as  well  as  all  of  the  furs 
they  had  accumulated.38  The  losses  sustained  in  the  bat- 
tle were  so  substantial  that  Pilcher  withdrew  the  Missouri 
Fur  Company  from  the  lower  Big  Horn  area,  and  after 
about  a  year  of  inconclusive  trading  along  the  Missouri 
River,  he  dissolved  the  firm.39 

In  1822,  another  St.  Louis  businessman,  William 
Ashley,  had  formed  an  informal  partnership  with  Andrew 
Henry,  and  they  too,  would  make  an  abortive  attempt  to 
establish  a  trading  and  trapping  operation  among  the 
Crow.  Henry  assumed  responsibility  for  field  operations 
and  by  September  of  that  year  had  built  a  small  stockade 
at  the  mouth  of  the  Yellowstone  to  serve  as  a  depot  for 
furs  being  collected  by  members  of  his  party  working  the 
tributaries  of  the  upper  Missouri  River.40  The  succeeding 
September,  Henry  moved  to  the  mouth  of  the  Big  Horn 
with  13  men  and  either  constructed  a  new  garrison  or 
occupied  Fort  Benton.41  Jedediah  Smith,  at  about  the 
same  time,  led  another  group  of  Ashley  men  across  the 
Big  Horn  Mountains  to  the  Big  Horn  River  where  he  and 
his  hands  trapped  until  late  November.  Smith  and  party 
then  moved  across  the  Owl  Creek  Mountains  into  the 
Wind  River  Valley  to  spend  the  winter  with  a  band  of  Crow 
Indians.42 

Andrew  Henry,  following  a  disappointing  season, 
closed  the  fort,  returned  to  St.  Louis  in  the  summer  of 
1824,  and  dissolved  the  partnership.43  Ashley  continued 
in  the  fur  trade  but  shifted  his  operations  to  the  friendlier 
and,  as  it  happened,  more  lucrative  environment  of  south- 
western Wyoming,  eastern  Idaho,  and  northwestern  Utah. 

The  Wind -Big  Horn  River  did,  nonetheless,  continue 
to  play  a  role  in  the  Rocky  Mountain  fur  operations.  Most 
of  the  prominent  mountain  men,  as  the  trappers  had 
begun  to  refer  to  themselves,  traded  and  trapped  on  the 
river  at  one  time  or  another  during  the  remaining  years 
of  active  beaver  hunting,  generally  from  1825  to  1840. 44 


53 


On  at  least  two  occasions,  once  in  182545  and  again  in 
1833, 46  the  lower  Big  Horn  was  used  as  a  waterway  to 
transport  furs  to  market,47  and  the  Wind  River  Valley 
hosted  major  rendezvous  in  1829, 48  183049  and  1838. 50 
Finally,  in  1832,  a  relative  newcomer  to  the  region,  the 
American  Fur  Company,  built  the  last  fur  post  to  be 
located  at  the  mouth  of  the  Big  Horn.51  Fort  Cass52  ser- 
viced the  Crow  until  1835,  when  it  was  vacated  in  favor 
of  the  safer  environs  of  the  Rosebud  River.53 

Because  the  Wind-Big  Horn  River  seemed  to  offer 
both  security  and  economic  opportunity,  it  served  as  the 
cutting  edge  for  our  nation's  first  attempt  to  exploit  the 
economic  resources  of  the  northern  Rocky  Mountain  area. 
Although  the  river  no  longer  served  as  the  hub  of  fur  trade 
activity  after  1811,  it  continued  to  attract  American  trap- 
pers for  many  years  thereafter.  Their  presence  had  the 
geopolitical  consequences  of  precluding  permanent  British 
occupation  of  the  region  and  providing  a  firm  basis  for 
American  territorial  claims. 


1 .  It  is  possible  but  unlikely  that  the  Verendrye  expedition  of  1742-43 
got  as  far  west  as  the  Wind-Big  Horn  River.  For  the  most  recent 
interpretation  regarding  the  itinerary  of  the  Verendrye  brothers, 
see  G.  Herbert  Smith  (W.  Raymond  Wood,  ed.),  The  Explora- 
tions of  the  La  Verendryes  in  the  Northern  Plains,  1738-43,  (Lin- 
coln and  London:  University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1980),  pp. 
115-127. 

2.  "Trudeau's  (Truteau's)  Description  of  the  Upper  Missouri"  in  A. 
P.  Nasatir,  (ed.),  Before  Lewis  and  Clark:  Documents  Illustrating 
the  History  of  the  Missouri,   1785-1804,  (St.   Louis  Historical 


Documents  Foundation,  1952) 


$1. 


3.  Charles  Le  Raye  may  have  preceded  Larocque  into  the  Crow 
homeland.  He  claimed  to  have  visited  the  Big  Horn  and 
Yellowstone  Rivers  in  1802  as  a  captive  of  the  Sioux.  However, 
his  descriptions  of  Indian  tribes  encountered  and  of  his  itinerary 
give  rise  to  doubts  about  the  authenticity  of  his  account.  The 
reader  is  invited  to  draw  their  own  conclusions  by  consulting  "The 
Journal  of  Charles  Le  Raye,"  South  Dakota  Historical  Collections. 
5  (1905),  pp.  150-180. 

4.  Ruth  Hazlitt,  (ed.).  The  Journal  of  Francois  Antoine  Larocque 
from  the  Assiniboine  River  to  the  Yellowstone,  1805,  (Missoula: 
University  of  Montana,  Sources  of  Northwest  History,  n.d.)  pp. 
7-22. 

5.  Meriwether  Lewis  and  William  Clark  (Reuben  Gold  Thwaites, 
ed.),  Original  journals  of  the  Lewis  and  Clark  Expedition,  (New 
York:  Arno  Press,  1969),  5,  p.  296. 

6.  Letter,  Thomas  Jefferson  to  Meriwether  Lewis,  January  22,  1804, 
in  Donald  Jackson,  Letters  of  the  Lewis  and  Clark  Expedition 
with  Related  Documents,  1783-1854,  (Urbana:  University  of  Illi- 
nois Press),  pp.  165-166. 

7.  Lewis  and  Clark,  Original  Journals,  p.  320. 

8.  Letter,  Meriwether  Lewis  to  Thomas  Jefferson,  September  23, 
1806,  in  Jackson,  Letters,  p.  321. 

9.  Nathaniel  J.  Wyeth  observed  in  1833  that,  for  a  large  stream, 
the  lower  Big  Horn  offered  the  best  trapping  in  the  Rocky  Moun- 
tains. Frederick  G.  Young,  (ed.).  The  Correspondence  andjour- 
nals  of  Captain  Nathaniel  J.  Wyeth,  (New  York:  Arno  Press, 
1973),  p.  207. 

10.  House  Document  No.  117,  Serial  136,  19th  Congress,  1st  Session. 

1 1 .  Henry  Alexander  and  David  Thompson  (Elliot  Coues,  ed.),  The 
Manuscript  Journals  of  Alexander  Henry  and  of  David  Thomp- 
son, 1799-1814,  (Minneapolis:  Ross  and  Haines,  Inc.,  1965),  1, 
pp.  398-399. 


12.  Ibid.,  2,  p.  720. 

13.  Senate  Document  No.  69,  Serial  181,  20th  Congress,  2nd  Ses 
sion;  Letter,  Manuel  Lisa  to  the  Spaniards  of  New  Mexico 
September  8,  1812,  in  Herbert  E.  Bolton,  "New  Light  on  Manue 
Lisa  and  the  Spanish  Fur  Trade,"  Southwestern  Historical 
Quarterly,  17  (1913),  pp.  61-66. 

14.  Reuben  Holmes,  "The  Five  Scalps,"  Glimpses  of  the  Past,  b'r 
(1938),  p.  8.  Edward  Rose  can  be  considered  to  be  the  first  Euro 
American  inhabitant  of  the  Big  Horn  region  in  that  he  lived  inter 
mittently  among  the  Crow  from  1807  until  his  death  in  1833 
For  other  references  to  Rose,  see  "Journey  of  Mr.  Hunt  and  his 
Companions  from  St.  Louis  to  the  Mouth  of  the  Columbia  b) 
a  New  Route  Across  the  Rocky  Mountains,"  in  Appendix  to  Philip 
Ashton  Rollins,  (ed.),  The  Discovery  of  the  Oregon  Trail:  Robert 
Stuart's  Narratives,  (New  York  and  London:  Charles  Scribner's 
Sons,  1935),  pp.  284-285;  James  H.  Bradley,  "Affairs  at  Fort  Ben 
ton  from  1831  to  1869,"  Contributions,  Historical  Society  of  Mon 
tana,  3  (1900),  p.  263;  James  P.  Beckwourth  as  told  to  Thomas 
D.  Bonner  (Delmont  R.  Oswald,  ed.),  The  Life  and  Adventurer 
of  James  P.  Beckwourth,  (Lincoln:  University  of  Nebraska  Press, 
1972),  pp.  83-84,  253-257,  259;  and  Washington  Irving  (Edgely 
Todd,  ed.),  The  Adventures  of  Captain  Bonneville,  U.S.A.  in 
the  Rocky  Mountains  and  the  Far  West,  (Norman:  University 
of  Oklahoma  Press,  1961),  pp.  166-168. 

15.  Henry  Marie  Brackenridge,  Views  of  Louisiana:  Together  with 
a  Journal  of  a  Voyage  up  the  Missouri  River,  in  1811,  (Chicago: 
Quadrangle  Books,  Inc.,  1962),  p.  92.  John  Colter,  who  had  beer 
with  Lewis  and  Clark,  left  the  expedition  on  its  return  trip  down 
the  Missouri  River  to  trap  and  trade  on  the  Yellowstone  with  For 
rest  Handcock  and  Joseph  Dixon  during  the  fall  and  winter  ol 
1806-1807.  On  his  voyage  upriver  in  1807,  Lisa  encountered  Col 
ter,  returning  to  civilization,  at  the  mouth  of  the  Platte  and  per- 
suaded him  to  join  the  expedition.  Other  Lewis  and  Clark  veterans 
who  accompanied  Lisa  to  the  mouth  of  the  Big  Horn  in  1807, 
included  George  Drouillard,  Edward  Robinson,  Peter  Wiser  and 
John  Potts. 

16.  Irving,  Adventures  of  Captain  Bonneville,  p.  173;  Hiram  Mar- 
tin Chittenden  and  Alfred  Talbot  Richardson,  (eds.),  Life,  Let- 
ters and  Travels  of  Father  de  Smet,  (New  York:  Arno  Press  and 
the  New  York  Times,  1969),  2,  p.  660;  Frances  Fuller  Victor, 
River  of  the  West,  (Oakland:  Brooks-Sterling  Company,  1974), 
p.  80. 

17.  "Map  and  Notes  by  William  Clark,  Based  on  Information  Fur 
nished  him  by  George  Drouillard,  1809,"  Missouri  Historica, 
Society,  has  been  reproduced  in  M.  O.  Skarsten,  Georgt 
Drouillard:  Hunter  and  Interpreter  for  Lewis  and  Clark,  and  Fui 
Trader,  1807-1810,  (Glendale:  The  Arthur  H.  Clark  Company,) 
1964),  p.  339. 

18.  Brackenridge,   Views  of  Louisiana,  p.  92. 

19.  Letter,  Pierre  Menard  to  Adrien  Langlois,  October  7,  1809 
Kaskasia  Papers,  Missouri  Historical  Society. 

20.  Senate  Document  No.  90,  Serial  213,  22nd  Congress,  1st  Session: 
Brackenridge,   Views  of  Louisiana,  p.  92. 

21.  Ibid. 

22.  Letter,  Pierre  Menard  to  Adrien  Langlois,  October  7,  1809. 

23.  Letter,  Reuben  Lewis  to  Meriwether  Lewis,  April  21,  1810 
Meriwether  Lewis  Collection,  Missouri  Historical  Society.  Reuber 
Lewis  represented  the  interests  of  his  brother  and  those  of  Williarr 
Clark  in  the  Missouri  Fur  Company.  He  was  an  active  partici 
pant  in  the  operations  of  the  firm  until  it  temporarily  withdrew 
from  Crow  country  in  the  summer  of  1813. 

24.  The  most  detailed  account  of  this  sequence  of  events  is  founc 
in  Thomas  James  (Milo  Milton  Quaife,  ed.),  Three  Years  Amon£ 
the  Indians  and  Mexicans,  (New  York:  The  Citadel  Press,  1966) 
pp.  64-84.  For  other  accounts,  see  Louisiana  Gazette,  July  26 
1810,  in  Skarsten,  George  Drouillard,  pp.  310-312;  and  Alex 
ander  and  Thompson,  Manuscript  Journals,  2,  p.  735. 


54 


Brackenridge,  Views  of  Louisiana,  p.  39;  Senate  Document  No. 
90. 

Brackenridge,  Views  of  Louisiana,  pp.  199-200. 
Hunt  and  party  started  up  the  Missouri  River  on  March  14,  1811. 
They  left  the  river  at  the  Arikara  villages,  striking  a  westerly  course 
for  the  Big  Horn  Mountains.  After  crossing  the  mountains  to  No 
Wood  River,  they  turned  south  to  follow  the  river  to  its  source. 
From  this  point  their  route  took  them  up  the  Wind  River  and 
on  to  the  Pacific  Coast.  The  most  complete  account  of  the  Hunt 
expedition  is  Rollins,  "Journey  of  Mr.  Hunt."  pp.  281-328.  Other 
references  to  this  journey  are:  "Expedition  of  Mr.  Hunt"  in 
Appendix  III,  John  Bradbury,  Travels  in  the  Interior  of  America, 
(Ann  Arbor:  University  Microfilms,  1966),  pp.  222-233;  Gabriel 
Franchere  (Hoyt  C.  Franchere,  ed.),  Adventure  at  Astoria, 
18101814,  (Norman:  University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1964),  pp. 
64-67;  and  Edwin  James,  Account  of  an  Expedition  from  Pitts- 
burgh to  the  Rocky  Mountains,  (Ann  Arbor:  University 
Microfilms,  Inc.,  1966),  pp.  465-466. 
Brackenridge,  Views  of  Louisiana,  p.  233. 
The  last  reference  to  Fort  Raymond  found  indicates  that  it  was 
still  occupied  in  March  of  1811.  Alexander  and  Thompson, 
Manuscript  Journals ,  2,  p.  732.  There  is  evidence  which  suggests 
that  Lisa  ordered  another  post  built  at  the  mouth  of  the  Big  Horn 
in  1812.  Bolton,  "New  Light,"  p.  63. 

John  C.  Luttig  (Stella  M.  Drumm,  ed.).  Journal  of  a  Fur  Trading 
Expedition  on  the  Upper  Missouri,  1812-1813,  (New  York: 
Argosy-Antiquarian,  Ltd.,  1964),  pp.  77,  100-105. 
For  specific  instances  of  increased  hostility,  see  Ibid.,  pp.  107-108, 
122-124.  American  traders  almost  always  attributed  Indian 
intransigence  to  British  instigation. 

Charles  E.  Peterson,  "Deposition  and  Interrogation  of  Michael 
Immel,  June  25,  1821,"  Bulletin,  Missouri  Historical  Society,  4 
(1948),  p.  79. 

Even   the   redoubtable   Edward   Rose   found  it   convenient   to 
withdraw  from  the  area  in  1813.  He  did  not  return  until  1822. 
Holmes,  "Five  Scalps",  Glimpses  of  the  Past,  pp.  39,  43. 
Senate  Document  No.  56,  Serial  89,  18th  Congress,  1st  Session; 
Senate  Document  No.  90. 

Jones,  a  resident  of  St.  Louis,  was  a  newcomer  to  the  Rocky  Moun- 
tain fur  trade.  Immel,  on  the  other  hand,  was  a  veteran  fur  trader 
who  had  served  under  Andrew  Henry  at  Fort  Raymond  and  in 
the  Three  Forks  region. 
Senate  Document  No.  90. 

Letter,  Benjamin  O'Fallon  to  Ramsay  Crooks,  July  10,  1823, 
Chouteau  Collection,  Missouri  Historical  Society. 
Letter,  William  Gordon  to  Joshua  Pilcher,  June  15,  1823,  in  "The 
International  Significance  of  the  Jones  and  Immel  Massacre  and 
of  the  Arikara  Outbreak  in  1823,"  Pacific  Northwest  Quarterly, 
30  (1939),  pp.  100-101;  Letter,  Benjamin  O'Fallon  to  William 
Clark,  July  3,  1823,  in  James  H.  Bradley  (Edgar  I.  Stewart,  ed.), 
The  March  of  the  Montana  Column:  A  Prelude  to  the  Custer 
Disaster,  (Norman:  University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1961),  pp. 
166-168. 

Senate  Document  No.  89. 
Maurice  S.  Sullivan,  The  Travels  ofjedediah  Smith:  A  Documen- 


tary  Outline,    Including  the  Journal  of  the  Great  American 
Pathfinder,  (Santa  Ana:  The  Fine  Arts  Press,  1934),  pp.  8-10. 

41.  Letter,  Daniel  T.  Potts  to  Robert  Tower  Potts,  July  16,  1826, 
in  Charles  L.  Camp,  "The  DTP.  Letters,"  Essays  for  Henry 
Raup  Warner,  (San  Francisco:  California  Historical  Society, 
1947),  p.  6;  Letter,  Daniel  T.  Potts  to  Thomas  Cochlen,  July  7, 
1824,  in  Dale  L.  Morgan,  (ed.),  The  West  of  William  Ashley, 
(Denver:  The  Old  West  Publishing  Company,  1964),  pp.  79-80; 
St.  Louis  Enquirer,  June  7,  1824,  in  Ibid.,  p.  76. 

42.  Charles  L.  Camp,  (ed.),  James  Clyman,  Frontiersman  The 
Adventures  of  a  Trapper  and  Covered-wagon  Emigrant  as  Told 
in  his  own  Reminiscences  and  Diaries,  (Portland:  Champoeg 
Press,  1960),  pp.  17-21. 

43.  Letter  Henry  Leavenworth  to  Alexander  Macomb,  December  20, 
1823,  in  Camp,   West  of  William  Ashley,  p.  68. 

44.  For  accounts  of  major  trapping  and  trading  expeditions  along 
the  river:  Irving,  Adventures  of  Captain  Bonneville,  pp.  174-185; 
Victor,  River  of  the  West,  pp.  57-58,  179;  Zenas  Leonard  (John 
C.  Ewers,  ed.),  Zenas  Leonard,  Fur  Trader,  (Norman:  Univer- 
sity of  Oklahoma  Press,  1959),  pp.  26,  74,  77-84;  Christopher 
Carson  (Milo  Milton  Quaife,  ed.),  Kit  Carson's  Autobiography, 
(Lincoln:  University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1935),  pp.  45,  47-48; 
Dorothy  O.  Johansen,  (ed.),  Robert  Newell's  Memoranda, 
(Portland:  Champoeg  Press.  1959),  pp.  34-37;  Stephan  Hall  Meek 
(Arthur  Woodward,  ed.),  The  Autobiography  of  a  Mountain 
Man:  1805-1889,  (Pasadena:  Glen  Dawson,  1948).  pp.  4-5:  and 
Osborne  Russell  (Aubrey  L.  Haines,  ed.),  Osborne  Russell'sjour- 
nal  of  a  Trapper,  (Lincoln:  University  of  Nebraska  Press, 
reprinted  from  1955  edition),  pp  56-58,  68-73. 

45.  Beckwourth,  Life  and  Adventures,  pp.  77-81;  "Ashley  Narrative" 
in  Morgan,   West  of  William  Ashley,  pp.  129-130. 

46.  Irving,  Adventures  of  Captain  Bonneville ,  pp.  174-178;  Young, 
Correspondence  and  Journals,  pp.  208-210;  Charles  Larpenteur 
(Elliott  Coues,  ed.),  Forty  Years  a  Fur  Trader  on  the  Upper 
Missouri:  The  Personal  Narrative  of  Charles  Larpenteur,  (Min- 
neapolis: Ross  &  Haines,  Inc.,  1962),  pp.  38-46. 

47.  Most  Wyoming  historians  have  erroneously  placed  the  Big  Horn 
River  head  of  navigation  at  the  lower  end  of  the  Wind  River  Can- 
yon. See,  for  example,  T.  A.  Larson,  Wyoming:  A  Bicentennial 
History,  (New  York:  W.  W.  Norton  &  Company,  Inc.,  1977), 
p.  27;  Charles  Lindsay,  The  Big  Horn  Basin,  (Lincoln:  Univer- 
sity of  Nebraska  Studies,  1932),  p.  37;  and  David  J.  Wasden,  From 
Beaver  to  Oil:  A  Century  in  the  Development  of  Wyoming's  Big 
Horn  Basin,  (Cheyenne:  Pioneer  Printing  and  Stationery  Co., 
1973),  p.  24.  As  the  citations  in  the  two  previous  footnotes  clearly 
demonstrate,  the  head  of  navigation  was  rather  at  the  lower  end 
of  the  Big  Horn  Canyon. 

48.  Victor,  River  of  the  West,  pp.  48-49. 

49.  Ibid.,  p.  89. 

50.  Johansen,  Robert  Newell's  Memoranda,  p.  37;  Carson,  Kit  Car- 
son's Autobiography,  p.  56. 

51.  Larpenteur,  Forty  Years,  p.  115 

52.  For  a  description  of  Fort  Cass,  see  Young,  Correspondence  and 
Journals,  p.  211. 

53.  Annie  Heloise  Abel,  (ed.),  Chardon's  Journal  at  Fort  Clark: 
1834-1839,  (Freeport:  Books  for  Libraries  Press,  1970),  p.  380. 


55 


BOOK  REVIEWS 


The  West  of  Wild  Bill  Hickok.  By  Joseph  G.  Rosa. 
(Norman:  University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1982). 
Index.  Illus.  233  pp.  Cloth,  $25.95. 

In  The  West  of  Wild  Bill  Hickok,  Joseph  G.  Rosa  has 
presented  an  impressive  array  of  some  168  photographic 
plates  that  depict  the  life  and  times  of  James  Butler 
Hickok.  The  volume  is  an  "impressive  picture  book"  that 
includes  brief,  but  sufficient,  biographical  text  to  accom- 
pany the  photographic  parade. 

Rosa's  preface  provides  a  nutshell  history  of  19th  cen- 
tury photography.  The  author  notes  that,  interestingly, 
Hickok's  lifetime  (1837-76)  "spanned  the  very  period  that 
gave  birth  to  photography  and  witnessed  many  of  its 
improvements."  Further,  Hickok  was  no  more  afraid  of 
the  camera  than  he  was  gun-shy.  During  his  lifetime,  he 
almost  constantly  attracted  photographers  and  reporters. 
Hickok  himself  once  stated,  "I  am  sort  of  public  property." 

In  the  introduction,  Rosa  presents  a  compendious  his- 
torical essay  of  the  Wild  Bill  Hickok  that  has  been  given 
to  photography.  The  author  provides  insight  to  the 
exhaustive  process  of  attempting  to  identify,  place  and 
credit  the  photographs.  The  research  required  in  sorting 
such  confusion  must  have  been  especially  difficult  in  light 
of  the  legend  surrounding  Hickok.  Rosa's  introductory 
remarks  make  for  an  interesting  springboard  into  the  bulk 
of  the  book. 

The  first  chapter  covers  Hickok  from  his  birth  in  Illi- 
nois to  the  outbreak  of  the  Civil  War  (1837-61).  Among 
the  photographs  in  this  chapter  are  those  showing  Hickok's 
birthplace  and  family.  Also  included  are  key  figures  in 
the  fighting  between  the  Kansas  "Free  Staters"  and  the 
Missouri  "Border  Ruffians"  that  enveloped  Hickok.  There 
is  a  noticeable  void  of  photographs  that  would  depict 
Hickok's  early  years  in  Illinois,  but  this,  of  course,  is 
through  no  fault  of  Rosa. 

Chapter  two  presents  plates  of  Hickok's  involvement 
in  the  Civil  War  as  a  Union  soldier  (1861-65).  Rosa  states 
that  Hickok's  various  employment  duties  included  wagon 
master,  scout,  sharpshooter,  policeman,  detective  and 
perhaps  spy.  Hence,  the  impetus  that  Hickok's  true  Civil 
War  adventures  should  become  mixed  with  fiction.  It  was 
during  the  Civil  War  that  Hickok  became  known  to  others 


as  "Wild  Bill."  The  plates  in  this  chapter  center  on  Civi 
War  personalities  with  whom  Hickok  was  associated  ii 
one  way  or  another,  and  several  sketches  of  Wild  Bill  tha 
appeared  in  an  1867  issue  of  Harper's  New  Mont  hi 
Magazine.  The  latter  do  their  measure  of  perpetuatini 
the  Hickok  legend. 

Following  the  Civil  War,  the  War  Departmen; 
became  engaged  in  Indian  affairs,  attempting  peact 
through  agreement  or  by  force.  Rosa's  third  chaptei 
focuses  on  Hickok's  spotty  post-war  service  to  the  arm; 
as  a  guide  (1866-69).  Part  of  Hickok's  military  assignmen 
was  with  the  famous  Seventh  Cavalry,  commanded  b\ 
Lieutenant  Colonel  George  Armstong  Custer.  The  photo 
graphs  here  include  several  excellent  ones  of  Hickok,  a; 
well  as  a  good  variety  that  portray  the  people  and  place; 
of  Hickok's  army  involvement  during  that  time. 

The  next  chapter  addresses  Hickok  as  peace  officei 
and  pistoleer  (1869-71).  As  acting  sheriff  of  Hays  City, 
he  brought  order  to  a  town  that,  in  its  hitherto  shori 
history  had  rapidly  earned  a  reputation  for  lawlessness 
Later,  as  marshal  of  Abilene,  he  was  successful  in  reg 
ulating  the  town's  gambling,  prostitution  and  rough 
housing  caused  by  the  growing  cattle  trade,  of  which 
Abilene  was  a  major  stop.  His  bout  as  Abilene's  marsha 
gained  Hickok  a  "reputation  that,  with  time,  became  ar 
important  part  of  the  legend."  The  photographs  in  thi,' 
section  present  a  good  assortment  of  the  elements  of  thi; 
period  in  Hickok's  life,  as  well  as  documents  bearing  hi; 
handwriting  and  signature,  pistols  reported  to  have  beer 
his,  and  some  superb  photographs  of  Hickok  himself. 

Chapter  five  accounts  for  Hickok's  life  as  showmar 
(1872-74),  which  he  grew  to  dislike.  His  initial  theatrica 
appearance  was  as  master  of  ceremonies  for  a  show  at 
Niagara  Falls,  New  York,  in  August  of  1872.  In  mid-1873 
he  joined  Buffalo  Bill  Cody  in  a  like  adventure.  Thi; 
period  of  Wild  Bill's  life  was  not  all  staged,  however.  Aftei 
returning  from  Niagara  Falls,  Hickok  attended  the  annua 
Kansas  City  Fair  as  a  spectator.  When  a  group  of  some 
50  Texans  disrupted  the  band,  Wild  Bill  confronted  them 
despite  their  pistols  "presented  at  William's  head,"  anc 
restored  order.  The  photographs  contained  here  are  pri 
marily  individuals  Wild  Bill  encountered  in  his  show 
endeavors.  Those  of  Hickok  himself  include  advertise 


56 


hnents  for  various  shows  and  what  Rosa  asserts  is  "perhaps 
lis  most  famous  portrait"     -  Wild  Bill  in  buckskins. 

The  final  chapter  deals  with  the  last  years  of  Hickok's 
ife  (1874-76).  Rosa  points  out  that  Hickok's  activities  dur- 
ng  this  time  are  obscure,  since  "only  scattered  mention 
if  him  is  found  in  the  press."  With  Cheyenne  as  his  base, 
le  traveled  a  good  deal  and,  in  July  of  1876,  journeyed 
o  the  Black  Hills  in  an  attempt  to  secure  funds  through 
he  gold  rush  there  to  support  his  new  bride.  His  actions 
here  and  at  least  one  letter  to  his  wife  evince  the  fact 
hat  Hickok  had,  by  this  time,  become  quite  aware  of  his 
nemies  and  their  desire  to  do  him  in.  On  an  afternoon 
,'n  August,  while  playing  poker,  he  was  murdered  by  a 
bcal  laborer  named  Jack  McCall.  Rosa  records  several 
'urious  stories  revolving  around  Wild  Bill's  death,  all  of 
/hich  add  to  the  legend  of  the  historical  Wild  Bill  Hickok. 
'ncluded  along  with  photographs  of  Hickok  are  those  of 
he  Deadwood  clientele,  Hickok's  wife,  and  his  final 
esting  place. 

Rosa  handles  the  historical  Hickok  admirably,  dispel - 
ing  certain  tall  tales  and  noting  Hickok's  constant  con- 
'ern  for  family  and  friends.  Due  to  the  limited  amount 
if  text,  one  can,  in  a  single  sitting,  grasp  a  feel  for  the 
Weadth  of  Hickok's  life.  The  book  is  recommended 
'eading  to  the  historian  and  enthusiast  alike. 

Rosa  has  authored  several  books  and  articles  on  the 
Vest,  of  which  The  West  of  Wild  Bill  Hickok  is  without 
loubt  a  commendable  addition.  Certainly,  the  book 
/ould  make  an  appropriate  companion  to  Rosa's  They 
Called  Him  Wild  Bill:  The  Life  and  Adventures  of  James 
iutler  Hickok.  The  West  of  Wild  Bill  Hickok  does  indeed 
ffer  a  superb  photographic  montage  of  Hickok's  fami- 
ly, friends,  foes  and  the  places  that  knew  him.  Yet,  to 
ielieve  that  the  plates  contained  in  his  work  make  up 
'lmost  the  entire  existing  collection  of  what  history  has 
'llowed  to  remain  of  Wild  Bill  Hickok  is  difficult,  but 
:nakes  Rosa's  endeavor  seem  even  more  valuable. 

Scott  T.  Tubbs 

'"he  reviewer  is  a  social  studies  educator  with  the  Rapid  City  public 
"hool  system. 


Deep  Enough:  A  Working  Stiff  in  the  Western 
Mine  Camps.  By  Frank  A.  Crampton.  Foreword 
by  W.  H.  Hutchinson.  (Norman:  University  of 
Oklahoma  Press,  1982).  Illustrations.  Maps. 
Index.  281  pp.  $16.95. 

In  the  vernacular  of  the  hard-rock  miner,  the  phrase 
deep  enough"  expresses  the  attitude  of  "I  don't  care"  or 
I've  had  it."  When  things  get  "deep  enough,"  it  is  time 
o  move  on  to  another  mine  or  some  other  venture.  This 
tutobiography  relates  the  varied  experiences  of  one  rather 


unusual  hard-rock  stiff,  Frank  Crampton,  over  the  first 
30  years  of  his  life. 

Crampton  was  born  into  a  well-to-do  and  socially 
prominent  New  York  City  family  in  1888.  He  led  a  very 
mischievous  childhood  and  adolescence,  despite  receiv- 
ing a  military  academy  education.  Like  many  other  scions 
of  wealthy  Eastern  families,  he  headed  West  to  make  his 
fortune  after  finding  college  not  to  his  liking.  Crampton 
left  his  family  in  1904  at  the  age  of  16,  and  in  Chicago 
fell  into  the  hands  of  two  bindle  stiffs,  John  T.  Harrington 
(John  T.)  and  Michael  Sullivan  (Sully).  These  two  men 
became  Crampton's  life-long  friends  and  associates,  and 
from  them  the  city  boy  learned  the  life  of  a  hard-rock 
miner. 

During  his  practical  education,  Crampton  became 
adept  at  the  single  and  double-jack  method  of  drilling 
into  a  mine  wall,  handling  powder,  tamping  explosive 
charges  and  spitting  a  fuse.  To  this,  he  added  his  own 
basic  education,  ambition  and  natural  curiousity  to  rise 
within  the  mining  profession.  Ultimately,  Crampton 
worked  as  an  assayer,  surveyor  and  engineer,  as  well  as 
a  miner.  Still,  he  never  forgot  what  it  was  like  to  labor 
underground,  and  he  remained  a  member  of  the  Western 
Federation  of  Miners  and  Industrial  Workers  of  the  World 
throughout  his  career  in  the  mines  of  California,  Arizona, 
Nevada,  Utah  and  Colorado  during  the  first  two  decades 
of  the  20th  century. 

This  book  is  most  valuable  as  a  primary  document 
of  Western  mining  at  a  time  in  which  it  was  becoming 
less  individualistic  and  increasingly  industrialized.  Cramp- 
ton's  reminiscences  include  some  of  the  romantic  aspects 
usually  attributed  to  the  individualistic  mining  frontier. 
Gambling  halls  and  prostitution,  for  example,  receive 
ample  and  often  favorable  attention.  Of  the  latter,  he 
writes  that  "the  girls  of  the  line  were  real  women  beneath 
their  coldly-warm  exterior,  and  not  many  were  the  hard- 
shelled  harlots  they  have  all  been  pictured." 

Crampton  also  recounts  the  revelry  attached  to  drill- 
ing contests,  the  practical  jokes  played  on  naive  green- 
horns and  the  colorful  personalities  of  prospectors  and 
desert  rats.  An  example  was  French -born  John  Lamoigne, 
who  with  his  one  great  discovery  built  a  castle  in  Death 
Valley,  only  to  blow  it  up  when  settling  in  one  location 
proved  impossible  to  his  roaming  nature. 

In  addition  to  the  romance,  Crampton  also  reveals 
some  of  the  harsh  realities  of  industrialized  mining. 
Undoubtedly,  the  most  gripping  chapter  in  the  book  con- 
cerns the  author's  ten-day  entombment  in  a  Utah  mine. 
He  clearly  blames  the  company's  lax  attitude  toward  safety 
for  the  cave-in  which  trapped  him  and  nineteen  other  men 
underground  for  what  seemed  to  them  an  eternity.  The 
notion  that  "men  are  cheaper  than  timber"  character- 
ized the  attitude  of  operators  of  this  mine,  and  many 
others.  According  to  the  eyewitness  account  of  Cramp- 
ton, a  similar  position  on  the  part  of  Colorado  Fuel  and 


57 


Iron  led  to  the  Ludlow  Massacre  in  the  southern  Colorado 
coalfields. 

The  author  also  accurately  portrays  the  inherent 
dangers  of  hard-rock  mining,  especially  in  the  use  of 
explosives.  Indeed,  Crampton's  good  friend  Sully  died 
when  a  metal  cleaning  spoon  he  was  using  to  tamp  down 
the  powder  in  a  drill-hole  apparently  caused  a  spark  which 
ignited  the  charge. 

For  all  its  strength  as  a  document  of  Western  mining 
during  a  period  of  transition,  however,  Deep  Enough 
should  be  approached  with  some  caution.  Regardless  of 
the  implication  of  his  subtitle,  Crampton  can  hardly  be 
considered  the  typical  hard-rock  stiff.  He  was  well-bred, 
very  articulate  and  sufficiently  educated  to  rise  to  some 
prominence  within  the  mining  profession.  Furthermore, 
his  New  York  background  provided  him  contacts  with 
Eastern  investors  for  ventures  initiated  by  the  mining  firm 
he  established  with  his  brother. 

In  reality,  Frank  Crampton  represents  an  amalgam 
of  two  characters  of  Western  mining;  the  hard-rock  miners 
recently  written  about  by  Ronald  C.  Brown  and  Richard 
E.  Lingenfelter,  and  the  mining  engineers  studied  by 
Clark  C.  Spence  over  a  decade  ago. 

Nevertheless,  this  is  but  a  minor  criticism.  On  the 
whole,  this  is  an  enjoyable  and  valuable  firsthand  account 
of  Western  mining  during  the  early  20th  century. 
Although  Crampton  never  worked  in  Wyoming,  those 
interested  in  Wyoming  mining  history  will  benefit  from 
the  good  mining  information  in  this  book.  It  captures  both 
the  romance  and  reality  of  Western  mining  during  this 
often  neglected  period.  The  University  of  Oklahoma  has 
done  a  fine  and  very  professional  job  in  reprinting  this 
classic  first  published  in  1956,  now  with  several  new 
photographs  and  maps. 

Bill  Bryans 

The  reviewer  is  a  graduate  student  m  the  Department  of  History, 
University  of  Wyoming. 


Land  Use,  Environment ,  and  Social  Change:  The 
Shaping  of  Island  County,  Washington.  By 
Richard  White.  (Seattle:  University  of 
Washington  Press,  1980).  Maps,  Illus.  Index.  Bib. 
246  pp.  $12.95. 

Land  Use,  Environment,  and  Social  Change  is  writ- 
ten with  the  premise  that  "social  history,  political  history, 
and  natural  history  are  the  three  horses  pulling  the  chariot 
of  the  study  of  people  and  their  relationship  with  the 
natural  environment.  But  historians  have  been  reluctant 
to  acknowledge  their  horses,  let  alone  harness  them." 
Richard  White's  study  of  Island  County,  Washington,  is 
an  initial  attempt  to  redress  the  academic  oversight  of 
not  pursuing  environmental  history.  As  a  pioneering  effort 
it  is  a  very  good  one,  although  it  is  marred  with  an  occa- 
sional lapse  of  balance  or  perspective. 


Land  Use,  Environment,  and  Social  Change  ampl 
demonstrates  the  impact  human  land  use  has  on  the  env> 
ronment.  For  example,  it  details  how  the  market  pric 
of  barley  affects  how  much  was  planted,  harvested,  th! 
consequences  for  soil  composition  and  water  retention 
the  introduction  of  invading  flora  and  fauna,  and  th 
future  productivity  and  options  available  for  that  land 
site.  White's  examples  are  usually  well  documented  an 
statistically  shored  up,  no  matter  if  his  subject  is  bull  tear 
logging  or  the  coming  of  large  scale  recreation  to  Islam 
County.  His  statistical  examples  are  particularly  wei 
drawn  since  his  subject  is  an  island  county  — a  nea 
geographical  and  political  unit. 

In  this  study  White  goes  out  of  his  way  to  demonstrat 
that  native  Americans,  in  this  case  the  Salish  tribes,  wer 
not  environmental  saints.  The  four  tribes  of  Salish  peo 
pie  living  on  Whidbey  and  Camano  Islands  did  signifi 
cantly  alter  the  island  environment  with  their  industria 
and  agricultural  pursuits.  White  belabors  the  point  tha 
native  Americans  were  agents  of  environmental  change 
His  error  is  one  of  degree,  not  substance.  While  the  Salisi 
altered  the  environment,  the  later  tenants,  the  Anglo 
Americans,  changed  it. 

The  original  well-balanced  analysis  of  the  boo 
becomes  skewed  when  the  subject  becomes  more  current 
Rather  than  affirming  his  three  part  schema  of  political 
social  and  natural  history  as  a  balanced  view  of  history 
the  analysis  slips  closely  toward  becoming  an  environ 
mental  diatribe.  The  old,  passe,  concept  of  environment 
determinism  can  be  inferred  in  some  passages. 

The  flaws  of  this  book  are  few  and  small  in  scope  fo 
such  an  important  and  novel  text.  Land  Use,  Environ 
ment,  and  Social  Change  is  being  touted  as  a  "mode 
study"  by  many  environmental  historians.  The  detailei 
examination  of  environmental  changes  wrought  by  socia 
and  political  forces  should  be  adapted  by  others.  Indeed 
the  question  about  Land  Use,  Environment ,  and  Socia 
Change  is  when  will  such  a  study  occur  in  Wyoming: 

Timothy  S.  Cochrane 

The  reviewer  is  with  the  Folklore  Department  at  the  University  c 
Indiana,  Bloommgton. 


Texas  Graveyards,  a  Cultural  Legacy.  By  Terry 
G.  Jordan  (Austin:  University  of  Texas  Press, 
1982)  Index.  Bibliography.  Notes.  Illustrations. 
220  pp.  $19.95 

As  a  genealogist  continually  searching  for  elusiv 
names  and  dates,  I  found  this  book  on  Texas  graveyard 
rather  unusual.  The  author  makes  it  clear  from  page  1 
however,  that  he  has  no  genealogical  interests,  and  hi 
only  goal  was  to  preserve  the  cultures  of  Texas.  Whei 
I  accepted  this  fact,  my  perceptions  changed  and  I  rapidl 
became  interested  in  what  Mr.  Jordan  had  to  say. 


58 


. 


This  is  not  a  book  the  average  person  would  pick  for 
nday  afternoon  light  reading.  Realizing  this,  the  author 
bok  the  time  to  arrange  this  material  so  even  a  casual 
pader  could  rapidly  involve  himself  by  taking  his  pick 
)f  the  several  racial  and  ethnic  groups  that  provide 
fcmarkable  clues  to  the  shaping  of  southern  and  Texas 
ulture. 

Mr.  Jordan  brought  home  several  basic  points  with 
>hich  the  reviewer  can  easily  agree.  He  found  the  rural 
oik  do  not  distinquish  so  sharply  between  life  and  death 
s  we  from  the  cities  and  universities.  "Death  is,  for  them, 
htertwined  so  tightly  with  life  as  to  be  inseparable."  In 
,ie  rural  burial  grounds  is  found  one  of  the  last  refuges 
'f  folk  culture.  The  author  feels  that  no  where  else  is  it 
Possible  to  look  so  deeply  into  our  people's  past.  Tradi- 
tional graveyards  are  endangered  and  our  modern  com- 
mercial cemetery  will  likely  obliterate  most  of  the  distinc- 
tive elements  of  our  traditional  burial  grounds.  Our  pres- 
pt  generation  may  be  the  last  to  have  access  to  the  rich 
material  culture  of  the  folk  cemetery. 

For  20  years  Terry  Jordan  has  tramped  Texas  cem- 
Jteries  involved  in  a  systematic  study  of  its  pioneers' 

! ulture.  This  book  is  divided  into  three  distinct  parts: 
outhern  Folk,  Hispanic-American  and  German.  The 
uthor  acknowledges  that  other  people  (Cajun  French, 
'■lavs,  Jews  and  Scandinavians)  have  contributed  to  Texas 
f ulture,  but  his  inability  to  read  their  language,  and  lack 
if  knowledge  of  their  culture  forced  him  to  devote  his 
.ttention  to  the  peoples  he  felt  he  could  research 
xcurately. 

The  Southern  folk  cemetery  in  Texas  was  the  sub- 
pct  of  two  chapters,  probably  because  descendants  of 
vealthy  planters,  "Crackers,"  slaves  and  southeastern 
ndian  tribes  are  buried  there.  Many  of  the  graveyards 
ire  located  on  private  family  property,  and  the  graves 
nay  be  covered  by  a  small  graveshed.  The  stone,  if  there 
s  one,  is  usually  small  with  a  terse  epitaph.  The  custom 
)f  "scraping"  was  new  to  me,  however,  and  I  became  quite 
nterested  in  explanations  for  this  curious  custom  of 
emoving  all  grass  from  the  gravesite.  Some  told  Mr.  Jor- 
lan  it  was  "just  customary"  or  "looks  nice,"  and  a  few 
iaw  it  as  a  good  way  to  escape  mowing  the  grass.  Others 
elt  that  "grass  on  a  grave  is  disrespectful  to  the  dead," 
ind  the  last  word,  "Grandpaw  killed  himself  keeping  the 
/veeds  out  of  his  cotton,  and  we're  not  about  to  let  them 
jrow  on  his  grave  now!"  Obviously,  the  original  reasons 
"or  scraping  were  forgotten  generations  ago,  perhaps  in 
Faraway  lands. 

Of  all  the  subjects  discussed  by  Mr.  Jordan,  the  sub- 
ject of  different  tombstones  was  the  most  interesting.  I 
felt  that  by  learning  which  type  of  stone  was  used  by  dif- 
ferent cultures,  the  knowledge  would  become  useful  to 
my  genealogical  research.  We  in  Wyoming  are  most  fam- 
iliar with  the  wooden  marker,  and  like  here,  Texas  has 
few  left,  and  most  are  unreadable.  In  addition,  hand- 
carved  native  stones,  so  painstakingly  worked,  were  lovely 


to  study,  even  in  pictures.  Mr.  Jordan  found  Southerners 
are  not,  and  never  have  been,  big  epitaph  writers.  Very 
few  lengthy,  poetic  or  humorous  inscriptions  are  found 
in  Texas. 

The  Hispanics  chapter  shows  diverse  cultural  contri- 
butions from  the  Castilian  to  Indian.  In  frontier  times, 
few  Spanish  settlement  cemeteries  used  markers.  The 
priest  merely  made  an  entry  in  the  Book  of  Burials  kept 
at  each  church.  Later,  when  markers  were  put  up,  wood 
was  the  preferred  material,  and  is  still  dominant  today. 
The  author  found  no  Hispanic  marker  in  Texas  over  a 
century  old.  Special  pictures  of  the  "nicos"  (a  small  pic- 
ture of  the  deceased  or  saint's  image  in  a  small  hollow 
with  a  crucifix)  were  delightful,  and  certainly  added  to 
this  chapter,  so  carefully  researched  by  the  author. 

The  Texas  German  graveyard  was  like  stepping  into 
a  completely  different  world.  In  the  "old  country"  the 
churchyard  cemetery  was  used  for  generations  of  families. 
However,  like  many  cultures,  the  German  had  to  adapt 
to  our  harsher  reality.  The  difficulty  of  transporting  bodies 
to  town  explains  the  German  adoption  of  rural  burials. 
Instead  of  family  plots,  the  Texas  Germans  usually  bury 
only  the  man  and  wife  side  by  side.  Plots  are  not  privately 
owned,  and  the  precise  place  of  burial  is  determined  by 
sequence  of  death.  One  row  might  contain  deaths  in  1917, 
and  the  next,  1918.  Separate  sections  for  children  were 
also  used. 

As  a  person  who  deals  with  searching  lives  of  our 
ancestors,  I  have  always  held  the  belief  that  to  understand 
the  history  of  a  community,  culture  or  just  a  family,  study 
the  nearby  cemetery!  Mr.  Jordan  feels  the  same  way,  and 
has  gone  even  further  to  record  how  this  culture  affected 
the  way  of  life  then  and  now.  The  author  also  feels  strongly 
about  climate  and  mindless  vandals  who  bring  steady 
destruction  to  our  graveyards ,  but  concedes  we  cannot 
rescue  folk  culture  intact.  Much  can  be  done,  however, 
to  record,  as  Mr.  Jordan  has,  the  diverse  cultures 
throughout  the  United  States.  He  concludes  with  some 
thoughts  to  guide  us:  "We  should  undertake  this  preser- 
vation effort  not  just  because  a  priceless  legacy  of  beautiful 
traditional  art  and  craftsmanship  is  endangered,  but  also 
because  folk  graveyards  are  such  revealing  and  remarkable 
records  of  our  several  cultural  heritages.  These  special 
places  are  not  just  repositories  for  our  dead,  but  actually 
museums  full  of  obvious  and  subtle  reminders  from  our 
ancient  past  and  distant,  diverse  ancestral  homelands." 

Final  pages  of  notes  on  each  chapter  and  a  large 
bibliography  and  index  will  act  as  an  invaluable  guide 
for  anyone  undertaking  this  type  of  research  in  other  areas 
of  our  country.  An  unusual  and  most  satisfying  occupa- 
tion awaits  someone  interested  in  art,  culture  and  our 
special  heritages  —  after  all,  that  is  history  in  a  very  fine 
sense  of  the  word. 

Sharon  Lass  Field 

The  reviewer  is  a  freelance  researcher  and  genealogist  who  directs  the 
WSHS  Graves  and  Cemeteries  Project. 


59 


Identifying  American  Furniture,  Colonial  to  Con- 
temporary. By  Milo  Naeve.  (Nashville:  American 
Association  for  State  and  Local  History,  1981) 
Index.  IIIus.  Reading  List.  87  pp.  Cloth,  $14;  The 
Tasteful  Interlude,  American  Interiors  Through 
the  Camera's  Eye,  1860-1917.  By  William  Seale. 
(Nashville:  American  Association  for  State  and 
Local  History,  1975)  (rev.  ed.,  1981)  Index.  Illus. 
284  pp.  Paper  $14. 

The  American  Association  for  State  and  Local  History 
has  a  reputation  for  publishing  useful  books  regarding 
the  study  of  history.  These  fine  volumes  treat  with  all 
aspects  of  that  humanist  discipline,  including  artifacts, 
architecture,  oral  history,  documents,  archaeology  and 
even  the  law  in  relation  to  history.  There  are  nearly  50 
works  in  all,  and  one  finds  them  read  by  amateur  and 
professional  alike. 

Two  recent  releases  are  Identifying  American  Fur- 
niture by  Milo  M.  Naeve  and  a  second  edition,  revised 
and  enlarged,  of  William  Seale's  The  Tasteful  Interlude. 
Because  they  both  deal  with  American  furniture  and  inte- 
riors, they  will  probably  be  enormously  popular  and  very 
well  may  be  cited  again  and  again  in  the  coming  years 
as  sources  on  the  subjects.  Both  provide  useful  data  and, 
if  appraised  and  relied  upon  in  the  proper  context,  they 
should  be  counted  as  solid  research  tools. 

The  first  publication  mentioned,  Identifying 
American  Furniture,  deals  with  the  styles  and  kinds  of 
furniture  produced  in  the  U.S.  from  the  early  17th  cen- 
tury to  the  present.  It  is  filled  with  photographic  illustra- 
tions and  is  replete  with  list  after  list  of  furniture  ter- 
minology. The  anatomical  terms  associated  with  furniture 
construction  are  included,  and  this  is  certainly  helpful 
to  those  wishing  to  familiarize  themselves  with  the  various 
parts  of  any  chair,  table  or  chest.  One  learns,  for  exam- 
ple, that  a  table  sometimes  has  an  apron,  a  chair  has  a 
splat,  and  cabinets  may  feature  balusters. 

Each  particular  style  is  allocated  two  pages,  with 
photographs  on  the  reader's  left,  and  the  text  informa- 
tion on  the  right.  For  the  most  part,  the  information  pro- 
vided is  concise  and  to  the  point.  While  there  is  nothing 
in  the  preface  or  in  the  promotional  material  to  indicate 
such,  one  perceives  that  the  book  was  designed  as  a 
museum  guide  or  a  shopping  guide.  It  is  approximately 
six  inches  by  nine  inches,  and  a  scant  half  an  inch  thick, 
making  it  easy  to  tuck  into  purse  or  pocket.  Because  of 
its  small  size,  layout  style  and  absence  of  weight,  it  can 
be  carried  about  to  museums,  historic  houses  and  antique 
shops.  Readers  can  quickly  flip  from  one  section  to 
another,  examining  various  styles  of  period  furnishings. 
It  should  be  noted  that  this  shoppers/museum  format 
closely  follows  that  used  in  the  excellent  Identifying 
American  Architecture  by  John  J.  G.  Blumenson. 

While  the  book  is  certainly  useful  in  some  instances, 
there  are  certain  shortcomings  that  this  reviewer  feels 
should  be  examined.  To  be  specific,  the  section  devoted 


to  Victorian  era  furnishings  seems  to  be  wanting  in  some 
areas  and  confusing  in  others.  Some  styles  are  not  precisely 
defined  or  are  given  definitions  that  contradict  ones 
previously  established  by  authorities  other  than  the  authoi 
of  this  volume. 

Granted,  there  are  built  in  difficulties  in  identifying 
Victorian  pieces.  Many  items  are  eclectic  blends  of  twc 
or  more  styles.  As  well,  some  Victorian  styles  were  known 
by  more  than  one  name.  This  information  should  have 
been  clearly  established  in  the  preface  to  prepare  the 
reader  for  inconsistencies  and  to  thwart  confusion. 

For  example,  the  "Naturalistic  Style"  discussed  or 
page  37  is  also  commonly  known  as  "Belter  Style."  Johr 
H.  Belter  is  credited  with  creating  two  pieces  illustrated, 
but  his  influence  on  the  period  is  ignored.  Duncan  Phyfe 
was  certainly  an  important  furniture  maker  and  a  style 
still  popular  today  bears  his  name.  He,  too,  is  given  sparse 
attention.  One  of  his  settees  is  used  as  an  illustration  and 
is  called  "Classical."  A  simple  a.k.a.  in  each  case  would 
have  been  fine. 

A  Leon  Marcotte  table  in  the  holdings  of  the  Metro 
politan  Museum  of  Art  has  used  an  example  of  "Loui; 
XVI"  on  page  39.  Katherine  Morrison  McClinton,  authoi 
of  seven  books  on  antiques  and  decorative  arts,  states  thai 
the  same  table  is  "Renaissance  Revival"  in  her  work,  Col 
lecting  American  Victorian  Antiques.  A  bed  Mrs.  McClin 
ton  and  the  editors  of  The  American  Heritage  History 
of  Antiques  would  categorize  as  "Renaissance  Revival' 
is  considered  "Neo-Greek"  in  Identifying  Americar 
Furniture . 

As  stated  previously,  this  all  leads  to  confusion.  A  brie 
group  of  statements  indicating  that  styles  were  combinec 
by  creative  and  enthusiastic  Victorian  furniture  maker: 
would  have  eliminated  this  problem.  Again,  a.k.a.'s  wouk 
have  been  sufficient. 

Wicker  porch  furniture  is  completely  ignored  anc 
lovers  of  that  species  will  be  disappointed.  It  is  rather  lik< 
a  book  on  Victorian  architecture  that  ignores  porche: 
altogether. 

A  rationale  for  the  omissions  and  confusion  must  exist 
While  the  book  can  and  should  be  used,  exercise  a  littli 
caution  if  you  use  the  section  devoted  to  mid-1 9th  cen 
tury  furnishings. 

The  second  book  under  consideration,  The  Tastefu 
Interlude  is  certainly  one  of  the  most  enchanting  and  mos 
enduring  books  in  some  time.  It  is  a  collection  of  ove: 
250  photographs  of  rooms  designed  and  decorated  by  ou 
Victorian  and  Edwardian  ancestors.  Each  photograph  i 
accompanied  by  a  most  informative  text  explaining  tht 
room  —  who  owned  it,  what  kind  of  furniture  is  in  it 
the  styles  used  and  the  approximate  date  of  the  photo 
graph.  Included  in  the  book  are  rooms  from  a  mininj 
shanty  in  Colorado,  the  mansion  of  Leland  Stanford,  th( 
parlor  of  a  Honolulu  home  owned  by  a  Chinese  emigrant 
the  bedroom  of  a  1900  Helena,  Montana,  girl  and  man; 
other  such  living  spaces. 

The  book  is  enchanting  because  it  transports  tht 


60 


eader  to  an  altogether  different  era  and  shows  honestly 
ow  people  put  their  environments  together.  It  is  endur- 
lg  because  the  reader  can  spend  hours  with  it.  Subse- 
uent  perusals  reveal  new  and  more  details  in  nearly  every 
hotograph.  It  never  gets  old.  It  is  always  fresh. 

The  information  in  the  17-page  introduction  is  exceed- 
lgly  helpful  in  that  it  provides  the  reader  with  a  good 
verview  of  all  Victorian  furniture.  It  explains  the  pro- 
enance  of  each  style,  the  rationale  for  the  creation  of 
le  style  and  fine  facts  about  innovators.  Seale  points  out 
rat  many  Victorian  styles  were  "revivals"  both  creative 
nd  historical.  It  goes  without  saying  that  the  Victorian 
nagination  soared  when  it  produced  furniture  considered 
Icreative  revival."  A  glance  through  the  book  certainly 
^11  indicate  to  the  reader  just  how  creative  the  furniture 
jesigners  were. 

Seale's  discussion  of  the  difference  between  style  and 
iste  is  particularly  perceptive.  He  points  out  that  style 
ertained  to  design  themes  and  that  taste  was  construed 
mean  judgment.  He  says,  "a  house  was  expected  to  be 
lot  only  an  essay  on  the  intellectual  judgment  of  its  prin- 
pal  inhabitants  but  a  lesson  in  judgment  for  the  young." 
I"hat  knowledge  helps  the  reader  better  understand  the 
oms  he  enters  through  the  book. 

There  are  remarks  on  trends,  not  only  in  furniture, 
'ut  in  the  manner  in  which  furniture  was  arranged  in 
he  rooms.  When  homes  were  lit  by  gaslight,  lamp,  or 
■andle,  items  were  arranged  in  clusters  around  the  illum- 
liation.  Later,  it  was  thought  finer  to  incorporate  the  fur- 
ishings  into  the  architecture  of  the  room  and  structure. 

The  Tasteful  Interlude  is  a  wonderful  adventure.  It 
I  recommended  for  both  serious  study  of  furniture  and 
elated  artifacts  and  for  pure  pleasure.  Among  the  many 
Hdividuals  who  can  find  a  good  use  for  it  are  those  inter  - 
5ted  in  living  history,  theatre  groups,  antique  hunters, 
imiture  restorers,  writers,  painters  and  anybody  else  with 
espect  and  affection  for  a  fascinating  era.  Consider  this 
<ook  an  investment,  not  an  expenditure. 

William  H.  Barton 

the  reviewer  is  Chief  of  the  Historical  Research  and  Publications  Dwt- 
on,  Wyoming  State  Archives.  Museums  and  Historical  Department, 
le  also  semes  as  co-editor  of  Annals  of  Wyoming. 

Montana's  Righteous  Hangmen:  The  Vigilantes 
in  Action  Edited  by  Lew  L.  Callaway,  Jr.  (Nor- 
man: University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1982,), 
including  contents,  list  of  Illus.  Foreword, 
Preface,  Notes,  Appendices,  Index.  233  pp.  Cloth 
$12.95 

Throughout  his  life  (1868-1951),  Lew  L.  Callaway, 
luccessful  Montana  lawyer  and  prominent  Chief  Justice 
if  the  Montana  Supreme  Court,  was  fascinated  by  the 
iieriod  from  1863-1864  in  Montana  history,  a  time  marked 
iy  the  emergence  of  the  extra-legal  organization  known 


as  the  vigilantes.  Callaway  finds  an  outlet  for  this  fascina- 
tion in  Montana  !$  Righteous  Hangmen,  an  account  of  the 
vigilante  movement  which  gains  importance  due  to  its 
novel  treatment  of  the  role  of  Capt.  James  Williams. 

Callaway  asserts  that  James  Williams,  an  individual 
whom  other  authors  (Thomas  Dimsdale,  The  Vigilantes 
of  Montana,  and  Nathaniel  P.  Langford,  Vigilante  Days 
and  Ways)  relegate  to  an  insignificant  role  in  the  vigilante 
organization,  was  actually  a  key  figure  in  this  operation. 
While  others  indicate  that  Williams  was  present  at  several 
meetings  and  was  involved  in  some  of  the  group's  "sanc- 
tions", Callaway  contends  that  Williams  played  a  pro- 
minent role  both  as  a  leader  and  as  an  enforcer  but 
attempted  to  maintain  anonymity  because  of  his  self- 
effacing  nature.  His  sources  for  this  novel  interpretation 
included  Williams  and  other  former  vigilantes  with  whom 
he  talked  as  a  young  man  while  working  on  a  ranch  owned 
by  his  father  and  Williams  in  Montana's  Ruby  Valley  in 
1881. 

In  addition  to  Callaway's  unique  portrayal  of  Williams' 
role,  he  argues  that  Dimsdale  and  Langford  greatly 
underestimated  the  size  of  the  vigilante  organization.  In 
contrast  to  these  earlier  accounts,  Callaway  indicates  that 
the  vigilante  movement  included  as  many  as  2,500  men. 
Again,  this  interpretation  is  based  on  information  he 
gathered  from  acquaintances  as  a  young  man. 

Callaway's  detailed  account  of  the  events  culminating 
in  the  hanging  of  Joseph  Slade  is  another  interesting  aspect 
of  Montana 's  Righteous  Hangmen.  Contrary  to  other  ac- 
counts that  examine  Slade's  part  in  the  vigilante  move- 
ment in  a  cursory  manner,  Callaway  provides  a  more  com- 
prehensive picture  of  Joseph  Slade's  character  and  the 
events  leading  to  his  execution  by  the  vigilantes. 

Callaway's  book  offers  several  unusual  interpretations 
of  the  vigilante  era.  However,  his  assertions  regarding 
Williams'  leadership  role  in  the  movement  and  the  total 
number  of  men  involved  in  the  organization  differ  drama- 
tically from  previously  published  works.  Thus  those 
readers  familiar  with  the  writings  of  Dimsdale  and 
Langford  will  undoubtedly  question  the  veracity  of 
Callaway's  statements.  In  addition,  although  Callaway 
differs  with  the  above  authors  on  several  points,  he  relies 
heavily  on  their  work  when  recounting  the  major  incidents 
of  the  vigilante  period. 

Montana's  Righteous  Hangmen  was  previously 
serialized  in  the  Virginia  City,  Montana,  Weekly  Madiso- 
nian  and  published  in  a  limited  edition  paperback  enti- 
tled Two  True  Tales  of  the  Wild  West  (1973).  This  latest 
edition  contains  numerous  photographs  and  illustrations 
and  a  detailed  map.  Although  Callaway's  book  does  not 
provide  answers  to  critical  questions  about  Montana's 
vigilantes,  it  will  be  welcomed  by  those  readers  interested 
in  that  turbulent  era. 

Dan  Gallacher 

Gallacher  is  with  Historical  Research  Associates  of  Missoula.  Montana. 


61 


INDEX 


Algier,  Keith,  "The  Wind-Big  Horn  River  and  the  Rocky  Mountain  Fur  Trade," 

51-55;  biog.,  64 
American  Fur  Company,  35 
Anderson,  Sen.  Clinton  P..   13 
Architects,  Fisher  and  Fisher,  4-6 
Architect's  Small  House  Service  Bureau.  4 
Arrak.  Thomas.  6 
Ashley.  William,  53 
Atlantic  Richfield  Company,  8 

B 

Baldwin,  Jim.  28 

Baldwin.  Sen.  Raymond,   11 

Barrett,  Sen.  Frank,   13;  photo,   15 

Barton.  William  H.,  review  of  Identifying  American  Furniture,  Colonial  to 

Contemporary,  60-61 
Bash.  Maj.  Daniel  N..  45 
Benton,  Virginia.  46 
Benton.  Sen.  William.   13 
Bernadi's  Exposition  Show.  3 
Big  Horn  River,  51  55 
Bingham,  Lt.  H.  S..  40 
Blick.  Roy.   15.   17 
Bourke.  Capt.  John,  43 
Bowers.  Sgt.  Gideon,  40 
Bozeman,  John.  32,  36;  photo.  36 
Bozeman  Trail.  32-50 

"The  Bozeman  — Trail  to  Death  and  Glory,"  by  Sherry  L.  Smith.  32  50 
Braeuninger,  Moritz,  35 
Bridget.   Jim     35 

Bridges.  Sen.  Styles.   14.  17;  photo.   15 
Brock,  J.  Elmer,  25 
Brown.  Capt.  A.  E.,  39 
Brown.  A.  H..  44 
Brown,  Horace,  46 
Brvans,  Bill,  review  of  Deep  Enough:  A   Working  Stiff  m  the  Western  Mine 

Camps,  57-58 
Burlington  Railroad,  48 
Burroughs,  Capt.  George.  40 
Butler    Sen.  John  M..  12 


Callawav,  Lew  L..Jr.,  editor,  Montana's  Righteous  Hangmen    The  Vigilantes 

m  Action,  review,  61 
Carlinville,  Illinois.  4 
Carrington,  Col.  H.  B  .  39-41 
Cassidy.  Butch,  23.  26.  30 
Childs,  Marquis,   17 
Chisum,  Emmett  D..  "The  Wilcox  Train  Robbery  —  Newspapers  and  Instant 

Mythmaking."  22-31;  biog..  64 
Clark.  William.  51-52 
Cochrane,  Timothy  S  ,  review  of  Land  Use,  Environment  and  Social  Change 

The  Shaping  of  Island  County,   Washington,  58 
Coffinbury,  Maj.  Cyrus  C  37 
Cole.  Col.  Nelson.  37-38 
Cole.  Capt.  O.  F. .  39 
Colter,  John.  52 
Connor,  Gen.  Patrick  E  .  37-38 
Conroy,  John  C,  45 
Consolidated  Oil  Company.  8 
Cook.  Will.  25 

Cooke,  Gen.  Phillip  St.  George.  41 
Crampton,  Frank  A.,  Deep  Enough:  A   Working  Stiff  m  the  Western  Mine 

Camps,  review,  57-58 
Creglown.  Fred  D.,  6 
Cunningham,  Dr    P.   M.,   15.   17 
Custer.  Col.  George  A..  42 

D 

Daniels.  Lt.  Napoleon  H  ,  40 

Deep  Enough:  A   Working  Stiff  m  the   Western  Mine  Camps,  by  Frank  A. 

Crampton.  review,  57-58 
Denig,  Edwin  T.,  32 
Denton,  Rep.  Winfield  K,  13 
DeSmet.  Pierre,  35 
Dodge.  Gen.  Grenville  M.,  37 
Douglas,  Sen.  Paul.   13.  18 
Dixon.  Daniel.  41 
Drouillard.  George,  52 


Edmunds,  Gov.  Newton,  39 
Eisenhower,  Pres.  Dwight  D.,   14 
EK  Mountain.  25 

Ewig,  Rick.  "McCarthy  Era  Politics:  The  Ordeal  of  Senator 
9-21;  biog..  64 


Ferguson.  Charles,  44 

Ferris  oil  field,  3 

Fetterman,  Capt.  William  J.,  40-42 

Field,  Sharon  Lass,  review  of  Texas  Graveyards,  A  Cultural 

Fish.  Sam,  24 

Fisher,  Arthur,  4 

Fisher.  William  E..  4 

Fitzpatrick.  Thomas.  39 

Foote,  Robert,  46 

Ford,  Gen.  James,  37 

FORTS 

C.  F.  Smith  (Mont).  41 

Connor,  38-39 

Fetterman,  42 

Laramie,  37.  39-44 

McKinney,  44;  photo.  48 

Phil  Kearny,  40-41;  photo.  40 

Raymond,  52 

Reno,  40-41,  43-44 
Frewen,  Moreton,  47 
Fur  Trade.  51-55 


Gallacher,  Dan,  review  of  Montana's  Righteous  Hangmen 

in  Action,  61 
Gallegos.  Rafael.  36 
Gamier.  Baptiste.  45 
Garrison.  Robert.  5 
Gibbon.  Col.  John.  42 
Gleason.  William  H.,  44 
Goodhue,  Bertram,  5 
Gore,  Sir  St.  George.  35 
Grouard,  Frank,  45 

H 

Hackney.  Hold  and  Williams  Livestock  Company.  47 
Hadsell,  Marshal  Frank,  26 
Hall,  Leonard  W.   16 
Hall,  J.  Tom.  46 

47 

.  47 


Hanna.  O.  P.,  44-45, 
Hart,  Col.  Verling  K 
Hayfield  Fight.  41 
Hazen.  Sheriff  Joe.  24-26 
Hazen,  Gen.  W.  B  .  41 
Hennings,  Sen.  Thomas.   13 
Henry.  Andrew.  52-53 
Henry.  Mike,  46 
Holding,  R.  E.  8 
Horn,  Tom.  29 
Hudspeth.  Al,  24 
Hunt,  Clyde,   14 
Hunt.  Lester  C,  Jr..  14-18 
Hunt.  Sen    Lester  C,  9-21; 
Hunt,  Wilson  Price,  34-35 


photos,  9.   17-18 


I 
Identifying  American  Furniture,  Colonial  to  Contemporary, 

review,  60-61 
Immel,  Michael.  53 
INDIANS -Chiefs  and  Individuals 

Arapooish,  34 

Black  Leg.  41 

Black  Shield,  41 

Bull  Bear.  34 

Crazy  Horse.  41-42 

Dull  Knife.  38.  41 

High  Back  Bone.  41 

Red  Cloud,  34,  38,  40,  42 

Sitting  Bull,  42  43 

Walking  Rabbit,  41 


62 


MDIANS-  Tribes 

Arapahoe,  39 
Blackfeet,  32,  35,  52 
Cheyenne.  34.  37,  42 
Crow,  32,  34,  52 
Hidatsa.  32 
Kiowa.  34 
Sioux.  34,  37-42 


acobs.  John,  36 

Dnes,  Robert.  53 

Dnes.  W.  R  .  23 

Drdan,  Terry  C,   Texas  Graveyards,  A  Cultural  Legacy,  review.  58-59 

K 

Lefauver  Crime  Investigation  Committee,  11 

Lefauver.  Sen.  Estes,   13 

.endrick,  Gregory  D.  "Parco,  Wyoming:  A  Model  Company  Town,"  2 

biog.,  64 
.idd,  Capt.  James  H.,  38 
.irk,  George  E. .  44 
arkpatrick.  James,  36 
Jstier.  Frank,  3-8 


.ambie,  C.  S..  6 

.and  Use,  Eniironment  and  Social  Change    The  Shaping  of  Island  County, 

Washington,  by  Richard  White,  review.  58 
gRaye,  Charles.  34 
.arocque.  Francois  Antoine.  34,  51 

,eeper.  Dr. 24 

,eFors,  Joe,  25 

,ewis,  Reuben.  52 

incoln  Highway,  3 

isa,  Manuel,  52 

,ost  Soldier  Oil  Field,  3 

owe,  Robert  S.,   16 

M 

McCarthy  Era  Politics:  The  Ordeal  of  Senator  Lester  Hunt."  by  Rick  Ewig. 

9-21 
IcCanhy,  Sen.  Joseph  R..  9-21;  photos,   10,   14 
IcCormick,  Robert  R  ,   12 
IcDonough.  George  L.,  44 
lackenzie.  Col.  Ranald,  43 
lalloy.  Judge  John  J.,   15 
lalmedv  hearings,   11 
lather.  Eugene.  46 
laynadier.  Col.  Henry  E.,  39 
leek.  Joe,  34.  35 
lenard,   Pierre.  52 
lissouri  Fur  Company,  53 
lonkers,  George  A.,  46 
lontanas  Righteous  Hangmen:  The  Vigilantes  in  Action,  edited  by  Lew  L. 

Callaway.  Jr.,  review.  61 
lontero,  Antonio.  35 

N 
faeve,   Milo,  Identifying  American  Furniture,   Colonial  to  Contemporary, 

review.  60-61 
lewspapers,  22-31 
lolan.  Jack.  23 
lover.  Barnet,   16 

O 

til  refineries,  3-8 

I'Mahoney,  Sen.  Joseph  C.,   13,   16;  photo,   17 


aimer,  Col.  I.  N..  41 

arco  Inn  (Hotel),  6;  photos.  2.  7 

Parco.  Wyoming:  A  Model  Company  Town,"  by  Gregory  D.  Kendrick.  2- 

arker.  Charles,  45 

armalee.  Maj.  C.  H.,  26 

atrick,  Algernon  S.,  44-45 

'atrick,  M.  T.,  44 

'atrick.  Col.  Mathewson.  44 

'ayton.  E.  T.,  24 

'earson.  Drew.  15,   17 

'hillips.  John  "Portugee."  41 

'ilcher.  Joshua.  53 

'ollock,  Capt.  Edwin.  43 

Portugese  Houses,"  35 

'ope,  Gen.  John,  37 


Powder  River  Cattle  Company.  47 

Powder  River  Crossing.  46 

Powell.  Capt.  James,  41 

Pratt  and  Ferris  Cattle  Company,  47 

Producers  and  Refiners  Corporation  (Parco),  3 


RANCHES 

Antelope,  46 

Cross  H,  47 

Double  Box,  46 
Ranchester,  Wyoming,  38-39 
Raynolds.  Capt.  William  F..  35 
Reynolds,  Col.  Joseph  J.,  42 
Richards.  Gov.  DeForest,  26 
Rock  Creek  Stage  Line,  48 
Rogers,  C.  J. ,   16 

Rosa,  Joseph  G..   The  West  of  Wild  Bill  Hickok,  review.  56-57 
Rose,  Edward,  52 
Ross.  Gov.  Nellie  Tayloe.  3 


Sawyer.  Col.  James  A.,  38 

Schulke,  Dr.  Julius  A.,  30 

Sculpture,  5 

Sinclair  (Parco),  Wyoming, 

Sinclair  Refining  Company,  8 

Smith,  Maj.  Benjamin,  41 

Smith,  Jedediah,  53 

Smith.  Sen.  Margaret  Chase,   12 

Smith,  Sherry  L.,  "The  Bozeman  -Trail  to  Death  and  Glory,"  32-50;  biog.,  64 

Spencer.  Percy.   17 

Spencer,  William  M.,   17 

Standard  Oil  Company.  4 

Story,  Nelson,  42 

Superior.  Wyoming,  3 


3-8;  photos:  2.  5,  6-7;  map,  4 


The  Tasteful  Interlude,  American  Interiors  Through  the  Camera's  Eye,  by 

William  Seale,  review,  60-6 1 
Taylor,  E.  B..  39 
Taylor,  Sen.  Glen  H  ,   12 
Templeton,  Lt.  George  H.,  40 
Terry.  Gen.  Alfred.  43 
Texas  Company  (Texaco),  3 

Texas  Graveyards.  A  Cultural  Legacy,  by  Terry  G.  Jordan,  review,  58-59 
Theaters  (Sinclair);  photo.  7 
Thorn,  J.  M.,  44 
Tongue  River,  38-39 

Tubbs,  Scott  T.,  review  of  The   West  of  Wild  Bill  Hickok,  56-57 
Trabing.  August.  46 
Truman.  Pres.,  Harry  S.,  9,   11 
Tydings.  Sen.  Millard,   12.   18 
Tyrone,  New  Mexico,  5 


L'nion  Pacific  Coal  Company,  3 


Vasquez,   Benito,  52 


U 


w 


Wagon  Box  Fight.  41 

Walker,  Lt.  Col.  Samuel,  37 

Wallace,  Henry,  9 

Wands,  Lt.  A.  H..  40 

Watenpaugh.  Henry,   15 

Welker,  Sen.  Herman,   12.   14,   17-18;  photo  12 

Wessels,  Lt.  Col.  Henry  W..  41 

The  West  of  Wild  Bill  Hickok,  by  Joseph  G.  Rosa,  review.  56-57 

White,  Richard,  Land  Use,  Environment  and  Social  Change:  The  Shaping 

of  Island  County,    Washington,  review,  58 
"The  Wilcox  Train  Robbery  —  Newspapers  and  Instant  Mythmaking,"  by 

Emmett  D.  Chisum.  22-31 
Wilcox,  Wyoming.  22-31 
Williford,  Capt.  George  W.,  38 
"The  Wind  Big  Horn  River  and  the  Rocky  Mountain  Fur  Trade."  by  Keith 

Algier,  51-55 
Wind  River,  51-55 
Wishart,  Capt.  Alexander,  41 
Wolton,  Wyoming,  28 
Wood,  Kenneth  Darnall.  17 
Woodcock,  E.  C,  23 


Yund,  Sheriff  Charles,  23,  26.  28 


63 


CONTRIBUTORS 


EMMETT  D.  CHISUM  is  research  historian  at  the 
American  Heritage  Center,  University  of  Wyoming.  He 
authored  three  articles  in  previous  issues  of  Annals.  Prior 
to  his  position,  Chisum  was  social  sciences  librarian  at 
the  University  of  Wyoming. 


RICK  EWIG  is  research  and  oral  history  supervisor  in  the 
Historical  Research  and  Publications  Division  of  the 
Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and  Historical 
Department.  He  attended  the  University  of  Wyoming 
where  he  received  B.A.  and  M.A.  degrees  in  history. 


KEITH  ALGIER  is  a  native  of  Worland,  but  now  resides 
in  Richmond,  Kentucky,  where  he  has  taught  history  at 
Eastern  Kentucky  University  since  1965.  In  addition  to 
his  teaching  duties,  Dr.  Algier  also  serves  as  the  faculty 
representative  on  the  institution's  Board  of  Regents  and 
on  the  Faculty  Advisory  Committee  to  the  Kentucky 
Council  on  Higher  Education.  He  was  recently  named 
to  the  Paper  Prize  Awards  Committee  for  Phi  Alpha 
Theta,  International  History  Honorary.  Previous  publica- 
tions include  articles  on  New  Spain's  northern  frontier 
and  co-editorship  of  a  source  book  on  college  teaching. 
He  holds  the  Ph.D  degree  in  history  from  the  University 
of  New  Mexico. 


SHERRY  LYNN  SMITH  is  presently  a  visiting  instruc- 
tor. Department  of  History,  University  of  Wyoming.  Pre- 
viously, she  taught  history  at  the  University  of  Colorado, 
and,  for  a  time,  was  Field  Historian  for  the  Wyoming 
Recreation  Commission.  Smith  received  a  B.A.  at  Pur- 
due and  an  M.A.  at  the  University  of  Washington,  and 
presently  is  a  Ph.D  candidate  at  that  institution.  She 
belongs  to  the  Western  History  Association,  American 
Historical  Association,  and  the  Organization  of  American 
Historians.  She  published  an  article,  "Army  Wives, 
Indians  and  the  Indian  War,"  in  the  Order  of  the  Indian 
Wars  Journal,  Winter,   1980. 


GREGORY  D.  KENDRICK,  a  historian  for  the  Rocky 
Mountain  Regional  office  of  the  National  Park  Service 
was  awarded  the  B.A.  from  the  University  of  California, 
Santa  Barbara,  and  the  M.A.  from  the  University  of  Wyo- 
ming. His  article,  "An  Environmental  Spokesman:  Olaus 
J.  Murie  and  a  Democratic  Defense  of  Wilderness"  was 
published  in  the  Fall,  1978,  issue  of  Annals.  Recently, 
he  edited.  The  River  of  Sorrows:  History  of  the  Lower 
Dolores  River  Valley.  He  lives  in  Denver. 


64 


0W*- 


WYOMING 


*.. 


■ 


is 


Volume  55,  Number  2 
Fall,  1983 


"'  ""Wp^JW"^'  •'>-"aJ*^**«»wr,>v--«'  " 


THE   WYOMING   STATE   ARCHIVES,    MUSEUMS    AND   HISTORICAL    DEPARTMENT 

The  function  of  the  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and  Historical  Department  is 
to  collect  and  preserve  materials  which  tell  the  story  of  Wyoming.  It  maintains  the  state's 
historical  library  and  research  center,  the  Wyoming  State  Museum  and  branch  museums, 
the  State  Art  Gallery  and  the  State  Archives.  The  Department  solicits  original  records  such 
as  diaries,  letters,  books,  early  newspapers,  maps,  photographs  and  art  and  records  of  early 
businesses  and  organizations  as  well  as  artifacts  for  museum  display.  The  Department  asks 
for  the  assistance  of  all  Wyoming  citizens  to  secure  these  documents  and  artifacts.  Depart- 
ment facilities  are  designed  to  preserve  these  materials  from  loss  and  deterioration. 


WYOMING  STATE  LIBRARY,  ARCHIVES,  MUSEUMS  AND  HISTORICAL  BOARD 

Ken  Richardson,  Lander,  Chairman 

Frank  Bowron,  Casper 

Dave  Paulley,  Cheyenne 

Eugene  Martin,  Evanston 

Jerry  Rillahan,  Worland 

Mrs.  Lucille  Dumbrill,  Newcastle 

Thomas  J.  Mangan,  Laramie 

A.  G.  McClintock,  Attorney  General  (ex-officio) 


ABOUT  THE  COVER — The  cover  painting,  "November  Came"  is  by  Wyoming  artist  Mike 
Kopriva.  Kopriva,  a  native  of  Powell,  studied  at  the  University  of  Wyoming  where  he  earned 
a  B.F.A,  and  an  M.F.A.  He  specializes  in  rural  still  life,  landscapes  and  has  executed  several 
character  portraits.  He  won  the  Wyoming  Arts  Council  Competition  to  paint  a  mural  in  the 
Capitol  Building  in  Cheyenne.  His  work  entitled,  "Wyoming,  the  Land  and  the  People"  hangs 
in  Room  307  of  the  Capitol  and  is  enjoyed  by  thousands  of  visitors  and  residents  each  year. 
Kopriva  presently  has  a  studio  in  Casper.  "November  Came"  was  lent  by  William  H.  Barton, 
co-editor  of  Annals. 


NNALS  of  WYOMING 


Volume  55,  No.  2 
Fall,  1983 


GOVERNOR  OF  WYOMING 

Ed  Herschler 

DIRECTOR 

Dr.  Robert  D.  Bush 

CO-EDITORS 

William  H.  Barton 
Philip  J.  Roberts 

ASSISTANT  EDITORS 

Jean  Brainerd 
Rick  Ewig 
Thelma  Crown 

EDITORIAL  ASSISTANTS 

Kathy  Martinez 
Ann  Nelson 

PHOTOGRAPHIC 
ASSISTANTS 

Paula  West-Chavoya 
Carroll  Jones 


WYOMING  STATE  PRESS 
MANAGING  EDITOR 

William  H.  Barton 


TABLE  OF  CONTENTS 

PIETISM  AND  PROGRESS:  JAMES  H.  HAYFORD  AND 

THE  WYOMING  ANTI-GAMBLING  TRADITION,   1869  1893    2 

By  William  Howard  Moore 

ECHO  PARK  DAM:  AN  OLD  PROBLEM  OF  FEDERALISM 9 

By  Mark  W.  T.  Harvey 

THE  QUEST  FOR  SETTLEMENT  IN  EARLY  WYOMING   19 

By  Bruce  Noble 

A  GERMAN  LOOKS  AT  CHEYENNE  IN  1876: 

THE  TRAVELS  OF  ERNST  von  HESSE  WARTEGG   25 

Edited  and  translated  by  Frederic  Trautmann 

THE  COUNTESS  OF  FLAT  CREEK  28 

By  Lynne  Cheney 

JOHN  C.  DAVIS,  SR.:  PORTRAIT  OF  A 

ROCKY  MOUNTAIN  DRUG  WHOLESALING  PIONEER 33 

By  Anthony  Palmieri,  III 

A  FUNERAL  AT  FORT  LARAMIE   36 

By  Lewis  A.  Eaton 

BOOK    REVIEWS    37 

Milner,  With  Good  Intentions:  Quaker  Work  Among  the  Pawnees,  Otos  and  O  ma  has  in 

the  1870's,  reviewed  by  Robert  E.  Smith 

Thomas,  Alonso  de  Posada  Report,   1686,   reviewed  by  Kenneth  E.   Hendrickson,  Jr. 

Yost,  Buffalo  Bill   His  Family,  Friends,  Fame,  Failures  and  Fortunes,  reviewed  by  Sherry 

L.  Smith 

Gidley,  Kopet    A  Documentary  Narrative  of  Chief  Joseph's  Last  Years,  reviewed  by  Roger 

Dunsmore 

Otien,  Oil  Booms,  reviewed  by  J.  Herschel  Barnhill 

Sessions,  Mormon  Thunder  A  Documentary  History  ofjedediah  Grant,  and  Pusey,  Builders 

of  the  Kingdom,  reviewed  by  Kenneth  Winn 

Stedman,  Shadows  of  the  Indian;  Stereotypes  in  American  Culture,  and  Iverson,  Carlos 

Montezuma  and  the  Changing  World  of  American  Indians,  reviewed  by  John  C.  Paige 

Coker  and  Rea,  Anglo-Spanish  Confrontation  on  the  Gulf  Coast  During  the  American 

Revolution,  reviewed  by  Robert  D.  Bush 

Welsch,  Mister  You  Got   Yourself  a  Horse,  reviewed  by  Timothy  S.  Cochrane 

Dunley,   Wolves  for  the  Blue  Soldiers,  reviewed  by  David  L.  Ferch 

Stegner,  Buried  Unsung   Louis  Tikas  and  the  Ludlow  Massacre,  reviewed  by  Walter  R.  Jones 

INDEX   45 

CONTRIBUTORS    48 

ANNALS  OF  WYOMING  is  published  biannually  in  the  Spring  and  Fall  by  the  Wyoming  State  Press. 
It  is  received  by  all  members  of  the  Wyoming  State  Historical  Society  as  the  official  publication  of  that 
organization.  Copies  of  previous  and  current  issues  may  be  purchased  from  the  Co-Editors.  Correspondence 
should  be  addressed  to  the  Co-Editors.  Published  articles  represent  the  views  of  the  author  and  are  not 
necessarily  those  of  the  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and  Historical  Department  or  the  Wyoming 
State  Historical  Society.  ANNALS  OF  WYOMING  articles  are  abstracted  in  Historical  Abstracts.  America: 
History  and  Life. 

©Copyright  1983  by  the  Wyoming  State  Press. 


Pietism  and  Progress: 

James  H-  Hayford  and  the 
Wyoming  Anti-Gambling  Tradition,  1869-189 

By  William  Howard  Moore 


'The  author  wishes  to  acknowledge  research  funding  for  this  project  from  the  Wyoming  Council  for  the  Humanities. 


"No  institutions  .  .  .  reflected  more  clearly  America's 
rapid,  uncontrolled  growth  than  did  the  saloon,  the 
brothel  and  the  gambling  den." 


Because  so  much  of  late  19th  century  reform  agita- 
ion  in  the  United  States  was  tied  to  problems  of  indus- 
rialization  and  urbanization,  students  of  early  Wyoming 
aistory  have  largely  ignored  reform  issues.  While  other 
ueas  of  the  country  experienced  the  disruptions  of  big 
ousiness,  mushrooming  cities,  and  class  and  ethnic  con- 
flict, Wyoming  remained  a  pristine  backwater  — a  moun- 
ainous,  semi-arid  land  of  ranching,  mining,  and  small, 
f  frequently  boisterous  towns.  Even  the  western  radicalism 
inherent  in  the  Wobblie  and  Populist  agitation  seems  to 
iiave  passed  over  the  state  lightly.1 

A  closer  look  at  Wyoming's  experience,  however,  indi- 
:ates  that  some  reform  issues  may  not  be  as  irrelevant  as 
once  believed.  If  the  state  missed  the  fury  of  industrial- 
zation  with  its  fragmenting  impact  on  family,  church, 
ind  community,  it  had  been  part  of  the  rapid  opening 
of  the  West  —  a  process  in  some  respects  just  as  explosive, 
lust  as  disruptive,  as  industrialization.  In  western  fron- 
ier  communities,  isolation  and  primitive  living  conditions 
iometimes  spawned  a  lawlessness  and  depravity  compar- 
ible  to  that  of  eastern  cities.  Contemporaries  in  the  West 
ippear  to  have  grasped  those  similarities  better  than 
;cholars.  In  the  1880s,  the  Rev.  Josiah  Strong  of  the 
\merican  Home  Mission  Society,  a  veteran  of  a  two-year 
ninistry  in  Cheyenne,  warned  of  the  rampant  materialism, 
iocial  fragmentation,  and  dissipation  both  on  the  western 
rentier  and  in  the  eastern  city.2 

No  institutions  either  in  the  city  or  the  frontier 
eflected  more  clearly  America's  rapid,  uncontrolled 
rrowth  than  did  the  saloon,  the  brothel,  and  the  gam- 
bling den.  These  institutions  are  easily  romanticized.  Here, 
iefenders  argued,  isolated  males  could  find  a  measure 
of  human  or  ethnic  companionship  denied  them  elsewhere 
n  the  community.  Here  a  worker  could  find  diversion  from 
i  grinding,  dangerous  job,  an  outlet  for  his  pent-up 
energies,  an  escape  from  his  humdrum  existence.  Here, 
oarticularly  in  the  saloon,  might  be  organized  the  political 
or  social  power  to  fend  off  repressive  forces  in  the 
:ommunity-at-large. 

Reformers  across  the  country  saw  the  issue  from  a  dif- 
,  ferent  perspective.  To  them,  the  saloon,  the  brothel,  and 
,:he  gambling  parlor  symbolized  disorder,  a  barbaric  waste 
|of  personal  and  community  energies.  They  threatened 
'  what  Norman  Clark  calls  the  "bourgeois  interior"  of  the 
nuclear  family,  already  strained  by  the  forces  of  expan- 
sion, industrialization,  and  urbanization.  Their  continua- 
tion institutionalized  a  certain  looseness,  a  tolerance,  a 
pluralism  of  values  that  many  reformers  found  repugnant. 
The  weakening  —  if  not  elimination  —  of  these  vices  would 


strengthen  the  ties  of  home,  encourage  thrift,  promote 
efficiency,  and  disrupt  the  wellsprings  of  political  corrup- 
tion.3 

Wyoming  certainly  shared  these  problems  with  the 
West  and  the  nation.  Saloons,  prostitution,  and  gambling 
of  all  types  flourished  both  in  the  "hell-on-wheels"  camps 
that  accompanied  the  construction  of  the  Union  Pacific 
Railroad  in  the  1860s  and  in  the  more  permanent  com- 
munities left  in  its  wake.  A  preponderently  unattached 
male  population,  a  high  percentage  of  transients  criss- 
crossing the  territory  for  various  mining  bonanzas,  and 
the  weakness  of  any  real  social  infrastructure  contributed 
to  a  tradition  of  hard  drinking,  easy  women,  and  games 
of  chance.  Cheyenne  in  particular  attracted  a  national 
reputation  for  its  uncontrolled  vice.  So  wicked  was  the 
community  that  a  section  of  Chicago's  notorious  First  Ward 
took  the  name  Little  Cheyenne.  In  the  early  1870s,  Rev. 
Strong  of  the  First  Congregational  Church  wrote  that  the 
city  was  worse  than  anything  in  London,  Paris,  or  New 
York.  From  his  front  gate,  he  reported  that  he  could  throw 
a  stone  into  half  a  dozen  houses  of  prostitution.4 

Gambling  may  well  have  been  even  more  widespread. 
It  served  as  a  competitive  attraction  in  most  of  the  saloons, 
and  was  common  among  all  classes  of  the  population, 
from  large  cattlemen  and  businessmen  to  transient  miners 
and  cowboys.5  Given  the  painfully  slow  rate  of  economic 
growth  of  the  territory  once  the  railroads  were  built,  mer- 
chants in  isolated  towns  and  villages  hoped  that  a  measure 
of  vice  might  entice  customers  to  their  establishments  and 
promote  development.  Because  it  was  so  deeply  engrained, 
the  debate  over  gambling  suggests  how  closely  moral  and 
social  issues  in  early  Wyoming  followed  national  patterns. 

Despite  the  wide-open  conditions,  a  forceful  anti- 
gambling  tradition,  closely  tied  to  national  values,  began 
to  take  shape  by  the  time  Wyoming  was  organized.  When 
the  first  territorial  legislature,  controlled  by  Democrats, 
voted  for  a  licensed  gambling  system  in  1869,  Republican 
Governor  John  A.  Campbell  vetoed  the  measure.  Camp- 
bell feared  that  "brilliantly  lighted"  public  gambling  halls 
would  entice  the  young  to  moral  ruin  and  suggested  that 
even  if  prohibitory  laws  could  not  be  enforced,  the  ter- 
ritory should  "at  least  pay  the  compliment  to  virtue  of 
endeavoring  to  do  so."  In  a  letter  to  the  Wyoming  Tribune, 
one  writer  probably  Joseph  M.  Carey,  later  U.S.  senator 
and  governor  —  argued  that  legalized  gambling  would  not 
only  subvert  enterprising  merchants,  clerks,  and  family 
men,  but  that  it  would  also  retard  emigration  to  Wyo- 
ming. Although  it  overrode  Campbell's  veto  in  1869, 
the  legislature  clearly  remained  sensitive  to  organized 


anti-gambling  pressure.  In  1873,  in  response  to  a  com- 
mon complaint  by  the  Union  Pacific,  it  prohibited  gam- 
bling on  passenger  cars  moving  through  the  territory.6 

No  Wyomingite  battled  gambling  more  forcefully  or 
consistently  than  James  H.  Hayford,  from  1869  to  1895 
the  editor  of  the  Laramie  Sentinel.  Born  in  upstate  New 
York  in  1826,  Hayford  taught  school  in  Ohio  and  Illinois, 
took  a  medical  degree  from  the  University  of  Michigan, 
and  then  studied  and  practiced  law  in  Fond  du  Lac,  Wis- 
consin. Fond  du  Lac  and  nearby  Ripon  were  caught  up 
in  the  Republican  anti-slavery  agitation  of  the  late  1850s, 
and  Hayford  joined  the  crusade.  In  1860,  he  served  as  a 
delegate  to  the  Republican  National  Convention  and  cast 
his  vote  for  Abraham  Lincoln.  During  the  war  he  prac- 
ticed law  in  Colorado,  then  followed  the  Union  Pacific 
first  to  Cheyenne  and  then  to  Laramie.  In  1869  he 
launched  the  Sentinel  and  over  a  30-year  period  served 
from  time  to  time  as  territorial  auditor,  ex  officio  super- 
intendent of  public  instruction,  Laramie  postmaster,  and 
district  judge.7 

A  devout  family  man,  the  father  of  19  children,  a 
longtime  elder  of  the  Presbyterian  Church,  an  advocate 
of  temperance  and  purity,  Hayford  epitomized  the  kind 
of  pietist  that  battled  to  reassert  Yankee  Protestant  values 
in  late  19th  century  America.  With  Hayford  — as  with 
pietists  in  the  Midwest  —  the  bedrock  of  the  nation's 
strength  lay  in  the  common  behavioral  values  shared  by 
the  Methodist,  Baptist,  Presbyterian,  Congregational 
churches  and  sympathetic  immigrant  groups.  The  pietists 
sought  to  strengthen  the  public  school,  to  inculcate 
patriotism  and  the  English  language,  to  enforce  Sabba- 
tarian injunctions,  and  to  compel  a  conformity  of  behavior 
through  eradication  of  the  saloon,  brothel,  and  gambling 
den.  Those  opposed  tended  to  be  less  assimilated  immi- 
grants, Lutherans,  and  Roman  Catholics.  These  groups 
feared  the  elimination  of  their  ethnic  traditions,  religious 
rituals,  and  "personal  liberty"  through  a  government 
imposed,  Protestant  based  conformity.  In  general,  pietists 
held  their  strength  in  the  Republican  party  while  their 
opponents,  the  so-called  'liturgicals,"  supported  the  Demo- 
crats who  had  historically  stood  for  minimal  government 
involvement  in  social  issues.8 

Through  Hayford's  agitation,  the  questions  of  tem- 
perance, gambling,  and  prostitution  became  the  staples 
of  politics  in  Laramie  and  Albany  County  in  the  late  19th 
century.  Convinced  that  a  newspaperman  should  attempt 
to  "mold  public  values,"  Hayford  used  the  Sentinel  to  de- 
nounce public  and  official  tolerance  and  on  occasion  even 
hinted  at  vigilante  justice.  While  Hayford  reported  in  some 
detail  on  the  misfortune  of  prostitutes  in  the  city  and  sup- 
ported an  1886  petition  of  the  evangelical  churches  call- 
ing for  a  legal  ban  on  prostitution,  he  devoted  most  of 
his  energies  to  an  attack  on  the  saloon  and  gambling.9 

Hayford  was  convinced  that  a  combination  of  grog- 
sellers  and  gambling  entrepreneurs  endangered  the  social 
fabric  of  the  community.  After  some  success  in  the 
mid-1870s   in    restraining   gambling   and   the   saloon,10 


Hayford  saw  the  liquor  and  gambling  forces  stage  a  come 
back  under  the  leadership  of  Democratic  Mayor  P.  F.  Gun 
ster  in  the  early  1880s.  The  fiery  editor  exposed  the  men 
dacity  of  the  city  fathers  in  hiding  behind  the  municipal 
charter  and  he  denounced  the  "free  gambling  hells  and 
Sunday  whiskey"  springing  up  in  the  community.  Aftei 
several  restless  nights,  Hayford  finally  enlisted  the  newh, 
chartered  local  chapter  of  the  Women's  Christian  Tern 
perance  Union  in  an  attempt  to  mobilize  temperance,  high 
license,  and  prohibition  advocates  into  a  common  and 
vice  front.  Mayor  Gunster  and  local  Democrats  respondec 
with  a  mass  meeting  and  the  formation  of  a  Citizens  Part] 
which  defeated  Hayford's  Temperance  alliance  in  the  188-? 
municipal  elections.11 

After  the  reversals  of  the  early  1880s,  Hayford  soughi 
to  expand  his  pietist  constituency  through  an  educationa 
campaign  aimed  at  local  businessmen  and  civic  leaders 
Far  from  being  a  stimulus  to  local  business,  gambling  was 
Hayford  insisted,  an  economic  parasite.  Gambling  entre 
preneurs  produced  nothing,  but  simply  trafficked  ir 
money  that  would  otherwise  support  wholesome  economi* 
activities.  The  editor  argued  that  when  a  laboring  mar 
squandered  his  money  in  the  ubiquitous  "gambling  hells,' 
he  was  unable  to  pay  his  debts  to  local  merchants.  Th< 
grocer,  the  dry  goods  and  clothing  merchants  then  hac 
to  absorb  the  loss  or  pass  it  along  to  customers  in  the  forn 
of  higher  prices.  Moreover  taxpayers,  including  business 
men,  ultimately  had  to  contribute  to  the  upkeep  of  th( 
wives  and  children  neglected  when  workers  lost  their  earn 
ings  in  saloons  and  gambling  dens.  Hayford  contendec 
that  the  prevalence  of  gambling  tempted  otherwise  hones 
and  stable  clerks  and  employees  of  businessmen  to  stea 
company  funds  or  to  turn  to  other  forms  of  disruptivt 
crime  and  dissipations.12  Finally,  he  argued  that  parent: 
from  outstate  were  reluctant  to  send  their  sons  anc 
daughters  to  the  new  university  in  Laramie  because  of  the 
gambling  and  drinking  temptations  available  in  the  town 
In  effect,  the  editor  maintained,  the  community  paic 
higher  prices  for  goods  and  suffered  generally  sluggisl 
economic  and  social  conditions  because  of  the  gambling 
parasite.13 

Next  to  excessive  drinking,  Hayford  found  gambling 
the  most  demoralizing  vice  in  Laramie  and  frontier  Wyo 
ming.  While  the  ultimate  debasement  took  place  in  th< 
gambling  halls,  an  earlier  "primary"  gambling  was  incul 
cated  in  church  fairs  and  raffles  and  in  half  the  respect 
able  business  establishments  in  the  town.  Hayford  com 
plained  that  one  could  not  remain  in  drug,  book,  or  ciga: 
stores  for  five  minutes  without  witnessing  some  form  o 
gambling.  Customers  of  all  ages  were  encouraged  to  shak< 
ubiquitous  dice  boxes  to  determine  whether  they  paid  dou 
ble  or  nothing  for  all  kinds  of  merchandise.  In  order  tc 
promote  sales,  otherwise  respectable  merchants  promotec 
raffles  and  lottery  schemes.  So  engrained  had  the  betting 
"mania"  become  that  the  ethnocentric  Hayford  feared  thai 
the  next  generation  of  Wyomingites  would  be  as  debasec 
as  "Italians,  Chinese  and  Indians."  The  course  of  history 


I  was  moving  away  from  gambling,  he  insisted,  and  Wyo- 
ming could  either  take  its  place  among  the  socially  and 
economically  civilized  portions  of  the  nation  or  expect  to 

;  attract  only  the  refuse  that  more  advanced  communities 

I  left  behind.14 

Hayford's   arguments,    blending  pietism   and  petit 

•  bourgeois  values,  brought  him  considerable  support  both 
locally,  and  by  way  of  the  state  wide  newspaper  exchange, 

(throughout  Wyoming.  In  Laramie  itself,  he  spoke  for  the 
so-called  "goody-goody"  faction  that  normally  controlled 
the  Republican  Party  and  sought,  through  anti-saloon  and 
anti-gambling  ordinances,  to  promote  community  growth. 
I  In  1887,  Hayford's  pressure  brought  a  close  to  Sunday 
gambling  and,  briefly,  in  1888  to  its  repression  in  Lar- 
amie altogether.  In  1890,  after  some  modification  in  state 
law  that  seemed  to  strengthen  ami -gambling  forces,  Lar- 
amie, Rock  Springs  and  other  communities  launched 
ambitious  clean-up  campaigns.  Between  1890  and  1892, 
Hayford  claimed  that  the  number  of  saloons  in  Laramie 
;had  dropped  from  28  to  14,  that  three-fifths  of  the  brothels 
|had  been  eliminated,  and  that  the  "gambling  hells"  had 
ibeen  closed  entirely.  Community  vagrants  had  either  been 
chased  out  of  town  or  forced  to  work  repairing  the  streets.15 

By  1892,  however,  Hayford  must  have  sensed  a  Demo 
Icratic  revival,  both  nationally  and  locally.  Community 
growth  was  still  painfully  slow  and  Laramie-based  rail- 
road workers  still  gambled  heavily  when  working  outside 
ithe  town,  supposedly  leaving  debts  to  local  merchants 
unpaid.  When  area  Democrats  rebuffed  his  efforts  to 
orchestrate  a  non-partisan  alliance  against  the  saloon  and 
igambling  forces,  Hayford  committed  the  Laramie  Repub- 
lican party  to  a  set  of  "goody-goody"  resolutions,  promis- 
iing  a  high  license  policy  on  saloons  and  the  continued 
suppression  of  gambling.  The  more  "liberal"  Democrats 
i swept  the  elections  and  experimented  for  a  year  with  a 
imore  tolerant  policy.  By  1893,  however,  their  own  expe- 
dience with  the  seemingly  unmanageable  problem  of  gam  - 
i  bling  and  Hayford's  strident  criticism  prompted  Democrats 
,to  try  prohibiting  gambling  in  the  city  once  more.16 

Although  Hayford  held  his  local  enemies  up  to  ridi- 
cule, he  recognized  that  part  of  their  difficulty  sprang  from 
iseeming  contradictions  within  the  basic  law.  Especially 
after  the  mid-1880s,  no  one  could  be  certain  just  what 
powers  local  government  had  over  gambling  in  Wyoming. 
The  original  statute  had  Vested  licensing  power  in  the 
counties  and  had  prohibited  towns,  cities,  or  municipal 
corporations  from  interfering  with  gambling  licensed  by 
county  officials.  Without  amending  the  basic  law,  how- 
:ever,   the  legislature  by   1886  had  proceeded  to  grant 

•  charters  to  several  cities  giving  them  powers  to  "prohibit, 
suppress,  or  regulate"  gambling  within  their  municipal 

i  boundaries.  To  further  confuse  the  situation,  the  law- 
makers had  also  begun  to  shift  the  receipts  from  licens- 
ing to  the  cities.  By  1888,  legal  uncertainties  over  the 
gambling  law  had  complicated  all  attempts  to  deal  with 

:  the  issue  in  Laramie,  Cheyenne,  and  Rawlins.17 

To  eliminate  the  confusion,  that  year  Albany  County 


E.  A.  Slack 


Harry  P.  Hynds 


Stephen  Downey 


Downtown  Cheyenne  showing  Inter- Ocean  Hotel. 


territorial  council  member  William  H.  Holliday  intro- 
duced a  bill  to  prohibit  gambling  in  Wyoming  and  to 
assess  stringent  fines  for  violations.  An  Ohio-born  Demo- 
crat, a  prosperous  businessman  involved  in  lumbering, 
building,  and  merchandising,  Holliday  had  opposed  Hay- 
ford's  rigid  anti-gambling  stance  earlier  in  the  decade. 
Now,  to  Hayford's  applause,  Holliday  delivered  a  stem- 
winding  speech  drawing  attention  to  the  "abominations" 
that  gambling  worked  on  society  and  called  for  its  elim- 
ination.18 

Hayford  entered  the  fray  with  a  few  ill-chosen  slurs 
on  an  alleged  gambling  lobby  in  Cheyenne,  thereby  pro- 
voking the  wrath  of  Colonel  E.  A.  Slack  of  the  influen- 
tial Cheyenne  Sun.  In  his  earlier  days  as  a  bitter  editorial 
rival  to  Hayford  in  Laramie,  Slack  had  stood  for  a  more 
relaxed  and  tolerant  policy  on  gambling.19  When  Hayford 
endorsed  the  Holliday  bill,  Slack  seized  the  opportunity 
to  renew  the  fight.  Hayford  was,  he  concluded,  a  "cranky 
moral  reformer"  and  Laramie  could  do  much  more  under 
its  present  charter  to  clean  its  house  of  gambling.  The 
Holliday  bill  was  too  moralistic,  too  extreme,  too  sudden, 
and  too  pretentious  for  Wyoming  at  the  present  time. 

A  prohibitory  law  that  would  place  gambling  under  strict 
surveillance,  permit  the  levying  of  periodic  fines,  .  .  .  keep 
the  vice  on  the  second  floor,  and  more  retired,  is  about  what 
our  people  are  prepared  for.  Anything  more  than  this  will 
be  a  failure.  Of  course  this  compromise  will  not  be  accepted 
by  the  goody-goody  people,  and  the  consequence  will  be  a 
continuation  of  the  methods  that  now  prevail.  When  Wyo- 
ming gets  to  be  a  state,  and  men  wear  plug  hats  and  sus- 


penders, it  will  be  possible  to  maintain  the  same  high  stan- 
dards of  appearance  that  prevail  in  the  east,  and  we  will  then 
substitute  stock  and  grain  gambling  for  games  of  cards,  and 
be  respectable.  But  we  can  not  hope  to  reach  that  elevated 
plane  at  one  jump.  There  are  plenty  of  examples  to  refer 
to.  They  all  indicate  that  reforms  of  this  class  are  of  slow 
growth,  and  come  from  a  change  in  man's  environment.20 
Slack  had  clearly  anticipated  the  fate  of  the  Holliday 
proposal.  Despite  petitions  from  across  the  state  and  the 
efforts  of  Cheyenne  representative  Willis  Van  Devanter  to 
work  out  a  compromise,  the  measure  met  stiff  resistance 
from  lobbyists  and  the  comic  barbs  of  Representative  Tom 
Hooper  of  Sundance.  On  the  critical  vote  in  the  house, 
the  bill  lost  13-10,  with  the  bulk  of  the  support  coming 
from  Albany  and  Laramie  counties  and  with  Republicans 
marginally  in  favor  and  Democrats  generally  opposed.  Two 
years  later,  the  legislature  repealed  the  original  prohibi- 
tion against  the  suppression  of  gambling  by  the  cities,  but 
still  left  the  licensing  in  non-incorporated  areas  to  county 
officials.  Such  a  policy  made  effective  local  enforcement 
problematical  and  encouraged  widespread  confusion  and 
contention.21 

In  1893,  two  Albany  County  Republican  legislators, 
Stephen  W.  Downey  and  Robert  E.  Fitch,  made  a  second 
major  attempt  to  repeal  the  licensing  law.  Downey,  a 
prominent  Maryland-born  Episcopalian  lawyer  had  been 
interested  in  promoting  educational  and  mining  develop- 
ment in  the  area  since  coming  to  Laramie  in  1869. M  A 
native  of  New  York  state,  Fitch  had  strong  ties  to  the  Con- 
gregational and  Baptist  churches.  He  had  been  involved 


in  the  development  of  the  public  education  system  in 
Laramie,  had  dabbled  in  sheep  ranching,  but  by  1893  was 
primarily  concerned  with  real  estate,  insurance,  and  loan 
operations.23  Both  stressed  the  economic  and  civic  argu- 
ments that  Hayford  had  been  preaching  for  years.  Repre- 
sentative Downey  emphasized  that  businessmen  (including 
saloon  keepers)  from  Rock  Springs,  Laramie,  Cheyenne  — 
and  not  church  people— had  urged  him  to  sponsor  the 
legislation.  Repeal  would  promote  the  dignity  of  Wyoming 
in  the  eyes  of  eastern  states  which  were  systematically  pass- 
ing anti-gambling  statutes,  and  it  would  promote  work- 
ing class  thrift  and  citizenship.  Fitch  sought  to  eliminate 
local  confusions  and  support  those  communities  which 
wanted  to  prohibit  gambling.24 

Downey  and  Fitch  picked  up  significant  support  from 
businessmen  along  the  Union  Pacific  line,  from  Cheyenne 
legislators,  and  from  the  Cheyenne  Sun  itself.  Editor  Slack 
was  now  convinced  that  gambling  should  be  stopped  as 
a  means  of  enhancing  the  image  of  the  new  state  and  as 
a  way  of  improving  citizenship.  He  noted  that  in  foreign 
cities  where  gambling  houses  were  permitted,  local  resi- 
dents and  youth  were  excluded,  whereas  in  Wyoming,  no 
such  protections  were  provided.  Gambling  encouraged 
profligacy,  the  neglect  of  family  support,  and  the  non- 
payment of  legitimate  debt;  it  ran  counter  to  good  business 
sense;  and  it  engendered  chronic  disruptions  in  local  poli- 
tics, especially  in  cities  such  as  Laramie. 

Even  more  than  with  the  Holliday  bill,  however,  the 
more  "liberal"  Democrats  and  representatives  from  smaller 
communities  outstate  opposed  the  Downey  measure. 
Natrona  County's  B.  B.  Brooks  helped  to  kill  the  measure 
by  drawing  attention  to  its  ban  on  church  fairs  and  the 
loss  of  revenue  it  would  entail  for  Casper  and  other  strug- 
gling towns.  Democrats  voted  against  the  measure  13-2, 
while  Republicans  favored  it,  8-3. 25 

Rejected  for  a  second  time  in  their  efforts  to  get  relief 
from  the  legislature,  Hayford  and  anti-gambling  reformers 
in  the  state  retreated  to  municipal  and  county  politics  after 
1893.  Given  the  deepening  depression,  the  free  silver 
debate,  and  the  repercussions  from  the  Johnson  County 
range  war,  most  recognized  that  there  existed  little  chance 
for  gambling  reform  at  the  state  level.  For  a  period, 
Hayford  remained  especially  bitter.  He  blamed  a  Chey- 
enne gambling  entrepreneur,  Harry  Hynds,  a  Roman 
Catholic,  for  the  defeat  of  the  Downey  bill,  and  he  drifted 
into  support  of  the  anti-Catholic  American  Protective 
Association  in  local  politics.  By  the  mid-1890s,  he  aban- 
doned the  financially  strapped  Sentinel  for  a  local 
judgeship.26 

Hayford,  however,  left  more  than  his  vindictive  spirit 
for  future  anti  -gambling  reformers.  Like  pietists  elsewhere 
in  the  country,  he  had  sought  to  recreate  in  the  West  the 
kind  of  stable,  conformist,  Protestant  community  that  he 
and  others  identified  with  Americanism  itself.  If  he  did 
not  encounter  industrialization  in  Wyoming,  he  did  wit- 
ness the  fragmentation  and  pluralism  that  had  sprung 
from  a  comparable  late  19th  century  development  — the 


rapid  opening  of  the  West.  While  he  focused  heavily  on 
gambling,  he  would  on  occasion  use  comparable  argu- 
ments against  those  other  social  threats  the  saloon  and 
prostitution.  When  his  prickly  moralism  proved  unsuc- 
cessful with  local  voters,  he  broadened,  even  secularized, 
his  arguments  to  appeal  to  the  petit  bourgeois,  growth 
oriented,  business  mentality  of  the  area.  By  1893,  he  had 
transformed  Albany  County  into  a  center  of  anti-gambling 
sentiment  and  had  armed  its  legislators  to  take  the  lead 
in  challenging  licensed  gambling  in  the  state.  Under  dif- 
ferent circumstances,  his  arguments  would  prevail  in 
1901. 27  By  blending  pietism  and  progress,  by  drawing  on 
national  anxieties  as  well  as  local  ambitions,  Hayford  had 
fashioned  the  anti-gambling  tradition  in  Wyoming. 


1.  Lawrence  Goodwyn,  The  Populist  Moment:  A  Short  History  of 
the  Agrarian  Revolt  in  America  (London:  Oxford  University  Press, 
1978);  Thomas  A.  Krueger,  "Populism  in  Wyoming,"  (Unpublished 
M.A.  thesis.  University  of  Wyoming,   1960),  66. 

2.  Josiah  Strong,  Our  Country:  Its  Possible  Future  and  Its  Present 
Crisis  (New  York:  Baker  and  Taylor  Company,  1885),  176-194; 
Dong-Bai  Chai,  "Josiah  Strong:  Apostle  of  Anglo-Saxonism  and 
Social  Christianity,"  (Unpublished  Ph.D.  dissertation,  LIniversity 
of  Texas  at  Austin,  1972),  34-38,  57,  69-70. 

3.  See  especially  Norman  H.  Clark,  Deliver  Us  From  Evil:  An  Inter- 
pretation of  American  Prohibition  (New  York:  W.  W.  Norton  & 
Company,   1976). 

4.  Robert  K.  DeArment,  Knights  of  the  Green  Cloth:  The  Saga  of 
Frontier  Gamblers  (Norman:  University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1982), 
307-314;  Duane  A.  Smith,  Rocky  Mountain  Mining  Camps:  The 
Urban  Frontier  (Bloomington:  Indiana  LIniversity  Press,  1967), 
224-241;  Lloyd  Wendt  and  Herman  Kogan,  Bosses  in  Lusty 
Chicago:  The  Story  of  Bathhouse  John  and  Hinky  Dink  (Bloom- 
ington: Indiana  University  Press,  1943),  25:  Chai,  "Josiah  Strong," 
34,  37. 

5.  Frank  W.  Mondell,  "My  Story:  An  Autobiography,"  (Unpublished 
typescript),  23,  in  Mondell  Biographical  File.  American  Heritage 
Center,  University  of  Wyoming  (AHC-UW);  T.  A.  Larson,  History 
of  Wyoming  (Lincoln:  University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1978),  214. 

6.  Lewis  L.  Gould.  Wyoming:  A  Political  History,  1868-1896  (New 
Haven:  Yale  University  Press.  1968),  26;  Campbell  to  Wyoming 
Territorial  Council,  December  9,  1869,  Campbell  Letterpress  Book 
#,  pp.  285-286,  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and  Historical 
Department,  Cheyenne  (AMH);  "J.M.C."  letter  to  editor,  Wyo- 
ming Tribune,  November  27,  1869;  Carey  statement,  Cheyenne 
Daily  Leader,  February  11,  1901;  Chapter  58,  The  Compiled  Laws 
of  Wyoming  (Cheyenne,  1876),  361. 

7.  Laramie  Boomerang,  July  29,  1902;  Elizabeth  Keen,  "Wyoming's 
Frontier  Newspapers,"  (Unpublished  M.A.  thesis,  University  of 
Wyoming,  1956),  43-50;  Hayford  notes,  folder  40,  C.  G.  Cou- 
tant  Papers,  AMH;  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming,   116fn. 

8.  Laramie  Boomerang,  July  29,  1902.  On  pietism,  see  Paul  Klepp- 
ner,  The  Cross  of  Culture:  A  Social  Analysis  of  Midwestern  Politics, 
1850-1900  (New  York:  The  Free  Press,  1970)  and  Richard  J.  Jensen, 
The  Winning  of  the  Midwest:  Social  and  Political  Conflict, 
1888-96  (Chicago:  University  of  Chicago  Press,  1971). 

9.  Laramie  Sentinel,  September  15,  1883,  October  10,  1873,  March 
10,  1883,  February  25,  1882,  February  1,  1890,  January  16,  1886. 
The  1886  petition  was  adopted  at  the  Presbyterian  Church  after 
a  series  of  joint  evangelical  prayer  services.  Thurman  Arnold 
reported  that  his  grandfather,  the  first  Presbyterian  minister  in 
Laramie,  believed  that  "God  put  sin  into  the  world  to  test  man- 
kind" and  that  he  opposed  legal  prohibition  on  prostitution. 
Clearly  this  was  not  the  perspective  of  Elder  Hayford  or  those 


sponsoring  the  1886  petition.  Thurman  Arnold.  Fair  Fights  and 
Foul:  A  Dissenting  lawyer's  Life  (New  York:  Harcourt,  Brace  and 
World.  Inc.,   1965),   13. 

10.  In  the  mid  1870s,  Laramie  had  been  the  center  of  a  nationwide 
lottery  swindle  operated  through  the  mails  by  James  M.  Pattee 
of  Omaha.  For  a  short  period  of  time  Pattee  stimulated  the  local 
economy  through  printing  contracts  and  charitable  contributions. 
While  apparently  benefiting  at  the  time  from  the  contracts, 
Hayford  was  also  an  early  critic  of  Pattee's  operations.  The  editor 
feared  especially  that  Pattee  and  subsequent  lottery  schemes  would 
blacken  the  town's  reputation  and  stunt  economic  growth. 
Ixiramie  Sentinel,  March  3,  1875,  September  6,  1876;  Philip  Gar- 
diner Nordell,  "Pattee,  the  Lottery  King:  The  Omaha  and  Wyo- 
ming Lotteries,"  Annals  of  Wyoming  (October  1962),  199-211:  Lar- 
son, History  of  Wyoming,   115-116. 

11.  Laramie  Sentinel,  February  25,  1875;  March  18.  May  13.  June 
17,  24,  1882,  December  1.  1883,  May  3,  10.  1884.  Although 
temperance  forces  had  been  organized  in  Albany  County  as  early 
as  1871.  Hayford's  wife  in  1883  became  the  first  president  of  the 
local  WCTU  chapter.  The  Prussian-born  Gunster  was  a  surgeon, 
having  studied  at  Yale  and  a  number  of  hospitals  in  New  York, 
Berlin,  Paris,  and  London.  After  practicing  in  Pennsylvania,  he 
had  arrived  in  Laramie  in  1878.  Albany  County  notes,  folder  68, 
and  Gunster  notes,  folder  15,  Coutant  Papers. 

12.  Laramie  Sentinel,  July  29.  1882,  March  31,  September  8,  1883, 
May  19,  1888  and  especially  June  11,  1887  and  March  7.  1891. 
In  the  Sentinel,  he  noted  the  fates  of  the  clerk  of  local  merchant 
Jo  Kellner,  of  a  "beardless  boy"  convicted  of  mail  theft  at  Fort 
Fetterman,  and  of  his  own  typesetter,  Jack  DeCoursey,  a  suicide. 
He  claimed  to  have  the  names  of  other  young  men  on  a  similar 
path  to  "ruin,  disgrace  and  the  penitentiary."  For  examples  of  the 
latter  argument  by  national  anti-gambling  spokesmen,  see  Jona- 
than H.  Green,  Gambling  Exposed  (Philadelphia:  T.  B.  Peter- 
son. 1857),  283,  288  and  John  Philip  Quinn,  Fools  of  Fortune 
(Chicago:  Anti-Gambling  Association,  1892).  623-624. 

13.  Laramie  Sentinel,  February  11.  1888.  July  23.   1892. 

14.  Laramie  Sentinel,  January  19.  1886,  February  4.  11,  March  3 
1888,  March  7,  1891.  Although  Hayford  did  not  dwell  upon  it 
others,  including  Laramie  Mayor  M.  C.  Brown  in  the  late  1890s 
focused  upon  gambling  in  the  home  as  a  source  of  public  gam 
bling.  John  Philip  Quinn  was  highly  critical  of  parents  who  per 
mitted  gambling  games  in  the  home.  Laramie  Daily  Boomerang 
January  20,  1897;  Quinn,  Gambling  and  Gambling  Devices, 
(Montclair,  N.J.:  Patterson  Smith  reprint.   1969),  74-81. 

15.  Laramie  Sentinel,  June  25.  1887,  July  7,  1888,  May  11,  1889,  April 
12,  19,  1890,  March  7,  1891,  April  2,  1892. 

16.  Cheyenne  Daily  Sun,  February  9,  1893;  Laramie  Sentinel, 
February  27,  April  2,  9,  1892,  June  10.  1893. 

17.  Chapter  58,  General  Laws  of  Territory  of  Wyoming,  1869  (Chey- 
enne, 1870);  Cheyenne  Sun,  February  14,  1888.  On  the  back- 
ground of  the  legal  problems,  see  the  conflicting  opinions  of 


attorneysj.  C.  Baird  and  E.  W.  Mann,  reprinted  in  the  Cheyenne 
Sun- leader,  January  8,  1900,  and  Wyoming  Tribune,  December 
20,   1899. 

18.  Cheyenne  Sun,  February  3,  4,  5,  1888;  "William  Helmus  Holi- 
day." in  Ichabod  S.  Bartlett,  History  of  Wyoming  (Chicago:  S.  J. 
Clarke  Publishing  Company,  1918)  II,  34-38;  Laramie  Sentinel, 
June  24,  1882,  May  3,  1884,  February  4.  18,  1888.  After  moving 
from  the  Midwest,  Holliday  (18431925)  spent  two  years  in  the 
Denver  vicinity  before  entering  the  lumber  business  near  Laramie 
in  1867.  He  had  been  active  in  politics  for  almost  15  years  by  1888 
and  would  be.  in  1894,  the  unsuccessful  Democratic  candidate 
for  governor.  Holliday  was  not  affiliated  with  any  church.  See 
Ijiramie  Republican  Boomerang,  February  21,  1925,  and  the 
William  H.  Holliday  Biographical  File,  AHC-UW. 

19.  lxiramie  Sentinel,  February  4,  1888,  March  26.  1873.  A  New 
Yorker  by  birth,  Slack  edited  a  newspaper  in  South  Pass  City  before 
coming  to  Laramie  in  1871.  After  1876,  he  moved  to  Cheyenne 
and  published  the  Sun  as  a  Republican  paper.  Larson,  History 
of  Wyoming,  235fn. 

20.  Cheyenne  Sun,  February  2,  4.  5,   1888. 

21.  Ibid.,  February  19.  24,  29,  28.  March  8,  9,  1888;  Chapter  49, 
Session  Laws  of  Wyoming  Territory,  1890  (Cheyenne,  1890),  p. 
83.  Van  Devanter  was  chairman  of  the  house  judiciary  commit- 
tee in  1888.  In  1910,  President  Taft  appointed  him  to  the  United 
States  Supreme  Court.  "Justice  Willis  Van  Devanter,"  Bartlett, 
History  of  Wyoming,  II,  26-29.  Albany  and  Laramie  counties  pro- 
vided eight  of  the  ten  votes  for  the  bill  but  only  four  of  the  thir- 
teen against.  Democrats  broke  9-4  against  the  bill,  while  Repub- 
licans were  6-4  in  favor. 

22.  Downey  (1839-1902)  had  served  with  Union  forces  during  the  Civil 
War  before  moving  west.  While  in  the  territorial  legislature  in 
the  mid-1880s,  he  had  been  instrumental  in  locating  the  state 
university  in  Laramie.  During  his  career,  he  repeatedly  lost  small 
fortunes  in  promoting  mining  in  the  Centennial  area  of  Albany 
County.  "Stephen  C.  Downey,"  in  Bartlett.  History  of  Wyoming, 
III,  596;  Alice  Downey  Nelson,  Biographical  Sketches  of  Stephen 
Wheeler  Downey  and  Eva  V.  Downey  (Laramie,  1938),  booklet 
in  Stephen  Wheeler  Downey  Biographical  File,  AHC-UW. 

23.  Also  a  Union  veteran,  Fitch  (1843-1918)  had  taken  college  degrees 
in  Iowa  before  coming  to  Laramie  in  1872.  He  was  one  of  the 
leaders  of  the  local  chapters  of  the  Grand  Army  of  the  Republic. 
His  son  married  one  of  Colonel  Downey's  daughters.  "Robert  E. 
Fitch."  in  Bartlett,  History  of  Wyoming,  II,  206-209;  Laramie 
Republican,  October  21,  1918. 

24.  Cheyenne  Sun,  February  7.  9,  1893. 

25.  Ibid.,  February  7,  4,  7,  17,  1893. 

26.  Laramie  Sentinel.  February  11.  March  24,  1893,  April  7,  July  7, 
1894;  Laramie  Boomerang,  July  29,  1902. 

27.  See  author's  unpublished  manuscript,  "Progressivism  and  the 
Social  Gospel  in  the  West:  Wyoming's  Anti-Gambling  Act  of  1901 
as  a  Test  Case." 


LEGEND 

Monument  Bound  iry 


ECHO  PARK  DAM:  An  Old  Problem  of  Federalis 


m 


By  Mark  W.  T.  Harvey 


"Here  would  be  one  of  the  world's  great  dams. 
Scenically  it  could  do  for  Colorado  what  the  Hoover 
dam  has  done  lower  down  — bring  tourists  in  droves 
to  see  it;  .  .  .  These  Americans  would  be  awed  and 
proud,  as  at  Hoover  Dam,  to  realize  what  their  coun- 
try can  do  in  the  way  of  a  gigantic,  useful,  beautiful, 
masterwork." 

—  Roscoe  Fleming 

"Let  no  member  of  Congress  forget  that  the  Col- 
orado River  System  since  before  the  memory  of  man, 
has  been  the  most  destructive  river  on  the  North 
American  continent." 

—Joseph  O'Mahoney 


The  state  of  Wyoming  sought  to  protect  its  water  rights 
and  bolster  its  economy  in  the  1950s  by  supporting  con- 
struction of  a  huge  dam  in  the  heart  of  Dinosaur  National 
Monument.  The  dam  was  to  be  built  at  Echo  Park  and 
the  proposal  raised  a  storm  of  controversy  because  of  the 
area's  pristine  beauty.  National  park  supporters  also  feared 
that  Echo  Park  dam  would  open  the  way  for  economic 
development  in  other  parks.1  Yet  Wyoming  residents 
believed  the  dam  offered  a  tremendous  opportunity.  It 
would  provide  employment,  recreation,  electrical  power, 
water  for  the  future,  and  more  control  over  its  deeply 
embedded  boom-bust  economy.  The  dam  would  enable 
Wyoming  to  assert  its  sovereign  rights  in  the  face  of  forces 
beyond  its  control. 

At  the  heart  of  Wyomingites'  support  of  the  dam 
rested  a  firm  belief  that  the  state  must  possess  stronger 
control  over  water  rights.  Perhaps  no  single  resource  was 
more  important  to  the  economy  or  to  the  state's  future 
than  water.  On  several  occasions  in  the  20th  century,  resi- 
dents who  hoped  to  make  use  of  water  in  the  state  had 
been  frustrated  by  other  states,  who  claimed  prior  rights 
to  waters  they  shared  with  Wyoming.  This,  in  turn,  had 
placed  Wyoming  at  the  mercy  of  the  Supreme  Court, 
which  had  handed  down  decisions  not  always  favorable 
to  the  state.2  Although  never  a  rich  agricultural  state, 
many  Wyoming  residents  felt  frustrated.  By  the  1950s,  a 
growing  population  meant  that  sufficient  water  must  be 
provided  for  the  years  ahead.  The  Echo  Park  dam  would 
provide  that  water,  and  offer  a  means  by  which  Wyoming 
could  protect  itself  from  federal  encroachment  over  its 
water  and  water  rights,  and  from  large  corporations  which 
dominated  its  economy.  The  dam  promised  the  state  a 
way  to  loosen  its  colonial  bonds. 

The  controversy  over  Echo  Park  arose  because  the 
National  Park  Service  and  the  Bureau  of  Reclamation  had 
developed,  by  the  1950s,  radically  different  conceptions 
of  how  lands  in  the  West  should  be  used.  The  Park  Ser- 
vice, under  Director  Newton  Drury,  emerged  from  the  war 
years  with  a  new  found  enthusiasm  for  protecting  the 
parks,  especially  the  large  and  pristine  parks  in  the  West. 
On  the  other  hand,  officials  of  the  Bureau  eagerly  planned 
large  river  basin  projects  for  the  West.  The  Bureau 
believed  that  free  flowing  rivers  were  wasteful  and  often 
destructive.  Large  watercourses  such  as  the  Colorado  and 
the  Columbia  must  be  harnessed  in  order  to  bring  water 
to  thirsty  lands,  power  and  flood  control  to  growing  com- 
munities, and  prosperity  to  western  citizens.  These  atti- 
tudes within  the  Interior  Department  inevitably  caused 
clashes  between  the  two  agencies.3  Echo  Park  became  the 
center  of  one  of  the  most  heated. 

The  Bureau  of  Reclamation  had  had  its  eye  on  Echo 
Park  as  a  dam  site  since  the  early  1940s.  The  Green  River, 
the  major  tributary  of  the  Colorado,  sharply  narrowed 
between  sheer  cliffs  in  the  heart  of  Dinosaur  National 
Monument,  just  below  Echo  Park.  A  dam  at  this  site  would 
be  excellent  for  storing  a  vast  volume  of  water  at  a  low 
rate  of  evaporation.  The  dam  could  also  provide  a  large 


hydroelectric  plant,  which  Wyoming  and  the  surrounding 
states  desired.4 

The  Bureau,  however,  could  not  simply  claim  the  dam 
site  because  the  Park  Service  held  jurisdiction  over  Echo 
Park.  Park  Service  officials  knew  the  Bureau  hoped  to  con- 
struct the  dam  and  they  never  firmly  stood  against  the 
idea  during  World  War  II.  Not  until  the  Bureau  made 
formal  claim  to  the  site  for  possible  development  did  park 
officials  react.  By  the  late  1940s,  the  whole  matter  boiled 
into  a  political  debate.  The  Bureau  had  won  overwhelm- 
ing support  for  the  Echo  Park  dam  in  the  upper  basin 
states  of  New  Mexico,  Colorado,  Utah  and  Wyoming.  With 
such  a  show  of  strength,  the  Bureau  expected  the  Part 
Service  to  withdraw  its  objection.  When  it  refused,  the 
issue  had  to  be  given  to  Secretary  of  Interior  Oscar  Chap 
man  to  decide.  If  Chapman  would  give  his  blessing  to  the 
Bureau's  plan,  the  Echo  Park  dam  could  be  incorporated 
into  legislation,  whereupon  Congress  could  then  decide/ 

After  holding  a  public  hearing  in  Washington  ir 
April,  1950,  Secretary  Chapman  found  the  pro-dam  argu 
ment  most  convincing.6  He  soon  approved  Echo  Park 
dam,  which  infuriated  the  nation's  preservationists,  whc 
responded  by  sending  Chapman  a  flood  of  letters  and  tele 
grams  expressing  their  anger.  Bernard  DeVoto  voiced  the 
concerns  of  numerous  conservationists  when  he  wrote  thai 
permitting  the  Dinosaur  dam  would  change  the  beautifu 
Green  River  into  a  "mere  millpond."7  On  a  more  practi 
cal  level,  others  argued  that  the  Echo  Park  site  was  nol 
the  best  for  minimizing  evaporation.  They  said  that  othei 
dam  sites  outside  the  monument  could  be  used  which 
would  store  more  water  and  cost  less  money.  Above  all 
they  feared  that  allowing  the  dam  to  be  built  would  sei 
a  dangerous  precedent  for  "invasions"  in  other  nationa 
parks  or  monuments.8 

Chapman  had  second  thoughts.  He  stalled  by  refus 
ing  to  send  his  approval  of  the  Bureau's  plans  to  the 
Bureau  of  the  Budget  for  many  months,  infuriating  resi 
dents  in  the  upper  basin.  Finally,  in  December,  1952 
Chapman  sent  a  report  of  the  Bureau's  plans  to  the  White 
House,  requesting  that  alternate  sites  be  more  thoroughly 
examined.  Chapman  left  office  a  month  later,  leaving  the 
difficult  decision  to  his  successor,  Douglas  McKay.9 

McKay  sympathized  with  the  notion  that  natura 
resources  should  not  be  "locked  up"  or  preserved,  bul 
utilized  for  the  nation's  economy.  Shortly  after  taking  office 
he  dispatched  Undersecretary  Ralph  Tudor  to  Dinosaui 
with  orders  to  reexamine  the  Bureau  of  Reclamation'.1 
computations  of  their  proposed  reservoirs'  evaporatior 
rates.  Tudor  soon  reported  that  the  Echo  Park  site  was 
superior.  He  wrote  McKay  that  he  was  "particularl) 
impressed"  with  the  fact  that  any  of  the  proposed  alter 
nate  sites  would  lose  an  additional  100,000-200,000  acre 
feet  of  water  per  year  over  Echo  Park.  In  December,  1953, 
Secretary  McKay  approved  the  Echo  Park  dam  as  pari 
of  the  Colorado  River  Storage  Project  and  the  controversy 
shifted  into  the  halls  of  Congress.10 

If  preservationists  were  again  angered,  Wyoming  and 


10 


:he  upper  basin  rejoiced.  Wyoming  State  Engineer 
L.  Clark  Bishop  thanked  McKay  in  a  letter,  saying  that 
ithe  amount  of  water  Echo  Park  dam  would  save  and  the 
recreational  value  of  the  new  lake  "will  much  more  than 
offset  any  primitive  area  value."11  Construction  of  the  dam 
would  also  produce  hydroelectric  power,  a  vital  need  of 
Wyoming  in  the  postwar  years.  The  state  needed  a  sup- 
ply of  inexpensive  power  to  attract  manufacturers,  who 
had  shunned  Wyoming  throughout  its  history,  and  kept 
the  state  dependent  on  eastern  industries.  Power  produced 
at  Echo  Park  would  also  supply  revenues  to  fund  three 
ismall  reclamation  projects  in  Wyoming's  Green  River 
|Basin,  the  Lyman,  LaBarge  and  Seedskadee  projects. 
Altogether,  these  irrigation  works  would  bring  water  to 
over  100,000  acres  of  meadow  lands  in  western  Wyoming. 
Power,  in  short,  would  foster  a  more  independent  economy 
iin  Wyoming.12 

Approval  of  the  Echo  Park  project  was  the  second  vic- 
tory for  Wyoming's  advocates  of  development.  A  signifi- 
cant water  treaty,  the  Upper  Colorado  River  Basin  Com- 
pact of  1948,  ensured  Wyoming,  Utah,  New  Mexico  and 
Colorado  legal  control  over  rights  to  the  mighty  river  that 
ithey  shared.  The  treaty  was  based  on  the  Colorado  River 
Compact  of  1922,  which  had  divided  Colorado  River  water 
between  the  upper  and  lower  basins.  The  1948  Compact 
apportioned  the  upper  basin  water  among  each  of  the  four 
states.  It  guaranteed  each  of  them  a  percentage  of  the 
annual  flow  while  obligating  them  to  send  75  million  acre 


feet  to  the  lower  basin  every  ten  years,  under  the  terms 
of  the  1922  Compact. 

The  1948  Compact  also  guaranteed  that  each  upper 
basin  state  could  plan  its  own  water  projects  without  inter- 
ference from  the  federal  government.  The  Bureau  of 
Reclamation  would  construct  dams  within  the  states,  but 
it  could  not  co-opt  any  state's  water  rights,  which  it  had 
been  able  to  do  in  the  past.  For  protection,  the  Compact 
created  the  Upper  Colorado  River  Commission,  composed 
of  one  representative  from  each  state  and  one  from  the 
federal  government.  The  commission  became  the  spear- 
head for  promoting  the  Colorado  Storage  Project  and  the 
Echo  Park  dam.13 

The  compact  also  forced  upper  basin  states  to 
cooperate  in  using  the  upper  Colorado  River  water.  Dur- 
ing the  1940s,  Colorado  had  threatened  Wyoming's  water 
rights  by  constructing  small  dams  on  tributaries  of  the 
Colorado.  Since  the  prior  appropriation  principle,  "first 
in  time,  first  in  right,"  was  the  West's  fundamental  water 
law,  Colorado  might  have  been  able  to  claim  water  rights 
over  Green  River  water  which  originated  in  Wyoming.14 
The  Upper  Basin  Compact  ensured  that  this  could  never 
happen.  It  promised  protection  of  each  state's  water  rights 
from  the  federal  government  and  allowed  each  state 
greater  independence  to  plan  for  its  own  reclamation  pro- 
jects. Wyoming  placed  great  faith  in  the  compact  and  fully 
supported  the  Bureau's  proposed  dams  which  would  make 
the  compact's  promises  a  reality.  The  Echo  Park  dam,  in 


Senator  Frank  Barrett 


Senator  Joseph  C.  O'Mahoney 


11 


effect,  was  the  physical  manifestation  of  the  compact.  It 
represented  an  opportunity  for  Wyoming  to  purchase 
power,  store  water  for  the  future,  and  foster  economic  and 
political  independence  from  outside  corporations  and  the 
federal  government.15 

The  debate  peaked  in  1954  when  Congress  considered 
legislation  for  the  Echo  Park  dam.  Wyoming's  economic 
hardship  of  that  year  strengthened  residents'  desire  for 
federal  reclamation  and  dam  projects.  In  late  1953,  a 
drought  had  blighted  southwest  Wyoming.  By  mid  1954, 
it  had  spread  across  the  state  which  forced  many  ranchers 
to  market  some  of  their  stock  early  for  lack  of  feed.  More 
importantly,  in  early  January  the  Union  Pacific  Railroad 
had  released  hundreds  of  miners  from  their  jobs  after 
replacing  coal  fired  engines  with  diesels  and  by  summer, 
unemployed  miners  in  southwest  Wyoming  numbered 
more  than  one  thousand.  Rock  Springs  was  devastated 
by  the  shutdowns.  The  railroad  had  crippled  an  entire 
town  in  a  single  blow.  One  resident  wrote  that  "Rock 
Springs  people  .  .  .  are  ready  to  go  all  out  for  anything 
that  could  help  their  situation."  Governor  C.  J.  Rogers 
implored  Congress  to  enact  the  Storage  Project  soon,  for 
the  Seedskadee  reclamation  project  would  employ  desper- 
ate miners  and  relieve  western  Wyoming's  thirsty  acres. 
More  than  ever  before,  Wyomingites  cried  for  help  from 
the  federal  government  and  advocated  reclamation,  while 
steadfastly  claiming  control  over  the  water  that  the  pro- 
jects would  store.16 

All  of  their  hopes  rested  with  Congress  approving  Echo 
Park  dam,  which  promised  to  be  difficult  because  a 
chorus  of  Americans  were  protesting  the  "invasion"  of 
Dinosaur  National  Monument.  From  Wyoming's  point  of 
view,  preservationist  groups  callously  ignored  her  economic 
woes.  One  resident  wrote  Senator  Frank  Barrett  that  "in 
view  of  the  fact  that  since  colonial  times  our  progress  has 
always  been  to  the  West  and  to  develop  the  West  to  its 
full  potentiality  depends  entirely  on  water  and  power,  it 
seems  to  me  it  would  be  the  height  of  folly  to  let  a  group 
of  maudlin  idealists  stand  in  the  way  of  progress."17  Still, 
it  was  not  enough  simply  to  proclaim  the  dam's  potential 
for  the  upper  basin.  Preservationists  were  worried  about 
the  sanctity  of  the  park  system  and  somehow,  their  con- 
cerns had  to  be  addressed.  In  Congress,  upper  basin  poli- 
ticians concentrated  on  pointing  out  the  advantages  of 
the  dam,  while  claiming  it  could  not  endanger  the  park 
system. 

They  argued  that  few  Americans  had  ever  seen  Dino- 
saur's canyons  because  of  their  inaccessibility.  Only  one 
rough  dirt  road  provided  access  by  land.  Only  the  swift 
Green  and  Yampa  Rivers  offered  a  route  to  Echo  Park  by 
water.  Neither  route  was  safe  and  most  travelling  Amer- 
icans were,  therefore,  unaware  of  the  monument's  pristine 
beauty.  Build  a  dam  along  the  Green  River,  however,  and 
all  would  change.  Visitors  could  then  view  the  magnifi- 
cent canyons  along  108  miles  of  a  lovely,  placid  lake  from 
canoes  or  outboards.  As  Dr.  J.  E.  Broaddus,  a  physician 
from  Salt  Lake  City  and  frequent  visitor  to  Dinosaur  said, 

12 


the  best  reason  to  dam  Echo  Park  would  be  to  "take  peo 
pie  down  through  there  in  a  boat  and  have  them  look  up 
to  those  magnificent  heights.  They  will  get  an  inspiratior 
such  as  they  will  never  get  anywhere  else  ...  in  the  Unitec 
States."18 

Proponents  also  claimed  that  Dinosaur  containec 
other  equally  impressive  areas.  Members  of  the  Upper  Col 
orado  Commission  listened  to  G.  E.  Untermann  o: 
Vernal,  Utah,  another  admirer  of  the  monument  whc 
had  little  patience  with  preservationists.  Untermanr 
denounced  their  ignorance,  asserting  that  they  obviousb 
knew  nothing  of  Jones  Hole,  "an  exact  duplication"  of  Ech< 
Park  just  three  miles  downstream  from  the  dam  site.  Hi 
contended  that  all  the  animal  and  plant  life  in  Echo  Pari 
existed  elsewhere  too.  Untermann  would  have  agreed  witl 
Albert  Bartlett  from  Wyoming,  who  wrote  Senator  Bar 
rett  that  "there  are  only  a  few  good  storage  reservoir  sites 
but  there  are  millions  of  square  miles  available  for  vaca 
tion  areas  without  interfering  with  water  conservation.  Ii 
fact  water  conservation  projects  can  be  very  attractive  fo 
playgrounds,  and  many  more  people  would  visit  and  enjo' 
the  areas  mentioned  if  they  are  developed  to  conservi 
water.   .  .  ."19 

When  statements  such  as  these  were  coupled  witl 
other  arguments  such  as  those  of  the  Commission's  lega 
counsel,  there  seemed  little  reason  to  worry  that  the  Ech< 
Park  dam  would  violate  the  park  system.  Attorney  Johi 
Will  asserted  that  was  impossible.  Will  had  discovered  tha 
President  Roosevelt's  proclamation  expanding  Dinosau 
National  Monument  authorized  a  dam  in  the  future.  Thi 
text  of  Roosevelt's  1938  decree  convinced  Will  that  "thi 
late  President  Roosevelt  thought,  the  Federal  Power  Com 
mission  thought,  the  Congress  thought,  and  the  genera 
public  thought  .  .  .  that  nothing  was  being  done  tha 
would  adversely  affect  the  eventual  use  of  the  area  for  pur 
poses  such  as  those  to  which  Echo  Park  dam  will  be  ded 
icated."  Will  saw  no  "invasion"  or  precedent  for  dan 
building  in  other  parks,  in  light  of  Roosevelt's  decree.2 

Nevertheless  preservationists  could  not  be  silenced 
Sierra  Club  Executive  Director  David  Brower  successful!' 
challenged  the  Bureau  of  Reclamation's  much  disputec 
evaporation  figures.  Using  simple  charts  and  "ninth-grad* 
arithmetic,"  Brower  proved  to  a  congressional  subcom 
mittee  that  Undersecretary  Tudor's  check  of  the  Bureau' 
calculations  was  faulty.  Brower  argued  that  use  of  the  Ech< 
Park  site  would  not  save  nearly  as  much  water  over  alter 
nate  sites  as  its  proponents  had  said.  Tudor  had  to  re-checl 
his  figures  and  preservationists  had  gained  the  offensive.2 

They  scoffed  at  the  assertion  that  the  Echo  Park  dan 
would  make  a  beautiful  area  more  accessible  to  a  largi 
public.  Herbert  Levi,  a  professor  of  botany  at  the  Univer 
sity  of  Wisconsin,  pointed  out  that  such  reasoning  wouk 
be  ludicrous  in  other  situations.  "Is  the  number  of  visitor 
the  criterion  of  national  park  standards?  Is  the  Adminis 
tration  to  place  comic  strips  in  the  National  Gallery  o 
Art,  or  convert  the  Smithsonian  Institution  into  a  circus 
to  attract  visitors?"  James  Munro,  president  of  Wyoming' 


jBig  Horn  Chapter  of  the  Izaak  Walton  League  also  failed 
jto  see  the  reasoning.  He  questioned  why  the  federal  gov- 
jernment  would  "set  aside  a  scenic  area  on  the  understand- 
ing that  at  some  later  time  another  Bureau  of  the  Gov- 
ernment would  come  and  build  a  dam  to  destroy  the  very 
lvalues  that  the  monument  was  created  to  preserve?"22 

This  all  seemed  like  trivial  bickering  to  the  vast  major- 
ity in  Wyoming.  Echo  Park's  defenders  appeared  insen- 
sitive to  residents  whose  jobs  had  been  taken  away,  whose 
ranch  lands  were  sun  baked,  and  who  understood  that 
water  must  be  conserved  in  the  arid  West.  The  Echo  Park 
jcontroversy  had  not  been  the  first  time  "nature  lovers"  had 
.blocked  Wyoming's  road  to  progress  but  the  state  had 
pearly  reached  its  limit  in  tolerating  them.  Wearily,  the 
\Casper  Tribune-Herald  proclaimed  that  the  controversy 
,"is  of  a  kind  with  that  which  rages  over  grazing  in  the 
national  forests.  Economic  development  takes  a  back  seat 
to  recreation.  It  is  not  conceded  that  the  two  can  go  hand- 
jin-hand."23 

The  Tribune-Herald  implied  that  those  who  hoped 
(to  preserve  Dinosaur  opposed  any  attempt  to  dam  the  Col- 
orado and  that  they  were  interfering  with  Wyoming's  right 
to  thrive.  The  implication  was  questionable.  Preservation- 
;ists  were  prepared  to  champion  the  Colorado  Storage  Pro- 
ject as  long  as  the  Echo  Park  dam  was  excluded  from  the 
bill.  They  did  not  seek  to  prevent  the  upper  basin  from 
putting  the  mighty  Colorado  River  to  good  use.  Though 
!many  of  them  later  regretted  the  authorization  of  the  Glen 
,Canyon  dam,  few  recognized  at  the  time  what  a  magnif- 
icent area  was  at  stake.  Still,  as  long  as  preservationists 
stood  firmly  against  the  Dinosaur  dam  they  delayed  the 
whole  Storage  Project  and  the  longer  the  project  was 
delayed  the  more  criticism  they  suffered  from  upper  basin 
residents. 

Eventually,  proponents  of  the  Echo  Park  dam  linked 
the  nation's  preservationists  with  all  others  who  did  not 
support  the  overall  project.  As  the  controversy  raged, 
Dinosaur's  environmental  defenders  gradually  were  seen 
as  a  smoke  screen  for  the  bigger  forces  at  work.  At  first, 
these  forces  could  not  be  identified.  The  upper  basin  sim- 
ply did  not  discern  any  hidden  motives  behind  preserva- 
tionists' protests  but  they  did  suspect  that  those  people 
who  spoke  of  the  sanctity  of  the  park  system  had  other 
motives  in  mind.  Then,  an  editorial  writer  from  the  Salt 
Lake  Tribune  sounded  the  alarm,  when  he  confessed  that 
"it  is  difficult  to  understand  why  Echo  Park  is  being  made 
the  blazing  symbol  of  conservation  at  this  time.  The  epi- 
demic of  editorials  and  intemperate  statements  arouses 
the  suspicion  that  Echo  Park  is  the  mere  window  dress- 
ing for  a  behind-the-scenes  movement  of  far  greater  con- 
sequence to  the  Intermountain  West,  and  indirectly,  to 
the  nation."24 

What  did  the  writer  mean?  Was  he  suggesting  that 
a  conspiracy  existed  against  the  upper  basin?  If  so,  who 
composed  it?  As  the  83rd  Congress  progressed  upper  basin 
congressmen  found  the  answers.  Preservationists,  they  con- 
cluded, constituted  only  a  minority  of  the  opposition  to 


Echo  Park  dam.  The  real  power,  the  driving  force  behind 
them  and  their  self-righteousness,  was  California.  Hav- 
ing reached  this  conclusion,  Echo  Park  dam's  proponents 
railed  furiously  against  California  congressmen  and  any- 
one possibly  allied  with  them.25 

The  Denver  Post  was  especially  fond  of  the  California 
conspiracy  notion.  It  saw  the  California -based  Sierra  Club's 
stand  on  Echo  Park  as  clear  proof  that  California  was 
covertly  leading  the  opposition.  The  paper  even  charged 
Bernard  DeVoto,  a  western  historian,  conservationist,  and 
Harper's  columnist,  with  accepting  California  money  to 
write  in  protest  of  the  dam.26 

Wyoming  editors  and  politicians  quickly  seized  the 
notion  as  well.  They  saw  California's  insatiable  desire  to 
horde  the  Colorado  River  water  behind  every  action  Cali- 
fomians  took.  In  January,  1953,  California  Representative 
Leroy  Johnson  had  introduced  a  bill  to  establish  Green 
River  Canyons  National  Park,  separate  from  Dinosaur  Na- 
tional Monument.  Johnson  wished  to  divide  the  river  can- 
yons from  the  dinosaur  bone  quarry  and  create  individual 
parks.27  Later  that  year  the  Denver  Post  asserted  that 
Johnson  did  not  "give  a  hoot  in  Gehemma  about  preserv- 
ing 'unspoiled'  the  scenic  wonders  of  the  Dinosaur  Monu- 
ment, but  he  knows  that  the  denial  of  the  Echo  Park  dam- 
site  would  upset  the  plans  of  the  Upper  Basin  states  for 
another  five  years  at  least,  and  all  the  time  California 
would  be  making  hay."  In  1954,  as  Congress  debated  the 
Storage  Project,  Breck  Moran,  a  member  of  Wyoming's 
Natural  Resource  Board,  mailed  the  Post's  article  to 
Senators  Barrett  and  Lester  Hunt.  Moran  said  that  it 
should  convince  those  who  believe  pristine  nature  is  the 
basic  issue  at  stake,  that  "Southern  California's  cupidity 
is  more  important."28 

Wyomingites  detected  California  influence  in  other 
publications.  In  the  spring,  1954  issue  of  Pacific  Spectator, 
Sierra  Club  Director  Brower  penned  an  essay  on  the  threat 
to  Echo  Park  that  infuriated  Wyoming  congressman  Wil- 
liam Henry  Harrison.  Brower  wanted  thoughtful  citizens 
to  speak  out  against  the  Storage  Project  and  he  questioned 
"how  fervently  the  federal  government  should  support,  at 
financial  risk  to  all  the  nation,  a  1922  river-allocating  com- 
pact which  in  1954  emerges  as  a  costly  device  to  lift  Col- 
orado River  economy  by  its  bootstraps."  Harrison  hardly 
sympathized  with  the  article  and  bristled  at  this  particular 
passage.  Brower,  evidently,  opposed  the  fundamental  water 
agreement  of  the  Colorado  River  and  the  upper  basin's 
right  to  develop  its  share.  To  Harrison,  Brower  was  "say- 
ing, in  effect,  that  although  the  lower  basin  is  benefit- 
ting to  the  extent  of  a  billion  and  a  half  dollars  through 
federal  reclamation  .  .  .  the  upper  basin  can  dry  up  and 
blow  away  .  .  ."  If  Brower  persuaded  most  Spectator 
readers,  he  unwittingly  contributed  to  the  suspicion  that 
California  plotted  to  deprive  the  upper  basin  of  its  right 
to  a  prosperous  future.29 

Californians,  of  course,  simply  looked  out  for  their 
own  interests  and  they  worried  how  the  Storage  Project 
legislation  might  affect  their  own  claims  to  the  Colorado 


13 


River.  Several  of  the  state's  congressmen  feared  that  the 
bill  could  undermine  the  Colorado  Compact  of  1922.  They 
had  misgivings  that  the  authors  of  the  upper  basin  bill 
had  not  considered  all  of  the  1922  compact's  implications. 
They  wanted  all  the  Colorado  basin  states  to  fully  agree 
on  any  proposed  projects.  Upper  basin  congressmen  had 
little  patience  for  such  concerns  and  they  grew  more  weary 
of  California  regional  protests,  more  mistrustful  of  Cali- 
fornia motives,  and  more  irritated  that  its  representatives 
delayed  the  legislation.  All  of  their  annoyance  with  Cali- 
fornia contributed  to  their  growing  belief  of  a  lower  basin 
plot. 

Wyoming's  congressmen  and  others  from  the  upper 
basin  soon  refused  to  accept  any  statements  from  Cali- 
fornians  at  face  value.  The  California  Division  of  Water 
Resources  and  the  Colorado  River  Board  had  prepared 
a  report  critical  of  the  Storage  Project  that  they  sent  to 
Secretary  McKay.  The  report  outlined  Californians'  fears 
that  additional  irrigation  in  the  upper  basin  would  harm 
the  quality  of  water  below  Lee's  Ferry.30  California's  heavy 
reliance  on  the  Colorado  for  agricultural  and  domestic 
use  prompted  this  concern.  But  by  expressing  it,  Califor- 
nians implied  that  they  took  a  dim  view  of  any  irrigation 
in  the  upper  basin. 

Congressmen  from  the  lower  basin  state  did  not  resent 


the  upper  basin's  1948  compact  or  its  plans  to  develop 
upper  Colorado  River.  They  were  more  concerned  al 
how  such  development  would  affect  their  own  water 
ply.  For  example,  California  Senator  Thomas  Ku 
believed  that  after  dams  were  built  the  upper  basin  ci 
use  any  amount  of  water  in  a  given  year,  as  long  as  it  c 
pensated  the  lower  basin  in  subsequent  years.  Natur 
for  Kuchel  and  his  southern  California  constituents, 
prospect  of  their  region  receiving  too  little  water  in 
year  was  grim.31  Upper  basin  congressmen  were  qui< 
point  out  that  the  whole  Colorado  Storage  Project 
based  on  the  requirement  for  the  upper  basin  to  sen 
million  acre  feet  of  water  to  the  lower  basin  every  ten  y 
Kuchel  was  not  satisfied  simply  with  a  ten  year  guarai 
He  wanted  a  yearly  guarantee.  Yet  it  seemed  to  upper  I 
congressmen  that  he  would  never  be  happy  with  the 
islation  until  every  last  detail  had  been  ironed  out 
Eventually,  Kuchel  asked  that  Congress  wait  unti 
Supreme  Court  decided  the  case  Arizona  v.  Calif oi 
a  complicated  litigation  centering  on  the  issue  of  divi 
the  lower  Colorado  River  water  between  the  two  st 
Kuchel  had  concluded  that  all  of  the  Colorado  basin  s 
had  a  vested  interest  in  the  case.  Yet  Wyoming  cong 
men  and  officials  from  each  upper  basin  state  were 
concerned  about  the  lawsuit's  outcome.  Moreover, 


Echo  Park 


14 


believed  that  California's  attempt  to  embroil  them  in  the 
lower  basin  controversy  was  really  a  smoke  screen  to  delay 
the  Storage  Project  and  the  Echo  Park  dam  for  good.33 

The  debate  in  Congress  raged.  As  Californians  con- 
tinued to  warn  that  the  Storage  Project  could  threaten 
their  state's  water  supply,  they  invariably  spoke  against 
Echo  Park  dam  as  well.  Some  embraced  the  arguments 
of  preservationists.  Others  claimed  the  large  dam  simply 
would  subsidize  upper  basin  reclamation  projects,  and  was 
unnecessary  as  a  storage  reservoir.  Regardless  of  their  rea- 
soning, they  created  more  suspicion  of  their  motives. 

During  congressional  debates  California  Representa- 
tive Leroy  Johnson  declared  his  opposition  to  the  proposed 
legislation,  then  added  that  he  did  "not  wish  to  deprive 
the  States  involved  in  this  legislation  of  any  water."34  The 
statement  was  contradictory.  If  Californians  did  not  mean 
to  block  water  development  in  the  upper  basin  why  were 
they  making  such  a  fuss?  And  why  were  they  protesting 
construction  of  Echo  Park  dam,  the  key  unit  in  the  whole 
project?  There  was  only  one  answer  for  congressmen  from 
the  upper  basin: 

The  lower  basin  apparently  is  not  yet  ready,  in  spite  of  legal 
agreement  and  sacred  promises  to  the  contrary,  to  help  limit 
their  own  potential  possibilities  just  as  long  as  water  must 
flow  downhill.  .  .  .  The  hungry  horde  in  the  lower  basin  wants 
every  possible  drop  and  they  want  to  get  this  clamp  of  first 
beneficial  use  on  it.  That  explains  this  proclivity  to  take  one's 
near  neighbors  to  court,  to  oppose  by  all  available  means 
one's  neighbors  development  — and  at  the  same  time  fatten 
one's  own  political  nest  irrespective  of  party.  .  .  .  We  in  the 
upper  basin  are  reaching  the  limit  of  our  endurance  of  such 
machinations.35 

Californians,  it  appeared,  had  resisted  the  Storage 
Project  and  Echo  Park  dam  as  much  as  preservationists 
from  around  the  country.  With  upper  basin  patience  wear- 
ing thin,  it  became  increasingly  difficult  for  congressmen, 
editors  and  the  public  in  Wyoming  and  the  other  states 
to  separate  Californians  from  protectors  of  Dinosaur.  Even- 
tually, the  two  were  linked  together  in  many  residents' 
minds.  The  Casper  Tribune-Herald  asserted  that  all  of 
those  protesting  against  Echo  Park  dam  were  "mainly 
pawns  of  .  .  .  California  groups  seeking  to  hog  Colorado 
River  water."  While  preservationists  and  "eastern  interests" 
were  partly  to  blame  for  holding  up  the  legislation,  "back 
of  it  all,  pulling  the  strings  on  the  mannequins,  stood  Cal- 
ifornia, with  an  eye  to  gaining  rights  to  upper  Colorado 
River  water  by  virtue  of  prior  use."  Or  as  the  Sheridan 
Press  put  it,  "We  are  positive  that  those  who  bludgeon 
the  Echo  Park  dam  project  care  nothing  about  Dinosaur 
National  Monument,  and  care  nothing  about  a  national 
park.  All  they  want  is  water  belonging  to  others."36 

Wyoming  residents  were  completely  persuaded.  If 
preservationists'  arguments  found  little  sympathy  in  the 
state  during  the  initial  years  of  the  Echo  Park  controversy, 
they  found  even  less  by  the  mid-1950s.  Wyoming's  faith 
in  the  Dinosaur  dam  had  been  strengthened.  Their  con- 
viction that  Congress  should  authorize  it  was  reinforced. 
For  it  was  clear  that  preservationist  opposition  was  insig- 


nificant, that  all  of  them  were  allied  with  California.  Most 
Wyoming  citizens  soon  became  totally  blind  to  the  pres- 
ervationist pleas.  They  thought  the  only  obstacle  to  a  dam 
at  Echo  Park  was  California's  insatiable  appetite  for  water. 
They  thought  that  once  again  Wyoming's  interests  were 
being  subordinated  to  powerful  political  forces  that  could 
not  be  controlled. 

Consequently,  Wyomingites  increased  their  crusade 
for  the  Echo  Park  dam  at  the  same  time  that  preserva- 
tionists were  garnering  nationwide  support  to  prevent  it. 
In  June,  1954,  Undersecretary  of  Interior  Tudor  admit- 
ted to  a  House  subcommittee  that  the  Bureau's  evapora- 
tion figures  were  incorrect.  Tudor  said  that  use  of  alter- 
nate sites  would  mean  only  a  loss  of  25,000  additional  acre 
feet  per  year.  This  figure  was  far  below  the  350,000  acre 
feet  figure  which  the  Bureau  had  calculated  in  1950.37 
But  the  Upper  Colorado  River  Commission  stood  firm. 
The  Commission's  engineering  committee  studied  the 
evaporation  rates  and  concluded  that  "it  would  be  unde- 
sirable to  further  confuse  the  issue  by  presenting  differ- 
ent figures  than  those  used  in  the  Bureau's  studies."38  In 
addition,  legal  counsel  John  Will  maintained  that  all  the 
clamor  against  Echo  Park  dam  was  simply  "emotional 
propaganda."39  If  the  Commission  could  publicize  the 
facts,  congressmen  would  no  longer  be  persuaded  by  pres- 
ervationists. The  Commission  soon  instituted  a  publicity 
campaign  to  reach  major  editorial  writers  and  the  Amer- 
ican public. 

The  Commission  and  upper  basin  politicians  realized, 
as  most  Wyoming  residents  and  the  state  press  did  not, 
that  preservationists  presented  the  strongest  opposition 
to  the  legislation.  Breck  Moran,  of  Wyoming's  Natural 
Resource  Board,  wrote  to  Senator  Barrett  that  "without 
Echo  Park  we  fear  the  project  cannot  be  justified,  and 
without  the  project  that  vast  area  of  the  Colorado  water- 
shed in  Wyoming  cannot  develop  its  great  potential."40 
Hence,  the  chief  task  for  the  84th  Congress  centered  on 
Echo  Park,  and  the  preservationists'  concerns.  Wyo- 
ming and  upper  basin  politicians  focused  their  efforts 
on  the  House  of  Representatives,  where  the  crucial  votes 
resided. 

Utah  Senator  Arthur  Watkins,  the  hardest  working 
congressman  for  the  controversial  dam,  addressed  pres- 
ervationist sentiment  in  a  speech  in  March,  1955.  After 
exhaustively  researching  the  issue,  Watkins  argued  that 
the  Echo  Park  dam  could  not  possibly  invade  a  national 
park,  and  whoever  believed  that  it  could  had  been  "mis- 
led and  misinformed."  The  senator  painstakingly  outlined 
the  history  of  Dinosaur  National  Monument,  and  the 
numerous  promises  which  had  been  made  before  Roose- 
velt's proclamation  that  dams  could  still  be  built  in  the 
Green  River  Canyon.  After  researching  through  Interior 
Department  and  Federal  Power  Commission  records,  Wat- 
kins concluded  that  if  anything,  the  National  Monument 
invaded  an  area  reserved  for  dam  construction,  instead 
of  the  other  way  around.  In  fact,  he  said  that  "it  is 
extremely  doubtful  that  the  National  Park  Service  has 

15 


now,  or  ever  has  had,  jurisdiction  over  these  areas,  except 
in  a  subservient  capacity."41 

Watkins  demonstrated  that  eleven  power  withdrawals 
for  dam  sites  had  been  designated  within  the  monument 
by  the  Federal  Power  Commission  and  Secretary  of  Inte- 
rior between  1904  and  1925.  He  argued  that  Roosevelt's 
decree,  which  said  the  new  area  of  Dinosaur  would  be  sub- 
ject "to  all  valid  existing  rights,"  referred  to  dam  site 
withdrawals.  Watkins'  statement  was  long  and  detailed 
and  displayed  such  extensive  research  that  it  justified  all 
of  the  dam  proponents'  stand.  It  injected  new  hope  into 
their  cause.42 

His  research  did  not  go  unchallenged.  Fred  Smith, 
Director  of  the  Council  of  Conservationists,  an  ad  hoc 
committee,  wrote  Watkins  that  he  had  completely  misin- 
terpreted the  spirit  of  Roosevelt's  decree.  Smith  asserted 
that  Roosevelt  meant  to  nullify  all  dam  site  withdrawals. 
Pennsylvania  Representative  John  Saylor  also  attacked 
Watkins'  speech  and  said  power  withdrawals  were  not 
nearly  as  sacred  or  legally  binding  as  Watkins  said  they 
were.  Saylor  said  "valid  existing  rights"  did  not  refer  to 
power  withdrawals,  which  simply  reserved  public  lands 
for  possible  power  development,  without  at  all  guarantee- 
ing that  the  development  would  be  undertaken.43 

For  several  weeks  in  the  84th  Congress,  the  whole  Echo 
Park  controversy  centered  on  Roosevelt's  1938  decree.  Yet 
the  debate  accomplished  little.  Those  who  supported  the 
dam  in  Dinosaur  upheld  Watkins'  interpretation.  Those 
who  feared  for  the  national  park  system  scoffed  at  the  Utah 
senator  and  concurred  with  Saylor  and  Smith.  Wyoming 
politicians  and  newspapers  completely  agreed  with  Wat- 
kins and  thereafter  accused  preservationists  of  ignoring 
the  history  of  the  monument.  Little  had  been  gained.  The 
two  sides  were  as  far  apart  as  ever. 

Wyoming  Senator  Joseph  O'Mahoney  took  a  different 
approach  to  the  Echo  Park  issue.  Congress,  he  said,  should 
not  fear  setting  a  precedent  for  invading  the  national  parks 
because  Dinosaur  was  not  a  park,  but  rather  a  monument. 
He  thought  it  lacked  the  outstanding  qualities  ever  to  be 
designated  a  national  park.  He  said  that  none  of  the 
so-called  great  national  parks— Yellowstone,  Grand  Teton 
or  Glacier  — had  originally  been  national  monuments;  all 
were  created  by  acts  of  Congress  whereas  monuments  were 
created  by  executive  decree.  In  his  mind,  this  was  the  key 
difference  between  these  two  units  of  the  national  park 
system,  and  the  difference  was  vital  to  the  whole  discus- 
sion over  Echo  Park. 

On  April  19,  1955,  Senator  O'Mahoney  debated  with 
Oregon  Senator  Richard  Neuberger,  who  had  introduced 
an  amendment  to  delete  Echo  Park  dam  from  the  Senate 
bill.  "I  venture  to  say,"  O'Mahoney  told  senators,  "that  the 
national  parks  have  not  had  a  more  persistent  defender 
than  I  have  been,  but  when  the  senator  from  Oregon  sug- 
gests that  a  national  monument  created  by  an  Executive 
Order  which  specifically  preserved  existing  rights  would 
set  a  precedent  for  invading  national  parks,  I  say  the  facts 
are  all  against  him."44  In  short,  Echo  Park  dam  could  be 


built  without  harming  the  conscience  of  national  park 
supporters. 

Only  a  handful  of  O'Mahoney's  Wyoming  constituents 
disagreed.  Olaus  Murie,  executive  director  of  the  Wilder- 
ness Society  from  Moose,  Wyoming,  asked  O'Mahoney  how 
he  could  have  forgotten  his  recent  involvement  with  the 
establishment  of  Grand  Teton  National  Park,  which  had 
been  a  national  monument  for  seven  years.  Another  con- 
stituent wrote  to  the  senator  that  "too  frequently  the  wishes 
of  the  masses  are  unheard  because  we  cannot  translate 
emotion  and  esthetic  values  into  figures.  .  .  .  Do  we  always 
have  to  measure  progress  in  terms  of  production  and  popu- 
lation?"45 Yet  such  statements  from  Wyoming  residents 
were  rare  and  most  eagerly  awaited  Congress'  approval 
of  the  Echo  Park  dam. 

The  vote  never  came.  On  June  9th,  1955,  the  House 
Reclamation  Subcommittee  deleted  the  dam  from  its  ver- 
sion of  the  Storage  Project  legislation.  Members  requested 
formulation  of  a  board  of  engineers  to  study  alternate  sites. 
Upper  basin  senators,  such  as  O'Mahoney  and  Barrett, 
still  hoped  the  dam  could  be  reinserted  into  the  bill  in 
conference  committee.  Their  hopes  were  dashed  because 
preservationists'  badgering  of  Congress  delayed  legislation 
for  Echo  Park  dam  throughout  the  1st  session  of  the  84th 
Congress. 

Wyoming's  press  expressed  anger,  and  remained  con- 
vinced that  greedy  Californians  stood  behind  Congress' 
failure  to  enact  the  bill.  While  congressmen  received  a 
flood  of  mail  from  Americans  who  feared  for  the  park 
system,  Wyomingites  remained  unconvinced.  "The  issue 
of  an  invasion  of  national  parks  is  a  complete  phony  and 
was  so  established  by  Senator  Watkins.  .  .  .  The  phony 
issue  is  being  used,  however,  with  some  measure  of  suc- 
cess, to  deprive  the  upper  Colorado  basin  states  of  the 
water  which  originates  in  them  by  preventing  their  devel- 
opment." O'Mahoney  was  disappointed  at  the  subcom- 
mittee's action  and  said  "we  must  sit  on  the  banks  of  the 
stream  and  watch  the  precious  flow  pour  down  the  stream 
to  the  City  of  Los  Angeles,  the  Imperial  Valley,  and  the 
Gulf  of  California."46 

Significantly,  opposition  to  the  whole  Storage  Project 
bill  persisted  even  after  Echo  Park  was  deleted.  Certain 
congressmen  balked  at  the  cost,  while  others  felt  the  bill 
was  an  overly  large  subsidy  to  western  agriculture,  and 
Californians  continued  to  object  out  of  their  concern  for 
water  rights.  This  again  signified  to  Wyomingites  that 
preservationist  strength  had  been  insignificant  through- 
out the  long  controversy.  More  importantly,  the  continu- 
ing delays  confirmed  their  belief  that  Wyoming  would 
always  remain  subordinate  to  powerful  political  factions 
in  Congress.  The  Green  River  Star  wondered  if  it  was  "to 
be  the  fate  of  the  Intermountain  West  to  be  limited  to 
our  present  extent  of  development?  Is  it  to  be  our  fate  to 
watch  our  range  and  our  farms  die  of  lack  of  water?  Are 
we  to  be  forced  to  stand  by  while  the  powerful  East  and 
California  decide  our  future?  It  looks  that  way."47 

The  Thermopolis  Independent  Record  complained 


16 


that  "greedy  easterners  want  to  enjoy  the  prosperity  of  the 
rich  farm  areas  and  high  industrial  concentration  and  hog 
the  income  of  our  public  lands  at  the  same  time."48  At 
no  other  time  did  Wyomingites  express  their  attitudes  so 
.sharply  during  the  whole  debate  over  Echo  Park.  Dele- 
tion of  the  dam  angered  state  residents,  not  so  much 
because    they    resented    preservation,    but    because    it 
reminded  them  of  their  utter  dependence  on  outside  polit- 
ical forces  for  their  own  well  being.  Echo  Park  dam  had 
been  an  opportunity  for  Wyoming  to  improve  its  economy, 
foster  economic  and  political  independence,  and  gain  con- 
•  trol  over  its  most  precious  resource,  water.  They  had  placed 
; great  faith  in  the  dam,  and  certain  eastern  congressmen 
■  had  removed  it  from  the  legislation  with  the  stroke  of  a 
pen. 

Despite  the  loss  of  Echo  Park  dam,  the  controversy 
did  not  end  in  failure  for  Wyoming.  In  1956,  Congress 
,  authorized  the  Colorado  River  Storage  Project  minus  the 
: Dinosaur  dam.  Glen  Canyon  and  Flaming  Gorge  dams 
would  be  the  major  storage  reservoirs  for  the  upper  basin. 
,  Funding  for  Wyoming's  small  reclamation  projects  would 
be  forthcoming.  Southwest  Wyoming  would  soon  benefit 
;  from  hydroelectrical  power  produced  at  Flaming  Gorge. 
(Wyomingites,  if  disappointed,  also  rejoiced  that  Congress 
had  seen  fit  to  authorize  much  needed  federal  reclama- 
tion for  the  state. 

Thus,  Wyomingites  gained  federal  dollars  to  bolster 
the  state's  economy,  but  at  the  same  time  these  dollars 
i  underscored  the  residents'  paradoxical  relationship  with 
the  federal  government.  In  urging  Congress  to  enact  the 
Colorado  Storage  Project,  Wyoming  hoped  to  curtail  fed- 
,eral  interference  over  its  water  rights  and  development. 
But  because  the  residents'  entire  vision  rested  upon  the 
Echo  Park  dam  they  could  not  avoid  the  federal  govern- 
ment's jurisdiction  over  Dinosaur  National  Monument, 
and  those  who  meant  to  see  that  it  was  respected.  This 
paradoxical  situation  exposed  what  was  an  old  problem 
for  the  state  of  Wyoming,  how  to  become  politically  inde- 
pendent and  economically  stable  and  contend  with  fed- 
eral regulations  at  the  same  time.  While  the  federal 
government  has  often  blessed  the  state  with  money  and 
employment  opportunities  it  has  often  done  so  by  inter- 
fering with  what  Wyomingites  consider  to  be  their  rights. 
It  is  a  problem  which  the  Echo  Park  controversy  exposed, 
and  it  is  one  which  has  by  no  means  disappeared  in  the 
state's  attempt  to  make  the  best  use  of  its  water. 


1.  For  accounts  of  the  controversy  see  Roderick  Nash,  Wilderness 
and  the  American  Mind,  2nd  edition,  (New  Haven:  Yale  Univer- 
sity Press,  1967),  pp.  209-219  and  Elmo  Richardson,  Dams,  Parks 
&  Politics,  Resource  Development  and  Preservation  in  the 
Truman-Eisenhower  Era  (Lexington:  The  University  Press  of  Ken- 
tucky, 1973). 

2.  See  T.  A.  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming,  2nd  edition,  (Lincoln: 
University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1978).  pp.  419-423. 

3.  U.S.  Department  of  Interior,  National  Park  Service  Annual 
Report,  in  Annual  Report,  Secretary  of  the  Interior,  1946,  pp. 
307,  323;  U.S.  Department  of  Interior,  The  Colorado  River,  "A 


Natural  Menace  Becomes  A  Natural  Resource,"  A  Comprehen- 
sive Report  on  the  Development  of  the  Water  Resources  of  the 
Colorado  River  Basin  for  Irrigation,  Power  Production,  and  other 
Beneficial  Uses  in  Arizona,  California,  Colorado,  Nevada,  New 
Mexico,  Utah  and  Wyoming,  March  1946,  pp.  11-25. 

4.  Department  of  Interior,  The  Colorado  River,  p.  120;  Clayton  R. 
Koppes,  "Oscar  L.  Chapman:  A  Liberal  at  the  Interior  Depart- 
ment, 1933-1953"  (Ph.D.  dissertation.  University  of  Kansas,  1974), 
p.  343. 

5.  Owen  Stratton  and  Phillip  Sirotkin,  The  Echo  Park  Controver- 
sy, (Interuniversity  Case  Program,  ICP  Case  Series  #46,  Univer- 
sity of  Alabama,  1949),  pp.  23-35. 

6.  "Proceedings  Before  the  United  States  Department  of  the  Interior: 
Hearing  on  Dinosaur  National  Monument,  Echo  Park  and  Split 
Mountain  Dams"  (April  3,  1950),  in  Nash,  Wilderness  and  the 
American  Mind,  pp.  210-211. 

7.  Bernard  DeVoto,  "Shall  We  Let  Them  Ruin  Our  National  Parks?" 
Saturday  Evening  Post,  July  1950,  p.  42. 

8.  U.S.  Grant  III,  "The  Dinosaur  Dams  Are  Not  Needed,"  Living 
Wilderness  15  (Autumn  1950):  17-24. 

9.  Stratton  and  Sirotkin.  Echo  Park  Controversy,  p.  63. 

10.  Elmo  Richardson,  "The  Interior  Secretary  as  Conservation  Villain: 
The  Notorious  Case  of  Douglas  'Giveaway'  McKay,"  Pacific 
Historical  Review  41  (August  1972):  339-342;  Stratton  and  Sirot- 
kin, Echo  Park  Controversy,  p.  69. 

11.  Bishop  to  McKay,  December  21,  1953,  in  "Colorado  River"  file, 
Box  3,  Frank  Barrett  papers,  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums 
and  Historical  Department,  Cheyenne,  Wyoming. 

12.  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming,  pp.  508-509. 

13.  There  is  little  published  literature  on  the  1948  Compact.  See 
Jean  S.  Breitenstein,  "The  Upper  Colorado  River  Basin  Compact," 
State  Government  22  (1949):  214-216,  225.  The  best  source  on 
the  Compact  negotiations  are  the  minutes  of  the  numerous  meet- 
ings: "Official  Record  of  the  Upper  Colorado  River  Basin  Com- 
pact Commission,"  (Denver,  1946),  (Mimeographed)  in  general 
collection,  William  Robertson  Coe  Library,  University  of  Wyo- 
ming. 

14.  Two  major  court  decisions  confirmed  prior  appropriation  as  the 
basis  of  Wyoming's  water  law  in  the  20th  century.  See  Paul  M. 
Holsinger,  "Wyoming  v.  Colorado  Revisited,  The  United  States 
Supreme  Court  and  the  Laramie  River  Controversy,  1911-1922," 
Annals  of  Wyoming  42  (April  1970):  47-56  and  Gordon  Hen- 
drickson,  "Water  Rights  on  the  North  Platte  River:  A  Case  Study 
of  the  Resolutions  and  of  an  Interstate  Water  Conflict"  (Ph.D. 
dissertation,  University  of  Wyoming,   1975). 

15.  See  L.  Clark  Bishop,  "Echo  Park  and  Split  Mountain  Reservoirs, 
Key  Projects  of  Colorado  River  Storage  Project,"  draft  of  January 
31,  1953,  later  published  in  Brand  Book  of  Denver  Westerners, 
in  "Upper  Colorado  River"  file,  Box  202,  Coll.  275,  Joseph  C. 
O'Mahoney  papers,  Western  History  Research  Center,  University 
of  Wyoming,  hereafter  cited  as  O'Mahoney  papers,  WHRC,  UW. 

16.  Leslie  Taylor  to  Harry  Henderson,  March  31,  1954,  in  "Upper  Col- 
orado River  Storage  Project"  file.  Cabinet  IV,  Drawer  III,  Coll. 
631,  Frank  Barrett  papers,  WHRC,  UW,  hereafter  cited  as  Bar- 
rett papers,  WHRC,  UW.  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming,  p.  518; 
C.  J.  Rogers,  U.S.  Congress,  House,  Committee  on  Interior  and 
Insular  Affairs,  Colorado  River  Storage  Project,  Hearings,  before 
a  Subcommittee  on  Irrigation  and  Reclamation,  House  of 
Representatives,  on  H.R.  4449,  4443,  4463,  83rd  Cong.,  2nd  sess., 
1954,  p.  284. 

17  Jack  Scott  to  Barrett,  March  27,  1954,  Barrett  papers,  WHRC, 
UW. 

18.  Official  Record  of  the  Upper  Colorado  River  Commission, 
"Minutes  of  March  20,  1950,"  p.  137,  available  in  general  collec- 
tion, William  Robertson  Coe  Library,  University  of  Wyoming. 

19.  Ibid.,  pp.  129-133;  Bartlett  to  Barrett,  March  31,  1954,  Barrett 
papers,  WHRC,  UW. 

17 


20. 


21 

22. 

23. 
24. 
25. 


26. 
27. 

28 


29. 


30, 


31 


32. 


33. 


John  G.  Will,  "In  the  Matter  of  the  Authorization  of  the  Split 
Mountain  and  Echo  Park  Dams,  In  Connection  With  the  Upper 
Colorado  River  Storage  Project,"  (April  3,  1950),  p.  6, 
(Mimeographed),  in  "Colorado  River"  file,  Box  2,  Coll.  270,  Lester 
Hunt  papers,  WHRC,  UW. 

Brower,  U.S.  Congress,  House,  Colorado  River  Storage  Project 
Hearings,  pp.  795,  824-826. 

Levi  to  New  York  Times,  May  13,  1954;  Munro  to  Sheridan  Press, 
March  19,   1954. 

Casper  Tribune-Herald.  February  8,  1954. 
Ernie  Linford  to  New  York  Times,  January  9.  1954. 
Distrust  of  California  had  also  arisen  during  the  debates  over  the 
1922  Colorado  River  Compact.  See  Norris  Hundley,  Water  and 
the  West,  The  Colorado  River  Compact  and  the  Politics  of  Water 
in  the  American  West  (Berkeley:  University  of  California  Press, 
1975),  p.   170. 

Richardson,  Dams,  Parks  &  Politics,  pp.  138-139. 
U.S.  Congress,  House,  83rd  Cong.,  1st  sess. ,  January  6,  1953,  Con- 
gressional Record  99:140. 

Roscoe  Fleming,  "Dam  Foes  Tweet  Alarm,"  Denver  Post,  March 
11,  1953;  Moran  to  Barrett,  February  5,  1954,  in  Barrett  papers, 
WHRC,  UW. 

Brower,  "Dinosaurs,  Parks,  and  Dams,"  The  Pacific  Spectator  8 
(Spring  1954):  158;  Harrison,  U.S.  Congress,  House,  83rd  Cong., 
2nd  sess.,  May  19,  1954,  Congressional  Record  100:6877. 
New  York  Times,  March  22,  1954;  a  copy  of  the  report  may  be 
found  in  U.S.  Congress,  Senate,  Committee  on  Interior  and  Insu- 
lar Affairs,  Colorado  River  Storage  Project,  Hearings,  before  a 
Subcommittee  on  Irrigation  and  Reclamation,  Senate,  on  S.  1555, 
83rd  Cong.,  2nd  sess.,  1954.  pp.  617-624. 

Kuchel,  U.S.  Congress,  Senate,  Committee  on  Interior  and  Insular 
Affairs.  Report  #1983,  "Authorizing  the  Secretary  of  the  Interior 
to  Construct,  Operate,  and  Maintain  the  Colorado  River  Storage 
Project  and  Participating  Projects,"  83rd  Cong.,  2nd  sess.,  July 
26,  1954,  p.  25. 

John  G.  Will,  "Comments  on  Senator  Kuchel's  Minority  Views," 
in  Barrett  papers,  WHRC,  UW. 

The  state  of  California  had  officially  asked  the  Supreme  Court 
to  make  the  upper  basin  states  a  party  to  the  lawsuit.  See  Hundley, 
Water  and  the  West,  ch.  9,  for  a  complete  discussion  of  Arizona 
v.  California;  Kuchel,  U.S.  Congress,  Senate,  Report  #1983,  p. 
26;  Will,  Official  Record  of  the  Upper  Colorado  River  Commis- 
sion, "Minutes  of  September  20,  1954,"  p.  16. 


34 


35 


36 


37 


Johnson,  U.S.  Congress,  House,  Colorado  River  Storage  Project, 
Hearings,  p.  298. 

Wayne  Aspinall,  U.S.  Congress,  House,  83rd  Cong.,  2nd  sess., 
August  16,  1954,  Congressional  Record  100:14700. 
Casper  Tribune-Herald,  August  29,  1954;  Sheridan  Press,  March 
12,  1954. 

Washington  Post,  June  6,  1954.  Still,  Tudor's  discovery  of  the  error 
in  evaporation  figures  did  not  cause  him  to  change  his  mind  about 
Echo  Park  dam.  If  Glen  Canyon  dam  were  built  higher  than 
originally  proposed,  Echo  Park  could  be  eliminated  with  not  much 
additional  evaporation.  But  Tudor  told  the  Senate  hearings  that 
"a  higher  Glen  Canyon  Dam  is  not  an  acceptable  alternative.  The 
storage  it  provides  is  at  the  extreme  lower  end  of  the  upper  basin 
and  would,  therefore,  be  very  substantially  less  effective  than 
upstream  storage."  See  Tudor,  U.S.  Congress,  Senate,  Colorado 
River  Storage  Project,  Hearings,  p.  48. 

J.  R.  Riter,  Official  Record  of  the  Upper  Colorado  River  Com- 
mission, "Minutes  of  November  7,  1954,"  p.  33. 
Will,  Official  Record  of  the  Upper  Colorado  River  Commission, 
"Minutes  of  September  20,  1954,"  pp.  1213. 
Moran  to  Barrett,  March  22,  1954,  Barrett  papers.  WHRC,  UW. 
U.S.  Congress,  Senate,  "The  Dinosaur  National  Monument  and 
the  Colorado  River  Storage  Project,"  84th  Cong.,  1st  sess.,  March 
28,  1955,  Congressional  Record  101:3806-3810. 
Ibid  ,  p.  3812. 

43.    Smith  to  Watkins,  April  16,  1955,  in  Barrett  papers,  WHRC,  UW; 
Saylor,  "National  Park  System  Threatened,"  84th  Cong.,  1st  sess., 
June  8,  1955,  Congressional  Record  101:7919. 
U.S.  Congress,  Senate,  84th  Cong.,  1st  sess.,  April  19,  1955,  Con- 
gressional Record  101:4654. 

Harold  Hagen  to  O'Mahoney,  February  5,  1955,  and  Murie  to 
O'Mahoney,  May  10,  1955,  in  O'Mahoney  papers,  WHRC,  UW. 
See  also  Gregory  O.  Kendrick,  "An  Environmental  Spokesman: 
Olaus  J.  Murie  and  a  Democratic  Defense  of  Wilderness,"  (M.A. 
thesis,  University  of  Wyoming,  1977),  pp.  136-138  and  Robert 
Righter,  Crucible  for  Conservation:  The  Creation  of  Grand  Teton 
National  Park  (Boulder,  Colorado:  Colorado  Associated  Univer^ 
sity  Press,  1982),  pp.  103-125. 

46.  Casper  Tribune-Herald,  June  16,  1955;  O'Mahoney  to  David  Scoll, 
July  2,  1955,  in  O'Mahoney  papers,  WHRC,  UW. 

47.  Star,  reprinted  in  Casper  Tribune-Herald,  July  17,  1955. 

48.  Record,  reprinted  in  Casper  Tribune-Herald,  October  23,  1955. 


38 

39. 

40 
11. 

42 


44 


45 


18 


The  Quest  for 

Settlement  in 

Early  Wyoming 


The  drive  to  attract  population  has  been  a  constant 
theme  throughout  the  history  of  the  Rocky  Mountain 
West.  Despite  its  spectacular  mountain  scenery,  the  region's 
high  altitude,  incessant  wind,  and  extreme  aridity  has 
often  made  it  seem  less  than  hospitable  to  prospective  set- 
tlers. Wyoming  has  always  appeared  particularly  forbid- 
ding to  people  unaccustomed  to  the  expansive  high  plains. 
Shortly  after  the  completion  of  the  transcontinental  rail- 
road in  1869,  one  traveler  captured  the  feelings  of  many 
observers  in  describing  the  Wyoming  prairie  as  "the  Great 
American  Desert— a  vast  barren  basin,  utterly  destitute 
of  life,  devoid  of  living  streams,  a  Sahara  without  a  single 
relieving  oasis,  truly,  the  Valley  of  the  Shadow  of  Death."1 
Such  dreary  accounts  discouraged  settlement  throughout 
Wyoming  and  the  West.  Hoping  to  offset  such  negative 
publicity,  Wyoming  officials  soon  realized  the  necessity 
of  actively  seeking  immigration. 

Immediately  following  the  organization  of  Wyoming 


Territory  in  1869,  the  first  legislative  assembly  launched 
the  campaign  to  attract  immigrants.  The  requirement  that 
states  attain  a  population  of  sixty  thousand  before  applying 
for  statehood  accentuated  the  need  for  growth.  Gover- 
nor John  A.  Campbell  advised  the  legislators  of  the  need 
for  new  population.  He  believed  that  anyone  who  might 
contribute  to  Wyoming's  resource  development  should  be 
enticed  to  come.  While  he  acknowledged  that  permanent 
settlers  were  the  most  desirable,  he  asked  the  legislators 
to  "remember  that  all  labor  is  profitable,  and  that  all 
immigrants  of  whatever  nationality,  who  will  aid  us  in  the 
development  of  the  resources  of  our  territory,  should  be 
aided  and  encouraged  to  come  amongst  us."2  To  further 
such  a  purpose,  Governor  Campbell  advocated  the  crea- 
tion of  a  bureau  of  statistics  to  collect  and  distribute  all 
information  pertaining  to  Wyoming's  resources.3 

Despite  Governor  Campbell's  request,  the  legislature 
did  not  appropriate  money  for  a  bureau  of  statistics. 

19 


Instead,  the  legislature  decided  that  a  women's  suffrage 
act  might  well  serve  to  attract  attention  and  population 
to  Wyoming  at  no  expense.4  The  women's  suffrage  bill 
proved  to  be  an  economical  way  to  publicize  the  territory 
in  the  East,  especially  following  the  selection  of  female 
justices  of  the  peace  and  jurors  in  Wyoming.5  Regarding 
population,  however,  the  Rocky  Mountain  News  reported 
that  women's  suffrage  drew  to  Wyoming  "a  few  hundred 
from  down  east;  but  alas!  The  country  is  as  barren  as 
before,  and  the  barreness  [sic]  is  steadily  increasing  for 
the  new  accessions  to  the  population  have  invariably  been 
old  maids  and  unaffiliated  grass-widows."6  Population  sta- 
tistics confirm  this  account.  The  vote  simply  did  not 
attract  thousands  of  Eastern  suffragettes  to  the  prairies 
of  Wyoming. 

In  the  meantime,  immigration  had  taken  on  a  new 
urgency  following  a  proposal  made  by  President  Ulysses 
Grant  in  1872.  Grant  favored  dividing  Wyoming  Territory 
into  four  sections  and  then  distributing  the  sections 
between  Colorado,  Utah,  Idaho,  and  Montana.7  Although 
Congress  did  not  adopt  the  proposal,  Governor  Camp- 
bell spoke  with  renewed  vigor  when  he  asked  the  1873  leg- 
islature to  create  some  sort  of  bureau  of  immigration. 
According  to  Campbell,  other  territories  outstripped  Wyo- 
ming in  terms  of  wealth  and  population  simply  because 
they  were  more  diligent  in  advertising  their  advantages. 
He  told  the  legislature  that  "the  adoption  of  such  mea- 
sures as  will  bring  to  our  own  people,  as  well  as  to  non-resi- 
dents, a  knowledge  of  the  almost  unlimited  resources  of 
Wyoming  appears  to  me  to  be  your  imperative  duty."8 
Given  the  exigency  of  the  request,  the  legislators  agreed 
to  appropriate  $4000  to  cover  the  expenses  of  a  Board  of 
Immigration  and  a  Commissioner  of  Immigration.  In 
1874,  the  newly  created  Board  published  a  promotional 
pamphlet  entitled  The  Territory  of  Wyoming:  Its  History, 
Soil,  Climate,  Resources,  etc.9  Despite  this  promising  start, 
the  Board  would  be  short-lived. 

In  1875,  John  M.  Thayer,  the  newly-appointed  gover- 
nor, asked  the  legislature  to  repeal  the  act  which  had  estab- 
lished the  Board  of  Immigration.  As  justification,  he 
pointed  to  "the  present  state  of  our  agricultural  depart- 
ment, and  the  uncertainty  of  the  market  for  labor  amongst 
us."10  He  may  also  have  been  motivated  by  a  need  for  fiscal 
cutbacks  during  a  time  of  economic  stagnation  in  Wyo- 
ming." In  either  event,  the  legislature  willingly  complied 
with  the  governor's  request. 

With  no  further  money  available  to  encourage  immi- 
gration, territorial  officials  hoped  that  the  annual  report 
of  the  governor  to  the  Secretary  of  the  Interior  in  Wash- 
ington would  fulfill  the  same  purpose.  The  Department 
of  the  Interior  had  begun  administrating  the  territories 
of  the  United  States  in  1878,  requiring  each  territorial  gov- 
ernor to  submit  an  annual  report.  These  reports  often 
included  information  pertaining  to  the  territory's  resources 
and  progress.  A  few  thousand  extra  copies  were  printed 
each  year  for  distribution  to  potential  immigrants.12 

These  initial  efforts  to  attract  population  to  Wyoming 


failed  to  achieve  great  success.  Several  factors  serve  to 
explain  the  lack  of  immigration  during  the  1870s.  Most 
published  reports  written  by  Union  Pacific  travelers 
described  Wyoming  as  a  barren  wasteland.  Furthermore, 
the  severe  winter  of  1871-72  caused  many  potential  immi- 
grants to  discount  previous  reports  describing  Wyoming's 
mild  climate.  Finally,  Wyoming  newspaper  editors  often 
published  exaggerated  accounts  of  Indian  dangers,  hop- 
ing to  pressure  the  federal  government  into  launching  mil- 
itary campaigns.  These  exaggerated  reports  received  con- 
siderable publicity  in  Eastern  newspapers,  thus  acting  as 
a  further  deterrent  to  immigration.13 

Despite  the  lack  of  success  encountered  during  the 
1870s  by  those  interested  in  attracting  people  to  Wyoming, 
the  search  for  settlers  continued.  In  the  late  1870s,  some 
prominent  Wyoming  citizens  argued  that  the  predomi- 
nance of  the  cattle  industry  prevented  population  growth 
by  precluding  farming.  In  1879,  Governor  John  W.  Hoyt 
commented  in  his  message  to  the  legislature,  "The  pres- 
ent growth  of  our  population  is  slow.  It  is  necessary  that 
it  should  be  so  long  as  the  stock  business  is  not  only  the 
leading  interest  — as  perhaps  it  always  will  be  — but  in  fact 
the  only  productive  industry  carried  on  to  any  considerable 
extent."  Hoyt  believed  that  the  power  of  the  cattle  industry 
explained  the  failure  of  the  now  inoperative  board  of 
immigration.14 

In  fact,  ranchers  were  not  enthusiastic  about  the  possi- 
bility of  small  farmers  settling  in  Wyoming.  The  presence 
of  settlers  posed  a  number  of  problems  for  the  cattle 
barons.  Settlers  usually  occupied  prime  land  along  streams 
in  order  to  secure  water  for  irrigation.  These  homesteads 
were  often  fenced,  thus  breaking  up  the  open  range  and 
barring  the  cattle  from  the  streams.  Furthermore,  the  set- 
tlers had  a  legal  advantage  over  the  cattlemen  because 
the  intent  of  the  homestead  laws  had  been  to  provide  pro- 
spective farmers  with  fee  simple  land  titles,  while  ranchers 
ran  cattle  on  the  public  domain  without  establishing  title.15 

Perhaps  more  important  than  the  practical  problems 
which  settlers  presented  to  ranchers  was  the  supposed 
moral  superiority  of  the  small  rural  farmer's  livelihood. 
In  connection  with  the  rhetoric  of  national  expansion, 
Americans  developed  a  hierarchical  concept  of  proper 
land  use  which  granted  farming  precedence  over  grazing 
and  hunting  and  gathering.  William  E.  Smythe  reflects 
this  bias  when  he  argued  in  The  Conquest  of  Arid 
A  merica  that  ranching  is  a  "pursuit  which  does  not  develop 
the  higher  possibilities  of  the  country,  either  in  a  material 
or  a  social  way,  and  so  long  as  its  influence  strongly  dom- 
inated the  life  of  the  community,  Wyoming  did  not  fur- 
nish an  attractive  field  for  settlers."  "There  was  a  time," 
continued  Smythe,  "when  prominent  men  actually  depre- 
cated the  growth  of  population,  and  boldly  asserted  that 
brute  cattle  were  more  to  be  welcomed  than  men,  women, 
and  children  in  that  sparsely  settled  empire."16 

Thomas  Moonlight  also  believed  in  the  superiority  of 
the  small  farmer's  lifestyle.  He  worked  to  weaken  the  influ- 
ence of  the  Wyoming  cattlemen  after  assuming  the  terri- 


20 


torial  governorship  in  1887.  Moonlight  was  a  granger  with 
a  veneration  for  the  small  homestead.  He  felt  that  Wyo- 
ming would  never  attract  a  large  population  until  large- 
scale  ranching  was  replaced  by  an  agricultural  system 
based  on  small  farms.  In  his  annual  report  for  1887  Moon- 
light proclaimed,  "The  first  great  demand,  then,  in  the 
way  of  population  is  farmers,  practical,  everyday  farmers, 
who  will  put  their  hands  to  the  plow  and  not  look  back."17 
He  further  noted  that  the  residents  of  Wyoming  had  been 
unsympathetic  to  an  increase  in  settlers  while  cattle  inter- 
ests dominated  the  territory,  but  now  "the  bars  are  down; 
the  land  is  open;  and  where  it  is  not  open,  those  holding 
it  are  willing  and  anxious  to  sell  .  .  ."18  While  the  cattle- 
men's willingness  to  sell  might  be  more  readily  explained 
by  the  disastrous  financial  losses  they  had  suffered  dur- 
ing the  severe  1886-87  winter,  Moonlight's  views  offer  evi- 
dence of  the  pressure  being  brought  to  bear  against  the 
territory's  ranching  community. 

Convinced  that  Wyoming's  promotional  efforts  were 
undermined  by  the  cattle  interests,  Moonlight  lamented 
that  "there  has  been  no  organized  or  systematized  effort 
made  by  the  Territorial  authorities  to  secure  immigra- 
tion."19 Moonlight  believed  that  Wyoming  had  agricultural 
potential,  but  the  territory  had  been  misrepresented  to 
prospective  farmers.  Settlers  would  remain  ignorant  of  the 
potential  until  the  legislature  established  a  promotional 
bureau  not  controlled  by  cattlemen.20 

Although  Wyoming's  efforts  to  attract  settlement 
did  not  satisfy  such  men  as  Thomas  Moonlight,  in  1889 
a  major  step  was  taken.  With  a  population  reported  to 
be  in  excess  of  60,000,  Wyoming  produced  a  constitu- 
tion and  soon  successfully  fulfilled  the  requirements 
for  statehood.  However,  the  population  remained  tiny  for 
the  huge  98,000  square  mile  state.  Wyoming's  first  state 
governor,  Francis  E.  Warren,  a  prominent  rancher  and 
politician,  suggested  a  number  of  measures  to  aid  the 
infant  state's  quest  for  immigration.  In  his  1890  legisla- 
tive message,  Warren  announced  that  more  than  10,000 
copies  of  the  promotional  pamphlet  entitled  "Resources 
of  Wyoming"  had  been  distributed  throughout  the  states, 
territories,  and  foreign  countries.  State  officials  had 
also  printed  and  distributed  4,000  copies  of  maps  show- 
ing the  mineral  resources  of  Wyoming.21  Finally,  War- 
ren advocated  that  Wyoming  complete  an  exhibition  for 
the  1892  World's  Fair  to  advertise  the  state's  advan- 
tages.22 Unfortunately,  the  state  publication  fund  was 
quickly  exhausted  and  no  further  money  was  made  avail- 
able.23 

Warren's  public  efforts  were  somewhat  tainted  by  his 
private  actions.  In  1891,  having  resigned  his  gubernato- 
rial position  to  join  the  United  States  Senate,  Warren  was 
charged  with  harassing  settlers  homesteading  in  the  vicin- 
ity of  his  land.  He  was  accused  of  ordering  his  sheepherders 
to  drive  settlers  out  of  territory  adjoining  his  ranges,  or 
forcing  them  to  sell  at  minimum  prices.24  Perhaps  reflect- 
ing his  ranching  background,  Warren  had  not  resolved 
a  personal  conflict  between  public  good  and  private  profit. 


The  issue  reached  a  climax  with  the  onset  of  the  John- 
son County  War.  While  the  Johnson  County  War  is  often 
portrayed  as  a  dispute  between  large  and  small  ranchers, 
the  incident  also  represented  a  feud  between  ranchers  and 
settlers.  Ranchers  were  outraged  when  settlers  home- 
steaded  on  land  which  had  previously  been  used  exclu- 
sively for  cattle  grazing.  In  April  of  1892,  a  party  of  cat- 
tlemen, stock  detectives,  and  hired  gunfighters  gathered 
together  in  Cheyenne  and  headed  north  to  Johnson  County 
to  subdue  the  settlers  and  small  ranchers.25  The  party  of 
"invaders"  boasted  that  ninety  percent  of  Wyoming's  citi- 
zens supported  their  efforts,  but  they  soon  found  that  they 
faced  overwhelming  public  opposition.26  In  the  end,  a 
detachment  of  United  States  cavalry  and  infantry  were 
dispatched  to  the  TA  Ranch  south  of  Buffalo  to  save  the 
invaders  from  being  massacred  by  a  heavily-armed  throng 
of  settlers.  While  this  setback  did  not  mark  the  end  of 
large-scale  cattle  ranching  in  Wyoming,  the  cattlemen  did 
lose  much  of  their  previous  political  power.  At  the  same 
time,  small  ranchers  and  farmers  had  won  the  right  to 
live  in  Wyoming  in  peace.27 

With  the  political  strength  of  the  cattlemen  somewhat 
curtailed,  state  officials  began  to  orient  their  promotional 
activities  around  Wyoming's  farming  potential.  The  state's 
concern  with  farming  reflects  popular  ideas  which  pre- 
vailed around  the  turn  of  the  century.  Such  groups  as  the 
so-called  urban  agrarians  expressed  reverence  for  farm- 
ers as  a  means  of  criticizing  the  social  and  political  changes 
connected  with  the  rapid  growth  of  America's  industrial 
cities.28  These  neo-Jeffersonian  groups  believed  that  the 
Republic's  safety  rested  with  the  self-reliant  farmers  who 
would  protect  national  values  from  the  incipient  urban 
radicals.29 

As  groups  like  the  urban  agrarians  promoted  the  vir- 
tues of  farm  life  at  the  national  level,  Governor  Bryant 
B.  Brooks  began  actively  working  to  lure  farmers  to  Wyo- 
ming after  taking  office  in  1905.  He  reported  to  the  1907 
legislature  that  reclamation  and  dry  farming  would  double 
the  state's  population  in  a  few  years.30  His  office  issued 
a  promotional  publication  entitled  The  State  of  Wyoming 
which  offered  a  general  overview  of  the  resources  of  the 
state.31  This  masterful  piece  of  state  advertisement  pro- 
claimed that  Wyoming  offered  10,000,000  acres  subject 
to  irrigation  and  cultivation,  48,000,000  acres  subject 
to  entry  under  United  States  land  laws,  and  the  "finest 
trout  fishing  known  to  mortal  man."32  When  writing  his 
memoirs  in  the  late  1930s,  Brooks  proudly  recalled  that 
"agricultural  interests  were  chiefly  responsible  for  the  influx 
of  approximately  15,000  new  settlers  in  Wyoming  in 
1909. "33 

The  legislature  also  revived  the  Board  of  Immigra- 
tion during  Governor  Brooks'  administration.  The  Board 
consisted  of  the  Commissioner  of  Public  Lands,  the  State 
Geologist,  and  the  State  Engineer.  These  three  men  had 
"jurisdiction  over  all  matters  pertaining  to  the  advertise- 
ment of  Wyoming  and  the  attraction  of  settlers  and  inves- 
tors."  The  legislature  further  required  the   Board  "to 

21 


collect,  compile,  and  distribute  reliable  information  in 
regard  to  the  various  resources  of  the  state  and  to  employ 
advertising  agents  to  carry  out  such  work  as  shall  dem- 
onstrate the  agricultural  and  other  possibilities  of  Wyo- 
ming .  .  ,"34  During  1907  and  1908,  the  Board  published 
numerous  promotional  pamphlets,  provided  aid  in  con- 
structing the  Wyoming  Industrial  Exhibit  in  Cheyenne, 
and  sent  a  display  to  the  National  Corn  Exhibition  in 
Omaha.35 

The  1909  legislature  provided  the  Board  with  ample 
financial  resources,  allowing  for  extensive  promotional 
activities  during  the  next  few  years.  Part  of  the  money  went 
toward  printing  a  new  pamphlet  entitled  "Wonderful  Wyo- 
ming." State  representatives  then  distributed  copies  of  the 
pamphlet  at  the  Chicago  Land  Show  and  the  National 
Corn  Show  in  Omaha.  Also  in  1908,  Wyoming  sent  an 
agricultural  exhibit  to  the  Nebraska,  Iowa,  and  Illinois 
state  fairs  and  to  the  exposition  at  Knoxville,  Tennessee. 
Finally,  the  Board  sent  Governor  Brooks  and  Congressman 
Frank  Mondell  to  deliver  addresses  to  the  National  Farm 
Land  Congress  held  in  Chicago.36 

Mondell  also  supported  legislation  designed  to  attract 
settlers.  Largely  because  of  his  efforts,  Congress  passed 
the  Homestead  Act  of  1909.  This  act  increased  the  amount 
of  free  land  available  to  homesteaders  from  160  to  320 
acres.37  The  act  further  specified  that  farm  land  which 
had  previously  been  locked  up  in  mineral  reserves  would 
be  opened  to  homesteaders  with  the  stipulation  that  the 
federal  government  would  retain  the  mineral  rights  to  the 
land.38  Such  inducements  brought  a  number  of  aspiring 
dry  farmers  to  Wyoming.39 

As  a  consequence  of  the  promotional  efforts  of  the 
Board  of  Immigration  and  the  passage  of  the  Homestead 
Act  of  1909,  Wyoming's  population  increased  substantially 
during  the  first  decade  of  the  20th  century.  Over  50,000 
new  residents  settled  in  Wyoming  between  1900  and  1910, 
a  population  gain  of  almost  58  percent.40  This  growth 
failed  to  satisfy  everyone.  State  immigration  agent  W.  T. 
Judkin  wrote  in  1910  that  Idaho,  Washington,  and  Oregon 
had  attracted  the  majority  of  new  settlers.  He  attributed 
the  growth  of  the  Northwest  to  the  fact  that  "these  peo- 
ple are  making  more  of  an  effort  to  get  the  home  seeker, 
they  make  liberal  appropriations,  get  out  vast  amounts 
of  literature,  and  see  that  it  gets  before  the  right  kind  of 
people  .  .  ."41  Judkin  exhorted  Wyoming  promoters  to 
adopt  similar  practices. 

Newly  elected  governor  Joseph  M.  Carey  also  believed 
that  the  state  could  do  more  to  secure  immigrants.  Call- 
ing immigration  "the  greatest  of  all  the  needs  of  the  state," 
Carey  told  the  1911  legislature  that  "the  matter  is  so  urgen 
[sic]  and  important  that  it  cannot  without  grave  conse- 
quences to  our  progress  as  a  state  be  neglected  or  even 
postponed  to  a  future  session."42  The  legislature  responded 
by  appropriating  $40,000  to  the  Board  of  Immigra- 
tion.43 

No  longer  impeded  by  lack  of  money,  the  Board 
launched  an  accelerated  program.  More  than  1,000,000 

22 


people  visited  the  Wyoming  booth  placed  on  display  at 
the  Pittsburgh,  New  York,  and  Chicago  land  shows  of  1911. 
The  Board  staffed  the  booth  with  special  representatives 
prepared  to  answer  questions  about  the  state.44 

Believing  that  Eastern  and  Midwestern  newspapers 
only  published  information  detrimental  to  the  image  of 
Wyoming,  the  Board  sponsored  a  tour  for  newspaper  writ- 
ers, seeking  to  show  them  the  state's  scenic,  agricultural, 
and  industrial  highlights.  State  officials  then  asked  the 
correspondents  "to  write  the  truth  as  they  saw  it  concern- 
ing what  Wyoming  had  to  offer  to  the  homeseeker,  inves- 
tor, or  capitalist."45  Following  the  tour,  Wyoming  articles 
appeared  in  numerous  publications,  including  the  Wash- 
ington Post,  New  York  Tribune,  Boston  Transcript,  Chi- 
cago Examiner,  and  Los  Angeles  Tribune.46 

Also  in  1911,  the  Board  appropriated  $500  per  month 
for  newspaper,  magazine,  and  farm  journal  advertising. 
The  Board  hired  the  National  Advertising  Company  to 
direct  the  promotional  campaign.  Hoping  to  lure  farmers 
to  the  state,  advertising  efforts  were  focused  on  the 
Midwest.  Advertisements  appeared  under  headings  such 
as  the  following:  "Wyoming  an  Ideal  Place  for  Dairymen," 
"Wyoming  Wants  10,000  Farmers,"  and  "Big  Money  Rais- 
ing Hogs  in  Wyoming."  The  advertisements  resulted  in 
inquiries  from  every  state  in  the  Union  and  from  14  foreign 
countries.  The  majority  of  the  inquiries  came  from  Illinois, 
Pennsylvania,  and  New  York.47 

The  Board  additionally  engaged  in  publishing  a  vari- 
ety of  promotional  pamphlets.  The  pamphlets  emphasized 
the  farming,  oil,  mineral,  stock  growing,  and  manufac- 
turing prospects  of  the  state.  In  particular,  the  Board 
hoped  to  take  advantage  of  the  expressed  interest  in  home- 
steading  in  Wyoming.  In  response  to  inquiries  concern- 
ing the  proper  method  for  obtaining  public  land,  immi- 
gration officials  published  20,000  copies  of  a  pamphlet 
entitled  "Free  Government  Lands  in  Wyoming,  and  How 
to  Obtain  Title  to  Them."  This  pamphlet  offered  a  synop- 
sis of  the  land  laws  applicable  to  Wyoming,  as  well  as  a 
statement  regarding  the  quality  of  land  in  several  state- 
wide districts.48 

Despite  this  unprecedented  flurry  of  promotional 
activity,  the  1913  legislature  had  reservations  about  the 
Board.  Drought  in  1910  and  1911  had  led  to  widespread 
crop  failures  throughout  the  state  causing  a  drastic  reduc- 
tion in  acreage  assessed  as  dry-farm  lands.49  This  reduc- 
tion no  doubt  induced  many  legislators  to  question  the 
practicality  of  appropriating  funds  to  advertise  the  state's 
farming  opportunities.  The  legislature  did  not  approve 
of  Board  of  Immigration  Commissioner  Roy  W.  Schenk's 
Progressive  politics.  Some  skeptics  claimed  that  the  pro- 
motion was  mainly  designed  to  benefit  Governor  Carey 
by  attracting  homesteaders  willing  to  invest  in  the  Carey- 
sponsored  Wheatland  irrigation  project.  Other  legislators 
charged  that  too  much  of  the  promotional  campaign  was 
directed  toward  the  East,  whereas  the  Midwest  offered 
better  immigration  prospects.  In  the  wake  of  these 
accusations,  the  legislature  appropriated  nothing  for  the 


continuation  of  the  Board  of  Immigration.50  Once  again, 
the  state  was  left  without  an  official  agency  to  coordinate 
efforts  for  securing  immigration. 

The  Board  of  Immigration  remained  inactive 
throughout  the  World  War  I  years,  but  in  1919  Governor 
Robert  D.  Carey  convinced  the  legislature  to  revive  the 
Board.51  Immigration  Commissioner  Charles  S.  Hill 
reported  in  1920  that  promotional  efforts  had  been  ham- 
pered by  the  drought  of  1919  and  the  railroad's  decision 
to  discontinue  reduced  excursion  fares  for  homeseekers 
and  tourists.  Nevertheless,  Commissioner  Hill  proudly 
announced  that  "Wyoming  experienced  an  undreamed 
of  influx  of  new  citizens"  following  the  war.52  The  Board 
remained  active  in  distributing  literature  pertaining  to 
state  resources.  Hill  displayed  a  willingness  to  follow  the 
advice  of  earlier  critics  when  he  reported  that  advertis- 
ing had  been  directed  at  the  states  of  Nebraska,  Kansas, 
Iowa,  the  Dakotas,  Montana,  Utah,  Idaho,  Colorado, 
Oklahoma,  Texas,  Missouri,  Illinois,  and  Indiana  "where 
experience  has  taught  that  it  is  reasonable  to  expect  the 
greatest  results."53  The  Board  also  claimed  direct  respon- 
sibility for  attracting  hundreds  of  former  servicemen  to 
the  state.  World  War  I  veterans  were  enticed  by  a  guar- 
anteed 60-day  preferential  right  when  filing  for  irrigated 
farm  land  opened  under  the  Shoshone  and  North  Platte 
reclamation  projects.54 

Although  state  officials  continued  to  promote  farm- 
ing, tourism  had  become  an  important  immigration  com- 
ponent by  1920.  Commissioner  Hill  noted  the  economic 
benefits  which  tourism  offered.  He  commented  that 
increased  automobile  and  motorcycle  travel  pointed  to  the 
necessity  of  improved  highways.  The  automobile  had 
helped  draw  more  tourists  to  Yellowstone  National  Park 


ivmi ;  1 1 ;  fd  n :  i  »ei  fthihmct^ 


wyoM- 


MS  ■  H 


IU  IS  6: 


Boosters  took  fruit  and  vegetable  displays  to  fairs  through- 
out the  nation  to  promote  the  virtues  of  Wyoming  agricul- 
ture. This  display  was  shown  at  the  Chicago  Land  Show 
in  1922. 


and  other  summer  resorts.  Following  a  request  from  Com- 
missioner Hill,  the  Forest  Service  began  publishing  a 
weekly  bulletin  concerning  fishing  in  Wyoming  which 
appeared  in  all  the  Wyoming  and  Denver  daily  news- 
papers.55 The  third,  and  final,  biennial  report  of  the 
Board  of  Immigration,  published  in  1923,  is  devoted 
largely  to  extolling  the  value  of  tourism.56  Whereas  the 
Board  had  originally  been  conceived  to  lure  permanent 
settlers  to  the  state,  by  1923  Wyoming  was  satisfied  to  lure 
the  transient. 

After  1923,  the  Board  of  Immigration  would  never 
again  be  resurrected  in  Wyoming.  A  number  of  factors 
contributed  to  the  Board's  demise.  At  the  national  level, 
America  witnessed  a  sharp  increase  in  nativistic  sentiments 
in  the  years  after  World  War  I.  The  proliferation  of  nativ- 
ism  was,  in  part,  a  reaction  to  the  rapid  growth  of  Amer- 
ica's European  immigrant  population.  Between  1905  and 
1915,  ten  million  Europeans  immigrated  to  the  United 
States.57  Most  of  the  immigrants  came  from  eastern  and 
southern  Europe  and  were  therefore  labeled  non-Nordics. 
Many  of  the  arriving  Europeans  were  poorly  educated, 
unskilled  laborers  who  practiced  either  the  Roman  Catho- 
lic, Greek  Orthodox,  or  Jewish  religions  — characteristics 
which  did  not  endear  them  to  most  native  Americans.58 
Some  Americans  held  the  view  that  immigrants  should 
be  discouraged  from  settling  in  scantily  populated  states 
like  Wyoming  because  rural  isolation  tended  to  perpet- 
uate old  country  traditions  and  hinder  assimilation.59  The 
hostility  toward  immigrants  culminated  in  the  Quota  Law 
of  1921  and  the  Immigration  Act  of  1924  which  aimed 
to  limit  the  number  of  eastern  and  southern  Europeans 
allowed  into  the  United  States.60  The  influence  of  nativism 
no  doubt  led  many  Wyomingites  to  question  the  contin- 
ued existence  of  an  immigration  board. 

The  onset  of  depression  in  Wyoming  was  perhaps  the 
most  important  factor  deterring  the  state  from  continuing 
efforts  to  attract  settlement.  Although  the  nation  as  a 
whole  prospered  during  the  early  twenties,  economic  hard 
times  struck  agriculture,  coal  mining,  and  petroleum 
interests.  Given  the  importance  of  agriculture,  coal,  and 
oil  to  the  state's  economy,  the  depression  hit  Wyoming 
earlier  than  elsewhere.  Deflation  and  the  1919  drought 
caused  setbacks  in  the  livestock  business.  Although  Wyo- 
ming homesteading  peaked  in  1920  and  1921,  the  com- 
bination of  drought  and  low  prices  for  farm  products  led 
to  a  steep  decline  in  homestead  entries  during  the 
remainder  of  the  twenties.  National  coal  strikes  resulted 
in  declining  wages  and  unemployment  in  Wyoming's  coal 
mines.61  In  response  to  the  depression,  the  state  govern- 
ment initiated  austerity  programs.  In  1923,  Governor  Wil- 
liam B.  Ross  requested  that  the  legislature  consider  abol- 
ishing departments  "the  expense  of  which  could  be  greatly 
curtailed  without  any  very  serious  loss  to  the  state."  The 
legislators  agreed  with  the  suggestion  that  the  Board  of 
Immigration  be  eliminated. 6Z' 

Despite  the  rather  inglorious  death  of  the  Board  of 
Immigration,   a  50-year  drive  to  encourage  settlement 

23 


had  shown  some  results.  In  1870,  Wyoming's  population 
barely  surpassed  the  9,000  level.  The  figure  had  grown 
to  almost  200,000  by  1920.  Wyoming's  rate  of  population 
increase  ran  well  ahead  of  the  national  average  throughout 
the  years  between  1870  and  1920. H  Nevertheless,  one  fact 
had  become  clear— Wyoming  would  remain  sparsely  pop- 
ulated. Soil  of  questionable  fertility,  an  extremely  short 
growing  season,  and  all  too  frequent  droughts  meant  that 
Wyoming  would  never  attract  the  same  number  of  farmers 
as  did  the  Midwestern  states.  Wyoming  was  destined  to 
remain  a  cattleman's  domain  after  all.  Scattered  mines 
and  oil  rigs  would  eventually  dot  the  open  range,  but 
Wyoming  would  remain  a  state  of  few  inhabitants. 

At  the  present  time,  Wyoming  still  awaits  a  massive 
influx  of  population.  Contemporary  promoters,  follow- 
ing a  trend  recognized  by  the  Board  of  Immigration  in 
the  early  1920s,  focused  their  attention  on  tourists  rather 
than  permanent  settlers.  Tourism  has  consequently 
become  a  leading  Wyoming  industry,  surpassed  only  by 
minerals  and  mining.  Wyoming  now  seeks  to  beckon  tour- 
ists by  publicizing  the  recreational  advantages  of  an 
unspoiled,  sparsely  populated  state.  Permanent  residents 
and  tourists  alike  enjoy  Wyoming's  unique  unpopulated 
character.  Such  attitudes  seem  to  indicate  that  Wyoming 
will  not  undergo  any  substantial  population  growth  in  the 
near  future.  The  long  desired  rush  of  settlers  must  await 
some  presently  unforeseen  turn  of  events. 


1.  Quoted  in  T.  A.  Larson,  Wyoming:  A  History  (New  York:  W.  W. 
Norton  &  Co.,  Inc.,  1977),  p.  75. 

2.  Message  of  Governor  Campbell  to  the  First  Legislative  Assembly 
of  Wyoming  Territory  .  .  .  1869.  Western  History  Research  Center, 
University  of  Wyoming.  Hereafter  cited  as  W.H.R.C. 

3.  Ibid. 

4.  Larson.   Wyoming,  p.  78. 

5.  Lewis  L.  Gould,  Wyoming:  A  Political  History,  1869-1896  (New 
Haven:  Yale  University  Press,  1968),  p.  27. 

6.  Quoted  in  Mary  Ann  Reidel,  "The  Image  of  Wyoming  in  the 
Rocky  Mountain  News"  (Unpublished  M.A.  Thesis.  University 
of  Wyoming,  Laramie,  Wyoming,  1967),  p.  63. 

7.  T  A.  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming  (Lincoln:  University  of 
Nebraska  Press,  1978),  p.  63. 

8.  Message  of  Governor  Campbell  to  the  Third  Legislative  Assembly 
of  Wyoming  .  .  .  1873  (Cheyenne.  1873)  pp.  6-7.  W.H.R.C. 

9.  Larson.  History  of  Wyoming,  p.   118. 

10.  Ibid. 

11.  Ibid.,  see  pp.  108-115. 

12.  Ibid. 

13.  Ibid.,  p.  119. 

14.  Message  of  Governor  Hoyt  to  the  Sixth  Legislative  Assembly  of 
Wyoming  .  .  .  1879  (Cheyenne,  1879),  p.  37.  W.H.R.C. 

15.  George  W.  Rollins,  The  Struggle  of  the  Cattleman,  Sheepman, 
and  Settler  for  Control  of  Lands  in  Wyoming,  1867-1910  (New 
York:  Arno  Press,  1979),  p.  308. 

16.  William  E.  Smythe,  The  Conquest  of  Arid  America  (Seattle: 
University  of  Washington  Press,  1899,  1905),  pp.  222-223. 

17.  Gould,  A  Political  History,  p.  97. 

18.  Ibid.,  pp.  97-98. 

19.  Report  of  the  Governor  of  Wyoming  to  the  Secretary  of  the  Inte- 
rior. (Washington,  D.C.:  Government  Printing  Office,  1887),  p.  7. 


20.  David  M.  Emmons.  Garden  in  the  Grasslands  (Lincoln:  Univer- 
sity of  Nebraska  Press,  1971),  pp.  68-69. 

21 .  Biennial  Message  of  Governor  Francis  E.  Warren  to  the  Legislature 
of  Wyoming  .  .  .  1890  (Cheyenne.  1890),  p.  18.  W.H.R.C. 

22.  Ibid  ,  p.  33. 

23.  Emmons,  Garden  in  the  Grasslands,  pp.  63-64. 

24.  Rollins,  The  Struggle  of  the  Cattleman,  Sheepman,  and  Settler, 
p.  313. 

25.  Helena  Huntington  Smith,  The  War  on  Powder  River  (Lincoln: 
University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1967),  p.  197. 

26.  Rollins,  The  Struggle  of  the  Cattleman,  Sheepman,  and  Settler, 
p.  339. 

27.  Ibid.,  p.  343. 

28.  David  B.  Danbom,  The  Resisted  Revolution  (Ames:  Iowa  State 
University  Press,   1979),  p.  25. 

29.  Ibid.,  pp.  26-27. 

30.  Message  of  Governor  Bryant  B  Brooks  to  the  Ninth  State 
Legislature  .  .  .  1907  (Cheyenne,  1907),  p.  7.  W.H.R.C. 

31.  Ibid.,  p.  12. 

32.  The  State  of  Wyoming  (Cheyenne:  The  S.  A.  Bristol  Co.,  1908), 
pp.  5-6. 

33.  Bryant  B.  Brooks.  Memoirs  of  Bryant  B.  Brooks  (Glendale, 
California:  Arthur  H.  Clark  Co.,   1939),  p.  229. 

34.  First  Report  of  the  Department  of  Immigration  of  Wyoming, 
1907-1908.  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and  Historical 
Department,  Cheyenne,  Wyoming.  Hereafter  cited  as  A.M.H. 

35.  Ibid. 

36.  Biennial  Report  of  the  State  Board  of  Immigration  of  the  State 
of  Wyoming,  1909-1910.  A.M.H. 

37.  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming,  p.  362. 

38.  Roy  M.  Robbins,  Our  Landed  Heritage  (Lincoln:  University  of 
Nebraska  Press,  1976),  p.  371. 

39.  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming,  p.  362. 

40.  Ibid.,  p.  619. 

41.  Annual  Report  of  the  Office  [of]  the  State  Immigration  Agent, 
State  of  Wyoming,  1910.  A.M.H. 

42.  Message  of  Governor  Joseph  M.  Carey  to  the  Eleventh  State 
Legislature  .  .  .  1911  (Laramie,  1911),  p.  19.  W.H.R.C. 

43.  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming,  p.  324. 

44.  Biennial  Report  of  the  State  Board  of  Immigration  of  the  State 
of  Wyoming,  1911-1912,  p.  40.  A.M.H. 

45.  Ibid.,  p.  30. 

46.  Ibid.,  pp.  33-34. 

47.  Ibid.,  pp.  15-18. 

48.  Ibid.,  p.  13. 

49.  Larson.  History  of  Wyoming,  p.  362. 

50.  Ibid.,  p.  331. 

51.  Ibid.,  pp.  415-416. 

52.  Second  Biennial  Report  of  the  Wyoming  State  Board  of  Immigra- 
tion to  the  Governor  and  the  Sixteenth  State  Legislature, 
1919-1920,  p.  7,  A.M.H. 

53.  Ibid.,  p.  4. 

54.  Ibid.,  p.  7. 

55.  Ibid.,  pp.  10-13. 

56.  Third  Biennial  Report  of  the  Wyoming  State  Board  of  Immigra- 
tion, 1921-1923.  see  pp.  15-25.  A.M.H. 

57.  Donald  J.  Bogue,  Principles  of  Demography  (New  York:  John 
Wiley  &  Sons,  Inc.,  1969),  p.  136. 

58.  Donald  R.  Taft  and  Richard  Robbins,  International  Migrations 
(New  York:  Ronald  Press  Company,   1955),  pp.  454-455. 

59.  Danbom,  Resisted  Revolution,  p.  30. 

60.  Taft  and  Robbins,  Migrations,  pp.  376  and  410. 

61.  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming,  pp.  411-413. 

62.  Message  of  Governor  William  B.  Ross  Delivered  Before  the  Seven- 
teenth State  Legislature  of  the  State  of  Wyoming  .  .  .  1923 
(Cheyenne,  1923),  pp.  6-7.  W.H.R.C. 

63.  Larson,  History  of  Wyoming,  p.  619. 


24 


A  German  Looks  at  Cheyenne  in  1876: 
The  Travels  of  Ernst  von  Hesse-Wartegg 


Edited  and  translated  by 
Frederic  Trautmann 


Ernst  von  Hesse-Wartegg  (1854-1918)  was 
perhaps  the  19th  century's  foremost  traveler  and 
greatest  travel  writer. '  At  21  he  began  the  trips  and 
the  books  that  led  him  all  over  the  world  and  brought 
the  world  to  countless  readers  of  several  languages. 
His  career  as  a  diplomat— counsul  in  London  for 
years— seems  to  have  been  handmade  to  his  travels, 
as  was  his  marriage  to  Minnie  Hauck  (1852-1912) 
who  performed  in  opera  around  the  globe  and  sang 
the  first  American  Carmen.2  Hesse-Wartegg  himself 
was  the  first  German  in  Korea.  Moreover,  he  was 
largely  responsible  for  the  maritime  practice  of  signal- 
ing positions  of  icebergs  and  wrecks,  and  for  univer- 
sal and  standard  time  zones.  To  call  him  an  author 
is  misleading.  He  was  a  writing  machine:  forty-odd 
books,  including  ones  on  the  Balkans,  Canada, 
China,  India,  Japan,  Korea,  the  Middle  East, 
Samoa,  Siam,  Tunisia,  South  America,  and  the 
United  States.  Probably  nobody  has  written  more 
American  description  and  travel  than  this  German. 
Some  of  the  eight  American  titles  went  into  later  edi- 
tions; others  were  in  multiple  volumes.  His  compre- 
hensive study  of  the  United  States,  four  volumes, 
appeared  in  Nord-Amerika:  Seine  Stadte  und 
Naturwunder,  sein  Land  und  seine  Leute  (North 
America:  Its  Cities  and  Natural  Wonders,  Its  Land 
and  People),  which  contains  a  chapter  on  Cheyenne. 
He  produced  this  work  like  so  many  others,  by  travel- 
ing in  the  places  discussed,  by  reading  their  history 
and  current  affairs,  and  by  questioning  authorities. 
Thus,  Cheyenne  was  on  the  itinerary  in  1876  and 
his  description  reflects  his  research  and  reflection  on 
Cheyenne's  past,  present,  and  future.  How  good  was 
he  as  a  travel  writer,  how  good  his  method  for  com- 
posing travels?  Thomas  D.  Clark  commends  "this 
German  observer's  writings"  and  their  "many  precise 
and  enlightening  observations,"  and  notes  that  in  Life 
on  the  Mississippi,  Mark  Twain  "leaned  heavily" 
on  Hesse-Wartegg.*  Below,  in  translation,  is  Hesse- 
Wartegg' s  description  of  Cheyenne.4 


Baron  de  Wartegg  about  1900. 

"Magic  City" 

We  had  crossed  Nebraska,  starting  at  its  eastern  boun- 
dary (the  Missouri  River),  and  now  were  speeding  along- 
side the  dry  bed  of  the  Lodgepole  River,  on  the  border 
of  Wyoming  Territory,  between  the  "cities"  of  Bushnell  and 
Pine  Bluffs.  The  plains  began  to  change,  brightening  with 
life.  We  had  been  seeing  short,  brown  buffalo  grass  and 
mile  after  mile  of  open  spaces  burned  by  fire  to  a  black 
desert.  Now  we  saw  long-stemmed,  flowering  grasses  and 
clumps  of  sunflowers.  These  big,  yellow  blooms  spring  up 
wherever  man  or  nature  disturbs  the  soil.  Thus  they  lift 
their  flaxen  heads  along  hundreds  of  miles  of  railroads 
and  wagon  trails.  In  eastern  Kansas  and  Nebraska  we 
viewed  square  miles  of  them,  seven  to  nine  feet  tall.  The 
farther  west,  the  shorter  they  became:  in  Colorado,  barely 
seven  to  nine  inches  yet  with  the  form  and  features  of  tall 

25 


ones.  Little  sunflowers  are  America's  most  curious  minia- 
ture plant. 

The  last  outpost  of  agriculture  on  these  plains  is  250 
miles  from  the  Missouri.  Then,  for  300  miles,  to  the  foot 
of  the  Rocky  Mountains,  the  landform  is  steppe,  not 
suitable  for  agriculture  but  merely  grazing  land  for  herds 
of  cattle,  buffalo,  and  wild  horses.  Water  there  is  none, 
irrigation  impossible,  and  the  uncertain  rain  never 
enough.  Indeed,  hundreds  of  square  miles  are  salt  flats 
and  alkali  wastes.  The  100th  meridian  is  the  boundary 
of  Anglo-Saxon  civilization. 

We  have  nearly  crossed  these  deserts  now.  Before  us, 
stretching  low  across  the  horizon  from  east  to  west,  clouds 
appear.  The  closer  we  get,  the  more  palpable  they  become. 
Day's  work  done,  the  sun  begins  to  retire  and  throws 
brilliant  rays  obliquely  over  those  clouds  — rays  bright 
yellow  and,  here  and  there,  as  white  as  glittering 
diamonds.  Eyes  that  have  seen  snowfields  will  see  them 
again  in  these  clouds.  Snowfields  and  diamonds  disap- 
pear now;  the  sun  dims  to  a  glowing  ruby,  one  bright  point 
on  a  darkening  horizon;  and  in  this  light  the  long,  low 
zone  of  clouds  seems  to  bristle  with  jagged  edges  and  sharp 
teeth,  and  to  cast  profound  shadows  across  the  edge  of 
the  plains  beneath  them.  But  our  eyes  deceive  us.  We  look 
again.  No  doubt  about  it:  we  have  reached  the  Rocky 
Mountains. 

In  all  those  mountains  only  one  peak  still  glows  in  the 
dull  red  of  the  vanished  sun.  The  peak,  as  far  from  us 
as  the  eye  can  see,  reflects  like  a  mirror  the  sun  from  there 
in  the  south  to  here  in  the  north.  When  darker  nuances 
announce  dusk,  when  mists  rise  into  a  magical  veil  over 
the  dying  light,  only  then  does  the  rosy  glow  fade  from 
this  peak,  this  lighthouse  of  the  Rockies.  It  is  Long's  Peak, 
highest  in  northern  Colorado,  as  high,  as  beautiful,  as 
imposing  as  Mont  Blanc. 

Long's  Peak  is  also  a  landmark  of  Cheyenne,  mistress 
of  these  wide-open  spaces  and  "Magic  City  of  the  Plains." 
Darkness  arrived  and  was  total  except  for  strong  light- 
ning flashing  to  the  north  and  sending  bursts  of  illumina- 
tion across  the  plains.  Silence  had  fallen  and  was  profound 
but  for  the  rumble  of  wheels  of  railroad  cars.  Only  Long's 
Peak  told  us  we  would  soon  be  at  our  destination,  at  the 
end  of  our  journey  across  the  plains.  Together  with  dark- 
ness we  advanced  and  entered  the  capital  of  the  Territory 
of  Wyoming. 

Cheyenne  is  decidedly  the  most  interesting  city  on  the 
plains.  Its  history  is  the  greatest  and  most  colorful.  Years 
do  not  pass  in  monotonous  single-file  here;  they  cluster 
and  glitter;  in  one  year  Cheyenne's  people  live  ten  years. 
The  evening  we  arrived,  however,  we  were  too  tired  to 
muster  energy  to  participate  in  this  giddy-paced  life  even 
for  a  few  hours.  We  enjoyed  an  excellent  night's  sleep 
instead,  in  the  handsome,  elegant  Inter-Ocean  Hotel. 

Next  morning,  when  we  looked  out  over  Cheyenne 
from  the  elevation  of  our  room,  we  could  not  understand 
how  a  city  of  4,000  could  emerge  in  this  place,  a  desert 
without  trees,  grass,  or  any  other  vegetation!  The  attrac- 

26 


tive  plains  that  we  admired  near  the  Nebraska  border, 
with  their  herds  of  cattle,  had  given  way  to  miles  of  red- 
dish stone  that  defies  agriculture  and  scoffs  at  grass.  There 
are  a  few  small  gardens  near  scattered  houses  and  onlyi 
there  do  plants  try  to  win  nourishment  from  this  niggardly! 
soil.  In  all  Cheyenne's  environs,  not  a  farm,  not  a  house, 
not  the  faintest  sign  of  culture,  yet  here  this  important 
city  thrives,  the  most  important  between  the  Missouri  and 
the  Great  Salt  Lake!  To  us  these  facts  added  up  to  a 
mystery,  including  Cheyenne's  nickname:  The  Magic  City 
of  the  Plains.  Cheyenne  is  magic  indeed.  But  of  the  plains? 
Thirty  miles  west  by  train  you  cross  the  Rockies  at  8,242 
feet! 

Cheyenne  is  another  American  miracle.  On  July  1, 
1867,  ten  years  ago,  Judge  Whitehead  built  the  first  house 
on  the  Cheyenne  plateau,  of  crude  lumber  caulked  with 
clay.  Ten  years  — yes,  only  ten  years  — and  we  arrive  by 
Pullman  Palace  Car  and  find  the  place  a  substantial, 
thriving  city  with  wide,  friendly  streets,  splendid  hotels, 
roomy  stores,  banks,  jail,  insurance  companies,  opera 
house,  and  — churches!  I  repeat:  churches!  Catholic, 
Methodist,  Presbyterian,  Congregationalist,  Episcopalian, 
etc.  Each  faith  has  its  own  church  in  a  city  that,  five  years 
ago  consisted  of  dugouts  and  moveable  shacks.  The  shacks, 
portable  on  their  little  wooden  wheels,  made  Cheyenne 
known  all  over  America  as  "Hell-on-Wheels."5 

The  most  interesting  thing  about  these  cities  of  the 
plains  is  their  history.  Cheyenne  takes  its  name  from  a  large 
and  formerlv  powerful  tribe  of  Indians.  Like  all  cities 
between  Omaha  and  California,  Cheyenne  owes  its  origin 
to  the  railroad.  Ten  years  ago  the  announcement  was  made 
that  during  the  winter  of  1867-1868,  Cheyenne  would  be 
the  terminus  for  the  railroad  (then  under  construction) 
and  that  construction  would  continue  from  Cheyenne  in 
the  spring.  Overnight  — in  almost  the  literal  sense  of  the 
word  — a  city  of  6,000  appeared  in  the  middle  of  the 
desert.  Where  did  the  people  come  from?  Nobody  knew. 
What  were  they?  Drunkards,  swindlers,  cardsharps,  bums, 
thieves,  trappers,  prostitutes,  saloon-keepers,  Indians, 
deserters,  Chinese  laborers  — in  short,  society's  dregs.  Places 
to  live  materialized:  tents,  lean-tos,  barrels,  boxes,  log 
cabins,  and  dugouts.  Every  race,  all  nations,  were 
represented.  The  city  was  created  and  building  lots  sold 
for  fabulous  sums.  People  passed  the  time  with  liquor, 
cards,  and  gunfights.  To  steal  whenever  possible  was  the 
highest  goal  of  the  thieving  toughs.  Robbery  occurred  day 
and  night.  Today  one  shudders  to  hear  the  oldest  resident 
tell  of  life  in  that  hell.6 

Of  course  this  state  of  affairs  could  not  last  long;  it 
would  have  meant  the  end  of  everyone.  The  decent  ele- 
ment got  fed  up  with  constant  theft  and  robbery,  possibly 
on  moralistic  grounds,  possibly  because  they  had  lost  too 
much  of  their  treasure.  The  city  authorities,  elected  a 
month  after  the  city's  creation,  could  not  stop  crime  that 
included  daily  arson  and  murder.  A  vigilance  committee 
was  organized.  The  honorable  Judge  Lynch  presided  at 
court  and  knew  no  mercy. 7  There  were  no  defense  attor- 


ineys,  appeals,  or  clemency  for  youth  or  mental  illness. 
^Witnesses  and  alibis  were  dispensed  with.  Juries  were 
always  unanimous  in  verdicts  quickly  reached  and  justly 
ideserved.  No  need  for  gallows:  telegraph  poles  and  the 
Irailroad  bridge  served  executions  well. 

Within  a  year,  twelve  desperados  were  hanged  or  shot 
;and  many  more  jailed  or  run  out  of  town.  Robbery  ended. 
iThe  committee's  effectiveness  can  be  read  in  the  statistics: 
;after  one  year  the  population  of  6,000  to  8,000  dropped 
to  2,000.  Former  inhabitants  went  elsewhere,  disap- 
peared.8 

The  remaining  2,000  would  not  have  stayed  either, 
but  for  the  immediate  discovery  of  gold  north  in  the  Black 
Hills  [in  1875],  a  stroke  of  the  best  luck  for  Cheyenne.  And 
'not  only  gold  but  a  lot  of  it,  so  much  that  in  New  York 
and  all  America's  big  cities  the  heart  of  every  vagrant, 
every  adventurer,  every  vagabond  beat  faster.  For  the 
irailroad  and  Cheyenne,  gold  fever  was  a  godsend.  Railroad 
(tickets  were  printed  in  millions,  bearing  the  words:  Black 
\Hills!  Take  the  U.  P.  Railroad  to  the  Black  Hills!  Lies 
turned  the  true  gold  into  fabulous  fortunes;  the  wealth 
thereabouts  was  described  in  such  glowing  terms  that  every 
I  adventurer  thought  his  pockets  full  the  minute  he  decided 
co  go  to  the  Black  Hills.  Gold  fever,  induced  by  Califor- 
nia and  Colorado,  raged  now  for  the  Black  Hills.  All 
doubtful  elements  of  the  civilized  East  moved  to  the  Black 
Hills.  What  the  East  was  freed  and  cleansed  of,  founded 
new  civilization  in  the  West. 

That  course  of  events  is  typical;  all  American  civiliza- 
tion had  such  rude  beginnings.  Pioneers  are  not  paragons 
;  of  culture  and  virtue.  The  polite  and  the  refined  do  not 
1  venture  into  the  wilderness.  If  they  did,  what  is  now  a 
thriving,  bustling  region  would  be  a  sorry  sight.  The  crude 
and  the  tough  blaze  trails  and  civilization  follows. 

With  astonishing  speed  and  strength,  gold  fever  swept 
the  eastern  cities  and  infected  its  victims,  the  foot-loose 
and  fancy-free.  The  fever  passed  over  nice  homes  and  pros- 
perous businesses  of  well-bred  citizens;  it  is  not  contagious 
there.  Its  victims  dwell  in  cheap  saloons  and  sleazy  board- 
inghouses  in  bad  neighborhoods  and  on  waterfronts. 
There  it  is  contagious;  and  its  victims,  the  adventurous 
and  the  unemployed,  in  delirium,  lust  after  gold.  The 
fever  draws  up  a  chair  at  a  table  in  a  cafe,  forces  the  door 
of  a  down-and-out,  flashes  the  yellow  nugget,  and  paints 
a  bright  future.  The  fever  flatters  the  dockworker  who 
came  to  America  with  a  high  heart  and  now  lives  without 
point  or  plan  amid  shattered  hopes.  The  fever  seduces 
the  bankrupt  businessman.  Workers,  adventurers,  busi- 
nessmen scrape  together  the  last  of  their  assets,  exhaust 
what  remains  of  their  credit,  and  buy  tickets  to  Cheyenne 
and  the  Black  Hills.  Eastern  cities  are  now  cleansed:  the 
cities  have  profited.  The  scum  has  drifted  west  to  settle 
and  improve  the  land:  the  West  has  profited. 

Thus  a  new  heyday  has  come  to  Cheyenne.  Years  ago 
the  rabble  of  the  railroad  and  the  outdoors  chose 
Cheyenne  as  their  arena.  Now  the  rabble  of  the  mines 
is  headquartered  here.  In  the  twinkling  of  an  eye,  Chey- 


enne has  changed  from  a  railroad  town  to  a  mining  town. 
If  the  railroad  town's  robbery,  murder,  and  dissolution  have 
disappeared,  the  mining  town's  coarseness  has  emerged 
instead.  Cheyenne  is  now  the  starting  point,  the  place 
where  mining  companies  organize  and  provision  for  the 
200-mile  trek  to  the  Black  Hills.9 

Only  a  few  companies  have  dared  follow  the  throngs 
into  the  gold  country,  still  owned  and  occupied  by  Indians. 
But  a  town,  Custer  City,  has  been  founded  there  [1875]. 
In  a  month  no  fewer  than  100  houses  were  built  in  forested 
Custer  Park.  In  two  months  the  population  was  3,000. 
Over  1,000  people  a  week  pour  into  the  area!  Thus,  in 
a  few  months,  forests  and  wide-open  spaces  become  thickly 
settled. 

This  migration  does  not  improve  Cheyenne's  manners 
and  morals  but  it  brings  coin  and  greenbacks.  Hence  the 
nice  homes,  big  hotels,  well -stocked  stores,  and  growing 
populace.  Cheyenne  is  in  a  bright  renaissance.  But  the 
railroad  is  to  be  extended  to  Fort  Laramie,  cutting  in  half 
the  present  trek  to  the  hills.  The  business  of  supplying 
the  mines  will  move  to  Fort  Laramie  and  an  important 
city  will  rise  there  and  stay  until  the  railroad  is  extended 
again.  Then  Fort  Laramie  will  disappear.  Now,  however, 
it  draws  people  and  commerce  from  Cheyenne.  Laramie 
will  thrive  while  Cheyenne  withers  to  its  former  debility.10 

Will  Cheyenne  have  a  third  renaissance?  Yes  — the 
renaissance  of  true  civilization,  which  is  eternal. 

1.  This  sketch  is  based  on  We  r  ist's,  VII  (Leipzig:  HAL.  Degener, 
1914),  p.  685:  Deutsches  Biographischesjahrbuch,  II  (Berlin  and 
Leipzig:  Verbande  der  Deutschen  Akademien,  1928).  p.  690: 
Meyers  Konversations- Lexikon,  VIII  (1893),  p.  753. 

2.  New  York  Times,  November  19,  1912,  p.  15. 

3.  "The  New  South"  in  Thomas  D.  Clark,  ed.,  Travels  in  the  New 
South:  A  Bibliography,  I  (Norman:  University  of  Oklahoma  Press, 
1959).  p.  190. 

4.  Nord-Amerika,  II  (Leipzig:  Weigel,  1880),  pp.  139-146.  This  book 
has  not  been  published  in  English.  Brief  passages,  unrelated  to 
Cheyenne,  have  been  deleted:  and  in  the  interests  of  unity, 
coherence,  and  emphasis,  a  few  sentences  have  been  rearranged. 
Words  in  English  in  the  original  are  italicized  their  first  time  in 
the  translation. 

5.  Hell-on-Wheels  usually  referred  to  any  "terminal  town"  at  the  tem- 
porary end  of  a  railroad  under  construction,  to  be  moved  to  a 
new  town  when  the  railroad  was  extended.  Cheyenne,  like  many 
other  western  cities,  began  as  a  terminal  town. 

6.  Hesse-Wartegg  echoes  others  of  his  day,  who  associated  Cheyenne 
with  hell  and  acknowledged  it  as  a  seat  of  crime,  gambling,  and 
vice. 

7.  Judge  Lynch  refers  to  the  two  Lynches  in  American  history  who 
originated  and  spread  the  terms  Lynch  Law  and  lynching.  In  1760, 
Captain  William  Lynch  drafted  a  compact,  the  first  Lynch  Law, 
to  deal  summarily  with  lawbreakers  who  seemed  outside  existing 
law  in  Pittsylvania  County,  Virginia.  Charles  Lynch,  also  of 
Virginia,  dispensed  his  own  Lynch  Law  in  the  late  18th  century 
and  spread  the  terms  associated  with  his  name.  A  justice  of  the 
peace,  Charles  Lynch  probably  began  the  termjudge  Lynch.  This 
concept  of  frontier  justice  and  the  terms  associated  with  it  received 
much  attention  from  German  travelers  in  19th-century  America. 

8.  The  exodus  was  probably  due  as  much  to  Cheyenne's  end  as  a 
terminal  town  as  to  the  committee's  achievements. 

9.  Via  the  Cheyenne  and  Black  Hills  Stage  Company. 

10.    In  point  of  fact,  Cheyenne  had  begun  to  thrive  as  a  cattle  town; 
indeed,  the  capital  of  a  huge  area  of  ranching. 

27 


_//££  Col 


Jdlj   -Lynns    C^nanzy 


Eleanor  Patterson 

Author's  Note:  A  few  summers  ago,  my  family  and 
I  were  invited  to  spend  several  days  at  Flat  Creek  Ranch, 
a  lovely  spot  located  east  of  Jackson,  Wyoming,  up  behind 
the  Elk  Refuge.  As  soon  as  we  got  to  the  ranch,  my  hus- 
band and  daughters  busied  themselves  fishing — and  excel- 
lent fishing  it  was.  I  contented  myself  with  wandering 
around  the  ranch  and  trying  to  understand  how  it  had  come 
into  being.  Even  in  1981,  it  was  very  difficult  to  reach. 
The  four-wheel  drive  vehicle  we  had  used  to  wind  our  way 
to  it  had  given  us  a  bone-rattling  ride  and  stalled  twice 
m  the  process.  How  hard  it  must  have  been  to  transport 
beds  and  sofas  and  tables  and  plumbing  fixtures  to  the 
ranch  site  some  50  years  ago,  when  the  main  cabin  and 
guest  cabins  appeared  to  have  been  built.  And  the  huge 
piano  in  the  main  parlor — how  had  that  been  managed? 

28 


And  who  had  decided  to  manage  it?  "It  was  a  Polish 
countess,"  one  of  the  hands  told  me,  but  he  couldn't 
elaborate  much  beyond  that.  "A  Polish  countess?"  I  asked 
myself.  What  was  a  Polish  countess  doing  building  a  ranch 
at  Flat  Creek?  It  seemed  so  unlikely  an  explanation  that 
1  even  began  to  wonder  if  I  were  the  victim  of  a  tall  tale. 
But  I  wasn't.  As  I  have  since  found  out,  there  was  a  count- 
ess at  Flat  Creek,  and  she  was  one  of  the  West's  most 
glamorous  dudes.  What  makes  her  story  even  more  intrigu- 
ing is  that  after  a  youth  filled  with  romance  and  adven- 
ture, the  countess  settled  down  to  become  a  person  of 
impressive  accomplishment.  For  a  time  the  proprietress  of 
Flat  Creek  Ranch  was,  in  the  words  of  Collier's  Magazine, 
"the  most  powerful  woman  in  America."1 


fid  of  \j~Lat  Ci££^ 


Born  in  1881,  Eleanor  Patterson  grew  up  in  Chicago 
in  a  family  of  wealthy  and  ambitious  men  and  women. 
Her  grandfather,  Joseph  Medill,  was  the  hard-driving 
editor  and  publisher  of  the  Chicago  Daily  Tribune.  Her 
father  in  his  turn  also  ran  the  Tribune,  while  the  family's 
women  sought  distinction  in  other  ways.  When  Joseph 
Medill  died,  leaving  Eleanor's  mother  an  extraordinarily 
handsome  addition  to  her  income,  Mrs.  Patterson  decided 
to  build  a  mansion  in  Washington,  D.C.  The  concentra- 
tion of  diplomatic  and  political  power  in  the  capital  city 
had  begun  to  attract  a  number  of  wealthy  families,  and 
Mrs.  Patterson  was  intent  on  making  her  mark  wherever 
society  decreed  it  ought  to  be  made.  Near  what  is  today 
known  as  Dupont  Circle,  she  bought  a  track  of  swampy 
land  for  $83,000,  and  she  commissioned  architect  Stan- 
ford White  to  build  an  elegant  — if  somewhat  showy  — 
home  upon  it. 

Meanwhile,  Eleanor  — or  "Cissy,"  as  everyone  called 
her— was  leading  the  extravagant  life  of  a  turn-of-the- 
century  debutante.  She  traveled  to  Europe,  where  her 
uncle,  Robert  McCormick,  was  minister  to  the  Austro- 
Hungarian  court.  Her  wealth  and  her  connections  meant 
a  multitude  of  invitations  to  court  balls,  race  meets  and 
opera  parties.  When  President  Taft  transferred  her  uncle 
to  Saint  Petersburg,  she  was  even  invited  to  a  ball  at  the 
palace  of  the  czar.  It  was  an  evening  of  shining  jewels  and 
gold-lace  splendor,  which  Cissy  later  described  in  a  novel 
she  wrote. 

The  walls  were  hung  with  tapestries,  she  remembered  of  the 
palace,  swords  and  lances,  armor,  game  heads  and  old  por- 
traits of  Boyars,  huge  bearded  men  with  squinting  tartar  eyes, 
shaven  heads,  and  thin  Mongolian  mustachios,  in  gorgeous 
fur  and  brocade  kaftans.  From  door  to  door  Cossack  servants, 
in  long  white  and  silver  trimmed  tcherkeska.  with  silver  dag- 
gers at  their  tiny  waists  and  soft,  heelless  boots,  stood  sen- 
tinel in  double  file.  Here  and  there  a  torch  blazed  up  from 
a  high  gold  sconce.  At  the  four  corners  braziers  of  burning 
aromatic  vinegar  lay  on  tall,  slim  tripods.2 
Wherever  she  went,  Cissy  was  usually  the  center  of 
attention,  not  because  she  was  a  great  beauty  so  much, 


but  because  she  was  striking.  "You  are  not  beautiful,"  the 
Baron  von  Rothschild  said  to  her  once.  "But  there  is 
something."  Her  nose  was  a  little  too  upturned,  her 
forehead  a  little  too  broad  for  classic  beauty,  but  her  red 
hair,  elegant  figure,  and  proud  bearing  helped  her 
dominate  whatever  room  she  entered.  Said  one  of  her 
female  contemporaries,  "Cissy  simply  hypnotizes  people 
into  thinking  she  is  a  great  beauty."3 

Among  those  who  gathered  round  her  was  a  tall,  dark- 
eyed  Polish  diplomat  to  whom  she  found  herself  increas- 
ingly attracted.  His  name  was  Count  Joseph  Gizycki,  and 
although  he  was  twice  her  age,  his  high  spirits  were  a 
match  for  her  own.  He  loved  to  ride,  as  she  did;  he  showed 
heroic  endurance  when  it  came  to  drinking  or  gambling, 
and  he  was  ardent  in  his  pursuit  of  the  young  American 
girl.  He  followed  her  through  Europe,  and  when  she 
returned  to  the  splendid  mansion  her  mother  had  built 
in  Washington,  D.C. ,  he  bombarded  her  with  love  letters. 

While  it  was  quite  common  at  the  time  for  wealthy 
American  girls  to  use  their  fortunes  to  marry  titled  Euro- 
peans, the  Patterson  family  was  less  than  enthusiastic 
about  Cissy's  involvement  with  the  Polish  count.  When 
Cissy  and  Gizycki  began  to  talk  of  a  wedding  date,  Mrs. 
Patterson  kept  pushing  it  back,  while  Mr.  Patterson 
demanded  proof  that   Gizycki's  estate  in   Poland  was 


Eleanor  Patterson  and  her  family.  Standing  next  to  her 
is  her  cousin,  Medill  McCormick,  later  U.S.  Senator  from 
Illinois.  Seated  (left  to  right)  are:  Eleanor's  cousin,  Robert 
R.  McCormick,  who  later  became  Chicago  Tribune 
publisher;  her  grandfather,  Joseph  Medill,  Tribune 
founder;  and  her  brother,  Joseph  Patterson,  founder  of 
the  New  York  Daily  News. 

29 


unencumbered.  But  such  objections  only  made  Cissy— 
who  had  spent  much  of  her  life  practicing  the  art  of  filial 
defiance  —  more  firmly  resolved  than  ever  to  marry  the 
Count.  A  date  was  set  for  spring,  1904,  and  the  April  wed- 
ding was  a  brilliant  affair,  though  somewhat  clouded  at 
its  conclusion  when  the  groom  went  to  his  hotel  to  change 
clothes  and  failed  to  return.  The  dowry  he  had  been  prom- 
ised had  not  been  deposited,  but  as  soon  as  that  error  was 
corrected,  he  appeared  to  collect  his  bride.4 

The  two-month  honeymoon  tour  of  Europe  was  also 
a  little  different  than  Cissy  had  expected.  While  Gizycki 
could  be  a  dashing  companion,  he  was  also  given  to  dark 
moods,  and  he  frequently  abandoned  his  bride  while  he 
went  off  to  drink  and  gamble.  In  Vienna,  he  showed  up 
at  the  door  of  her  room  at  five  in  the  morning  to  demand 
$11,000  to  pay  his  gambling  debts.  Intimidated  for  what 
was  probably  the  first  time  in  her  life,  she  gave  it  to  him. 
The  Polish  countryside  through  which  they  traveled 
on  their  way  to  Gizycki 's  home  gave  her  some  comfort. 
Cissy  later  remembered  its  loveliness  in  her  novel  Free 
Flight.  It  was,  she  wrote, 

[a]n  enormous  country.  Stretching,  yearning,  enticing  the 
vision  on  and  on  to  an  ever  more  indefinite  horizon.  An  enor- 
mous country  under  an  enormous  fair  sky  .  .  . ,  this  Ukraine 
was  rich  with  forest  and  green  fields  and  bright  with  ponds 
and  running  water.  A  meadowlark  rose  singing  in  dizzy  spirals 
of  flight.  .  .   .5 
But  Gizycki's  castle  was  another  matter  entirely.  It  looked 
for  all  the  world  like  a  huge  barn,  and  it  was  in  a  state 
of  sorry  disrepair.  Worse  yet,  there  was  evidence  inside 
of  recent  occupancy  by  another  woman.  The  very  rooms 
Gizycki  declared  to  be  Cissy's  own  had  some  of  the  woman's 
possessions  in  them. 

Somehow  the  marriage  survived  four  years.  After  two 
years  a  baby  was  born,  a  girl,  but  an  offspring  did  not 
transform  the  footloose  Gizycki  into  an  attentive  spouse, 
and  when  Cissy  took  to  berating  him  for  his  infidelities, 
he  began  to  beat  her.  Cissy  fled  to  London,  taking  two- 
year  old  Felicia  with  her.  Gizycki  sent  detectives  after  her, 
and  they  kidnapped  Felicia  from  a  London  suburb  where 
Cissy  had  installed  her  with  a  nurse,  and  transported  the 
child  to  a  convent  in  Austria.  The  subsequent  custody  bat- 
tle over  Felicia  provided  considerable  entertainment  to 
tabloid  readers  on  two  continents  until  finally  President 
Taft  himself  became  involved  and  wrote  a  direct  letter  to 
Czar  Nicholas.  The  result  was  an  imperial  decree  order- 
ing Felicia  to  be  returned  to  her  mother. 

The  process  of  divorcing  Gizycki  took  years.  The  char- 
ismatic Cissy  never  lacked  for  male  companionship  dur- 
ing this  period,  and  the  days  when  she  wasn't  in  court  were 
filled  with  such  elegant  diversions  of  the  rich  as  polo  and 
hunting;  nevertheless,  the  long,  drawn-out  proceedings 
took  a  toll  on  her.  A  friend  suggested  she  might  find  the 
tonic  she  needed  for  her  flagging  spirits  in  the  West  — 
and  so  it  was,  at  age  thirty-five,  that  she  began  her  love 
affair  with  Wyoming. 

Cissy  arrived  in  Jackson  Hole  in  1916  bringing  her 
twelve-year-old  daughter,  a  French  maid,  and  seven  trunks 

30 


of  clothing.  Years  later,  Felicia  would  remember  the  way 
her  mother  looked  the  day  they  first  came  to  Jackson.  "I 
remember  my  mother  striding  ahead  in  her  lovely  long- 
skirted  tweeds  from  Paris  and  her  custom-made  walking 
boots.  She  looked  like  a  big  wildcat  and  her  red  haii 
flamed  in  the  mountain  sunlight."6  Within  a  day  of  hei 
arrival,  Cissy  sent  home  the  French  maid  and  six  of  the 
trunks,  and  before  the  end  of  the  summer,  she  had  decided 
that  the  dude  ranch  where  she  was  staying,  pleasani 
though  it  was,  was  a  little  too  tame  for  her.  She  got  herseli 
a  guide  named  Cal  Carrington,  a  tall,  handsome  man. 
and  with  Felicia  in  tow,  Cissy  and  Cal  set  off  on  a  hunt 
ing  expedition.  It  was  the  first  of  many,  for  the  formei 
debutante  quickly  developed  a  taste  for  blood  sport.  "Tc 


Alice  Roosevelt  Longworth  was  Cissy's  long-time  socia, 
rival.  Alice  is  pictured  here  with  her  husband,  Nicholas 
Longworth,  and  her  famous  father,  President  Theodore 
Roosevelt. 


the  natural-born  hunter,"  she  wrote,  "the  mere  sight  of 
game  stirs  to  the  roots  an  ancient,  fundamental  instinct, 
inherited  through  the  ages,  probably  from  the  days  when 
a  fight  between  man  and  beast  was  a  fight  on  both  sides 
of  deadly  consequence.  It  is  the  same  animal  instinct 
which  throws  a  setter  dog,  for  instance,  into  a  trembling 
ecstasy  at  sight  or  scent  of  a  grouse." 

Tracking  elk  through  canyons,  driving  a  team  of  horses 
over  a  mountain  pass,  sitting  out  a  sudden  snowstorm  in 
a  hunting  camp  Wyoming  offered  such  experiences  to 
Cissy  and  she  loved  them.  The  West  gave  her  ways  of 
testing  herself  mentally  and  physically  which  her  life  in 
society  did  not  provide,  and  she  was  at  her  best  when  chal- 
lenged. "She  would  go  anywhere  an  elk  went,"  said  one 
guide  who  sometimes  accompanied  her.  "She  would  ride 
all  day,  never  want  to  quit  or  pitch  camp  early.  And  there 
was  no  fuss  or  bother."  Another  guide  observed,  "She  was 
the  best  shot  of  all  the  women  I've  ever  seen." 

A  second  reason  Jackson  became  important  to  her  was 
its  people.  No  one  put  on  airs  or  tried  to  impress  anyone 
else.  People  said  what  they  meant,  and  often  what  they 
had  to  say  was  quite  extraordinary.  As  Cissy's  daughter 
Felicia  described  Jackson  in  the  days  when  her  mother 
was  there,  "[It]  used  to  be  full  of  characters  who  could 
be  themselves  without  benefit  of  psychiatry  or  interfer- 
ence from  the  law."7 

Cal  Carrington,  who  began  as  Cissy's  guide  and  was 
a  companion  of  hers  on  and  off  for  the  rest  of  her  life, 
was  a  perfect  example  of  what  Felicia  meant.  His  origins 
were  uncertain,  but  he  had  developed  a  reputation  as  an 
accomplished  horse  rustler  in  the  twenty-some  years  he 
had  been  wandering  about  the  far  West.  He  had  a  sharp 
eye,  exquisite  skill  with  a  rifle,  and  many  a  tale  to  tell, 
usually  about  how  he  had  managed  to  stay  a  step  or  two 
ahead  of  various  sheriffs.  In  the  course  of  his  adventures, 
he  had  developed  a  tough  self-reliance  which  impressed 
Cissy  tremendously.  Cal  also  owned  a  homestead  site  up 
Flat  Creek  Canyon.  He  claimed  it  was  the  perfect  place 
for  keeping  horses  about  whose  ownership  there  was  some 
question,  but  as  soon  as  Cissy  saw  it,  she  had  other  plans 
for  it.  She  talked  Cal  into  selling  it  to  her,  and  with  him 
as  her  foreman,  she  began  building  on  the  land.  Soon 
a  ranch  took  shape,  a  main  lodge  with  a  stone  fireplace, 
several  bedroom  cabins  across  the  stream,  a  corral,  and, 
somewhat  improbably,  a  red  barn,  such  as  Cissy  might 
have  seen  in  her  childhood  in  Illinois. 

Completing  the  ranch  took  several  years,  largely 
because  of  the  difficulty  of  transporting  materials  to  the 
site  from  Jackson.  One  of  the  carpenters  who  helped  in 
the  heroic  building  task  at  Flat  Creek  was  Henry  Crab- 
tree.  His  wife,  Rose,  a  plain-spoken  Jackson  hotel  owner, 
became  one  of  Cissy's  dearest  friends.  Over  a  period  of 
forty  years,  the  two  women  visited  one  another,  wrote  to 
one  another,  confided  in  one  another.  They  could  hardly 
have  come  from  more  different  backgrounds  — Rose  had 
been  born  in  Weeping  Water,  Nebraska,  and  had  spent 
her  life  in  the  West  — but  they  had  fiercely  independent 


spirits  in  common.  At  one  point,  Rose  became  something 
of  a  national  celebrity  when  she  ran  against  her  husband 
Henry  for  the  Jackson  town  council  — and  beat  him.  She 
and  Cissy  became  quite  close.  In  one  letter  to  Rose,  Cissy 
wrote,  "I  laughed  with  you  and  cried  with  you  more  than 
with  anyone  else  in  the  world." 

The  natural  beauty  of  Jackson  Hole  was  also  tremen- 
dously important  to  Cissy.  She  set  a  part  of  her  second 
novel,  Glass  Houses,  in  the  valley.  "Long  blue  and  purple 
veils  floated  down  from  the  peaks  of  the  mountains,"  she 
wrote, 

peaks  desolate  and  tortured  by  day,  melted  and  warmed  to 
a  semblance  of  familiar  life  in  the  evening  light.  Immense  — 
calm.  Calm  disturbed  at  last  by  a  first  shuddery  chill;  the 
breath  of  approaching  night.  Ever  so  far  off  and  very  gently 
the  stars  came  out,  one  by  one.8 

The  main  character  in  Glass  Houses,  Mary  Moore, 
finds  a  contentment  in  the  West  which  her  life  in  the  city 
does  not  provide,  and  so  it  was  with  Cissy  as  the  years 
passed.  The  time  at  Flat  Creek  was  rich  and  satisfying, 
but  when  she  wasn't  in  Wyoming,  all  her  problems  would 
resurface.  There  was  no  challenge  in  her  life,  no  moun- 
tain to  climb.  She  wandered  restlessly  from  Newport  to 
Chicago  to  Canada,  usually  traveling  in  a  private  railroad 
car.  She  suffered  from  mysterious  illnesses.  She  quarrelled 
violently  with  her  now-grown  daughter,  but  when  Felicia 
married  a  young  man  named  Drew  Pearson,  Cissy  found 
herself  so  bereft  she  rushed  into  an  ill-considered  mar- 
riage herself  with  a  New  York  lawyer  named  Elmer  Schles- 
inger.  Within  two  years,  there  was  talk  of  divorce,  an  event 
Schlesinger  circumvented  by  collapsing  and  dying  on  a 
golf  course. 

Cissy  wrote  her  two  novels,  Fall  Flight  and  Glass 
Houses  in  1926  and  1928,  and  began  to  edge  toward  the 
career  in  which  she  would  finally  find  the  challenge  she 
wanted.  She  had  already  done  some  newspaper  writing— 
her  first  efforts  had  been  to  describe  Wyoming  for  the  Chi- 
cago Herald  and  Examiner  —  and  now  she  took  on  some 
more  assignments,  including  covering  the  sensational 
murder  trial  of  Ruth  Snyder,  a  Long  Island  housewife 
accused  of  joining  with  her  lover  in  killing  her  corset- 
salesman  husband. 

Cissy  began  to  think  about  buying  her  own  newspaper. 
Discouraged  by  her  brother  Joe,  who  edited  the  family 
newspaper,  the  Chicago  Tribune,  and  who  had  founded 
the  New  York  Daily  News,  Cissy  did  the  next  best  thing 
to  buying  a  paper:  she  talked  William  Randolph  Hearst 
into  naming  her  the  editor  of  the  Washington  Herald. 

In  her  new  role,  she  was  unusual  to  say  the  least.  The 
first  night  she  walked  into  the  city  room,  she  shouted  to 
the  assembled  staffers,  "I  suppose  you  think  this  is  just 
a  stunt."  As  the  typewriters  fell  silent,  she  added,  "Well, 
even  if  you  do,  let's  all  try  to  put  it  over."  Mercurial  and 
quixotic  though  she  was,  she  managed  to  attract  a  sin- 
gularly bright  group  of  newsmen  and  women  to  the 
Herald.  Once  they  were  at  her  mercy,  she  "cajoled, 
stormed,  and  goaded,"  them,  as  Drew  Pearson  described 


31 


it,  "into  putting  out  a  first  class  sheet."9  Gossip  columns 
made  it  particularly  lively  reading.  Cissy  enlivened  them 
with  tidbits  she  picked  up  in  the  salons  of  the  powerful 
or  at  the  spectacular  dinner  parties  she  gave  in  the  now- 
refurbished  family  mansion  on  Dupont  Circle.  From  time 
to  time  she  disguised  herself  and  personally  went  out  on 
a  story.  One  gambit  that  drew  a  good  deal  of  attention  — 
probably  because  of  the  irony  involved  — was  Cissy's 
appearance  on  Washington  streets  as  "Maude  Martin,"  a 
destitute  woman  looking  for  a  job. 

Within  six  years,  the  newspaper's  circulation  had 
doubled,  and  Cissy  began  pressing  Hearst  to  let  her  buy 
the  paper.  Finally  he  agreed  to  sell  not  just  the  Herald, 
but  the  Washington  Times  as  well.  It  too  was  losing  money, 
but  Cissy  bought  both  papers  from  Hearst,  merged  them, 
and  continued  her  campaign  to  provide  Washingtonians 
with  lively  reading.  When  all  else  failed,  she  would  pro- 
vide her  own  news  by  throwing  a  particularly  incendiary 
piece  of  wood  on  the  fire  of  one  of  the  many  feuds  she 
had  going.  When  publisher  Eugene  Meyer,  who  owned 
the  Washington  Post,  did  her  out  of  one  of  her  favorite 
comic  strips,  she  purchased  a  pound  of  raw  meat,  wrapped 
it  as  carefully  as  if  it  were  a  bouquet  of  delicate  blossoms, 
and  shipped  it  off  to  him  with  a  note,  "Take  your  pound 
of  flesh  ."10  One  of  the  most  frequent  targets  of  her  ire  was 
Alice  Roosevelt  Longworth,  Theodore  Roosevelt's  daugh- 
ter, and  Alice,  no  slouch  in  the  cutting  remark  depart- 
ment herself,  did  her  part  to  keep  the  animosities  alive. 
After  a  dinner  party  at  the  Longworths  during  which  Cissy 
spent  much  time  in  an  upstairs  library  with  a  charming 
young  nobleman,  Alice  sent  her  a  note:  "Dear  Cissy,"  it 
read,  "Upon  sweeping  up  the  library  this  morning,  the 
maid  found  several  hairpins  which  I  thought  you  might 
need  and  which  I  am  returning."  Cissy  wrote  back,  "If 
you  had  looked  on  the  chandelier  you  might  also  have 
sent  back  my  shoes  and  chewing  gum."11  Cissy  redoubled 
her  efforts  to  goad  Alice  by  flirting  outrageously  with 
Alice's  husband,  Nick. 

Cissy  was  quite  willing  to  use  her  newspaper  to  espouse 
causes  in  which  she  believed.  Her  love  of  blood  sport  had 
abated  by  the  time  she  became  a  newspaper  magnate,  and 
she  had,  in  fact,  become  an  ardent  animal  lover,  strongly 
opposing  vivisection  and  campaigning  against  cruelty  to 
animals.  Once  when  a  sudden  freeze  left  geese  on  the 
Potomac  without  food,  Times  reporters  were  sent  up  in 
a  dirigible  to  throw  cracked  corn  to  the  birds.  A  photog- 
rapher was  sent  along  to  record  the  event,  a  layout  was 
prepared  — but  the  story  had  to  be  pulled  when  reports 
began  to  come  into  the  newspaper  of  Potomac  geese  fall- 
ing victim  to  assassins  who  were  pelting  them  from  a 
dirigible. 

Four  years  after  Cissy  purchased  her  newspaper,  it  was 
in  the  black.  It  had  taken  her  nearly  a  half-century  of 
living  to  find  the  professional  challenge  she  wanted,  but 
now  she  was  an  undeniable  success.  When  she  became 
board  chairman  of  the  company  which  owned  the  New 
York  News,   as  well  as  the  successful  publisher  of  the 


Washington  paper,  there  was  strong  justification  for  call- 
ing her  the  most  powerful  woman  in  America. 

But  that  too  had  its  price,  she  discovered.  She  had 
made  more  enemies  than  friends  in  her  life.  Even  those 
who  might  have  wanted  to  approach  her  were  frightened 
off  by  her  unpredictable  behavior.  One  of  her  biographers 
has  compared  her  to  Elizabeth  I,  and  like  the  queen,  Cissy 
grew  old  alone.  Cal  Carrington  was  usually  off  working 
on  some  scheme  or  other,  Rose  Crabtree  was  in  far  off 
Jackson,  Cissy  and  her  daughter  tended  to  quarrel  after 
more  than  five  minutes  in  the  same  room.  Cissy's  closest 
companions,  as  her  60th  birthday  came  and  went,  were 
her  pet  poodles,  rather  vicious  animals  if  one  judges  by 
the  numbers  of  people  they  bit.  Noticing  that  her  love 
for  the  dogs  seemed  matched  by  an  aversion  to  people, 
a  reporter  who  interviewed  her  labeled  her  a  "misan- 
thrope."12 

Another  penalty  of  her  success,  Cissy  found,  was  that 
she  no  longer  had  time  to  go  to  Wyoming.  For  fourteen 
years  she  was  unable  to  visit  the  ranch  she  loved  so  much. 
Finally,  in  the  summer  of  1948,  she  resolved  she  would 
go.  Plans  were  made  for  a  private  railway  car  to  take  her, 
and  she  was  looking  forward  to  the  trip,  hoping,  no  doubt, 
to  find  once  more  in  the  West  the  kind  of  solace  she  had 
known  previously.  But  one  morning,  just  a  month  before 
she  was  to  leave,  she  failed  to  ring  for  her  breakfast.  When 
the  servants  investigated,  they  found  67-year-old  Cissy  Pat- 
terson lifeless  in  bed. 

The  newspaper  she  had  made  such  a  success  did  not 
survive  long  without  her.  Within  six  years,  Eugene  Meyer, 
the  owner  of  the  Washington  Post  had  purchased  it  and 
closed  it  down.  But  one  monument  does  remain,  for  in 
a  remote  mountain  meadow  of  Wyoming,  the  ranch, 
where  she  knew  contentment,  goes  on. 


1.  Biographical  facts,  anecdotes  and  quotations  by  and  about 
Eleanor  Patterson  are,  unless  otherwise  stated,  from  Paul  F.  Healy, 
Cissy  (New  York:  Doubleday,  1960),  or  Alice  Albright  Hoge,  Cissy 
Patterson  (New  York:  Random  House,  1966). 

2.  Eleanor  Gizycki,  Fall  Flight  (New  York:  Minton,  Balch  and  Com- 
pany, 1928),  p.  68. 

3.  Jean  Stansbury,  "A  Glimpse  of  Eleanor  Patterson,  Part  Two,"  The 
Senator  I  (April  15,  1939),  13. 

4.  Marguerite  Cassini,  Never  a  Dull  Moment  (New  York:  Harper 
and  Brothers,  1956).  p.  202. 

5.  E.  Gizycki,  Flight,  p.  163. 

6.  Felicia  Gizycki,  "Jackson  Hole  1916-1965:  A  Reminiscence,"  Vogue 
(April  1,  1965),  pp.  200  and  203. 

7.  Ibid.,  p.  208. 

8.  Eleanor  Gizycki,  Glass  Houses  (New  York:  Minton,  Balch  and 
Company,  1926),  p.  151. 

9.  Drew  Pearson,  More  Merry  Go  Round  (New  York:  Liveright,  Inc., 
1932),  p.   17. 

10.  Drew   Pearson,    "Our   Leading   Lady   Publisher,"   Redbook   25 
(December,  1937),  93. 

11.  Drew    Pearson,     Washington    Merry    Go    Round    (New    York: 
Liveright,  Inc.,  1931),  p.  13. 

12.  Jean  Stansbury,  "A  Glimpse  of  Eleanor  Patterson,  Part  One,"  The 
Senator  I  (April  8,  1939),  14. 


32 


I      John  C.  Davis,  Sr.: 

Portrait  of  a 

Rocky  Mountain 

Drug  Wholesaling 

Pioneer 

By  Anthony  Palmieri,  III 


Hard  work  combined  with  good  timing  and  sound 
business  judgment  made  John  Charles  Davis,  Sr.  successful. 
Born  March  14,  1852,  in  Tipperary,  Ireland,  he  attended 
public  school  in  England  and  came  to  New  York  in  1871 
at  the  age  of  19.  In  1872  he  moved  west,  first  into  Kansas 
and  in  the  following  spring,  to  Wyoming.1 

Davis  reached  Laramie,  Wyoming,  March  10,  1872, 
working  as  a  commissary  clerk  for  the  Union  Pacific  Rail- 
road work  teams.  He  studied  telegraphy,  was  appointed 
telegraph  operator,  and  worked  until  1876  at  various  sta- 
tions along  the  Union  Pacific  Line  from  Green  River  to 
Laramie.  After  a  six-month  return  trip  to  England  that 
year,  he  became  the  night  operator  at  Fort  Steele.  But 
he  didn't  keep  the  job  long.  He  quit  and  went  to  work 
for  Trabing  Brothers  Mercantile. 

Although  officially  a  civilian,  on  September  21,  1879, 
Davis  joined  the  "Ute  expedition"  sent  to  put  down  the 
so-called  "Meeker  Uprising"  of  Ute  Indians.  In  the  action 
he  received  a  serious  foot  injury.  After  his  foot  had  healed 
Davis  then  joined  the  mercantile  firm  of  J.  W.  Hugus  of 
Rawlins.  Hugus  apparently  recognized  Davis'  potential 
quickly  because  after  working  for  only  a  short  time,  Hugus 
made  him  a  partner.  It  was  while  working  for  Hugus  that 
Davis  became  the  West's  first  chain  store  merchant.  He 
opened  the  firm's  branch  stores  in  Medicine  Bow  and  Raw- 
lins and  soon  the  Hugus  company  had  stores  in  14  towns. 
At  one  time  it  was  the  largest  distributor  of  general  mer- 
chandise in  the  Rocky  Mountain  area  with  stores  in  south- 
ern Wyoming  and  northern  Colorado. 


On  January  8,  1893,  Davis  married  Ella  Mary  Casti- 
day  of  Medicine  Bow  and  his  business  interests  contin- 
ued with  great  success.  In  Rawlins,  Davis  was  a  banking 
and  business  leader  and  he  became  very  active  in  politics. 
He  was  elected  mayor,  and  as  an  active  member  of  the 
Republican  party,  he  was  an  unsuccessful  candidate  for 
U.S.  Senator  in  1895.  He  was  also  very  active  in  the 
Masonic  Lodge.2 

Soon  he  invested  heavily  in  land,  sheep  and  cattle. 
He  became  one  of  the  largest  wool  growers  in  Wyoming.3 
The  partnership  also  owned  several  banks  with  a  payroll 
larger  than  the  gross  sales  of  many  stores.  While  Davis 
was  living  there,  Rawlins  was  a  wild  west  city  of  2,300. 
Bandits  and  ladies  of  the  evening  were  ever-present  and 
Davis  decided  to  move  so  he  could  give  his  children  the 
advantages  of  a  larger  town. 

In  October,  1901,  on  a  trip  to  Denver  he  met  Lester 
Bridaham  who  owned  a  retail  drugstore  with  a  small  stock- 
room for  drugs  to  be  sold  to  other  commercial  operations. 
Bridaham  had  formed  the  business  with  Frank  Quereau 
in  the  spring  of  1896.  In  October,  1901,  Quereau  withdrew 
from  the  business.  Bridaham  had  come  west  from  Wash- 
ington, D.C.,  working  first  as  a  drug  clerk.  In  that  job 
he  developed  ideas  of  manufacturing  and  wholesaling 
which  he  put  into  practice  in  the  Bridaham-Quereau  part- 
nership and  in  his  later  association  with  Davis. 

A  month  after  he  had  met  Bridaham,  Davis  had 
bought  into  the  business.  Davis,  Bridaham  and  Fred  L. 

33 


flgS 


r" 


I  A 


A  Davis  Album 


P*te®Fj    jit 


-i  "-^^ 


.*|:  if!  .*-;■■  s      m.   .  I  ti   i:    \i  ;•— 

UlmMs  JiiJLJalBi    "-■•' 


Davis  began  his 
career  with  the  J.   W. 
Hugus  Company  in 
Rawlins  (top).  In 
1901  he  moved  to 
Denver  and  became 
a  partner  in  the  firm 
of  Davis- Bridaham, 
(offices  pictured  at 
bottom  left).   The 
store  was  previously 
known  as  Bridaham- 
Quereau  (right). 
Fred  Andrews  (bot- 
tom, right)  was  one 
of  the  firm's  most 
valued  employees. 
He  later  became 
president  of  Davis 
Brothers  Drug  Com- 
pany. (All  photos 
from  the  American 
Heritage  Center, 
University  of 
Wyoming) 


34 


Andrews  incorporated  the  Davis-Bridaham  Drug  Com- 
pany on  November  18,   1901. 

Andrews  was  responsible  for  much  of  the  continued 
success  of  the  firm  over  the  years.  (He  was  a  dedicated 
employee  who  worked  for  the  successive  corporations  from 
September,  1900,  until  his  death,  October  12,  1967,  at 
age  94.  He  was  general  manager  of  the  firm  from  1943-46 
and  president  from  1946-53.)  Davis  agreed  to  buy  into 
the  company  only  if  Fred  Andrews  would  continue  with 
the  operation. 

Davis  and  Bridaham  were  in  business  together  for 
eight  years.  They  purchased  a  building  at  1515  Blake 
Street,  Denver,  in  1901  and  inventoried  it  with  $65,000 
in  goods.  The  trade  territory  initially  consisted  of  about 
100  drug  accounts  and  the  firm  employed  20  men  includ- 
ing three  salesmen.  At  that  time,  druggists'  stock  was  not 
very  diversified  and  the  spirit  of  the  business  at  Davis- 
Bridaham  maintained  that  concept  as  well.  The  growth 
of  the  firm  was  steady  and  gradual  over  the  next  few  years. 
Davis  and  Bridaham  became  very  close  to  one  another 
with  Davis  effectively  running  the  firm  and  Bridaham 
looking  up  to  him  as  a  father  as  well  as  a  partner.4  Soon 
Davis  realized  the  need  for  diversification  of  the  company's 
line  and  began  selling  many  other  items. 

At  the  same  time,  Davis  remained  head  of  J.  W.  Hugus 
Co.  and  was  actively  involved  in  the  business.  He  divided 
his  time  among  his  business  interests. 

Denver  had  grown  to  a  city  of  150,000  in  the  early 
1900s.  It  was  developing  as  a  center  for  trade  in  the  Rocky 
Mountain  area. 

Davis  divided  the  sales  area  among  the  salesmen  and 
by  1908,  the  business  had  outgrown  its  original  location. 
The  firm  moved  into  the  old  Chamber  of  Commerce 
Building  at  14th  and  Lawrence  Street. 

In  the  beginning  of  January,  1909,  Davis  was  at  the 
height  of  success.  His  businesses  were  flourishing.  He  and 
his  wife  had  recently  celebrated  their  26th  wedding  anni- 
versary and  they  had  three  sons  and  two  daughters. 

On  Friday,  January  15,  1909,  he  was  making  a  tour 
of  some  western  Colorado  towns  in  which  he  operated 
Hugus'  stores  and  owned  banks.  After  finishing  business 
in  Walcott,  Colorado,  he  took  the  Denver  and  Rio  Grande 
train  to  Rifle.  Davis  usually  rode  in  a  Pullman  car  because 
he  thought  them  safer  than  the  older,  flimsy  chair  cars. 
But  by  the  time  he  got  aboard,  it  was  late  and  not  want- 
ing to  disturb  the  sleeping  Pullman  car  attendant,  he  rode 
in  the  chair  car. 

Near  the  Dotsero  station  the  train  was  involved  in  a 
head-on  collision  with  a  doubleheader  freight.  Davis  was 
one  of  24  people  who  died  in  the  crash.  All  were  in  the 
chair  car.  The  Pullman  car  was  relatively  untouched.  The 


blame  for  the  wreck  was  placed  on  the  engineer  of  the 
passenger  train  who  either  read  his  orders  incorrectly  or 
believed  he  had  more  time  to  make  the  next  siding.  The 
engine  crews  escaped  serious  injury  when  they  jumped 
from  the  trains  once  they  realized  the  inevitable.5 

A  year  before  his  death,  on  a  trip  to  Ireland  he  was 
asked  how  people  could  be  successful  in  the  U.S.  "I  have 
been  asked  that  question  a  thousand  times,"  he  said,  "and 
my  answer  had  always  been  'work'.  I  have  never  known, 
in  my  35  years  experience,  a  man  to  go  into  any  line  of 
business  stay  with  it  all  day  and  dream  of  it  all  night  — 
but  what  his  hopes  have  been  realized.  He  has  done  quite 
as  good  as  he  has  expected,  and  the  harder  the  work,  the 
more  money  he  had  made."6  His  estate  was  estimated  in 
seven  figures. 

Upon  his  father's  death,  Roblin  H.  Davis,  a  1907 
Princeton  graduate,  was  elected  president  of  Davis-Brida- 
ham. Lester  Bridaham  remained  vice-president  and  gen- 
eral manager.  The  J.  W.  Hugus  stores  were  eventually  sold 
to  their  individual  managers  or  sold  to  outside  people 
shortly  after  Davis'  death. 

Rumors  indicated  that  Bridaham  and  Roblin  Davis 
differed  often  and  because  of  that,  Bridaham  sold  his 
interest  to  the  Davis  estate.7  Apparently  suffering  from 
financial  reverses,  ill  health,  depression  and  melancholy, 
Bridaham  jumped  seven  stories  to  his  death  on  October 
18,  1912.  The  next  year  the  name  of  the  firm  was  changed 
to  Davis  Brothers  Drug  Company.8 

Roblin  Davis  was  president  from  1913  to  1933  and  his 
brother  John  C.  Davis,  Jr.,  was  president  from  1933  to 
1943.  When  John  died,  Fred  Andrews  became  general 
manager  and  president  until  1953.  He  also  served  as  board 
chairman  until  his  death  in  1967. 

The  company  purchased  operations  in  Montana  and 
New  Mexico,  and  expanded  steadily  to  include  all  of  the 
Rocky  Mountain  West.  John  C.  Davis,  III,  was  president 
of  the  firm  from  1953  to  1979  when  he  became  chairman, 
a  position  he  still  holds.  The  firm  purchased  Hatton  Drug 
Wholesalers  in  Miami,  Florida,  in  1983,  and  continues 
to  operate  throughout  the  Rocky  Mountain  area. 

1.  Unpublished  manuscript.  Fred  L.  Andrews,  dated  August  8,  1958, 
on  file  in  the  offices  of  Davis  Brothers  Wholesalers,  Denver, 
Colorado. 

2.  Ibid. 

3.  "Know  Your  Wholesalers  No.  2,  Davis  Brothers  Drug  Company," 
Mountain  State  Druggist,  April,  1944,  p.  20. 

4.  Olive  Bertram  Peabody,  "John  Charles  Davis— The  West's  Chain 
Store  Tycoon,"  Golden  West,  March,  1973,  p.  20. 

5.  Palisade  (newspaper)  Mesa  County,  Colorado,  January  23,  1909. 

6.  The  Denver  Times,  October  18,  1912,  p.  1. 

7.  Semi-Weekly  Republican,  January  25,  1902,  p.  24. 

8.  Andrews,  op.cit. 


35 


A  Funeral  at  Fort  Laramie 


By  Lewis  A.  Eaton 


There  are  records  of  deaths  and  burials  located 
at  Fort  Laramie  National  Historic  Site.  Usually  the 
record  gives  the  rank,  name,  date  of  death  and 
sometimes  cause  of  death. 

My  curiosity  was  aroused  when  I  read  the  follow- 
ing: 

"Preparations  have  been  going  on  for  two  or  three  days 
for  a  funeral  which  comes  off  today  at  two  o'clock.  Tis 
of  a  sergent  of  the  ninth  Kansas  who  was  killed  last  first 
day  by  the  falling  of  a  part  of  a  mud  wall  near  the  stables. 
He  had  been  tending  a  saw  mill  up  in  the  mountains  and 
came  down  to  the  fort  to  get  provisions,  had  got  every  thing 
ready,  and  was  on  the  point  of  starting  back,  when  the 
accident  happened  which  terminated  his  life.  He  leaves 
a  wife  and  five  children.  Two  of  the  boys  went  up  last  first 
day  to  inform  her  of  his  death,  and  bring  her  down  to 
the  fort.  She  took  it  very  hard,  but  she  said  she  derived 
some  consolation,  from  what  he  often  told  her  as  he  would 
come  in  from  his  work.  She  said  she  had  forebodings  that 
something  would  happen  [to]  him  while  he  was  gone, 
before  he  went  away;  but  he  told  her  that  he  was  the  hap- 
piest man  in  the  mountains  and  she  need  not  fear  for  him, 
the  same  that  he  often  told  her  as  he  would  corne  in  from 
the  mill.  The  flag  is  still  flying  at  half  mast  and  the  gar- 
rison is  out  in  line  awaiting  the  sound  of  the  bugle  to 
march  off  to  [the]  cemetery.  The  bugle  sounds,  six  young 
officers  are  seen  to  come  out  of  a  room  bearing  the  cof- 
fin on  three  muskets,  the  coffin  wrapped  in  the  American 
flag.  The  band  falls  in  front,  and  strikes  up  a  mournful 
air,  the  corpse  follows,  and  the  files  of  soldiers  close  in 
behind,  and  they  all  march  round  the  parade  ground 
keeping  step  to  the  mournful  music.  Having  left  the 
parade  they  march  off  to  the  graveyard  which  is  situated 


on  a  little  eminence,  two  or  three  hundred  yards  north 
of  the  fort,  the  soldiers  form  around  the  grave  the  coffin 
is  lowered,  fourteen  guns  — the  number  allowed  according 
to  the  rank  of  the  deceased  — are  fired  over  his  grave,  the 
Soldiers  march  off  at  a  quick  pace  and  the  funeral  is 
ended.  I  should  have  said  before  the  guns  are  fired,  the 
Chaplain  makes  a  few  remarks  appropriate  to  the  occa- 
sion."1 

Who  was  this  sergeant?  In  searching  the  military 
records  I  found  the  following: 

Sergeant  E.  H.  King  of  the  8th  Kansas  Vol.  was 
buried  in  Grave  #71  December  9th  1863. 2  From  Post 
Records  November  1863,  E.  K.  King,  Sergt,  Co.  G, 
8th  Regt  Kansas  Vols,  is  on  extra  duty  in  the  Quarter- 
master Department.  On  the  December  returns  is 
found:  Edward  K.  King,  Sergt.  Co.  G,  8th  Vol.  Inf. 
died  at  this  post  December  6,  1863,  but  nothing  is 
given  about  the  cause  of  death.  However,  on  the  final 
December  Post  Returns  is  found  this  final  note: 

E.  H.  King,  Sergt,  Company  G.,  8th  Kansas  Vols. 
Died  Dece.  6,  1863,  of  wounds  received  from  a  adobe 
house  falling  upon  him.3  (emphasis  added) 

My  curiosity  is  now  put  to  rest,  the  funeral  is  def- 
initely Sergeant  Edward  H.  King's. 

1.  Letter  December  9,  1863,  by  Pvt.  Hervey  Johnson ,  Co.  G.  11th 
Ohio  Vol.  Cav.  from  Tending  the  Talking  Wire,  by  William  E. 
Unrau  (Salt  Lake  City:  University  of  Utah  Press,   1979),  p.  73. 

2.  Record  of  Military  Deaths  in  Wyoming.  Fort  Laramie  National 
Historic  Site.  Record  Book  of  Interments  in  Post  Cemetery  File 
CEM-1,  Drawer  1. 

3.  Post  Returns  for  November  and  December  1863.  Fort  Laramie 
National  Historic  Site. 


MmWmwFim 


Painting  by  C.  Moellman,  1863. 


36 


BOOK  REVIEWS 


With  Good  Intentions:  Quaker  Work  Among  the 
Pawnees,  Otos,  and  Omahas  in  the  1870's.  By 
Clyde  A.  Milner,  II.  (Lincoln:  University  of 
Nebraska  Press,  1982).  Preface.  Illus.  Maps. 
Index.  238  pp.  Cloth,  $21.50. 

Clyde  A.  Milner  II  analyzes  the  experience  of  Hicksite 
Quaker  Indian  agents  serving  three  Nebraska  tribes  dur- 
ing the  era  of  Grant's  Peace  Policy.  He  examines  the  in- 
teraction of  these  agents  only  with  the  Pawnee,  Oto- 
Missouri  and  Omaha  Indians,  because  although  other 
Native  Americans  resided  in  Nebraska,  only  the  three 
selected  tribes  were  native  to  the  area.  The  Omahas  re- 
mained in  Nebraska,  but  the  Pawnees  and  Oto-Missouri 
removed  to  Indian  Territory  in  present  Oklahoma. 

The  book  is  more  than  a  survey  of  Hicksite  Quaker 
administrative  policy  in  Nebraska  during  the  Peace  Policy 
era.  Milner  makes  their  agency  administrations  the  cen- 
tral theme,  but  he  also  examines  their  impact  on  the 
Indian  people  dealing  with  the  harsh  life  of  frontier 
Nebraska. 

We  learn  that  each  of  the  selected  tribes,  possessing 
similar  life  styles  and  economic  bases,  was  also  unique. 
Milner  points  out  that  these  Indians  usually  experienced 
the  same  trials  of  grasshopper  plagues,  drought  and 
disease,  as  white  settlers,  but  in  addition  they  were  con- 
fronted by  the  reality  of  discrimination,  the  larceny  of 


white  pioneers,  and  an  almost  constant  fear  of  Sioux 
raiders.  The  excellent  reputation  of  the  Quakers  in  deal- 
ing with  Native  Americans  is  recognized  but  Milner  states 
that  from  the  era  of  William  Penn,  the  Friends  were  not 
without  fault.  He  mentions  numerous  instances  of  Quaker 
administrations  plagued  by  nepotism,  agents  following 
their  own  beliefs  with  little  regard  for  tribal  wishes.  He 
mentions  agents  who  named  tribal  chiefs  willing  to  follow 
the  dictates  of  the  agent.  Unfortunately,  more  traditional 
tribal  members  lost  their  standing  in  the  tribe  because 
they  would  not  conform  to  white  dictates. 

But  some  non-traditional  Indians,  especially  Joseph 
LaFlesche  of  the  Omahas,  were  not  trusted  by  Quaker 
agents.  Omaha  agent  Robert  Furnas  feared  LaFlesche 
because  he  was  a  "shrewd,  cunning  ambitious  and  aspir- 
ing politician,  who  has  never  been  willing  to  be  subor- 
dinate to  an  agent,  or  even  [to]  the  Hon.  Comr.  of  Indian 
Affairs."  But  perhaps  this  mixed-blood  Omaha  Indian  had 
something  to  offer,  because  with  his  support  and  encour- 
agement the  Omahas  occupied  111  houses  when  the  last 
Quaker  agent  left  their  agency.  His  famous  white  educated 
daughter,  Susette,  or  "Bright  Eyes,"  became  a  teacher  at 
the  Omaha  School  on  the  reservation  at  half  the  salary 
of  a  white  teacher.  But  at  least  it  was  a  start  toward  equal- 
ity because  she  soon  proved  that  she  was  an  excellent 
instructor.  Milner  notes  that  nepotism  was  rampant  dur- 
ing Agent  Vore's  tenure  among  the  Omahas.  But  in  the 

37 


end  the  Omahas  did  accommodate  the  whites  in  their  own 
way,  and  the  Omaha  "ukite"  or  community  survived 
despite  many  hardships. 

This  interesting  perceptive  book  is  a  fascinating  anal- 
ysis of  the  Hicksite  experience  as  Indian  agents  in 
Nebraska.  Milner  contends  that  the  Hicksite  Friends  did 
not  look  beyond  the  humanitarian  consensus  of  the  time 
for  the  benefit  of  the  Nebraska  Indians.  Their  actions  as 
Indian  agents  were  partially  responsible  for,  rather  than 
preventing,  the  loss  of  the  Indians'  land  base. 

Robert  E.  Smith 

Smith  is  a  Professor  of  History  at  Missouri  Southern  State  College  at 
Joplin. 


Alonso  de  Posada  Report,  1686.  A  Description  of 
the  Area  of  the  Present  Southern  United  States 
in  the  Seventeenth  Century.  Translated  and  Edited 
by  Alfred  Barnaby  Thomas.  (Pensacola:  The  Per- 
dido  Bay  Press,  1982).  viii  +  69  pp.  Bib.  Illus. 
Index.  Paper,  $8.95. 

In  1678  and  again  in  1685  King  Charles  II  of  Spain 
ordered  the  Viceroy  of  New  Spain  to  prepare  a  report  on 
the  northern  interior  provinces  of  Quivira  and  Tequayo. 
This  was  done  to  determine  whether  or  not  it  was  feasi- 
ble to  open  a  port  on  the  Gulf  of  Mexico  to  be  used  as 
the  point  of  origin  for  a  route  to  Santa  Fe.  Also,  Spain 
needed  to  know  whether  or  not  a  French  proposal  to  send 
an  expedition  to  Quivira  constituted  a  threat  to  the 
Spanish  Empire.  The  Viceroy  selected  Fray  Alonso  de 
Posada,  a  Franciscan  with  many  years  experience  in  New 
Spain,  to  write  the  report.  Posada  completed  the  task  in 
1686. 

Professor  Thomas  has  devoted  a  lifetime  to  the  study 
of  the  Posada  report.  He  discovered  four  copies  of  the 
document  in  Seville,  Madrid,  Paris,  and  Mexico  City  and 
selected  the  first  of  these  for  publication  since  it  is  the 
most  nearly  complete.  His  meticulous  study  and  editing 
of  the  document  has  provided  scholars  with  a  very  useful 
tool  because  from  the  report  can  be  gleaned  information 
concerning  the  Spaniard's  conception  of  North  American 
geography,  Indians,  and  international  rivalries  in  the  late 
17th  century.  Professor  Thomas  is  to  be  congratulated 
upon  the  successful  completion  of  this  monumental  task. 

Kenneth  E.  Hendrickson,  Jr. 

The  reviewer  is  a  professor  in  the  Humanities  Division,  History  at 
Midwestern  State  University,   Wichita  Falls,   Texas. 


Buffalo  Bill:  His  Family,  Friends,  Fame,  Failures, 
and  Fortunes,  by  Nellie  Snyder  Yost  (Chicago:  The 
Swallow  Press,  1979).  Notes.  Index.  Illus.  446  pp. 
Cloth,  $16.95. 

Acknowledging  a  debt  to  Don  Russell's  solid  attempt 
to  separate  fact  from  fiction  in  The  Lives  and  Legends 
of  Buffalo  Bill,  Nellie  Snyder  Yost  focuses  her  study  of 
Cody  on  his  connections  with  North  Platte,  Nebraska.  Her 
reason,  she  states,  is  "None  of  his  previous  biographers 
have  bothered  to  write  much  about  North  Platte,  which 
for  35  years  the  Colonel  made  his  home  and  headquarters." 
In  looking  at  Cody's  North  Platte  connection,  one  sees 
him  as  "husband,  father,  neighbor  and  citizen  in  the  town 
he  adopted  and  loved." 

The  result  is  a  combination  biography/local  history 
wherein  one  learns  who  daughter  Arta  was  entertaining 
at  the  Cody  Welcome  Wigwam,  as  reported  in  the  society 
pages  of  the  North  Platte  Tribune,  while  her  father  enter- 
tained Europe's  royalty  at  London's  Earl's  Court  Station. 
One  learns  more  about  how  Cody  secured  uniforms  for 
the  town's  Gordon  Silver  Comet  Band  than  how  he  secured 
property  and  developed  the  town  of  Cody,  Wyoming,  or 
set  up  the  Big  Horn  Project. 

Yost  presents  the  legendary  figure,  in  fact,  as  the  peo- 
ple of  North  Platte  saw  him.  Drawing  on  interviews  with 
"Platters"  that  were  conducted  and  collected  in  the  1940s, 
Yost,  a  Platter  herself,  provides  a  small-town  view  of  a 
world  famous  entertainer.  His  contemporaries  variously 
portrayed  him  as  a  womanizer,  a  drunkard,  a  generous 
benefactor  to  North  Platte  churches,  a  hero,  a  fraud,  a 
gentleman,  a  spendthrift,  a  liar,  and  a  man  who  was 
always  kind  to  children.  Cody's  marital  problems,  his 
alleged  affairs  with  showgirls  (not  to  mention  with  Queen 
Victoria  and  the  Princess  of  Wales),  his  children's  early 
and  untimely  deaths,  the  suicides  of  sons-in-law,  his  sen- 
sational and  unsuccessful  attempt  to  divorce  wife  Louisa 
—  all  make  up  the  stuff  and  substance  of  small  town  scan- 
dal. And  the  book  itself,  while  carefully  researched, 
borders  on  the  gossipy.  That,  in  the  end,  is  its  appeal. 
The  reader  is  drawn  into  the  drama  —  or  melodrama  — 
of  Cody's  family  triumphs  and  tragedies.  Did  Louisa  really 
trash  Cody's  hotel  suite  when  she  discovered  him  living 
there  with  another  woman?  Would  Will  and  Louisa  ever 
be  reconciled? 

This  is  not  a  book  for  those  who  hope  to  place  Cody 
and  his  Wild  West  Show  in  some  kind  of  cultural/intellec- 
tual context  or  who  seek  some  larger  meaning  in  Buffalo 
Bill  as  symbol.  Yost  is  simply  not  concerned  with  that  sort 
of  thing.  This  is  a  book  for  those  people  who  want  to  know 
the  details  of  Cody's  stormy  marriage  or  the  details  of  how 
North  Platters  greeted  Buffalo  Bill  on  his  periodic  visits 
to  the  Welcome  Wigwam  or  Scout's  Rest  Ranch.  It  is  a 
hometown  history  of  a  showbiz  celebrity  and  adopted 
native  son. 

Buffalo  Bill  fans  will  no  doubt  devour  it.  Others  may 
find  Yost's  continual  tendency  to  repeat  legends  and  fan- 


38 


ciful  stories,  only  to  debunk  them,  rather  tedious.  But 
there  is  something  compelling  about  the  personal  story 
of  Cody's  family  relations,  business  failures,  generosity,  and 
perpetual  optimism  that  can  appeal  to  those  with  little 
interest  in  Buffalo  Bill  or  his  Wild  West  Show.  Yost's  book 
presents  a  19th  century  Western  town's  willingness  to 
capitalize  on  Cody's  fame  in  order  to  boost  its  own 
economic  prospects,  to  forgive  him  his  excesses  ("It  wasn't 
his  fault  that  women  went  crazy  over  him"),  and  to  lament 
his  final  passing  (thirteen  members  of  the  local  Knights 
Templar  attended  his  Denver  funeral).  And  her  book  pro- 
vides an  intimate  view  of  a  19th  century  Westerner,  an 
American  type  —  a  showman,  entrepreneur,  a  man  con- 
tinually on-the-make  who  never  really  made  it  outside  of 
the  realm  of  myth  and  legend. 

Sherry  Smith 

Smith  is  a  insiting  professor  in  the  History  Department  of  the  Univer- 
sity of  Wyoming. 


Kopet:  A  Documentary  Narrative  of  Chief  Joseph's 
Last  Years.  By  M.  Gidley.  (Seattle:  University  of 
Washington  Press,  1981)  Illus.  Chronology.  168  pp. 
Cloth,  $19.95. 

Kopet:  A  Documentary  Narrative  of  Chief  Joseph's 
Last  Years,  is  a  handsome,  large-format  style  book.  It  has 
over  70  photographs  taken  on  the  Colville  Reservation 
from  1890-1910  where  Joseph  and  his  Wallowa  band  of 
Nez  Perces  were  sent  in  1885  after  seven  years  confine- 
ment on  reservations  in  Kansas  and  Oklahoma.  It  is  an 
expensive  book,  but  the  photographs  themselves  are  worth 
the  price,  especially  the  one  of  Chica-ma-poo,  or  Old  Jean, 
more  than  90 -years  old,  carrying  a  stack  of  firewood  on 
her  back,  her  axe  strapped  into  the  load,  a  small  dog 
following  her,  and  her  determined  expression.  She  was  the 
oldest  survivor  among  Joseph's  band  at  Nespelem,  one  who 
"deliberately  joined  the  Nez  Perce  war  effort  in  1877,  even 
against  the  wishes  of  her  husband." 

The  bulk  of  this  book  is  made  up  of  narrative  accounts 
by  seven  white  witnesses  to  Chief  Joseph's  final  years.  It 
is  to  Gidley 's  credit  that  he  sets  his  reader  straight  on  the 
first  page  of  his  "Preface"  lest  they  be  led  astray  by  the 
publisher's  subtitle,  "A  Documentary  Narrative  of  Chief 
Joseph's  Last  Years."  To  quote  Mr.  Gidley, 

I  hope  this  book  will  not  be  thought  of  as  a  conventional 
biographical  study  of  those  years.  It  is  not.  It  does  not  at 
all  attempt,  for  example,  to  reconstruct  or  recreate  what 
Joseph  was  thinking  and  it  does  not  come  near  to  describ- 
ing his  day-to-day  life  or  many  of  the  significant  activities 
in  which  he  played  his  part. 

Rather,  it  is  highly  selective  and  concerns  those  parts  of 
his  life  that  touched  the  lives  of  a  number  of  white  men  at 


the  turn  of  the  century  —  and,  of  course,  those  parts  of  their 
lives  that  touched  his.  The  narrative  is  unfolded,  therefore, 
largely  through  a  series  of  documents,  mainly  letters  and 
photographs  produced  by  these  men  and  newspaper  items 
in  which  they  Figured. 

Imagine  this  reviewer's  astonished  disappointment  to 
discover  that  the  "Documentary  Narrative  of  Chief  Joseph's 
Last  Years"  consisted  of  the  letters  and  other  documents 
of  seven  white  men  who  could  publicly  claim  "I  knew  Chief 
Joseph"  and  had  their  photos  of  him  or  with  him  to  prove 
it!  Central  to  these  seven  is  Edmond  S.  Meany,  the  pro- 
fessor from  Seattle,  to  whom  several  of  the  others  cor- 
responded. They  include  Edward  Curtis,  the  famous 
maker  of  Indian  photographic  portraits;  Edward  Latham, 
agency  physician  at  Nespelem  and  amateur  photographer; 
and  Henry  M.  Steele,  the  Bureau  of  Indian  Affairs  sub- 
agent  assigned  to  teach  the  Nez  Perces  to  farm.  Finally 
the  person  who  appeared  closest  to  them,  most  trusted 
and  respected  by  them,  and  whose  life  ended  tragically 
in  murder  and  suicide,  Albert  M.  Anderson.  He  was  a 
storekeeper,  clerk,  then  chief  assistant  to  the  agent  for  the 
Colville  Reservation  1889-93.  He  also  served  as  agent  to 
the  Colville  Reservation  from  1897  to  1903.  He  was  later 
removed  from  his  post  and  entered  the  real  estate  business, 
eventually  becoming  "right-of-way  and  tax  agent  for  the 
Great  Northern  Railway.  In  this  capacity  he  bought  de- 
velopment land  for  the  railroad,  including  land  supposedly 
held  in  perpetuity  by  the  Indians  of  the  Colville  and 
Spokane  Reservations." 

One  omission  which  this  reader  found  especially  dis- 
tressing had  to  do  with  a  Joseph  detractor.  Henry  M. 
Steele,  in  a  letter  to  Meany  describing  the  preparation  for 
raising  a  monument  above  Joseph's  grave  in  1905,  states 
that  he  is  sending  Meany  the  Spokane  Chronicle  because 
of  an  article  in  it  by  one  Lew  Wilmot.  "He  [Wilmot]  was 
a  member  of  the  volunteer  party  sent  against  Joseph  in 
'77.  It  [the  article]  should  be  answered  and  hope  you  will 
do  so.  I  am  acquainted  with  Wilmot  and  know  him  to 
be  very  much  biased  and  prejudiced  against  Joseph.  He 
is  about  70  years  old  and  in  his  dotage."  Meany  published 
"Highest  Type  of  Indian"  in  the  Seattle  Times  of  June  13th 
as  a  refutation  of  Wilmot's  attacks. 

It  seems  to  me  that  this  attack  on  Joseph  by  an  old 
Indian  fighter  and  Joseph's  defense  by  the  Professor  would 
give  us  an  excellent  view  of  the  contemporary  range  of 
responses  to  him,  and  of  the  conflicts  which  these  could 
precipitate.  Instead,  we  are  treated  exclusively  to  the  "I 
knew  Chief  Joseph"  types  maneuvering  over  who  will  have 
exclusive  rights  to  photograph  the  events  commemorating 
the  monument,  or  confessing  their  desire  for  some  impor- 
tant piece  of  Joseph's  belongings. 

Perhaps  the  most  revealing  portrait  in  the  text  is  of 
Edward  Curtis  at  the  commemoration  of  the  Joseph  Mem- 
orial. In  Meany  s  article  for  the  Post- Intelligencer  entitled 
"Unveil  Monument,"  he  reports  that  "the  older  Indians 
objected  to  the  presence  of  photographers"  and  that  it  took 
two  hours  of  negotiation  and  the  "soothing"  presence  of 

39 


Captain  Webster  to  "calm  their  fears."  This  was  not  the 
end  of  the  matter,  however,  for: 

Incidentally,  however,  Mr.  Curtis  encountered  a  great  deal 
of  trouble  in  the  Nez  Perce  country.  That  particular  tribe 
is  torn  assunder  over  the  successor  to  the  late  Chief  Joseph. 
A  contemptible,  ignorant,  lazy  loafer,"  to  quote  Mr. 
Curtis  literally,  by  the  name  of  Albert  Waters,  is  trying  to 
take  the  place  of  the  late  ruler,  and  for  some  reason  he  con- 
ceived the  idea  that  Curtis  was  bad  medicine  and  refused 
to  let  him  take  photos  of  the  unveiling  of  the  Joseph 
Monument. 

Albert  Waters  walked  up  to  the  Curtis  camera  and 
pushed  it  roughly  aside  just  as  the  local  photographer  was 
about  to  press  the  button.  Naturally  that  made  Edward 
somewhat  angry.  He  restrained  himself,  however,  and,  look- 
ing the  Indian  squarely  in  the  eyes,  delivered  himself  of  the 
following: 

"Albert,  if  you  lay  your  hands  on  that  camera  again  I 
will  feel  compelled  to  punch  your  face,  and  if  that  is  not 
sufficient,  I  will  blow  the  top  of  your  head  off,"  and  so  say- 
ing he  pulled  a  saucy  little  six-shooter  out  of  his  pocket, 
whereupon  Albert  Waters  quit  like  a  dog.  Turning  to  Big 
Bull  or  Little  Bull,  or  whichever  member  of  the  Bull  family 
it  was  that  was  an  eye  witness  to  the  affair,  Curtis  said: 
"Bull,  what  do  you  think  of  Albert  Waters?" 
"Oh,"  replied  Bull,  "you  pick  'em  up  old  sock,  and  wash 
him  and  make  him  chief.  All  same  Albert  Waters." 
Even  though  the  new  chief,  Albert  Waters  (we  need  to 
know  more  about  him!)  is  spoken  of  badly  by  Curtis  and 
one  member  of  the  Bull  family,  the  incident  casts  Curtis 
in  a  less  than  positive  light  too.  The  objection  to  the 
presence  of  photographers  (Latham  and  Moorhouse  were 
also  present),    is  described  as  coming  from  the  older 
Indians  and  involving  two  hours  of  negotiation.  Curtis, 
in  his  passion  to  photograph,  belittles,  threatens  and  then 
pulls  a  pistol  on  Waters,  all  in  the  interest  of  photographic 
documentation.  By  1905,  he  should  have  understood  more 
about  Indians  and  photography. 

Too  much  of  this  book  is  a  description  by  white  males 
maneuvering  around  the  distant  magnificence  of  a  tragic 
leader  in  his  last  days,  photographing  him,  bringing  him 
to  the  University  of  Seattle  to  lecture,  desiring  his  belong- 
ings. Joseph  comes  through  as  a  man  with  one  plea  - 
a  desire  to  return  to  his  homeland,  the  Wallowa  Valley, 
that  earth  with  which  he  was  of  one  mind. 

Roger  Dunsmore 

The  reviewer  is  an  Associate  Professor  in  Humanities  at  the  Univer- 
sity of  Montana  in  Missoula. 


Oil  Booms:  Social  Change  in  Five  Texas  Towns. 
By  Roger  M.  Olien  and  Diana  Davids  Olien.  (Lin- 
coln: University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1982).  Notes. 
Index.  Illus.  Charts.  220  pp.  Cloth,  $16.95. 

Although  space  is,  in  the  cliche,  the  final  frontier, 
there  remains  an  area  of  American  life  in  which  frontier 
conditions  maintained  until  just  recently.  That  holdover 

40 


from  the  frontier  era  is  the  topic  of  Oil  Booms.  The  Oliens' 
study  of  five  Texas  oil  boom  towns  uses  the  modern  fron- 
tier thesis  as  a  basis  for  the  examination  of  the  impact 
of  the  oil  industry  in  West  Texas.  Olien  and  Olien  argue 
that  the  stereotypical  portrayal  of  lawlessness  epitomized 
in  the  classic  film,  Boom  Town,  is  but  one  small  episode 
in  the  larger  phenomenon  associated  with  American  oil 
exploration  and  production.  Admittedly,  the  early  stage 
on  any  frontier  is  one  in  which  law  and  civilization  suffer 
great  setbacks,  if  not  complete  breakdown.  But,  as  the 
authors  affirm,  such  a  situation  is  only  temporary.  Bor- 
dellos and  banditry  quickly  give  way  to  law  and  order. 
Even  before  the  boom  runs  its  course,  the  impact  of  the 
boom  is  confined  to  economic  change  and  pressures  on 
city  services  such  as  schools  and  sewers.  The  impact  of 
an  oil  boom  is  analogous  to  that  of  a  military  installation 
or  any  other  cause  of  rapid  expansion  of  services. 

The  emphasis  of  the  Oliens  is  on  description  of  the 
short-  and  long-term  impacts  of  boom  and  prosperity  on 
five  towns  in  West  Texas.  Those  towns  are  Midland, 
Odessa,  Wink,  McCamey,  and  Snyder.  All  were  compar- 
atively insignificant  backwaters  prior  to  the  exploration 
for  and  discovery  of  oil.  All  had  problems  in  coping  with 
the  rapid  growth  associated  with  the  exploration  and  dev- 
elopment periods.  All  survived,  prospered,  and  declined 
—  the  extent  of  each  stage  varying  with  local  conditions. 
For  instance,  Midland  and  Odessa  maintained  their  pros- 
perity fairly  well  because  they  adapted  to  serve  as  centers 
for  post-boom  petroleum  operations  and  as  service  centers 
for  the  later  oil  exploration  activities  in  the  region.  In  con- 
trast, towns  without  adaptability  or  a  strong  tie  to 
petroleum  operations  tended  to  fade.  Another  example 
of  the  varying  degree  of  impact  of  the  oil  cycle  was  Snyder, 
where  the  boom  to  normality  evolution  was  less  intense 
because  when  it  happened,  20  years  after  the  other  epi- 
sodes, the  petroleum  industry  was  more  organized,  effi- 
cient, and  controlled  than  in  the  earlier  era.  Despite  varia- 
tions, however,  the  cycle  posited  by  the  authors  of  Oil 
Booms  remains  a  workable  model. 

The  Oliens  have  broken  new  ground  in  oil  history. 
Although  they  develop  no  startlingly  new  thesis  for  20th 
century  Western  history,  they  utilize  a  now  generally 
accepted  theory  in  a  new  way  and  in  an  area  which  has 
long  been  in  need  of  their  type  of  critical  analysis.  If  that 
were  the  sole  contribution  of  Oil  Booms,  the  work  would 
be  a  valuable  addition  to  the  scholar's  book  shelf.  However, 
there  is  more. 

Further  enhancing  the  value  of  this  volume  is  the 
quality  of  the  research.  Rather  than  relying  on  the  lurid 
reporting  which  led  earlier  writers  astray,  the  researchers 
utilized  modern  methodology.  Not  only  did  they  devote 
great  effort  to  collecting  and  examining  oral  histories,  but 
they  also  undertook  a  major  examination  of  city  records, 
a  painful  process  at  best.  The  quality  of  the  research 
enhances  the  worth  of  Oil  Booms. 

Finally,  the  University  of  Nebraska  Press  deserves 
acknowledgement  for  its  fine  and  skillful  preparation  of 


ithe  book.  Not  only  is  the  text  clean,  but  the  presentation 
is  highly  pleasing. 

Oil  Booms  may  not  receive  the  recognition  it  is  due. 
Nevertheless,  it  is  a  significant  work  which  must  be  reck- 
oned with  by  all  who  choose  to  further  examine  the  field. 
Most  important  of  all,  it  is  a  pleasure  to  read. 

J.  Herschel  Barnhill 

Dr.  Barnhill,  author  of  From  Surplus  to  Substitution:  Energy  in  Texas, 
[is  an  archivist  for  the  Oklahoma  State  Archives  in  Oklahoma  City. 

Mormon  Thunder:  A  Documentary  History  of 
Jedediah  Grant.  By  Gene  A.  Sessions.  (Urbana, 
Illinois:  University  of  Illinois  Press,  1982).  Illus. 
Append.  Notes.  Index,  xvii  +  413  pp.  Cloth, 
$16.95. 

Builders  of  the  Kingdom:  George  A.  Smith,  John 
Henry  Smith,  George  Albert  Smith.  By  Merlo  J. 
Pusey.  (Provo,  Utah:  Brigham  Young  University 
Press,  1981).  Illus.  Chart.  Append.  Notes.  Index, 
xiv  +   392  pp.  Cloth,  $10.95. 

In  1833  seventeen  year  old  Jedediah  Morgan  Grant 
repented  his  sins  and  embraced  the  "restored  gospel"  of 
the  three  year  old  Mormon  church.  A  congenital  mission- 
ary, he  spent  the  better  part  of  the  next  fourteen  years 
spreading  the  gospel  among  the  "gentiles."  Despite  his  fre- 
quent visits  to  the  principal  church  settlements  in  Ohio, 
Missouri,  and  Illinois,  Grant  had  no  permanent  home 
among  his  brethren  until  after  the  Saints'  great  migra- 
tion to  the  Salt  Lake  Valley  in  1847.  Even  then,  church 
assignments  in  the  East  frequently  kept  him  from  home 
until  1852.  In  Utah,  Grant's  long  service  on  the  outposts 
of  Mormondom  was  rewarded  when  he  became  a  brigadier 
general  in  the  Nauvoo  Legion,  the  first  mayor  of  Salt  Lake 
City,  the  speaker  of  the  territorial  House  of  Represen- 
tatives, and,  in  1854,  a  member  of  the  First  Presidency 
of  the  church  as  second  counselor  to  Brigham  Young. 
Grant  was  blunt,  tough-minded,  energetic,  and  obsessed 
with  Mormon  perfectionist  doctrines.  He  gave  unquestion- 
ing loyalty  to  his  church  superiors  and,  in  turn,  expected 
an  unquestioning  loyalty  from  those  beneath  him.  To 
Grant's  great  disappointment  his  brethren  often  seemed 
lacking  in  both  perfectionist  zeal  and  loyalty.  His  fixa- 
tion with  their  sins  finally  led  him  to  preach  the  doctrine 
of  "blood  atonement,"  the  belief  that  those  who  break  their 
covenant  with  the  Lord  should  make  restitution  with  their 
lives.  Grant's  fervor  earned  him  the  nickname  "the 
sledgehammer  of  Brigham,"  and  although  his  premature 
death  at  the  age  of  40  did  not  allow  him  to  see  it  through, 
he,  in  large  part,  sparked  the  "Mormon  Reformation  of 
1856-7"  which  plunged  the  church  into  a  thoroughgoing 
revival . 

In  Mormon  Thunder  Gene  A.  Sessions  assembles 
excerpts  from  Jedediah  Grant's  missionary  journal,  let- 


ters, and  sermons,  along  with  similar  material  from  his 
contemporaries  into  a  full-scale  biography.  Grant  was  a 
highly  interesting  man,  and  Sessions'  able  transitions  keep 
the  narrative  flow  moving  at  a  respectable  pace.  Sessions, 
however,  is  not  merely  content  to  retell  the  particulars  of 
Grant's  life.  In  his  view,  Grant  epitomized  early  Mor- 
monism  more  closely  than  Andrew  Jackson  did  the  "Jack- 
sonian  era."  To  extract  the  essence  of  early  Mormonism 
from  these  documents  is,  as  Sessions  admits,  a  "tall  order." 
Unfortunately,  it  is  in  this  basic  endeavor  that  his  effort 
falters.  His  conclusion  that  Grant  archetypically  repre- 
sented his  brethren  in  his  total  dedication  through  the 
church  to  millennial  perfectionism  in  both  spiritual  and 
temporal  spheres  breaks  no  new  ground  in  our  understand- 
ing of  early  Mormonism.  Much  of  Sessions'  failure  to  elicit 
greater  meaning  from  his  subject  stems  from  his  conscious 
decision  to  eschew  a  recital  of  the  old  familiar  story  of 
early  church  history.  Yet  if  a  narrative  recitation  of  events 
is  not  needed,  a  discussion  of  Grant's  life  within  its  wider 
context  is.  For  example,  bereft  of  a  solid  contextual  foun- 
dation readers  might  wonder  if  the  Saints  were  indeed 
the  sinful  backsliders  Grant  suggested,  or  whether  Grant 
himself  had  lost  touch  with  reality  in  his  zeal.  Similarly, 
Grant  was  an  original  member  of  the  controversial  "Coun- 
cil of  Fifty"  and  heavily  involved  in  the  planning  of  the 
State  of  Deseret,  yet  here  too,  Sessions  provides  only  passing 
discussion  of  Mormon  political  ideas  and  aspirations. 

To  some  extent  Sessions'  troubles  are  rooted  in  his  deci- 
sion to  stay  close  to  his  documentary  evidence.  This  strat- 
egy often  guides  the  discussion  toward  extant  material  and 
not  necessarily  toward  what  might  prove  more  biograph- 
ically  revealing.  Sessions  sometimes  publishes  documents 
of  limited  value  because  of  the  dearth  of  significant 
material,  especially  for  the  years  before  Grant's  rise  to 
eminence. 

There  are  other  problems  as  well:  occasional  lapses 
into  an  overly  melodramatic  style,  an  attempt  to  give  Grant 
an  intellectuality  he  did  not  possess,  and  superficial  com- 
parisons of  Grant's  activities  to  those  of  Puritan  divines. 
Nevertheless,  Sessions  has  not  wasted  his  time.  Shorn  of 
its  ambitious  designs  Mormon  Thunder  reads  well  and 
will  provide  a  useful  source  book  for  professional 
historians. 

Merlo  Pusey  has  written  the  type  of  book  Sessions 
scorns.  In  Builders  of  the  Kingdom  Pusey  follows  the  lives 
of  George  A.  Smith  (1817-1875),  his  son  John  Henry  Smith 
(1848-1911),  and  his  grandson  George  Albert  Smith 
(1870-1951)  down  the  well-beaten  path  of  Mormon  history. 
Yet  if  Pusey  has  little  to  offer  those  already  familiar  with 
his  subject,  he  nevertheless  covers  old  ground  in  a  highly 
readable  style  and  with  arresting  quotations. 

Pusey  originally  began  work  on  his  history  of  the 
Smiths  in  the  late  1950s  and  completed  it  in  the  1960s. 
Because  a  member  of  the  Smith  family  objected  to  cer- 
tain portions  of  his  manuscript,  Pusey  delayed  publishing 
it  until  1981.  Although  he  has  revised  his  text  in  light  of 
recent  developments  in  Mormon  historiography  many  of 

41 


his  interpretations  remain  dated.  They  are  also  subtly  par- 
tisan. Although  Pusey  never  deems  the  Saints  faultless  in 
Mormon-Gentile  conficts,  he  often  lacks  detachment  from 
old  battles.  Builders  of  the  Kingdom,  however,  was  clearly 
written  with  a  Mormon  audience  in  mind  and  no  doubt 
few  of  his  readers  will  object  to  his  slant.  Curiously,  in 
the  last  and  longest  section  of  the  book,  covering  the  life 
of  George  Albert  Smith,  Pusey  drops  the  wide  lens  view 
of  history  which  characterizes  his  first  two  sections.  Instead 
he  presents  a  strikingly  intimate  portrait  of  Smith  that 
often  borders  on  hagiography.  George  Albert  suffered  from 
delicate  health  his  entire  life,  much  of  it  psychosomatic. 
Although  Pusey  refuses  to  speculate  on  its  roots,  he  spares 
us  no  cold,  scratch,  or  near  accident.  Ironically,  this  sec- 
tion of  the  book,  which  is  its  weakest,  will  prove  of  greatest 
interest  to  professional  historians  for  its  abundant  fund 
of  information  gleaned  from  letters  and  oral  interviews 
unavailable  elsewhere  and  its  relative  candor  in  discuss- 
ing the  private  relationships  of  the  Apostles. 

Kenneth  Winn 


The  reviewer  is  with  the  Department  of  History,  Washington  Univer- 
sity, St.  Louis,  Missouri. 


Shadows  of  the  Indian:  Stereotypes  in  American 
Culture.  By  Raymond  William  Stedman.  (Nor- 
man: University  of  Oklahoma  Press,  1982).  Index. 
Illus.  281  pp.  Cloth,  $24.95. 

Carlos  Montezuma  and  the  Changing  World  of 
American  Indians.  By  Peter  Iverson.  (Albuquer- 
que: University  of  New  Mexico  Press,  1982). 
Index.  Illus.  222  pp.  Cloth,  $17.50. 

These  works  examine  the  myth  and  reality  of  the 
American  Indian.  Stedman's  Shadows  of  the  Indian: 
Stereotypes  in  American  Culture  analyzes  the  various 
depictions  of  the  Native  Americans  found  in  the  mass 
media  for  the  purpose  of  determining  white  attitudes 
toward  them.  Iverson's  Carlos  Montezuma  and  the  Chang- 
ing World  of  the  American  Indian  is  a  biography  of  a 
late  19th  and  early  20th  century  Indian  leader  that  tries 
to  humanize  that  race's  search  for  an  identity  through  the 
personal  journey  of  this  single  tribesman.  These  books  are 
very  different  in  tone  and  execution.  Yet,  each  seek  to  cor- 
rect white  misconceptions  concerning  Native  Americans. 

In  order  to  properly  judge  the  success  of  these  books 
in  this  challenging  endeavor,  we  will  examine  each  sep- 
arately. The  Stedman  monograph  is  cleverly  written,  but 
attempts  to  cover  too  much  material  in  too  slim  a  volume. 
Instead  of  placing  reasonable  parameters  on  his  study,  the 
author  chooses  to  encompass  all  forms  of  mass  communi- 
cation from  novels,  articles,  diaries,  radio,  cinema,  com- 
ics to  television  within  his  book.  His  range  of  time  is  from 
1492  until  the  present.  The  only  self-imposed  restriction 

42 


is  that  all  materials  reviewed  be  produced  by  white  Amer- 
icans. Once  this  restriction  is  mentioned,  it  is  quickly 
ignored  as  the  author  discusses  works  of  European  writers. 
The  sheer  magnitude  of  Stedman's  task  renders  it  impossi- 
ble for  him  adequately  to  cover  all  sources  available.  He 
ends  up  concentrating  on  20th  century  novels  and  movies 
while  scant  attention  is  given  to  radio  and  television. 

Stedman  reveals  that  the  Indian,  at  one  time  or 
another,  has  been  portrayed  as  a  child  of  nature,  devil 
incarnate,  implacable  foe,  despoiler  of  white  women, 
unreasoning  animal,  faithful  servant  and  living  in  har- 
mony with  the  natural  world.  These  stereotypes  often  con- 
tradict one  another  and  are,  for  the  most  part,  demean- 
ing. It  does  not  take  much  sensitivity  to  realize  that  the 
mass  media  has  unfairly  treated  the  red  man,  but  the  same 
criticism  can  be  made  concerning  all  other  ethnic  groups. 
Stedman  in  attempting  to  redress  one  injustice  selectively 
chooses  those  works  that  support  his  contentions  and  ig- 
nores a  substantial  body  of  films  and  literature  which  por- 
tray the  American  Indian  with  dignity  and  understanding. 

Peter  Iverson's  Carlos  Montezuma  and  the  Changing 
World  of  the  American  Indian  describes  the  real  rather 
than  mythical  world  of  Native  Americans.  He  focuses  on 
the  life  story  of  Carlos  Montezuma  of  the  Yavapai  tribe. 
In  the  book's  narrative,  Montezuma  becomes  the  symbol 
of  the  American  Indian  community  and  its  search  for  an 
identity  in  the  20th  century.  This  work  is  written  in  a  dry 
and  academic  tone. 

It  follows  the  traditional  format  of  biographies  begin- 
ning with  a  discussion  of  the  genealogy  and  birth  of 
Montezuma  in  the  1860s.  As  a  young  man,  Carlos  receives 
his  formal  education  at  Carlisle  and  emerges  to  take  his 
place  in  white  society  as  an  assimilated  Indian.  He  does 
this  by  obtaining  a  medical  degree  from  the  Chicago  Med- 
ical College  and  establishing  a  practice  in  that  city.  At 
this  point,  Montezuma's  life  undergoes  a  dramatic  trans- 
formation as  he  becomes  involved  with  the  Society  of 
American  Indians  and  an  Indian  rights  crusader.  He  turns 
from  assimilation  and  starts  a  lifelong  journey  to  under- 
stand his  identity  as  a  Yavapai. 

His  life's  work  becomes  a  campaign  to  have  the  Bureau 
of  Indian  Affairs  abolished  and  to  obtain  full  protection 
of  the  Fort  McDowell  reservation's  water  rights.  In  order 
to  carry  out  his  first  goal,  he  founds,  writes  and  edits  a 
newspaper  entitled  Wassaja.  Roughly  translated  into 
English  it  means  signalling  or  beckoning.  The  signal  he 
wished  to  send  was  that  all  tribes  should  actively  work 
toward  the  dismantlement  of  the  Bureau  of  Indian  Affairs. 
Montezuma  perceived  that  the  agency  was  the  single  big- 
gest obstacle  to  Indian  progress.  Needless  to  say,  he  was 
unable  to  accomplish  the  abolition  of  the  Bureau  in  his 
lifetime. 

His  second  goal  required  the  constant  applications  of 
time  and  money  in  fighting  against  government  attempts 
to  reduce  the  water  rights  allocated  to  the  Fort  McDowell 
reservation.  These  struggles  continued  until  his  death  from 
tuberculosis  in  January  of  1923. 


Iverson's  biography  of  the  Indian  leader  is  a  slender 
eight  chapter  work  with  two  chapters  devoted  to  the  strug- 
gle for  the  abolition  of  the  Bureau  of  Indian  Affairs  and 
the  securing  of  tribal  water  rights.  These  chapters  are 
exhilarating  depictions  of  the  American  Indian  in  tran- 
sition. The  rest  of  the  book  suffers  noticeably  in  com- 
parison. Another  difficulty  with  this  biography  is  that  the 
reader  never  gains  more  than  a  superficial  understanding 
of  the  complex  character  of  Montezuma.  In  the  final  anal- 
ysis, he  remains  only  an  intriguing  enigma  and  not  a  flesh 
and  blood  person. 

The  work  does  succeed  in  depicting  the  Indians  search 
for  an  identity  in  the  20th  century.  One  gains  a  deeper 
appreciation  of  the  individual  and  tribal  turn  away  from 
assimilation  and  toward  perceived  traditional  values.  This 
search  is  told  with  compassion  and  insight. 

Both  Iverson's  and  Stedman's  books  attempt  in  dif- 
ferent ways  to  give  a  better  understanding  of  the  Native 
Americans  by  the  white  community.  These  works  form 
part  of  a  growing  volume  of  literature  reassessing  the 
Indian  and  his  place  in  history.  These  authors  in  their 
fervor  to  correct  past  distortions  have  created  new  ones. 
These  works  will,  however,  provide  a  portion  of  a  larger 
mosaic  that  will  eventually  give  a  more  balanced  picture 
of  the  Indian.  As  yet,  it  remains  to  be  completed. 

John  C.  Paige 

The  reviewer  is  a  research  historian  with  the  National  Park  Service 
in  Denver. 

Anglo-Spanish  Confrontation  on  the  Gulf  Coast 
During  the  American  Revolution.  Edited  by 
William  S.  Coker  and  Robert  R.  Rea.  (Gulf  Coast 
History  and  Humanities  Conference;  Volume  9, 
1982)  Index.  Illus.  Maps.  218  pp.  Cloth,  $10.95; 
Paper,  $6.95.  Mailing  50<.  (Available  from  Book 
Sales,  John  C.  Pace  Library,  University  of  Western 
Florida,  Pensacola  32511). 

At  first  glance,  the  logical  question  concerning  this 
publication  is  its  relevance  to  the  history  of  Wyoming?  For 
historians  of  the  18th-century  in  general,  and  those  per- 
sons interested  in  the  era  of  the  American  Revolution  in 
particular,  this  volume  has  a  great  deal  to  offer.  First,  the 
scholarly  articles  contained  in  the  published  proceedings 
of  the  Ninth  Gulf  Coast  History  and  Humanities  Con- 
ference which  met  in  Pensacola  on  May  7-8,  1981,  con- 
stitute a  superb  recent  bibliography  on  the  historiography 
of  the  era.  Three  students  of  Professor  Herbert  Eugene 
Bolton,  who  is  considered  the  "father"  of  Spanish  Bor- 
derlands history,  participated  in  the  conference,  as  well 
as  a  number  of  the  foremost  contemporary  scholars  in  the 
field.  Second,  the  range  of  topics  covered  in  this  volume 
suggests  that  much  more  historical  research  and  writing 
is  needed  to  expand  upon  the  subjects  discussed  here. 

The  range  of  subjects  discussed  in  the  book  cover  a 


diverse,  yet  interrelated  number  of  topics  from  "Anglo- 
Spanish  Commerce  in  New  Orleans  during  the  American 
Revolutionary  Era,"  by  Professor  Robin  F.  A.  Fabel  to 
"French  and  Spanish  Military  Units  in  the  1781  Pensacola 
Campaign,"  by  Jack  D.  L.  Holmes.  There  are  twelve  essays 
on  many  subjects  of  interest,  along  with  the  relevant  maps 
and  other  illustrations  worthy  of  note. 

But  let  us  return  to  our  original  question.  What  does 
the  Pensacola  campaign  of  1781  have  to  do  with  the  history 
of  Wyoming?  It  ought  not  to  be  forgotten  that  the  Anglo- 
Spanish  confrontation  along  the  Gulf  Coast  was  the  result 
of  a  much  bigger  picture  from  Spain's  point  of  view.  That 
was:  to  keep  the  British  out  of  Spain's  possessions  in  the 
rest  of  North  and  South  America.  Spain  regarded  her 
Louisiana  colony  as  a  necessary  buffer  against  such  intru- 
sions, and  her  military  campaigns  in  the  Mississippi  Valley 
and  on  her  western  frontier  were  designed  to  stop  such 
incursions  by  British  or  even  American  traders  from  the 
northeast  and  Canada.  The  protection  and  trade  of  Span- 
ish Mexico  was  dependent  upon  this  strategy.  Portions  of 
present  day  Wyoming  were  considered  as  part  of  Spain's 
frontier  possessions,  and,  in  fact,  her  prior  explorations 
north  of  the  provincial  capital  at  Santa  Fe  may  well  pro- 
vide us  with  new  information.  Although  a  great  deal  of 
historiography  remains  to  be  done  on  the  subject  of 
Spanish  administration  and  exploration  in  the  Rocky 
Mountains,  there  is  enough  information  emerging  in 
modern  scholarship  to  tantalize  us.  For  example,  a  French 
map  of  1718  contains  the  following  marginal  note  on  the 
northern  Rocky  Mountain  area:  "At  this  locality  in  the 
report  from  the  Indians,  the  Spanish  crossed  the  [Upper] 
Missouri  on  horseback  from  where  [they]  negotiated  with 
some  Indian  nations  located  to  the  Northwest  from  whom 
they  brought  news  of  the  'yellow  iron';  it  was  in  this  way 
that  they  [the  Indians]  expressed  it." 

In  summary,  the  series  of  twelve  essays  contained  in 
Anglo-Spanish  Confrontation  on  the  Gulf  Coast  provide 
new  insights  into  the  comprehensive  and  pervasive  role 
of  Spain  in  our  nation's  western  history.  The  traditional 
view  of  Spain  as  the  lethargic,  or  "has  been"  power  of  an 
earlier  era  in  the  Age  of  Exploration  is  in  need  of  revi- 
sion. For  within  the  empire  of  Spain  and  her  borderlands 
with  the  other  colonial  powers,  including  that  of  the  young 
American  Republic  after  1783,  the  frontier  figured  prom- 
inently in  Spanish  planning.  It  ought  not  to  be  forgotten 
that  while  France  sold  Louisiana  to  the  United  States  and 
transferred  it  accordingly  on  December  20,  1803,  that 
France  herself  did  not  take  possession  of  the  colony  from 
Spain  until  November  30,  1803!  And  Spain  had  held  it, 
with  Wyoming  included,  since  1763.  The  more  we  come 
to  know  about  the  Spanish  empire  in  North  America,  the 
more  we  will  come  to  know  about  our  own  history. 

Robert  D.  Bush 

The  reviewer  is  director  of  the  Wyoming  State  Archives,  Museums  and 
Historical  Department. 

4.5! 


Mister  You  Got  Yourself  a  Horse:  Tales  of  Old-Time 
Horse  Trading.  By  Roger  L.  Welsch.  (Lincoln: 
University  of  Nebraska  Press,  1981).  Gloss.  Bib. 
207  pp.  Cloth,  $14.95. 

Mister  You  Got  Yourself  a  Horse  is  about  horse  trading 
and  horse  use  in  Nebraska  before  the  wide-spread  adop- 
tion of  gasoline  or  steam  powered  farm  equipment  and 
automobiles.  Disregarding  humorous  details,  it  is  about 
humanity's  all  too  common  proclivity  to  gamble.  Horse- 
trading  was  a  game  with  agreed  upon  conventions  that 
insured  a  dramatic  ending.  Usually  the  result  was  someone 
got  something  valuable  for  nothing,  with  the  "loser" 
accepting  the  loss  begrudgingly.  Combine  most  Amer- 
icans' love  of  sporty  transportation  or  powerful  draft  horse 
teams  with  gambling  instincts  and  you  have  a  former 
national  passion  —  horse  swapping. 

Mister  You  Got  Yourself  a  Horse  is  composed  of 
numerous  short  stories  or  vignettes.  The  stories  are 
primarily  the  product  of  a  retired  horse  trader  raconteur, 
Lew  or  Luke  Croughan.  Welsch's  comments  are  limited 
to  introducing  and  explaining  the  intricacies  of  trading 
and  the  science  of  "doctoring"  or  discovering  equine  afflic- 
tions. Without  his  glossary  of  equine  ailments  we  would 
be  befuddled  by  diagnoses  of  "bull-windy,  sweenied, 
stump-sucker,  or  moon-eyed"  horses. 

As  in  his  earlier  book,  A  Treasury  of  Nebraska  Pioneer 
Folklore,  Welsch  has  selectively  mined  the  Nebraska 
W.  P.  A.  Writer's  Project  files  to  assemble  this  collection. 
His  aim  is  to  present  the  W.  P.  A.  articles  as  stories  or 
proto-folklore,  not  as  historical  documents.  Employing  the 
stories  this  way,  Welsch  uncaps  most  of  the  strengths  of 
the  New  Deal  project  and  neatly  bypasses  the  thorny  issue 
of  its  historicity. 

Still  from  a  folklore  standpoint  some  questions  per- 
sist. For  example,  it  would  be  helpful  (albeit  impossible 
at  present)  to  know  more  about  the  lesser  storytellers  whose 
tales  are  presented.  It  would  be  helpful  to  know  more 
about  the  circumstance  of  the  telling  of  these  tales  to 
fieldworkers,  which  can  have  a  dramatic  effect  on  the  story 
style,  length,  and  word  choice.  We  also  do  not  know  how 
esoteric  or  public  this  genre  of  horse-trading  tales  were. 
Did  everyone  tell  these  stories  or  just  horsetraders? 

These  small  quibbles  aside,  Mister  You  Got  Yourself 
a  Horse  is  a  lively  book  geared  toward  the  general  reading 
audience.  Scholars  may  be  dismayed  by  the  lack  of  detailed 
discussion  of  horse-trading  tales  as  an  art  form  with 
particular  characteristics  and  rules.  However,  such  crit- 
icism is  largely  unfair,  since  the  book  attempts  to  develop 
an  appreciation  of  stories  which  explain  and  delight  in 
the  economic  and  recreational  activity  of  bartering 
horses. 

Timothy  S.  Cochrane 

Cochrane  is  with  the  Folklore  Department  at  the  University  of  Indiana, 
Bloomington. 


Buried  Unsung:  Louis  Tihas  and  the  Ludlow 
Massacre,  by  Zeese  Papanikolas  with  forward  by 
Wallace  Stegner.  (Salt  Lake  City,  Utah:  Univer- 
sity of  Utah  Press,  1982).  Index.  Illus.  240  pp. 
Cloth,  $25.00. 

"What  I  am  about  to  write,"  Zeese  Papanikolas  tells 
us  in  his  book,  Buried  Unsung,  "is  hardly  fiction,  nor  is 
it  quite  history."  He  then  narrates  a  story  centered  around 
the  slaying  of  Louis  Tikas,  a  Denver  coffee-house  proprie- 
tor who  became  a  labor  organizer  and  was  shot  to  death 
on  April  20,  1914  near  a  coal-mine  strikers'  tent  town  at 
Ludlow,  Colorado. 

With  the  compassionate  grace  of  Irving  Stone  in 
Clarence  Darrow  for  the  Defense  and  the  intriguing 
literary  style  of  Wallace  Stegner  who  wrote  Buried  Un- 
sung's  forward,  Papanikolas  pieces  together  fragmentary 
accounts  of  Tikas'  experiences  as  an  immigrant  coal-mine 
labor  leader  whose  life  in  the  Colorado  coal  fields  sym- 
bolizes "a  whole  generation  of  immigrant  workers  who 
found  themselves,  in  the  years  before  the  First  World  War, 
caught  between  the  realities  of  industrial  America  and 
their  aspirations  for  a  better  life."  Papanikolas  is  honest 
about  the  scarcity  of  information  on  Tikas  and  he  is 
equally  open  about  his  sympathies  for  the  Colorado  miners 
who  lived  in  a  mean  world  of  three-dollar-a-day  coal- 
company  gunmen,  scabs  and  thugs,  spies,  violent  National 
Guardsmen,  jealous  and  militant  labor  leaders,  and  coal 
mine  owners  who  believed  in  Social  Darwinism. 

As  protagonist  of  Buried  Unsung  Louis  Tikas  is  por- 
trayed as  a  person  of  considerable  mystery.  In  a  sense 
Papanikolas'  book  becomes  a  chronicle  of  the  author's 
search  for  Tikas'  identity  —  and  for  his  own  in  a  fashion 
similar  to  Jack  Burden's  self  quest  in  Robert  Penn  War- 
ren's novel,  All  the  King's  Men.  Enough  evidence  exists 
in  the  form  of  old  men's  memories,  newspaper  files,  union 
records  and  photographs  to  allow  Papanikolas  to  present 
an  image  of  Tikas,  but  he  admits  that  much  of  the  book 
is  the  product  of  imagination  and  speculation:  "It  is  full 
of  doubts,  a  work  of  reconstruction,  of  guesses  as  well  as 
facts."  The  results,  however,  are  rewarding  because  Papa- 
nikolas presents  an  admirable  picture  of  Tikas  as  a  man 
who  genuinely  cared  about  Colorado's  immigrant  miners 
and  who  did  all  he  could  to  help  them  and  their  families 
during  the  coal  strike  of  1913-14. 

In  spite  of  the  dearth  of  information  on  Tikas  for 
Buried  Unsung,  the  book  reveals  Papanikolas'  thorough 
research,  shrewdly  analytical  methods,  and  enthusiasm 
for  his  subject.  The  author's  style  is  straightforward,  and 
his  discussion  of  facts  about  coal  mining  in  general  and 
the  Colorado  strike  of  1913  demonstrates  his  competent 
knowledge  of  labor  history  while  his  reference  notes  and 
bibliography  illustrate  his  coverage  of  the  subject.  The 
result  of  it  all  is  a  gentle  account  of  a  labor  tragedy. 

Much  exists  in  the  exploitive  nature  of  coal  mining 
in  1913  to  generate  anger,  yet  Papanikolas  condemns  softly 


44 


(but  accurately)  and  praises  Tikas  in  a  manner  that  evokes 
compassion  rather  than  hatred. 

Alluding  to  a  period  in  his  own  life  when  he  was 
writing  "failing  fictions,"  Papanikolas  has  now  entered  a 
time  of  considerable  literary  success.  He  is  skilled  at  com- 
bining the  substance  of  history  with  the  style  of  a  poet. 
Reading  Buried  Unsung  gave  this  reviewer  the  same  sense 
of  provocative  pleasure  that  he  had  experienced  several 
summers  ago  while  reading  Bernard  DeVoto's  Across  the 
Wide  Missouri.  Buried  Unsung  is  a  moving  experience. 

Walter  Jones 

The  rexnewer  is  an  archivist  at  the  University  of  Utah,  Salt  Lake  City. 


Wolves  for  the  Blue  Soldiers:  Indian  Scouts  and 
Auxiliaries  with  the  United  States  Army,  1860-90. 
By  Thomas  W.  Dunlay.  (Lincoln:  University  of 
Nebraska  Press,  1982).  Index.  Bib.  Illus.  Maps. 
304  pp.  Cloth,  $21.95. 

Dunlay  has  written  an  informative  account  of  the  U.S. 
Army's  use  of  Indian  scouts  or  "wolves"  during  the  Indian 
wars  of  the  trans-Mississippi  West.  Combining  previous 
scholarship  on  specific  Indian  campaigns  with  fresh 
archival  material,  Dunlay  synthesizes  numerous  expe- 
riences of  Indian-white  military  cooperation  into  a 
readable  analysis  of  the  complex  relationships  that  devel- 
oped between  those  Indians  who  assisted  in  subjugating 
other  Indians  and  the  military  men  who  recruited  and 
led  them. 

What  Dunlay  does  so  well  is  to  juxtapose  the  motives 
and  objectives  of  the  field  commanders  and  officers  who 


employed  Indian  scouts  with  the  motives  and  objectives 
of  Indian  enlistees  and  those  tribal  and  band  leaders  who 
encouraged  enlistment  in  the  scouting  service.  For  field 
officers,  the  reconnaissance  and  martial  skills  of  Indian 
allies  helped  off-set  their  immediate  problem  --  cam- 
paigning with  troops  too  few  in  numbers  and  ill-trained 
for  Plains  Indian  warfare.  Moreover,  many  within  the  army 
held  that  the  scouting  service  drew-off  potential  trouble- 
makers from  the  reservations,  further  weakened  tribal 
authority,  and  facilitated  assimilation. 

Indian  recruits,  on  the  other  hand,  viewed  the 
scouting  service  as  a  means  of  acquiring  status  in  the  tradi- 
tional manner,  of  gaining  supplemental  support  for  their 
families  through  army  pay  and  rations,  and  of  escaping 
the  crushing  acculturation  of  reservation  life.  Tribal  and 
band  leaders  held  the  scout  service  to  be  a  means  of  align- 
ing with  a  force  capable  of  striking  a  serious  blow  against 
traditional  enemies  or  factional  rivals  and  of  ensuring 
favorable  reservations  and  better  treatment  for  their 
peoples.  The  story  that  emerges  is  how  these  conflicting 
motives  for  cooperation  dovetailed  to  produce  a  Great 
Plains  fighting  force  which  both  effectively  shortened 
Indian-US.  wars  and  eased,  at  least  for  some  Indians,  the 
painful  adjustment  to  the  dominant  culture. 

Like  many  recent  scholars  of  the  19th-century  Indian 
wars,  Dunlay  owes  much  to  Robert  Utley's  influential  Fron- 
tier Regulars  (1973).  Indeed,  for  those  who  have  read  and 
enjoyed  Utley,  Dunlay  s  Wolves  for  the  Blue  Soldiers  will 
be  a  welcome  addition  to  their  reading  list. 

David  L.  Ferch 

The  reviewer  is  with  the  Department  of  History,  Mount  Mercy  Col- 
lege, Cedar  Rapids,  Iowa. 


45 


INDEX 


Alonso  de  Posada  Report,  1686.  A  Description  of  the  Area  of  the  Present 
Southern  United  States  in  the  Seventeenth  Century  translated  and  edited 
by  Alfred  Barnaby  Thomas,  review,  38. 

American  Protective  Association,  7 

Andrews,  Fred,  35 

Anglo-Spanish  Confrontation  on  the  Gulf  Coast  During  the  American  Revolu- 
tion, edited  by  William  S.  Coker  and  Robert  R.  Rea,  review,  43 


Federal  Power  Commission,  12 

Ferch,  David  L,,  review  of  Wolves  for  the  Blue  Soldiers:  Indian  Scouts  and 

Auxiliaries  with  the  United  States  Army  1860-90,  45 
Fitch.  Robert  E.,  6-7 
Forts 

Laramie,  36 
"A  Funeral  at  Fort  Laramie,"  by  Lewis  A.  Eaton,  36 


B 

Bartlett,  Albert,   12 

Bamhill,  J.  Herschel,  review  of  Oil  Booms:  Social  Change  in  Five  Texas  Towns, 

40-41 
Bishop,  L.  C,   11 
Bridaham,  Lester,  33 
Broaddus,  Dr.  J.  E.,  12 
Brooks,  B.  B.,  7,  21 
Brower,  David,   12 
Buffalo  Bill:  His  Family,  Friends,  Fame,  Failures,  and  Fortunes,  by  Nellie 

Snyder  Yost,  review,  38-39 
Builders  of  the  Kingdom:  George  A.  Smith,  fohn  Henry  Smith,  George  Albert 

Smith,  by  Merlo  J.  Pusey,  review,  41-42 
Bureau  of  Reclamation,   10-17 
Buried  Unsung:  Louis  Tikas  and  the  Ludlow  Massacre,  by  Zeese  Papanikolas, 

review,  44 
Bush,  Robert  D.,  review  of  Anglo-Spanish  Confrontation  on  the  Gulf  Coast 

During  the  American  Revolution,  43 


Campbell,  Gov.  John  A.,   19 

Carlos  Montezuma  and  the  Changing  World  of  American  Indians,  by  Peter 

Iverson,  review,  42-43 
Carrington,  Cal,  30-32 
Castiday,  Ella  Mary,  33 
Chapman,  Oscar,   10 

Cheney,  Lynne,  "The  Countess  of  Flat  Creek,"  28-32 
Cheyenne,  26 
Cochrane,  Timothy  S.,  review  of  Mister  You  Got  Yourself  a  Horse:  Tales  of 

Old-Time  Horse  Trading,  44 
Coker,  William  S.,  Anglo-Spanish  Confrontation  on  the  Gulf  Coast  During 

the  American  Revolution,  review,  43 
Colorado  Compact  of  1922.  14 

"The  Countess  of  Flat  Creek,"  by  Lynne  Cheney,  28-32 
Crabtree,  Henry,  31 
Crabtree,  Rose,  32 


Davis-Bridaham  Drug  Co.,  35;  photo,  34 

Davis,  John  C.  Jr.,  35 

Davis,  John  C,  Sr.,  33  35 

Davis,  Roblin  L.,  35 

DeVoto,  Bernard,   10 

Dinosaur  National  Monument,  10,   15 

Dotsoro,  Colo.,  35 

Downey,  Stephen,  6-7;  photo,  5 

Drury,  Newton,  10 

Dunlay,  Thomas  W.,  Wolves  for  the  Blue  Soldiers:  Indian  Scouts  and  Aux- 
iliaries with  the  United  States  Army,  1860-90,  review,  45 

Dunsmore,  Roger,  review  of  Kopet:  A  Documentary  Narrative  of  Chief  Joseph's 
Last  Years,  39-40 


Echo  Park,  10-18,  map,  9;  photo,   14 

"Echo  Park  Dam;  An  Old  Problem  of  Federalism"  by  Mark  W.  T.  Harvey,  9-18 


Gambling,  2-8 

"A  German  Looks  at  Cheyenne  in  1876;  The  Travels  of  Ernst  von  Hesse- 

Wartegg,"  edited  and  translated  by  Frederic  Trautmann,  25-27 
Gidley,  M.,  Kopet:  A  Documentary  Narrative  of  Chief  Joseph's  Last  Years, 

review,  39-40 
Gizycki,  Count  Joseph,  29-32 
Gizycki,  Felicia.  30 
Gunster,  Mayor  P.  F.,  4 

H 

Harrison,  William  Henry,   13 

Hauck,  Minnie,  25 

Hayford,  James  H.,  3-8;  photo,  2 

Hendrickson,  Kenneth  E.,  Jr.,  review  of  Alonso  de  Posada  Report,  1686.  A 
Description  of  the  Area  of  the  Present  Southern  United  States  in  the  Seven- 
teenth Century,  38 

Hesse-Wartegg,  Ernst  von,  25-27 

Hill,  Charles  S.,  23 

Holliday,  William  H  ,  6 

Hooper.  Tom.  6 

Hoyt,  John  W.,  20 

Hugus,  J.  W.,  33,  35 

Hynds,  Harry,  7;  photo,  5 

I 
Inter-Ocean  Hotel,  26 
Iverson,   Peter,   Carlos  Montezuma  and  the  Changing  World  of  American 

Indians,  review,  42-43 
Izaak  Walton  League,  13 


"John  C.  Davis,  Sr.;  Portrait  of  a  Rocky  Mountain  Drug  Wholesaling  Pioneer," 

by  Anthony  Palmieri,  III,  33-35 
Johnson,  Leroy,  13.  15 
Jones.  Walter,  review  of  Buried  Unsung:  Louis  Tikas  and  the  Ludlow  Massacre, 

44-45 
Judkin,  W.  T.,  22 

K 

King,  Sgt.  E.  H.,  36 

Kopet:  A  Documentary  Narrative  of  Chief  Joseph's  Last  Years,  by  M.  Gidley, 

review,  39-40 
Kuchel,  Thomas.  14 


Levi,  Herbert,   12 

Longworth,  Alice  Roosevelt,  32;  photo,  30 

Longworth,  Nicholas,  photo,  30 

M 
McCormick,  Medill,  29 
McCormick,  Robert  R.,  29;  photo,  29 
McKay,  Douglas,   10 


46 


Medicine  Bow.  Wyo..  33 
Medill.  Joseph.  29;  photo.  29 
|Meyer,  Eugene.  32 
Milner.  Clyde  A..  II.  With  Good  Intentions:  Quaker  Work  Among  the  Pawnees, 

Otos,  and  the  Omahas  in  the  1870's,  review,  37-38 
Mister  You  Got  Yourself  a  Horse:  Tales  of  Old-Time  Horse  Trading,  by  Roger 

L.  Welsch,  review.  44 
Mondell.  Cong.  Frank.  22 
Moonlight.  Thomas,  20  21 
Moore.  Mary.  31 
Moore.  William  Howard,  "Pietism  and  Progress:  James  H.  Hayford  and  the 

Wyoming  Anti-Gambling  Tradition.   1869-1893,"  2-8 
iMoran,  Breck.   13.  15 
Mormon  Thunder   A  Documentary  History  ofjedediah  Grant,  by  Gene  A. 

Sessions,  review,  41-42 
Munro,  James,   12 
Murie,  Olaus,   16 

N 

National  Park  Service.  10 

Neuberger,  Sen.  Richard.  16 

Noble.  Bruce.  "The  Quest  for  Settlement  in  Early  Wyoming."  19-24 

O 

Oil  Booms:  Social  Change  m  Five  Texas  Towns,  by  Roger  M.  Olien  and  Diana 

Davids  Olien,  review,  40-41 
Olien,  Roger  M..  and  Diana  Davids  Olien,  Oil  Booms:  Social  Change  in  Five 

Texas  Towns,  review,  40-41 
O'Mahoney,  Sen.  Joseph  C,  photo,   11 


Paige,  John  C-,   review  of  Carlos  Montezuma  and  the  Changing  World  of 

American  Indians,  42-43 
Paige,  John  C  review  of  Shadows  of  the  Indian:  Stereotypes  in  American 

Culture.  42-43 
Palmieri.  Anthony.  Ill,  "John  C.  Davis:  Portrait  of  a  Rocky  Mountain  Drug 

Wholesaling  Pioneer."  33-35 
Papanikolas,  Zeese,  Buried  Unsung:  Louis  Tikas  and  the  Ludlow  Massacre, 

review.  44-45 
Patterson.  Eleanor,  29-32;  photos,  28-29 
Patterson,  Joseph,  photo,  29 
Pearson,  Drew,  31 
"Pietism  and  Progress:  James  H.  Hayford  and  the  Wyoming  Anti-Gambling 

Tradition,   1869-1893,"  by  William  Howard  Moore,  2-8 
Pusey,  Merlo  J. ,  Builders  of  the  Kingdom   George  A.  Smith,  John  Henry  Smith. 

George  Albert  Smith,  review.  41-42 


Quereau,  Frank,  33 

"The  Quest  for  Settlement  in  Early  Wyoming,"  by  Bruce  Noble.  19-24 

R 

Rawlins,  Wyo..  33;  photo,  34 

Rea,  Robert  R..  Anglo-Spanish  Confrontation  on  the  Gulf  Coast  During  the 

American  Revolution,  review,  43 
Religion.  3-8 
Rogers.  C.  J.  "Doc",   12 
Ross,  Gov.  William  B.,  23 


Schenk,  Roy  W.,  22 

Schlesinger.  Elmer,  31 

Seedskadee  Project.  12 

Sessions.  Gene  A..  Mormon  Thunder:  A  Documentary  History  ofjedediah 

Grant,  review.  41-42 
Shadows  of  the   Indian:   Stereotypes  in   American   Culture,    by   Raymond 

William  Stedman.  review,  42-43 
Slack,  E.  A..  6;  photo,  5 
Smith.  Fred.   16 
Smith.  Robert  E. ,  review  of  With  Good  Intentions:  Quaker  Work  Among  the 

Pawnees,   Otos,  and  Omahas  in  the  1870's,  review,  37-38 
Smith.  Sherry,  review  of  Buffalo  Bill    His  Family,  Friends,  Fame,  Failures, 

and  Fortunes,  38-39 
Smythe.  William  E.,  20 
Snyder.  Ruth,  31 
Stedman,  Raymond  William,  Shadows  of  the  Indian   Stereotypes  in  American 

Culture,  review,  42-43 
Strong,  Rev.  Josiah.  3 


Thayer.  John  M..  20 

Thomas.  Alfred  Barnaby,  Alonso  de  Posada  Report,  1686  A  Description  of 
the  Area  of  the  Present  Southern  United  States  m  the  Seventeenth  Cen- 
tury, review,  38 

Trabing  Brothers  Mercantile,  33 

Tudor.  Ralph.   10 


U 

Untermann.  G.  E..  12 

Upper  Colorado  River  Commission.   11 


Van  Devanter.  Willis,  6 


M 

Warren,  Sen.  Francis  E.,  21 

Watkins.  Sen.  Arthur,   15 

Welsch.  Roger,  Mister  You  Got  Yourself  a  Horse:  Tales  of  Old-Time  Horse 

Trading,  review,  44 
Whitehead,  Judge,  26 
Will,  John,   12,  15 
Winn.  Kenneth,  review  of  Builders  of  the  Kingdom:  George  A    Smith,  John 

Henry  Smith,  George  Albert  Smith,  41-42 
Winn.   Kenneth,   review  of  Mormon   Thunder    A  Documentary  History  of 

Jedediah  Grant,  41-42 
With  Good  Intentions:  Quaker  Work  Among  the  Pawnees,  Otos,  and  Omahas 

in  the  1870's,  by  Clyde  A.  Milner.  II,  review.  37-38 
Wolves  for  the  Blue  Soldiers    Indian  Scouts  and  Auxiliaries  with  the  United 

States  Army,  1860-90.  by  Thomas  W.  Dunlay,  review.  45 
Women's  Christian  Temperance  Union,  4 


Yost,  Nellie  Snyder,  Buffalo  Bill  His  Family,  Friends.  Fame,  Failures,  and  For- 
tunes, review,  38-39 


47 


CONTRIBUTORS 


WILLIAM  HOWARD  MOORE  is  an  Associate  Professor 
of  History  at  the  University  of  Wyoming.  He  earned  his 
Ph.D.  degree  at  the  University  of  Texas  in  Austin.  An  ac- 
tive writer,  he  has  authored  numerous  articles,  and  the 
sequel  to  his  Annals  piece  will  be  published  in  a  forthcom- 
ing issue  of  Western  Historical  Quarterly.  As  well,  he  is 
the  author  of  the  book,  The  Kefauver  Committee  and  the 
Politics  of  Crime,  which  was  published  in  1974.  Moore 
is  a  member  of  the  Organization  of  American  Historians 
and  the  American  Historical  Association. 


MARK  W.  T.  HARVEY  is  a  Ph.D.  candidate  at  the 
Department  of  History  at  the  University  of  Wyoming  and 
works  for  the  department  as  a  teaching  assistant.  He  lived 
in  Jackson  during  the  summers  from  1972  through  1979 
working  for  the  Teton  Boating  Company  on  Jenny  Lake. 
Most  recently,  he  has  served  as  an  interpretive  ranger/guide 
at  Mesa  Verde  National  Park  in  Colorado.  Harvey  is  the 
author  of  a  Colorado  Heritage  article  entitled,  "Misguided 
Reformer,  Nathan  Meeker  Among  the  Ute."  In  his  leisure 
hours,  Harvey  enjoys  rock  climbing  and  photography. 


BRUCE  J.  NOBLE,  JR.  received  a  B.A.  in  American 
Studies  from  the  University  of  Wyoming.  He  is  presently 
a  graduate  student  in  history  at  the  same  institution.  His 
interest  in  the  history  of  the  American  West  helps  to  justify 
his  decision  to  reside  in  the  Rocky  Mountains.  Most 
recently,  he  has  experienced  a  summer's  employment  at 
historic  South  Pass  City  in  Fremont  County.  He  has  a  pas- 
sion for  skiing,  and  was  a  member  of  the  U.W.  History 
Department's  basketball  team. 


FREDERIC  TRAUTMANN  is  an  Associate  Professor  of 
Speech  at  Temple  University.  He  earned  both  his  M.S.  and 
Ph.D.  at  Purdue.  Trautmann  has  authored  The  Voice  of 
Terror:  A  Biography  offohann  Most  and  numerous  arti- 
cles relating  to  travel  in  America.  He  is  a  member  of  the 
German  Society  of  Pennsylvania,  the  Historical  Society 
of  Pennsylvania  and  the  Library  Company  of  Pennsyl- 
vania. 


LYNNE  VINCENT  CHENEY  grew  up  in  her  native  state 
of  Wyoming,  received  her  B.A.,  with  highest  honors,  from 
Colorado  College,  and  her  M.A.  from  the  University  of 
Colorado.  In  1970,  she  received  a  Ph.D.  in  English  lit- 
erature from  the  University  of  Wisconsin.  Since  then,  she 
has  taught  at  George  Washington  University  and  the  Uni- 
versity of  Wyoming.  She  is  the  author  of  many  historical 
articles  and  her  work  has  appeared  in  publications  rang- 
ing from  Highlights  for  Children  to  American  Heritage 
and  Smithsonian  Magazine.  She  has  written  two  novels, 
Executive  Privilege,  which  was  set  in  the  White  House, 
and  Sisters,  which  was  set  in  Cheyenne  in  1886.  She 
recently  co-authored  a  history  of  the  United  States  Con- 
gress called  Kings  of  the  Hill. 


ANTHONY  PALMIERI,  III,  is  Associate  Professor  of 
Pharmaceutics  at  the  University  of  Wyoming's  College  of 
Pharmacy.  A  graduate  of  the  University  of  Rhode  Island, 
he  was  awarded  an  M.A.  degree  from  Rhode  Island  and 
a  Ph.D.  from  the  University  of  Georgia.  His  article,  done 
with  Chris  Humberson,  "Medical  Incidents  in  the  Life  of 
Dr.  John  H.  Finfrock"  was  published  in  the  Fall,  1981  issue 
of  Annals.  The  John  C.  Davis  article  in  this  issue  was 
presented  as  a  paper  to  the  American  Institute  of  the 
History  of  Pharmacy  at  their  1983  Annual  Meeting  in  New 
Orleans.  Palmieri  is  the  editor  of  The  Mask  of  Kappa  Psi, 
a  quarterly  magazine. 


LEWIS  A.  EATON  was  Park  Technician  at  Fort  Laramie 
National  Historic  Site  from  1966  until  his  recent  retire- 
ment. In  that  capacity  Eaton  was  engaged  in  the  living 
history  role  of  Post  Trader.  He  conducted  research  for  the 
James  A.  Michener  book  Centennial  and  for  the  National 
Geographic  publication,  Trails  West.  Eaton  has  received 
a  Superior  Performance  Award  from  the  National  Park 
Service  and  has  been  recognized  for  his  outstanding  work 
as  visitor  services  technician,  library  technician  and  daily 
business  manager.  He  has  been  a  frequent  participant  in 
the  famous  Fort  Laramie  Moonlight  Tours  held  each 
summer. 


48 


WYOMING  STATE  HISTORICAL  SOCIETY 

The  Wyoming  State  Historical  Society  was  organized  in  October,  1953. 
Membership  is  open  to  anyone  interested  in  history.  County  chapters  of  the  society 
have  been  chartered  in  most  of  the  twenty-three  counties  of  Wyoming.  Past 
presidents  of  the  society  include:  Frank  Bowron,  Casper,  1953-55;  William  L. 
Marion,  Lander,  1955-56;  Dr.  DeWitt  Dominick,  Cody,  1956-57;  Dr.  T.  A.  Lar- 
son, Laramie,  1957-58;  A.  H.  MacDougall,  Rawlins,  1958-59;  Mrs.  Thelma  G. 
Condit,  Buffalo,  1959-60;  E.  A.  Littleton,  Gillette,  1960-61;  Edness  Kimball 
Wilkins,  Casper,  1961-62;  Charles  Ritter,  Cheyenne,  1962-63;  Neal  E.  Miller, 
Rawlins,  1963-65;  Mrs.  Charles  Hord,  Casper,  1965-66;  Glenn  Sweem,  Sheridan, 
1966-67;  Adrian  Reynolds,  Green  River,  1967-68;  Curtiss  Root,  Torrington, 
1968-69;  Mrs.  Hattie  Burnstad,  Worland,  1969-70;  J.  Reuel  Armstrong,  Rawlins, 
1970-71;  William  R.  Dubois,  Cheyenne,  1971-72;  Henry  F.  Chadey,  Rock  Springs, 
1972-73;  Richard  S.  Dumbrill,  Newcastle,  1973-74;  Henry  Jensen,  Casper,  1974-75; 
Jay  Brazelton,  Jackson,  1975-76;  Ray  Pendergraft,  Worland,  1976-77;  David  J. 
Wasden,  Cody,  1977-78;  Mabel  Brown,  Newcastle,  1978-79;  James  June,  Green 
River,  1979-80;  William  F.  Bragg,  Jr.,  Casper,  1980-81;  Don  Hodgson,  Torrington, 
1981-82,  Clara  Jensen,  Lysite-Casper,  1982-83. 

Membership  information  may  be  obtained  from  the  Executive  Headquarters, 
Wyoming  State  Historical  Society,  Barrett  Building,  Cheyenne,  Wyoming  82002. 
Dues  in  the  state  society  are: 

Life  Membership  $100 

Joint  Life  Membership  (husband  and  wife)   $150 

Annual   Membership    $5 

Joint  Annual  Membership  (two  persons  of  same  family 

at  same  address)  $7 

Institutional   Membership    $10 

President,  Fern  Gaensslen,  Green  River 
First  Vice  President,  Dave  Kathka,  Rock  Springs 
•     -  Second  Vice  President,  Mary  Garman,  Sundance 

Secretary-Treasurer,  Ellen  Mueller,  Cheyenne